Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

Posts

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#126

Black Hone Slate

David Weaver

My guess is hone slates were always something used when someone didn't want to pay for a novaculite hone. They're slower, the edge is always a little less fine, but they're not uncommon in England and I've seen them at flea markets here in PA.


Hone slates are popular in razor circles because they work well enough to give a rough shave, and then can be stepped up with pastes or powders.

This looks OK, but if you look at the very edge, it just never quite gets fine, and combined with the slow honing, it makes for something that just won't be used unless nothing better is available.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#127

pic of the stone

David Weaver


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#128

The real Llyn Idwall

David Weaver

I think the other one really is just dark gray trans ark. I found another container of shaving stones (stones kept just to use on razors).

There are two idwalls in it. This is the result of the first .


This was the other one that I'm not sure what it is, but it may not be an arkansas stone, either. Both are extremely fine.

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/md/read/id/495209/sbj/llyn-idwall/

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#129

Picture of the stone

David Weaver

Gray with characteristic light colored dots.

Usually around $50-$75, often small (This one is almost as big as an 8x2 bench stone). At the time of this post, there's a high dollar one on ebay ($150) that I attempted to make an offer on a little closer to the going rate, but the automated system says "no thanks, pal" (vince mcmahon voice), the seller must want close to his ask.


beware grayish green and greenish blue stones that look similar and have sort of waves of dots in them in more of a pattern - those are often a stone called a dalmore. Those are not as fine.

These are sometimes called "grecian hone", not sure why - the idwalls that is. They are novaculite and feel like very fine novaculite, but the dalmores are not (I think they're sedimentary).

A reasonable sized idwall is literally the equal (maybe slightly better) of the finest trans and black ark stones, but out and about in much smaller numbers.

Best used with oil.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#130

Re: Picture of the stone

Mike In Los Angeles

Would be nice to see a few more photos of that stone if you have time, might solve the riddle of identifying a stone I got in a bundle last year. Matches your description of its behavior too.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#132

Re: Picture of the stone

David Weaver

I'll get a few more pictures of it and another more dotted gray idwall.

i think when they don't have the typical characteristics of each type (e.g., charnley green stones with red streaks on them), it starts to get hard to tell exactly what they are.

Charnley stones have been a bit softer in my experience, though.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#133

Re: Picture of the stone

David Weaver

I think the fractures would have a different shape (conchoidal) if that was an idwall, but am not an expert on them by any means (and haven't broken any of mine). I'll see tomorrow if either of mine has chips on it that would spill the beans, so to speak.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#134

Re: Picture of the stone

Mike In Los Angeles

This one is weird to me, soft but fine. Doesn’t stay as flat as a trans or even a hard arkansas but cuts fast.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#135

Linde A - Paraffin Buffing Bar

David Weaver

The linde A abrasive is so slow on wood due to its tiny particle size that I thought it might be interesting to see on a new buffer wheel, if it could just barely refine a washita edge or a larger oxide edge (tried both) that would be quick to get to, and leave an edge as crisp as the finest hand honed edge that I can make (in terms of picking up a super thin shaving). I think the answer is yes.

In order to get the linde on a buffing wheel, I melted it into paraffin. Not sure that's the right medium for a buffing bar - we'll see - it dries to things and is a bit more sticky as a wax than whatever is in buffing bars.

Reason for the buffing wheel instead of doing things by hand is simply how fast the buffer can work and how much better it is at avoiding contamination.


Still on a low angle to see if there is a strength problem and even with this tiny amount of round over, I found no edge problems off of the 23 or so degree secondary.

Thin shaving pickup even at crazy thinness was crisp, finish on an SYP board where the hard rings are usually polished and what's in between them isn't - really nuts. The two parts are almost identical in shine (looking toward the garage door windows)



This is still sort of "unicorn 1 buffing", the bevel side has the bulk of the work and the back side very minimal (diagonally across the buffing wheel - doing some abrading, but not much).

the procedure before this is to refine the edge a little bit more on the washita and then tease most of the wire edge off so that there isn't a big stiff wire edge going to the slow cutting buff, but the buff has to be more than a strop because it needs to replace the scratches at the very tip with something much more refined than the washita.

