Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

Posts

Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#1

Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

David Weaver

as promised (and not welcomed by any!), I will start to add the finish from various stones, a post or two a day.

Thanks to winstons wonderful app, they'll be listed here. I'll comment about working speed that goes along with each picture.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#2

Kitayama waterstone

David Weaver

not particularly fast, not particularly fine. Needs a slurry to work, and if it doesn't have one, the stone loads and then the loaded areas actually deflect the edge to an amount that can be seen under the microscope.


Probably takes a solid 20-30 seconds to remove the back unicorn from uni lite, which really means that's about how long it should be used for any worn plane iron when flattening.

Richard's split policy is probably a good one for any of these slower stones.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#3

Fine washita

David Weaver

Not the finest washita that I have, but my favorite one for plane backs. Settled in (these pictures have been seen already).

First with heavy pressure and a wire edge fanning out - 10 seconds of heavy work and uni-lite is removed.

Second picture is 10 seconds more with light pressure, literally the work from picture one removed in that time. A real treat of a stone for sharpening anything.



Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#4

Shapton Cream

David Weaver

1.2 microns or so, very aggressive combination of binder and abrasive, and fairly hard on the edge. fast for its fineness, but slower in use than the washita, probably 20 seconds to remove uni-lite. light colored stone that makes spectacular diluted black slurry, but the color makes it look like more is going on than is actually going on.

Note compared to other stones just how strong and uninterrupted the abrasive grooves are on the iron.


These are known for being hard on the edges of razors and not a good shaving stone (but they can be used with a really light touch). Look at an edge that's actually in the ball park of 30-35 degrees total, you can imagine they'd be hard on an edge twice as acute.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#5

Fine White Okudo Suita

David Weaver

A nice stone, probably 20 seconds of time to remove uni-2. Slurry has to be managed on natural japanese stones (or not if chosen to go without). This stone works better with laminated tools as it's fast when it makes just a little bit of self slurry. As good of a practical fine finisher as can be found anywhere.

Good dimension (ability to be used with more or less pressure, slurry or not), but not as wide ranging on western tools as a washita.


Important to focus mostly on the last several thousandths of an inch as some stones like the washita seem to do the same thing at the edge as anywhere else, and stones that slurry tend to show the effect of the slurry in more aggressive work at the edge.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#6

Practical question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Does this site coupled with how ever Winston shrinks render sufficient resolution to make valid comparisons? If not post somewhere that has the resolution.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#7

Re: Practical question

David Weaver

All pics same size and scale.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#8

Re: Practical question

Wiley Horne

David,

He’s asking if Winston’s 100K resolution is as good as what you get on the external host sites.

I’m a big fan of Winston’s resizer!

Wiley

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#9

sorry, addressed differently

David Weaver

I took that to mean, is there a chance that the pictures could be scaled differently from each other so that the relative comparison isn't worthwhile.

No, all pictures start the same size and are scaled the same way.

As for the ultimate resolution and could we miss anything at the edge? I don't think so. The most stark thing so far that I've noticed is the wonderful straightness at the edge of the light pressure washita finish compared to most other thing short of the small diamonds and oxides (I'll do those later, but they generally will look nearly the same - nothing visible).

Limited focused depth of field and changes in software gain that I just don't feel like faffing with for each picture are a bigger problem in getting pictures of perfection than the resolution that these are posted at.

When two pictures look almost the same (adding a second japanese natural stone will show that), it's because what they do is almost the same (feels it, leaves a similar surface, etc). Any difference significant enough to be felt will be seen easily on these pictures.

Interestingly, the shapton is very hard on the very edge of an iron, but it's pretty quick. The edge that's shown settles in with some use just fine, but the initial sharpness feel is very transient. I always thought that was just due to wear, but it's probably partially due to the edge having no lateral support where it's ragged. That can be seen now whereas it's a little bit harder to see with a loupe.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#10

request

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

it is interesting to look at these pictures. But I don't have the experience looking and the feed back of looking then using to interpret what I am seeing. In the end give us a summary of what you have learned from this work and put it in terms of woodworking, and leave the confusion of shaving out of the discussion.

The results of these abrasions are different but are they significant and how?

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#11

Brief comments...

David Weaver

the brief comments with each picture about time spent flattening are pretty much that.

If a stone comes up short with sharpness, that'll be mentioned. In comparing most of these to the mysterious washita, where they come up short is in how long they have to be used and not fineness. Some can be fiddly to use, too (like the kitayama waterstone - it doesn't work well without lots of water and rolling slurry).

Will do on leaving the shaving out with one exception - one of these stones is going to be a graded razor stone from japan.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#12

Supremely Fine Japanese Natural Razor Stone

David Weaver

This is my finest effective razor stone from japan. Effective means that it will cut fast enough to use (not just burnish), and when slurried, the particles are as fine as one will find so that no matter which way it's used, it will create a sharp razor. Most japanese stones sold for razors don't really meet these three conditions that well.

