Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

Posts

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#101

Re: Now I am more confused

David Weaver

That's a generalization if they're only used a certain way. This stone is faster than a settled in soft arkansas at this point, and leaves a finer edge. If soft arkansas stones maintained good cutting speed and fineness at the same time, nobody would slurry the fine stones.

What's open to debate is how much, what to scuff the surfaces with and what level of "waking up" is desirable.

To me, this is surprisingly nice, but it's novel - I wouldn't have a practical use for it as it's just as easy to use the settled-in stone and bias the cut only at the very edge (like the rolling before unicorn).

If someone was used to the cutting power of synthetics or came over from waterstones, they might do this in an effort to try to get the stone to act like one they were used to. This kind of stuff is why there are so many arguments about what natural stones do, and then it's compounded by the fact that most new black hard stones outside of those sold by dans aren't as fine as this stone, anyway, and some of the trans stones sold now aren't that fine, either.

Cutting speed of soft stones from various vendors, even when treated the same on the surface, probably varies by a factor of 3. Dan's and Nortons softs are kind of finer and slower, which isn't really what most of us are looking for. At one point, a vendor named "natural whetstone" sold very even strong cutting softs and hards (the hards were just slightly finer soft stones), and they were the bees knees for fast cutting with novaculite - different mine, different stone characteristics despite similar density.

Last I saw that fellow's stones, they didn't look the same as mine, so I couldn't even say to go to a certain vendor to get something specific and even that is true of norton. A true hard (translucent) stone from norton can vary quite a lot, and some of the packaged soft stones look to me like pike washitas. And some of the later washita stones without a grade weren't any treat - either.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#102

Re: This is sort of a loaded situation...

Wiley Horne

David and all,

This is an excellent series on all the stones. The takeaway from it all, it appears to me, is that natural stones are a never-ending study in nuance and variability.

So now let me put this in an aggressive way, not to be argumentative, but to try to find a bottom to this inquiry:

Hypothesis: Natural stone mines, the veins of rock yielding gradable stone, whether in Japan or Arkansas—are played out. Your odds of finding a really good stone on the new market are slim and none. Therefore, the practical solutions for us are (1) find a dealer in used vintage oil or water stones we trust, and pay their price, or (2) use manmade, whether King, ceramic, diamond or what have you.

True or False?

Wiley

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#103

Re: I will make an exception…

Steve Voigt

…to my current aversion to posting to stand up for Arks a bit. And to make the discussion of them a little less black and white.

Bill says: "Someone recommended grinding the surface of an ARK stone … so it would cut as fast as a stone 1/3 the price?"

I'm not sure where this 1/3 number comes from. If you pay full price for a Dan's finish stone, it is comparable (in price) to a fine waterstone, and less than many. And you don't have to pay full price. My Dan's trans Ark came from Sierra Trading Post and was $40, I think. I also have a very nice unbranded Washita I got on Ebay for about the same price. As David has shown in his pics, both of these stones acquit themselves very well when compared to other finishing stones.

As far as abrading goes: Larry's video and Warren's many posts have created the impression that there is no middleground between "abrade every time" and "never abrade." Nonsense. I abrade mine infrequently, maybe after a couple weeks, maybe a couple months. It keeps them flat and cutting well. And as David's pics show, a freshly abraded stone will still leave a keen edge. And they settle in pretty quickly; at least the initial brashness fades pretty fast.

In summary, oilstones are economical, they need far less maintenance than waterstones, they cut plenty fast and leave a good edge. I could care less if people don't want to use them, but to ridicule them as inefficient or outmoded is just ignorant.

And to Wiley: where did you get the notion that Arkansas mines are played out? As Dave mentioned, Dan's is still producing very high quality stones.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#104

Not defending wiley...

David Weaver

.though his manners are much better than mine and sometimes I feel like I should!!

There has been a lot of blog type and vendor type information about good quality fine stones becoming scarce. I think there may have been an economic industrial viewpoint for that and Dan's has blown it away.

