Re: This is sort of a loaded situation...
David Weaver
So, for oilstones - dan's goes as deep as economics will allow. Not a huge fan of their soft stones, their "hard" relatively inexpensive stones are a decent finish stone, but not a true hard.
Their true hard, black and translucent stones branded "dan's" and not sold by someone else where they say "these came from dan's" are as good as anything I've ever seen from any of the types. If a 1/2" thick black or trans stone can be found at retail and glued to another half inch stone to make the whole thing feel like a full sized stone, it's effectively as good as any ark finish stone and lifetime is only limited by the ability to avoid dropping (fortunately, I didn't do that, but they don't tolerate being dropped).
Halls/preyda - OK, but while dan's black is available, there's no great reason to buy their black stones (i Had a couple - they release the odd particle here or there and just aren't as subjectively good).
Norton, can't tell - I've gotten some borderline finishers from their stones (faster, translucent stones that are on the bubble with small pores, etc). They could go back to the mine and get a new dose and everything could change.
As far as japanese stones:
* ohira mine is still operating last I checked. Their stones are OK. There can be some spectacular stones from them, too. You just don't know as the buyer and a moderate quality large suita is in the $400-$500 range. They will have association and mine stamps on them and be OK
* new old mine stones (nakayama, okudo, shinden, etc) - some of that stuff can be old stock that was stored and never stamped. But it's often sort of blah material that looks good and the association allows stamping of mines now where it wasn't stamped originally - risky bet
Any new dealer with anything average will try to get top price. Anything that's really spectacular will be higher yet. My opinion, it's hard to really go get good stuff without just buying a huge pile of used stones and then keeping the best older stuff. That's what I did. It was a huge time investment, and on break even terms, most would find it not worth it. Fortunately, my buyee and etsy and paypal records will show no profit, but at the volume I moved, I guess it could be subject to checking. Never happened. Making a profit on stones intentionally will yield not that much profit if one is honest, and then you get to have a business that files taxes and needs to be insured. No thanks.
My favorites, though, are the slightly odd shaped pieces that cut like magic (which doesn't mean they're 10 times better than anything else - it just means they have a combination of qualities that makes them fast for what their composition is supposed to be, fine for their speed and tough on the surface and pleasant to use for their purpose. They're a little better in all the places where it counts.).
If someone is just looking for sharpening capability, I'd avoid buying stones from any dealers in volume - you end up with, let's say, a $1k stone that's really worth a third to half of that at best (unless the cachet of the dealer can be transferred to the next buyer) and there's a good chance that a little $110 slice of suita like the one I showed above may beat it. You get into the conundrum that I did - on the left, I have a 2kg pretty block of nice cutting. On the right, I have a short and inexpensive piece of stone that looked really impressive in the picker's ad on buyee and when it showed up, it easily matched what their demo showed. What am I going to use when I'm working? I could fight to get the most out of the bigger stone and then easily match that with the other one - eventually the big one goes. Hopefully it wasn't too expensive.
I think the odds are just against the buyer, and the sellers and distributors know more about the stones than the buyers usually do - especially in regard to separating aesthetics vs. capability. Big push for everyone wanting kiita stones in hte last decade. Kiita stones are usually soft and a little coarse. Once in a while a real trooper comes through. But nondescript barber shop pulled stones that are old and well used may be a real trooper 7 out of 10 times, and a kiita stone of the same shape 1 out of 20. Karasu is a popular decoration sold by dealers - but karasu stones are often glassy and scratchy. What's the chance that they match a good vintage green tomae stone for every day use? less than 50%, but at much greater cost.
There's much value to be made in convincing people that these are great stones. Some of the new ones are great - or may be great for something slightly different than as sold (a stone sold as a razor stone but that's too coarse may be a great tool finisher, but if you struggle sharpening a razor on one and you're assured by someone else that it's a good razor stone, then how do you know? A great razor stone, you just rub a razor on it any way you want to use it, linen and strop and you have a comfortable shave. Most of the modern razor stones being sold are either glassy, and too coarse when slurried or they're soft and too coarse to match the vintage barber shop pulls.
what if you get 3 barber shop pulls and two aren't that great? well, all three would cost less than a barber sized new stone, and now you have one great stone and two that you can wait to find a use for.
i'm sort of going in circles with this. Going through a bunch of mediocre stones in person (where there are some that are great and just what you want) is a whole different proposition in a store in japan where there are 150 stones to try. They'll be cheaper there, too. I think I probably bought 15 stones in total from dealers in japan or the US. I don't have any of them at this point. If any would've been better than the stones that I kept, I'd still have them instead of the stones I have now.
Final answer - for natural stones, best bet is to buy 5 washitas, keep one fine one, one coarse one, and buy one good trans or black stone (vintage trans is fine, black new from dan's is the best bet there). Everything else that I've gotten (new coticules, etc, all iffy. Vintage coticules have been better on average, too, but they're usually expensive and some are stinkers).