Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

Posts

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#26

I do both

David Weaver

but most of the time finish with diagonal strokes (at least partially) into the edge to weaken a wire edge, so straight scratches remain.

whatever a stone seems to like to work quickly, I do when getting the first 5 or 10 seconds of work done. When you're working with any stone that doesn't allow good cutting action however you move a tool around (diamond on cast doesn't care which way you move it, for example, it just cuts any way). On stones sometimes, when there is an abrasive slurry, if one just pushes a blade up and down the stone, some of them will cause skidding (shaptons do) and you get better cutting action if focusing small strokes in a spot (to keep the metal in contact with the stone, and not skidding on a loaded area) and gradually move that spot down the stone, it works much faster and the stone isn't loaded.

Or to be plainer, you do whatever you need to to keep the steel in contact with abrasive and not floating on an area that's loading/clogged or where a sloppy swarf is preventing good abrasion.

I like the circles, but haven't done any testing to see if they have any advantage. I also like the last few strokes to terminate in the edge at not be side to side so that if one of them is deep, the area of damage is just where the stroke terminates, and not a section of edge that comes off many times wider than the groove. Plus, the "tooth" that way feels subjectively a little sharper.

Circles are often good with heavy pressure in a small area on a stone that exhibits loading or suspending behavior because the iron doesn't escape an area where it's in good contact.

This is all personal preference, though - led by laziness (whatever seems to work fastest with the least effort).

Separate from these stones, there is a large improvement in flattening the backs of tools on sandpaper if the back flattening is finished with circular strokes - the number of dominant deep grooves from the sandpaper seems to be far less. I'll try to get a picture of that - it allows someone to, for example, go from worn 80 grit paper to a middle stone right away without steps between, and takes about 10 seconds to remove the dominant deep in line grooves that someone may get preparing an iron that's far out of flat.

As to the circles vs. lines, etc, one of the hallmarks of a beginner's stone is that it tolerates just about anything someone can do regardless of the way they move a tool. A fine india stone is kind of like this - you can take long strokes, do circles, whatever you want, and it cuts the same. A step or two finer than fine india (which is harder to find) does the same thing. Diamond on cast is like this on the backs of tools - move the tool around, the stone works).

Stones of nuance (Washita, oilstones, japanese natural stones), you can manipulate those things to make a stone work finer or faster, but I doubt most people have any interest in that - it's really only critical for razor sharpening.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#27

Looking at this picture..

David Weaver

..I took this one a few days ago, so I didn't remember what I did. If a stone is agreeable and strong cutting and doesn't clog, then the scratches will be all in one direction on my pictures. It looks like they go several directions on this one solely because if you use this stone just in one direction, it loads quickly. Some of the scratches are an artifact of keeping the stone surface clean and free of loading.

At the woodworking level, it would make little difference in the edge here. This is an older white alundum stone and probably would've been soaked to make it break down relatively quickly. since i'm not going to take 15 minutes to soak these stones to use them for 30 seconds, they are more finicky to use than they would otherwise be. I'll soak this particular stone and use it again just to see how much of a difference that makes, but focus not so much on the direction of all of the scratches and more on how big they are and what the condition of the very edge is (e.g., is it perfectly even looking visually like it is with 1 micron diamonds, or does it look chewed up like this one).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#28

Thanks David


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#29

Coticules - Fine and Coarse

David Weaver

First, the coarse coticule - these are a cream colored belgian stone with natural garnet articles in them - their boast is that the particles are round and more gentle (at least that's how they're framed for razors).

At one point, 7 companies were mining these as they also come with belgian blue stone mining. The blue and yellow seams meet and the combination is a natural yellow stone (unstable) with a blue stone backing (stable).

Now, one company mines them and for the price, they're not worth the hassle. They are all massively different from one to the next, though "select" grade stones are fine enough for finishing edges. But they could be fast or slow, you'll never know, and a large bench stone size will be less fine than an oilstone and could cost $300.

The first coarse stone is fast enough that it could be used for woodworking, but it's size is only about 2.75" x 5.5" and it's sort of irregular. Even this size is $100. I'll spare everyone the nuances that make it worth having one for razors.


notice how shallow the grooves are from the round particles. you can actually see the bottoms of some of the grooves, which isn't common in short field of depth. This stone blackens swarf quickly. Maybe the fastest of these I've had (out of about 15).