Still a very quick sharpening process, no threat to getting off track while doing "actual work (TM)"

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#136

Picture of the "stone"

David Weaver

no stone, just a container of tiny white alumina particles.

To make the bar, all I did is find a plastic container, but a big puff of linde A in it and then torch half of a bar of gulf wax held in pliers (it melts off and dribbles into the tray.

The tray stays liquid enough to stir for a while and then you just end up with a strange misshapen buffing bar that can be used on the wheel or anywhere that you can put a drop of oil or mineral spirits down to dissolve a bit of the bar tip off on a surface. More convenient than the tiny white dust.


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#137

Also with iron oxide bar

David Weaver

If you recall from the buffing bar tests, I also had a very inky iron oxide bar that has no alumina in it. It was super fine but too slow to use by hand.

I tried that same bar on this wheel, and the buffer has enough power to use it and get very similar results.

BUT, the iron oxide in it in tiny particles makes for a very inky bar and everything is iron oxide red - your hands, the compound that's flung onto the iron, anything below the buffer, whatever you rest the bar on.

That said, it's a viable alternative to this if the bar is wrapped and used sparingly.

Another example of media that's just too slow to use by hand, but the buffing wheel can make it usable and use it to mimic an extremely crisp submicron edge without having to use a bonkers fine stone or slow regimen.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#138

one other side benefit

David Weaver

(I read through some MSDS from other buffing bars - it appears that most bars are some kind of glycerine or fatty acid, and far higher content in abrasive concentration. This bar by weight is probably only 25% abrasive. Commercial bars are more like 75%+

If the ingredient is glycerine or fatty acid, I wonder if it's rendered so that they're basically soap - i'm guessing not, but who knows).

The other side benefit, though is that even with a shallow bevel angle, even this tiny tip rounding seems to be somewhat protective of the edge. Haven't planed silica laden wood yet, but noticed no small lines on work yesterday, even planing through knots, and no need to maintain more than one shallow angle on plane blades. Very very little material removed, so little chance for error with geometric issues.

A nice option, but does require the second wheel that doesn't see a more aggressive abrasive.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#139

Fine buffing compound

Winston

Impressively thin wood shaving! Maybe you should enter a kezorou-kai competitionon. :D

Are you saying that there is a benefit to using a compound that's finer than the 5 micron stuff you've used in the past?

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#140

practically...

David Weaver

..i don't know. For entering a thinnest shaving contest, there may be some.

The faster compound makes buffing sort of an afterthought, and the edge is really strong. Clearance is only a little bit less perfect. For chisels, the fast compound is much nicer to use.

I can't imagine them allowing a western plane with a buffer at kzerou-kai competitions!! Actually, doing this by hand is probably still best because you can leave the biting edge, but day to day, this is a whole lot more practical and takes about a third of the time (this being the really fine compound wheel and honing off most of the wire edge so that the treated edge is only tiny).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#141

Re: Picture of the stone

David Weaver

There are lots of fine-gritted hone slates in the UK, but not so many being sold now with any provenance.

Water of Ayr comes to mind as the finest that I can think of, and in Germany, the thuringian stones (they are a bit overrated because some enterprising shavers managed to drive the typical yellow green hone value from $100 with a label to about $600 or a little more).

I've had a bunch of different slates - they vary a lot, and I've only kept the one black one in this thread. They generally slurry more easily than novaculite stones so they can be hard to control for really fine work and dug into.

Never was able to get a WOA hone - cheapest good black labeled stone that I've seen of any size was $425. Rarity makes them worth more now than they were when they shut down the mine, and small alumina and synthesized small abrasives (and lack of silversmithing) probably put the mine out of business.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#142

two llyn idwalls

David Weaver

pictures of both - one with more waves of dots, the other with fewer - both extremely hard:










Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#143

Try bee wax

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think it will be a better vehicle for the abrasive.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#144

Gray China (Guangxhi?) natural waterstone

David Weaver

Woodcraft sells these. I've had maybe two from them and 6 elsewhere. They can vary - some self slurry, some are gritty feeling, and some are smooth on slurry and very sticky feeling on clear water (the last are the best type I've come across).