I am not a water carrier for anyone, so my fascination with dan's is just as a stone pig - every first quality stone I've gotten from them on the fine side, and every second I've gotten from their webpage, and several from sierra trading, etc....all of the black stones are a lot alike.

Joel had done a story at one point about the price of the norton 8x3x1/2 vs. the 8x2x<1 stone. The former was $79 and the latter was $169 or so. I asked why so high and norton's answer was that the level of waste in the full thickness stones was so high. I'm still confused as to how they have so many clear veins 1/2 inch thick but not 0.8 inches thick, especially given some narrowness of the latter type allows for less than 3" wide.

But that was the story, hard to get.

Fast forward to dan's. Dan has raised the bar on first quality stone price :b but the trans and black stones are the best I have ever seen anywhere. The bone colored trans in this thread is a thing of beauty. Dan's milky colored trans stones are just as fine or finer. What's the difference between Dan's and norton? I don't know for sure but dan said this:

* there is no supply issue on fine stones as long as the economic incentive is there to go deep enough to get them.

I said something about getting clear stones on the razor forum and someone who had taken a tour of dans said "no, it's not that hard - I recall seeing giant blocks of clear stone at dan's and they were slicing them into more stones". I think either the stock that dans is pulling from the deep is either clearer than nortons, or there is some labor factor that dan is willing to go to, and to finish stones where those issues that norton had aren't a dan's issue. Or both.

The person who took that tour showed me a picture of a giant billet of true hard (like 2.6+ specific gravity) material being cut on a giant table. It must've been a thousand pounds of rock. Good mostly clear looking wonderful material.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#105

Separately - a very good point made

David Weaver

...the manipulation of the stones is on a spectrum. The edge I showed is a very fine edge. It's actually free of the small defects that occur on a clear black stone that I usually don't capture in photos.

I can't say what one person would use better than another, but the feel of the stone in this middle setting was nice, and the edge is honed by the stone on both sides and once the wire edge is removed, the edge is not torn up.

It becomes a good bit harder to get an edge as good across various steel hardnesses once more porous stones are used.

I could advocate for the washita, but the truth is the one I've taken pictures of is one of my finer washitas, and may of the fine ones out there just don't cut that well. It's an example of why buying 10 stones and keeping two may be better than buying two (if one bothers to go through the labor).

The lack of use of natural stones probably has a lot to do with the lack of desire of folks learning to manipulate them. Larry's making planes. I know when I'm making planes or refitting planes, I'm looking for speed (the same reason that I buff the wire edge off of the cap and deburr the front of the cap after filing or heavy grinding - it can be done in 10 or 15 minutes by hand). If larry is finishing his irons by hand or demonstrating a lot in person, then he's going to be biased toward completing the job first and fineness second.

In short, I never scuffed this stone before intentionally and waited after I flattened it for it to slow down. But I kind of liked this!! it's between what I did the first time and my normal MO of letting a stone settle way in to minimize the wire edge.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#107

Re: This is sort of a loaded situation...

David Weaver

So, for oilstones - dan's goes as deep as economics will allow. Not a huge fan of their soft stones, their "hard" relatively inexpensive stones are a decent finish stone, but not a true hard.

Their true hard, black and translucent stones branded "dan's" and not sold by someone else where they say "these came from dan's" are as good as anything I've ever seen from any of the types. If a 1/2" thick black or trans stone can be found at retail and glued to another half inch stone to make the whole thing feel like a full sized stone, it's effectively as good as any ark finish stone and lifetime is only limited by the ability to avoid dropping (fortunately, I didn't do that, but they don't tolerate being dropped).

Halls/preyda - OK, but while dan's black is available, there's no great reason to buy their black stones (i Had a couple - they release the odd particle here or there and just aren't as subjectively good).

Norton, can't tell - I've gotten some borderline finishers from their stones (faster, translucent stones that are on the bubble with small pores, etc). They could go back to the mine and get a new dose and everything could change.