The large articles still slurry dull the edge a little bit.

And next is a fine coticule - this is an older stone of mine. It's extremely slow, which is useful for razors, but only after another finish stone. worthless for woodworking.

notice the slurry dulling is less, but still not a great combination for use.


George stocked this at CW because there were a few european tradesmen who used them. They spit on them (they can be used with water or oil, but most are used with water now - oil is a good way to see if a crappy one will do better on oil than water, and it doesn't go deeply into them as they're not porous).

Fun fact, showing a label that said "with water or oil" on a vintage coticule and stating that using oil on them is fine could get you banned from a shaving forum that I was on because one of the moderators said at one point they couldn't be used with oil (he didn't feel obligated to learn whether or not that was true) and maintained that it would be the rule by banning anyone who said otherwise.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#30

garnet

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When used as a woodworking abrasive garnet paper wears in a way that leads to burnishing wood as well as milling of sanding dust. Great for sealing end grain. So the claim that the harder than silica garnet could be rounded when using these stones could be valid.

Would photomicrographs of these stones aid us in interpreting their result?

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#31

not sure

David Weaver

...i'm not sure if there are photomicrographs of the particles or not.

I think they're not as abrasive dense as the nearly pure ark stones, and I think the claim about the abrasive shape is that they are already a bit rounded in the stone (presumably due to a natural process).

I'll have to go look at garnet hardness...as I recall, it was mohs between silica and alumina oxide. it "feels" like it's halfway between, but shape could affect that. Plus, they feel miles different just from one stone to the next, but one with enough abrasion power to feel gritty feels kind of like a dull gritty.

If I can find some substantiation, I'll post it.

Their reputation with razors (with testimonials rather than A/B tests as far as I've seen) is that sometimes a razor that will fall apart at the edge with a faster stone will still sharpen on a coticule. Even if that's the case, we would refer to that as a defective razor, and one to be thrown away given that it's possible to use a razor for an entire lifetime with an initial cost of $60. Might as well get a good one.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#32

Dan's black Hard Ark

David Weaver

An expensive stone, but the best black arkansas I've seen from anyone anywhere and I've four. If they're bought as first quality or directly from dan, they are apparently all superb.

with heavy pressure

with light pressure


For whatever reason, black stones have always left little tiny dings here and there on edges after stropping. I mean tiny enough that you won't notice them on a surface. I'm puzzled as to why that is.

I prefer a fine washita for chisels and plane irons because their "go fast" pressure is faster and they work about as fine.

When I did stone type tests during the plane iron test, one of my fine washitas went slightly longer than the dan's black.

There is a difference with other brands - any newer norton (which they haven't done much of) has small pores in it and the halls (probably preyda) now that I had long ago would release a large glom of particles at once once in a while and then was very slow cutting once it settled in. You'd dig in, a bit would come loose and go across the surface and clink.

The virtue of halls stones is they were inexpensive before people complained that they weren't flat (they weren't). about 1/4th the cost of dan's. Then halls started lapping them flat and the price went way up and i'm not sure where preyda is.

A second from the dan's page is good and some authorized dealers (I got a 10x3 from someone on ebay) will be able to do better than dan's page price without a drop in quality. I wanted a big one (10x3, and I requested >1" thickness as dan's prices 0.75" thick and 1.1" the same - when you pay huge money, you kind of want the stone to look like a thick stone - it feels different in their pre-made boxes or in any base - there's more finger room).

Dan's black and trans, though, both as good as any of each ever made when it comes to fineness.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#33

Very expensive (to me) japanese natural

David Weaver

This is a white suita from ohira mine. it's as thick as 8/4 planed lumber and is full of something known as blue renge. It's hard and fine and kind of finicky. The other okudo short stone shown in this picture series is more practical for day to day use, and I have this stone only because I'm not looking forward to the challenge of selling it for a reasonable price as it's nearly four figures and has rough sawn sides and will be just shy of 3 inches wide if I lap the sides.

I got it a while ago on a bender.

with a slurry, which is typical as the stone gets "grippy and skippy" without one and is hard enough not to raise its own slurry very quickly. it is a fine stone, though, about as fine as a natural japanese stone with fresh particles would be.