This stone was sold by an antique dealer who liquidates barber shops and lists everything (he's not a stone specialist) on japan's version of ebay.

Shown as a comparison to the suita. Out of about 100 razor stones, this one has the finest particles I've seen, and any other harder stones that will slowly burnish an edge (not desirable, but sold now because those stones are available in abundance) show their true colors if slurry is made from them - they are aggressive and particles large, just as an ark stone would be if it was slurried.


Edge created with clear water (no slurry on the surface)


if this stone is used with very light pressure on razors (lighter than practical for tools, then the finish can be chased a bit finer). The point is less about what can be done with razors and more as above, what can be done with moderate pressure to finish tools. The cutting power is stronger than the washita, so it doesn't change as much with varying pressure in tools.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#13

question for David

Howard Pollack

Hi, when you buy stones off of the Japanese auction site do you usually pay for extra protective packaging or is that not necessary? Thanks. -Howard

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#14

very few will care about mines or stamps...

David Weaver

(When I bought used stones at the outset, I tried to buy mostly unstamped stones because at least half of the stamps are fake. This stone was perfectly uniform with no flaws, and about the same color as older shobu and nakayama stones - stones like that coming from people who pick razors shops usually do pretty well and if they're unstamped, they don't cost much and they're better than most current stamped stones -even legitimate stamped stones).

This stone ended up being one of the cheapest stones I ever bought (there are more folks looking for them to re-sell now, and such deals are scarce) at about $37 or something (figure after all is said and done, it costs about $70 to get a stone like that over here if it's bunched together with others by the proxy shipper and then sent on the ground).

It had glue on one end, and one corner is partially broken off, but not enough to affect function. the glue was a little loose, so I picked it off, and under it is this:

正本山合� �

That's not a specific stamp, but an older style stamp that specifies that the stone is a true finishing stone. IT may be used in combination with other stamps on newer faked or restamped versions, but usually fakers can't resist either clarifying that the stone is nakayama and often maruka (one of the few kanji with a circle around it).

The value of stamps is so high that now the legitimate dealers have decided they can mine-mark unmarked stones if they feel the characteristics are right. I don't agree with that, but never made a profit, so I don't really care. The used market at the time that I sold unstamped used and graded stones would pay twice as much for a stone with a bright purple fake maruka stamp on it and usually a bunch of other stuff all over the stone, and then physical or aesthetic flaws that never would've been stamped at all. People would buy a stone from me for $200 that I graded and showed comparative microscope pictures from (this is why I actually have this scope) on razor edges, and then gloat about a maruka stone that they had that they "only gave $800 for, but it's worth at least $3500 according to the dealer who sold it".

The fake stamp thing is a weird issue because there were dealers who specialize in selling stones in the US (not alex gilmore, by the way) as well as dealers in japan who specialize in selling to europe and the US and they have faked stamps off and on, ultimately getting to the point that it was ridiculous. There is no legal protection for the stamps that they used, so there's no recourse other than getting kicked out of trade groups, but if you're selling europeans and americans and quadrupling the price of stones, why care?

Ultimately, the association in japan decided that since there are a lot of unmarked stones around, the legitimate dealers may also start stamping stones based on their best guess at what they are. I don't like that, but I wanted to do two things:

* put pressure on the antisocial jerk dealers in the US who specialize in marking nearly valueless stones in japan, and then won't take returns - they'll sell them to unwitting beginners for 4-6 times what they are actually worth

* do an at-cost look at a whole bunch of stones, keep a few good ones, and make an expectation for the market that stones would otherwise be sold with some kind of proof about how they work

I bought two stones early on from alex. They were what he said they were and no fake stamps (well, one was more coarse than he said - a suita, but I learned in time that instead of getting what I thought was a steal, I got a fair price on that one and it had excellent feel and there's lots of room for actual use of a strong cutting stone like that - it's kind of the washita of japanese stones). I no longer have either one of them, and he asked if I would give a testimonial and put my name on his website with someone else's testimonial....that was weird, but all stone nuts are a little eccentric and if it was just mixed up from a bunch of emails with other people, that's OK. I'm wary of most other dealers - and no matter who the dealer is, it's always going to be about 3 times the price of what a stone would be in japan, and the standards may not be what you're expecting . They're running a business and have costs and can't just sit on 2/3rds of the stones and sell them as "just OK".

no more boring stories aside from the fact that out of a couple of hundred stones, this is the only one out of all of them that unexpectedly had an old stamp on it.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#15

Re: question for David

David Weaver

If I got expensive individual stones, I used their insurance. I tried to buy a volume of used stones and grade them instead, opting not to insure and then "wait and see".