As far as japanese stones:

* ohira mine is still operating last I checked. Their stones are OK. There can be some spectacular stones from them, too. You just don't know as the buyer and a moderate quality large suita is in the $400-$500 range. They will have association and mine stamps on them and be OK

* new old mine stones (nakayama, okudo, shinden, etc) - some of that stuff can be old stock that was stored and never stamped. But it's often sort of blah material that looks good and the association allows stamping of mines now where it wasn't stamped originally - risky bet

Any new dealer with anything average will try to get top price. Anything that's really spectacular will be higher yet. My opinion, it's hard to really go get good stuff without just buying a huge pile of used stones and then keeping the best older stuff. That's what I did. It was a huge time investment, and on break even terms, most would find it not worth it. Fortunately, my buyee and etsy and paypal records will show no profit, but at the volume I moved, I guess it could be subject to checking. Never happened. Making a profit on stones intentionally will yield not that much profit if one is honest, and then you get to have a business that files taxes and needs to be insured. No thanks.

My favorites, though, are the slightly odd shaped pieces that cut like magic (which doesn't mean they're 10 times better than anything else - it just means they have a combination of qualities that makes them fast for what their composition is supposed to be, fine for their speed and tough on the surface and pleasant to use for their purpose. They're a little better in all the places where it counts.).

If someone is just looking for sharpening capability, I'd avoid buying stones from any dealers in volume - you end up with, let's say, a $1k stone that's really worth a third to half of that at best (unless the cachet of the dealer can be transferred to the next buyer) and there's a good chance that a little $110 slice of suita like the one I showed above may beat it. You get into the conundrum that I did - on the left, I have a 2kg pretty block of nice cutting. On the right, I have a short and inexpensive piece of stone that looked really impressive in the picker's ad on buyee and when it showed up, it easily matched what their demo showed. What am I going to use when I'm working? I could fight to get the most out of the bigger stone and then easily match that with the other one - eventually the big one goes. Hopefully it wasn't too expensive.

I think the odds are just against the buyer, and the sellers and distributors know more about the stones than the buyers usually do - especially in regard to separating aesthetics vs. capability. Big push for everyone wanting kiita stones in hte last decade. Kiita stones are usually soft and a little coarse. Once in a while a real trooper comes through. But nondescript barber shop pulled stones that are old and well used may be a real trooper 7 out of 10 times, and a kiita stone of the same shape 1 out of 20. Karasu is a popular decoration sold by dealers - but karasu stones are often glassy and scratchy. What's the chance that they match a good vintage green tomae stone for every day use? less than 50%, but at much greater cost.

There's much value to be made in convincing people that these are great stones. Some of the new ones are great - or may be great for something slightly different than as sold (a stone sold as a razor stone but that's too coarse may be a great tool finisher, but if you struggle sharpening a razor on one and you're assured by someone else that it's a good razor stone, then how do you know? A great razor stone, you just rub a razor on it any way you want to use it, linen and strop and you have a comfortable shave. Most of the modern razor stones being sold are either glassy, and too coarse when slurried or they're soft and too coarse to match the vintage barber shop pulls.

what if you get 3 barber shop pulls and two aren't that great? well, all three would cost less than a barber sized new stone, and now you have one great stone and two that you can wait to find a use for.

i'm sort of going in circles with this. Going through a bunch of mediocre stones in person (where there are some that are great and just what you want) is a whole different proposition in a store in japan where there are 150 stones to try. They'll be cheaper there, too. I think I probably bought 15 stones in total from dealers in japan or the US. I don't have any of them at this point. If any would've been better than the stones that I kept, I'd still have them instead of the stones I have now.

Final answer - for natural stones, best bet is to buy 5 washitas, keep one fine one, one coarse one, and buy one good trans or black stone (vintage trans is fine, black new from dan's is the best bet there). Everything else that I've gotten (new coticules, etc, all iffy. Vintage coticules have been better on average, too, but they're usually expensive and some are stinkers).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#108

The other real issue with japanese finishers..

David Weaver

...stones that are a little coarse are not uncommon, and sometimes fast.