And then, just because I wanted to see if I could coax it into finer-than-it-is behavior, I experimented with something I learned a while ago with the sigma power stone - use the stone dry after the edge is finished. It can't be used dry first, it has to be done to its max as normal, and then used dry afterwards. The slurry dulling (that makes the flat part cleaner than the edge in terms of finish) stops and the edge becomes much sharper. If it's used wet without a slurry, it will not match this finish - it'll have bad use characteristics and continue to leave grooves to the edge.

the shaving behavior of the iron after this was fantastic, but it's not practical for woodworking (it took 2 minutes of extra work to get to this point) - remember that the washita does nearly as well in a total of 20 seconds.


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#34

Re: Very expensive (to me) japanese natural

David Weaver

I have never seen anyone do what I did to this second stone, or with it. So it's sort of a curiosity to me as I've also never looked at the dry burnish under a microscope before, just used it to increase the polish on waterstones. synthetics often won't tolerate it.

If I figured out how to do this in isolation just by experimentation, though, I'm sure someone else has.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#35

Another White Alundum Japanese Stone

David Weaver

At least white alundum is what I'm assuming. This stone absorbs less water, works better without a slurry (makes only a tiny amount of its own) and sounds like a ceramic mug when you tap it (clink clink).

Note how different the edge looks. Much finer and more even, but evidence of strong cutting, very strong cutting. I like it better than the shapton cream stone. Since no particles appear to really be rolling around loose on the stone (unless you make them on purpose by lapping it), there is no slurry dulling (deep scratches right at the edge but less organization further back from it), and there's a tiny toothy look, but the actual edge is really fine, and not irregular.

When clean, the two stones look the same. Who made either? I have no clue - they came in boxes of stones where I was really trying to get the gaggle of natural stones in a haul. I suspect this one is more modern than the other one as the abrasive seems to be much more closely graded and the feel is better.


Use for heavy back wear is still about half as fast as the washita, though - it doesn't remove a tiny buffed stripe nearly as fast.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#36

LV Green / Formax Microfine

David Weaver

Not suitable by itself as a finisher, but a refiner of finishing. Hard leather and pine can be considered similar, but I like softwood for more than light stropping more than leather. You can use it more like a stone.

Here's what the Green stuff (this is not graded chrome, rather the wax stick that is 70% or so alumina - it has some stray large particles in it, but is generally fine on average).

brand new corian kind of sucks for it because there's nothing to break tension on the surface. It's slow cutting, which makes the finish look finer than it really can be practically used and the larger stray particles still scuff the edge. sanded corian would probably work well (didn't try).


So, for something that works better and cuts a lot faster, I applied it to pine. It works several times faster, the result is at least as good or better at the edge and the harsh particles have less solid footing.


A couple of sample pictures to describe what this is actually good for. If you're using it for 10 hard seconds after a finish stone, but the edge isn't perfect, it improves things a little, makes the polish on what you're using more clear, but note the edge. It's better to use it to chase the edge back a little bit and then work the back some (This is just back work with a little bit of light work on the bevel side)


Used for another 30 seconds more on pine (the above picture is using it on pine, too), including some bevel side work.


Of course, far better is to use it after a stone that leaves an even edge.

Common on razor forums for people to say that the oxides and buffing bars give them inconsistent results, sometimes super sharp, sometimes not. People will spend hundreds or thousands of dollars on razors, but buying a $20 hand held microscope is a bridge too far, and they would quickly see that where they come up short is in the quality of the edge before the post-edge refinement.

This gives a chance to plug the buffer - what the buffer does quickly is to make fine scratches in huge volumes to remove this stuff from the edge. Even if the buffer is only used on the bevel side, the deep scratches on the bevel side are removed and the edge is refined reasonably well. Most deep scratch damage (where there is a break out around a deep groove) is at the edge and if it can be removed gently, then the area where the scratch terminates won't be nearly so big - just the groove sticking out through the edge.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#37

attractive old wives tales

David Weaver

since you can't really get a good shave with an incomplete edge, but you can do good woodwork, there's a desire on the shaving side to create more OWTs. OWTs breed where there is a possible explanation, or one that seems plausible even if it isn't.

I don't frequent shaving forums and didn't for too long as they're not really results based and people who have never sharpened anything are starting with the most sensitive thing you could sharpen (or one of the most).