Out of about 200 stones, probably 160 weren't insured, and 3 broke catastrophically. Maybe another 3 were damaged.

Doing what i was doing, those 3 (catastrophic) made tomonagura after I recut the broken halves into manageable regular-shaped pieces.

If you're going to buy a dozen or two stones and keep 3 that you really like, then I don't think insurance or packaging is necessary. If you buy a bunch in one lot, then sellers in japan do skimpy packaging and I'd pay for protective packaging or they'll all come over having pinballed each other in the box. IF you use buyee's insurance (they're a bugger to deal with if you have a problem and don't buy it, even if they caused the problem), they should make you use protective packaging on something like that, but they don't always.

Far more economical to use it if you buy a half dozen things, pay them to consolidate and have things shipped surface mail (there's a risk there, too, but if you can insure it and have the patience to wait, it should work out).

Not all stones make good tomonagura, either. A very fine slow stone that's a little softer is ideal and two of my three broken stones were that.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#16

The purpose of the omnibus...

David Weaver

..isn't unicorn related, or entirely.

There's a certain interest on my part to talk about how fast a stone works because some uni work is further buffing on the flat face, and some not. Some stones or oxides that look spectacular under a microscope, but may take a minute or literally have to be used after a finish stone as they won't remove all wear in a minute.

I'll comment about that.

This is more related to just seeing what exactly is going on at the edge of a blade when (in most cases) the bevel side is buffed to a polish, removing any deep scratches so that the actual depth of the stone's work can be seen on the back.

- Fast and coarse is mediocre unless fine enough to buff (then ok if you want to).

- Really fine and slow is OK if you want to stand over the stone and rehearse something unrelated in your head for a while

- Pretty fine and really fast is excellent for day to day work because you'll complete what you do each time you sharpen without having to count seconds close to 6 digits or scream each time you run into a contaminant right after you sharpen

There may be some usefulness to also compare the stone scratches to a buffer edge just to see if you may not feel the need to buff something after the stone because the finish difference isn't much (e.g., it's still a lateral move in clean wood to buff edges, and it's easy to do worse- a good crisp sharpened high polish edge in clean wood is always long wearing and strong pulling into the wood).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#17

Not unicorn related,  more clear

David Weaver

These back pictures have nothing directly related to the unicorn methods. I guess it's a bad time to post other curiosities because we're on a rail right now and anything that's remotely sharpening related could be confused as being unicorn content.

I feel type casted!

:)

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#18

Re: Practical question + another regarding scale..

John Aniano in central NJ

David,

Many of Winston's photos have a reference scale superimposed on the micrograph images. I know you have a different setup, but is it possible to have a notation of the scale or magnification?

Just my $0.02...

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#19

Hand American 0.5 micron Green Chrome Ox

David Weaver

Capable of a visual polish (nothing that shows scratches meets the standard of a visual polish though a partial polish will lead you to believe you're seeing one. Polishing whatever you're looking at with a pigment like this will let you know it was a hazy polish).

Speed: one minute to get to the picture with corian (first picture), and a second full minute to improve to the level of polish shown on the oxide-on-softwood picture - not practical for woodworking. Diamonds on a hard surface or in wood are far faster and functionally similar in terms of edge quality:

chrome ox on corian:


chrome ox follow-up on pine.


(these pigments have to be graded to get a finish like this. I have bought ungraded pigment before and it's pretty coarse. Still green, but coarse).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#20

Scale overlay

Winston

David, if you have a separate file with the scale overlay, I could provide you with a simple command line to overlay it on the images. Or I could provide a modified version of the app that could do that.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#21

Re: Practical question + another regarding scale..

David Weaver

all of these pictures are .02" tall.

I'd love to drop them somewhere permanent, and I have a wordpress account, but I'm too lazy.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#22

What else the creator of the weaver bevel post? 


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#23

Re: Scale overlay

David Weaver

I have been using a separate file and gauging it by pixel to size it and then placing it wherever it doesn't seem to intrude on interpretation of a picture. whatever is handy would be fine. command line would be OK, they're all in the same directory.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#24

Unknown Japanese White Alundum

David Weaver

This is an older early japanese attempt at a strong cutting white alundum sharpening stone. I can't tell if it's resin or vitrified, I would imagine it's a resinous stone, but a little porous. It needs water and a slurry or it loads quickly.

If one finds a group of sharpening stones in japan, you come across early fine synthetic stones. Lots of them. The idea that kings were something new is sort of weird, especially given synthetic alumina razor stones with binder have been around since at least the early 1900s.

This stone would've probably been described as JIS old standard of 5000 or 6000. It would work better if it was wet all the time.


The cost as part of a group was probably less than $10.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#25

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You said you "rub" in circles. Yet all your pictures are characterized by parallel intersecting scratch lines with about a 30 degree intersection. What is the origin of this ubiquitous scratch pattern.