. stones that are really fine and really slow are not uncommon

(talking about natural japanese stones)

Neither of these should be worth that much money, but if they are even and work well, they will match the 1 in 100 stone that kind of matches both of the above stones in one. As in, use the first of the above stones ,and then kiss the edge of a tool with the second. The result is pretty hard to top with any single stone and the combination is usually faster.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#109

Re: This is sort of a loaded situation...

Wiley Horne

Thank you, David. I know that was a pain to write down.

So, to get down to cases, here is Dan’s bench stone page:

https://www.danswhetstone.com/product/combination-bench-stones/

1. Can someone who wants to use natural oilstones go here and get outfitted? Assume they hollow grind. What is the sharpening sequence?

2. You have your special washita—can something similar be had other than by sorting through many stones with a discerning eye and skill?

Maybe Steve or Warren will have an opinion.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#110

Re: This is sort of a loaded situation...

Orlando in So. Fl.

Like Wiley, I'm also interested in acquiring a fine washita, or similar quality, to add to my oilstone collection

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#111

Re: This is sort of a loaded situation...

Steve Voigt

1. Can someone who wants to use natural oilstones go here and get outfitted? Assume they hollow grind. What is the sharpening sequence?

2. You have your special washita—can something similar be had other than by sorting through many stones with a discerning eye and skill?

Hi Wiley,

If you have a grinder, a tried and true approach is to pair a medium or fine india stone with a hard black or trans ark. Add a bare leather strop and you're set. I did this for years.

I also recommend an Atoma 400 grit diamond plate to resurface stones. A cheaper alternative is 60-80 grit loose SiC on a piece of glass. Very cheap, but coarse and kind of a hassle. I still use this method on my india stone and save the diamond plate for my hard stones.

Things get a little more complicated when you want a tweener stone. The tweener stone is nice because the India is soft and can get bits of wire edge embedded in it, which is a pain. With a tweener, you can skip the India unless you need to raise a really fat wire edge. Dave is right that a vintage Washita is the best choice here. I have a soft ark--I think it's from natural Whetstone--that works just fine. Dave says the soft arks from Dan's are too fine and I trust what he says. But bottom line, a tweener stone is a luxury and not essential--the two stone method will work fine.

At the end of the sharpening sequence, one can also add abrasive stropping to further refine the edge, but it's not essential. I've messed around with a lot of compounds but mostly I keep coming back to my bare strop.

Finding a vintage Washita is not really that hard, unless you're Dave and have insanely high expectations. :D Watch Dave's video on identifying Washitas and buy a nice looking unbranded stone off ebay. You might strike gold on the first try--I did!

But to repeat my bottom line, start with the two stones that are readily available. You can get fancy and add on from there, but it's not essential. That's really all there is to it.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#112

dan's and washita.

David Weaver

Dan's black and a slurried washita would probably be my go-to (or not necessarily slurried, just agitated if you want to use the washita as a middle stone prior to a black or trans stone).

Actually black or trans from dans.

Nearly all washitas are good. Their level of coarseness only varies a little except for the very finest and then the rest of their behavior is in how you use them. They're safe to buy used, just as long as you avoid the listings where people think the're a $100+ stone.

There are some on ebay from time to time for about $50, once in a while less, often not labeled as washita.

UK sellers usually have half a dozen at any one time, but shipping from the UK is expensive. While I notice the difference in fineness from one to the next, I don't know if most would notice that much - especially if you can abrade the surface.

Flatness can be an issue if they're heavily worn - I flatten the stones that have a lot of sway by using the idler (hard contact point) on a cheap belt sander - and outside with a mask if there's no breeze.

I just checked naturalwhetstone.com and their pictures of softs still look good. Actually, many of the inexpensive softs are really good coarse stones - NW's are good, so are the ones marked "case" brand, etc - the ones with kind of banding on the surface. They're generally coarse and fast.

IF the washita seems a challenge (could be out of flat, always used, etc), a soft from one of the non-dan's places above, then a "hard" from dans (not true hard, but one the grade below) and the black or trans is a really nice progression.