My opinion, the hand held scope is what someone needs to have if they want to judge what their stones are doing and what they're doing. Not to make things take longer, but to learn to make them take less long.

A process to set up and hone a truly dull razor out of use is about 10 minutes, but it can be done wrong or ruined pretty easily. Or it can be learned and done easily. what folks end up doing is a bunch of work and the finest work doesn't get to the edge. If they had a hand held scope and spent 2 minutes confirming that they had uniform scratches to the edge each time and no damage in the edge, then they'd learn what makes results the first time.

So what follows is old wives tales and unlikely culprits. These same things end up in woodworking tools, but you can use the tools just fine without worrying about it if they're kind of sharp.

The unlikely culprits are proposed after an hour of this or that, and my comment would generally be " buy a hand held scope because whatever you're doing, you probably don't have the finest scratches all the way to the edge on both sides of the bevel".

"oh no, that can't be it. It's probably microchipping, a defective razor, large particles in the stropping compound, bovine leather instead of horse leather, ..."

on and on. And 95% of the time or more, the first look through a microscope shows things like the 3rd picture in this post does - the faces of the honed areas are bright almost right away, but the bits hanging around in the edge are still there. I can't see them. my vision is better than 20/20. I don't think anyone can see them - they don't reflect enough light to show up.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#38

Relevance? Question?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

And 95% of the time or more, the first look through a microscope shows things like the 3rd picture in this post does

After planing 20 linear feet of wood would the edge from this flawed sharpening in PIC 3 look any different from starting at the refinement illustrated in the other pictures?

Adding the capability to buff for 5 seconds with 5 micron polishing stick renders obsolete all these alternatives when chiseling and planing is the application?

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#39

Re: Relevance? Question?

David Weaver

Yes, it takes a while to wear the defects out and the person doing the planing is cheated out of the sweetest part of the planing.

The defects actually get a little worse for a while as they break off due to lack of lateral support and then wear makes the edge more uniform.

This wasn't covered in our plane iron tests because all of the edges were confirmed uniform end to end before planing.

Yes on the buffer as long as there's no clearance issue. I think it's not a bad idea to get a hand scope (for anyone who does a *lot* of planing, folks who do small amounts/fitting or work on joints with a bunch of glue lines and scrape and sand probably won't care as much). It takes no more time to make an edge that's uniform (without buffer) than it does to make one that is uniform.

When warren talks about sharpening far more frequently than absolutely needed and avoiding damage, I believe it's to aid this.

My discussion of separating geometry from edge honing is generally to make it so that you can do the same thing even when an edge is completely worn or has minor damage.

On chisels, the buffer does this well. On bevel up, well. With some touch, on bevel down plane irons, it does it well, but if it took me about 10 irons to really figure out the touch, someone who is less enthusiastic may not have an opportunity to make the feel a feel (as in, they may not be able to do it consistently without running the clearance out). That's what I'm seeing so far in comments from various forums - chisel success is almost immediate (which means folks who use a 25 degree BU iron, if they take the time to stone all of the damage off of the flat side of the iron, will have a super BU plane experience if they just buff a 25 degree bevel on the bevel side of their plane. that should be immediate, and if it's not, it's probably a problem on the back side of the blade.

But I can see BD planes vexing people off and on where doing the same geometry (20/23 and then adding a tiny microbevel at 33 or so with a honing guide on fine media would be more successful for most on bevel down planes).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#40

Clear summary thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A great breakthrough for Pedestrian Planers. We like to lessen the things we need be concerned with.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#41

Dursol (Autosol) Metal Polish

David Weaver

I wanted to do Autosol because it's better known, but I can't find my tube of it. What I do have is Dursol, which was sent to me to look at by someone a decade or so ago. It is more greasy than Autosol and more stinky, but otherwise similar. It has alumina in it, it hones, it leaves a film behind to lengthen the time you have to use it next as a metal polish.

First on a hard surface - cast in this case (instead of corian - corian just has no surface relief and the polished side is getting to be a pain to use).

Aggressive. I don't know that it's the dursol, it may just be having a heavy hand on cast and causing failures - who knows. At any rate, it's fast, but cast isn't the right surface for it.


on yellow pine, feeling that it needed a little relief and could stand having a slightly more forgiving background...