They smell slatey or chalkey. to work up a slurry on them, a fine diamond hone is perfect, or you can make a slurry stone out of something similar (see stone picture attached to this).

They are pretty easy to use with a slurry, and on clear very sticky on something like a blade back, slow and sort of unpleasant to use. On small tools like carving tools, chisels and razors this stickiness isn't an issue. I think the reason they're not more popular is that they're slow and most people who try to use them with just water probably don't like what they find. I never tried using one with soapy water, but that may make them more workable (the slurry works fine).

slurried


clear


Not a great deal of difference. The edge finish is even, but there is a little bit of evidence of slurry dulling (which makes for a smoother feel rather than harsh initial bite - the dulling isn't significant enough to make them feel "dull")

Mujingfang or woodwell distributes the stones that woodcraft sells. I have gotten them from aliexpress, too - in my estimation, the ones that come with a picture of the same box that woodcraft has are less risk, but I've heard shaving folks say that they got four from woodcraft and two good, two not that great, etc.

too slow for flat tools on clear water as is, though, and slow on slurry - usable, but nothing stands out that would make you use them over another stone like an ark stone or idwall (the idwall is far better and can sometimes be found for a similar price or a little more).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#145

pic of the stone

David Weaver

two stones - the wet one is the one I tested (otherwise it would be lighter gray). The center one came from a razor supplier, and so did the piece on the right. The piece on the right self slurries a little and never finishes a razor that well, so parts of it get sawed off to make a slurry stone for other ones.

No difference in fineness scuffing the left most stone with a fine diamond hone (like broken in 400 grit atoma) or using a slurry stone from another stone (if the second slurry stone is more coarse, the slurry without scuffing the base stone will actually be more coarse)


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#146

Re: two llyn idwalls

Mike In Los Angeles

Thanks David. Mine looks different, doesn’t have waves etc. I’m still playing with it, don’t have enough experience to know what to make of it but I like it.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#147

Greasy/Coated India Stone

David Weaver

This stone appears to be an extra fine india or something of the type, but it's flat and near perfectly covered on all sides and edges with a layer of grease or something to shut down its cutting ability.

I've seen washitas maintained like this to sharpen razors, but this stone is from japan. These stones without being coated like this will cut evenly, relatively fast and leave a pretty strong wire edge.

tried with water


Tried with a dot of mineral oil (didn't try first as I was afraid it may remove the coating).

Interesting result -very slow, but look at the edge where finger pressure is concentrated.


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#148

Re: Greasy/Coated India Stone

David Weaver

pictures of the stone - the corner gives a glimpse of what's under the stone:


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#149

crest complete (And more dursol)

David Weaver

OK, washita edge with no buffer zinging off the wire edge (toothpaste would follow this).

"complete" is a whitening toothpaste (gritty) with mouth wash (stinky) added to it.


(this is also without any bevel work. The alternating back and forth of working the back and bevel prevents the wire edge from being so large).

Now, after crest complete - almost a minute. no black in the crest (on white pine). It did shine the metal up a little, and the stropping action was achieved, but it could've just been the white pine base that did this. since this was supposed to be a finish step, I worked back and forth to remove the wire edge.


To check to see how fast dursol would clean this up, I used white pine (this pine is just too soft - it's low density) and I couldn't really lean on it. Nonetheless, 10 seconds on the back and then 25 strokes on the bevel side freehand effectively makes the iron sharp.


Too much pressure combined with the too soft backer and the iron digs into the pine and cuts a sliver off.

Out of curiosity with this subpar performance, after taking a picture, I went back to the yellow pine lap that I used (much harder, but still soft compared to a metal lap or corian) and then 10 seconds of dursol - bliss.


This gives a good tip for dursol - don't use wood that's too soft. If you can't lean on it (cherry, SYP, etc, all OK) then no good.

(Sorry Mike, I don't have any scraps of MDF at the moment!!).

One last thought. Crest must have sugar or something similar in it - when it dries, it's STICKY. the iron needed to be washed off.

Dursol is still king. It's better than any finish stone that I've ever used of any type and doesn't even require follow-up stropping on leather (none was done here)

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#150

Re: crest complete (And more dursol)

Mike In Los Angeles

At least now we know the cutters are getting more care than the teeth