I talked to dan on the phone years ago (or rather, he was over the shoulder of the CS guy) and they don't have access to real washita. Their washita grade stone is just really soft fragile low density stone (which they readily stated) and it's not worth having - mine was broken before it got to me (no big deal, I was curious to see what a really low density soft was like and it wasn't expensive), but the real issue with it was very soft and fragile and didn't hold its structure on the surface that well. It just ended up feeling like it was crushed on the surface and lost the fast bite that the cheap softs above have.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#113

Re: This is sort of a loaded situation...

David Weaver

If I had 20, i'd just start dealing them out. As of now, I think I have about 6, and two are "normal" and the rest oddballs.

Best place to look for them is ebay (if you can't look locally - I'm sure they show up for a few dollars at flea markets as they were super common stones - even my dad had one without knowing it).

Try for one that you can tell is a washita (earwax type color and look mottled in with some white, and if you can see across a corner in the pictures, they have sort of a waxy look at the edge) - and try for flat. I've learned to flatten them with a belt sander idler pretty quickly, but not much else is quick, and they smell like fiery death when flattening them.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#114

Japanese "Barber Oilstone"

David Weaver

A very hard and slow ceramic stone. Think much like spyderco if spyderco made giant 8x3x1 inch stones.

I've never tried to wake this stone up, but suspect that the particles aren't actually that fine - they're just dull on the surface from use. It's almost flat, and that's how it'll stay - it'd be a bear to flatten by hand.

Same "clink clink" noise as a coffee cup.

Better as a burnisher, the surface has to be absolutely clean (or whatever is on it will beat up an edge) and less than significant pressure results in almost nothing.

As slow as stones like this are, they're good for things like the hand edge roll, but you have to use them so long and with enough pressure that it's hard to get an edge photo perfect (they won't remove much, not even middle stone scratches and the pressure may result in minor defects - there are some of those in various spots on this blade, but i misplaced my normal blade, so they may have already been there).

Not available in the US, but seen regularly in antique pickers piles of stones on japan's version of ebay (that's how I got this one).


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#115

Pictures of the stone

David Weaver

Pictures of the stone, front and back.



Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#116

Soft India?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"because the India is soft "

"India Stone" is a Norton trade name for aluminum oxide stones. I have one I have sharped kitchen knives on for decades and it is still fairly flat. I would call this stone exceptionally hard. Maybe there are differing grades of India hardness?

Silicon carbide of that particle size on glass is not the best choice for abrading. Silicon carbide is a brittle abrasive and readily crushed. Trapped between two similarly hard surfaces I would expect it to crush to finer abrasive quickly. No hands on experience but I would try it on Corian and see if it lasted longer and cut faster. Even better could be to sprinkle 220 grit diamond grits on Corian.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#117

Re: This is sort of a loaded situation...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Assume they hollow grind. You lost me here. My guess is you don't hollow grind your Japanese chisels. Why treat a chisel like a piece of junk? There are situations where the wedging action is important; a flat bevel makes a better wedge.

I would recommend a soft Arkansas over a translucent or black Arkansas. I think a smooth soft Arkansas gives a better surface than a finer stone that is roughed up. If you feel the need to abrade to get the stone to cut, it is probably too fine a stone for your purposes. As I mentioned earlier, if you abrade a stone you are then sharpening with the resultant scratches, not with the underlying grit.

I use Washita stones that were mined about forty years ago. I like them, but I don't have experience with other types.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#118

Re: Soft India?

Steve Voigt

Bill, I mean soft compared to a hard or trans ark. Compared to those, an India stone will cut much faster, dish more quickly, and gouge more easily. And as I mentioned, metal can get embedded, which doesn't happen with the harder stones.

The names of India stones are misleading. There's very little difference between medium and fine, and both are what I'd call coarse, aggressive stones--very effective as the first stone after hollow grinding.

For those who don't have a grinder, something coarser would be needed for bulk metal removal. A waterstone or a Norton Crystolon will work. I have had bad luck with what Norton calls a coarse India stone, and do not recommend them. They don't seem to like being resurfaced the way a medium or fine does.

Regarding SiC and glass, that is a standard way of flattening oil stones and it works very well. Yes, the SiC breaks down, but you just sprinkle a little more on. You can also stick PSA laminate sheet down to the glass, which saves the glass. Lee Valley sells them.

I bought a pound of the SiC on Ebay years ago. I think it was $4.25 plus shipping and I'll never have to buy more--a little goes a long way. But there's no doubt a diamond plate works better and is way more convenient.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#119

soft vs. hard

David Weaver

Over the years, I've gotten a bunch of india stones. As well as crstolon.

Subjectively, the older ones are far harder (in both cases), but I can't say for sure if that's an issue of the older stones being harder when sold, or if they've gotten harder over the years. I'd guess the latter, but it's nothing other than a guess.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#120

Re: This is sort of a loaded situation...

David Weaver

hollow grinding with CBN or even any graded wheel doesn't harm japanese chisels.

I don't do it because it's not aesthetically pleasing, but I've never noticed any issue as I may grind used chisels or plane blades initially if they show up basket cases.

Their temper isn't as fragile as people like to contend - temper at 300F is often an unusably hard japanese chisel and the effective temper for a really hard chisel made of white 1/2 or a swedish equivalent will be around 325F.

The steel on japanese chisels sparks so well that the backing metal gets hot and not the edge, and they become undesirable to handle. Not saying that someone can't stab them into a burned edge, but they grind better than their reputation would suggest.

As far as a soft ark vs. an abraded trans or black stone, it's not that easy to make a blanket statement. A dan's "soft" or a norton may be as fine as a finish stone or close once they're pretty much shut down, but they don't produce an edge finer than the one I showed as abraded.

The other softs available (smiths, natural whetstone, "case" branded, etc) will never work as finely as the abraded trans or black pictures here, and there is a range of suitability - 400 grit diamond hone on a trans or black stone is never going to create the kind of aggressiveness that much deeper scratches do.

But, trans and black stones are expensive and that's washita territory (almost all washitas).

There is a bigger difference between washitas of grade than of age. I made the comment that some of norton's later washitas are unimpressive, but I think they had given up on grade under the behr manning label and sold stones they may not have earlier (the ungraded type that just say "washita oilstone"). The behr manning graded stones (no 1, lilywhite) are still good stones, and there are very very fine older stones, but they are not as common and usually are placed in a razor box.

I get the inclination sometimes to stock washitas and grade them and sell them at cost, but the way they've caught on some, it's hard to get them in the states and I'd need to charge $80 just to break even.

The reason I'd even do that is that most people don't complete sharpening. When I put videos on youtube suggesting a grind and then a hone at a higher angle with a washita (no other steps), that suggestion was to help people understand what a completed edge is like. It's immediate confirmation that someone using finer stones isn't completing the job when they come back with "I'm getting better edges than I have before". Then, with that understanding, they can go back to their finer stones and start to make a decision about whether or not they can get enough better of an edge with finer stones than learning to use the washita well. The reality is that other than for paring chisels and carving tools, the answer is usually no. Some familiarity with any decent washita will yield edges at least as good as an 8k waterstone with a very desirable wire edge quality (fanned out, thin and not damaging when it comes off).

It usually results in some kind of shock that such a poorly regarded stone has existed among us and can do the job so easily.

Kind of like finding out that remington's new rifle model that's got tons of "improvements" isn't as good as the one dad had from 60 years ago.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#121

Smiths Hard Arkansas

David Weaver

Before the internet and strong grading information, it appears that smiths and some others sold "hard" stones that don't meet the definition we're used to (nearly poreless). Norton's hards have always been black or trans, or gray trans.

This is a "smiths hard". We would consider it a soft arkansas with some tooth, and it has just a hint of washita behavior. Not sure why that is - it's a bit more toothy, but it's an interesting stone.

Here's the issue - this one was $10 plus $10 shipping. It's fantastic at that. I often see them listed for a price that one would buy a used true hard ($100). They are no good at that. It says hard on the box and someone does an ebay search to figure out a price, and then that's that.

This is also a "teachable" moment - this stone can still be manipulated based on steel hardness, settling in of the stone and pressure.

First, a softer carbon steel iron- stropped and not buffed on the opposite side (notice that there are little bits left in the edge - this would be a good usable sharp iron and the speed of the stone makes it likely that most would do better iwth this stone than a trans or black - they'd finish the job easily).


if the opposite side is finished with the buffer rather than this stone and a bare strop, notice the little nits at the edge are gone - this is a better edge.


And after that iron (which is probably mid-high 50s in hardness), my house O1 iron, which is more like 62/63, tempered only enough to stop chipping.

Notice how the edge is a little finer - the abrasive in arkansas stones gives some ability to game edge finish quality on a given stone by matching steel hardness. To see this, look less at the scratches on the back and more directly at the edge.


Now, here's the important point. This stone isn't as good as my washitas, but it was (and should be cheap) and is otherwise *great* uniform quality. It's a fine soft arkansas stone and I don't abrade it. If you stick your neck out and buy a new $180 trans or black stone, will it be better than the finish of this iron after 15 seconds on dursol on softwood (hardwood would be better - this ate up the white pine that I tried it on because the wood is just too soft).

The answer is no. This is kind of like the comment I made to wiley yesterday about two matched cheap japanese stones generally beating really expensive finishers that are fine and relatively fast for japanese stones.


Both the bevel and back side could be addressed in 15 seconds if this was done on cherry instead of white pine. The edge rounding would be slightly less. This is yet another budget setup that's fast, easy to complete and better than expensive stones of any type.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#122

Re: Smiths Hard Arkansas

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have a Smith's Catalog from January 1978, I think their first catalog. They did mostly wholesale business for several generations, but opened a retail store in 1968.

In the catalog they have four grades: Washita, soft, hard, and black.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#123

Re: Smiths Hard Arkansas

David Weaver

I always thought all black stones were pretty much pore free, and then I got a glimpse of a couple of inexpensive stones a couple of year ago and they had poor uniformity, lots of pores, and were capable of finishing.

I don't know that much about smiths except that I've bought a few new stones (on plastic bases) and a few old ones like this "hard", which is probably only 70s old or so.

I like this stone. I like the really coarse softs, but I haven't seen a trans from them. If at some point, they were relabeling other mines' stones, then maybe that's not an accurate statement. Not sure who owns the names now. I thought the case brand was entirely owned by zippo now, or zippo by case, and maybe they also have the smiths name and maybe not. It's hard to keep track of, but I've seen so many stones that when someone tells me they saw a black stone that was no good, I know there's a good chance of it.

It's hard to find a stone that passes light really well that's not a really fine stone, so that's my suggestion to nervous people. Not all really fine stones pass light (dan's has mid 2.6SG stones that don't pass light), but what I've seen, all stones that are novaculite and that pass light really easily are very fine (I think the pores inside the less dense stones scatter the light).

The stone I pictured here can be manipulated. Over lunch, I fished around with it with carpenter XHP, which shuts down most stones and slows down strong washitas. I'll finish the back of the same iron on it now and see if it's visually better.

All of these little bits and bobs are good examples of why familiarity with a set of tools and stones is more important than exactly what they are. Not that it's important for anyone to see here, but I prepared an edge with this stone, the dursol on pine, and no buffer and no strop. The results were circus type fodder.

I later tried with XHP and the results were still decent, but the softer iron did better with that setup - XHP really needs something else as a middle stone as the chromium grades novaculite way too much.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#124

Clarifying hollow grind

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I never grind to the bevel tip. I want to preserve the straight line of the bevel tip I established "in the beginning". So grinding never has any opportunity to do anything to the part of the chisel that comes to a point.

The hollow, even on a 7" wheel that I use, is not very hollow. I can not imagine that this tiny depression could affect any application of the chisel. It is so shallow I polish it away with a few resharpenings and it has to be renewed.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#125

pictures of the stone

David Weaver



A pleasing stone to use. After I did over the edge with dursol, this is the resultant thin shavings.