That's serious business right there. It's fast enough to be used as a finish hone by itself, though you can't bring too rough of a wire edge to it from a stone (it'll just scuff up the pine and maybe get embedded in it. The same thing happens to corian with a strong wire edge - it (Corian) gets damaged, too).

This is a practical option and with the right substrate -softwood or MDF, it's super fine. Subjective sharpness is about as good as anything you'll find and a pea sized amount will work over several irons. It's carried in some kind of petroleum stuff, so a drop or two of mineral oil or a bit of WD 40 will bring a dried up cake of it back to softness and usability again.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#42

(this one is good enough for everyone)

David Weaver

while a bunch of the other back pictures show something expensive, or something marginal, autosol and dursol (i've looked at them before) on a substrate are a seriously good option for fineness (and unrequested corrosion mitigation).

I don't have a shapton 30k, but had a suehiro gok 20k at one point (Same abrasive size, much bigger stone than shapton 30k, and lower in cost) and a simple $7 tube of autosol on pine works at least as fast as either of those stones (I've used the 30k -a friend had to buy one when he saw how much they cost), and probably faster, and the effect is more gentle on edges at the same time.

The results aren't just a visual anomaly. I thought maybe I was seeing things the first time "maybe the polish clogs the grooves and you just can't see them", but I wiped the snot out of the back of this iron yesterday, as well as the edge, and there is no real weakness. To top it off, the softwood or MDF strop rounds just the tip a tiny bit and makes the polish really easy to use.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#43

Re: (this one is good enough for everyone)

Mike In Los Angeles

Autosol on a dowel has been great for gouges.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#44

Re: (this one is good enough for everyone)

David Weaver

Its goodness on wood is undeniable. At one point, I used the autosol version on shaped stuff and on MDF for the backs of irons. I looked at it under a hand held scope back then and was baffled back then as at some point, someone told me that it's 3 micron (like an old king stone).

I didn't understand using the subtrates for effect back then and why it was so good on MDF.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#45

Turkish Oilstone

David Weaver

There are two stones called Turkey, and a third "cretan" from the crete area called the same.

The cretans are still mined and sold and the finer of the two is probably close to this stone. I have the lighter version of the two and it's a little more coarse than this stone.

These stones are more or less friable arkansas stones. They were preferred according to holtzapffel for their ability to cut harder steels (which an ark will do fine if you slurry one with a diamond hone). This one is conditioned from using only hardened steel on it. A laminated tool would wake it up and make it cut more coarsely. These are less sensitive to pressure as they're strong cutters.


A try at lower pressure yields little difference. The stray scratches are from heavy work letting the iron hang over the end of the stone (to keep the stone flat). Kind of a one trick pony, and if you keep it awake, a very fast strong cutter, but the edge quality is good for its speed.

Hard to find type of stone, though, and often expensive for what it is.


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#46

Re: (this one is good enough for everyone)

Mike In Los Angeles

Seems great, glad I wasn’t just telling myself that. What scope are you using? These binoculars of my dads just aren’t the tool for the job haha

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#47

Re: (this one is good enough for everyone)

David Weaver

It's an Indian brand called radical with a separate halogen light source and coarse and fine adjustments with a camera turret and camera. Ot wasn't expensive for what it is...about the cost of a lie Nielsen plane.

It's 75-600 optical but I have to admit I rarely use above 150.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#48

Llyn Idwall

David Weaver

This is a UK novaculite stone. They're usually a little on the small side compared to an 8x2 bench stone, but they're very fine. I bought this from the UK, and they all have a little different look except for the types that are light gray with black dots, so I never really feel sure that they're idwalls vs. an old scrap of dark gray arkansas translucent.

But this one has a characteristic of feeling hard and smooth, but also if you dig in a little bit, it'll develop some tooth from releasing particles.

The significance of these if you only need a slightly smaller stone is that sometimes they'll sell for $50. They are a great straight razor stone. Noisy looking flat surface, but fine even edge.

I have one of the gray type with small dots, but its location eludes me I think it may be slightly finer than this stone.

Fine like a true hard arkansas stone, but also slow.


The stone - these often have little flaky imperfections on the surface somewhere


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#49

Re: Kitayama waterstone

David Weaver

stone picture - with dried slurry.

This process gives me a chance to see what it is that I still have, and I dumped this stone on ebay yesterday - there's some stuff that I have that I really have no use for (like the shaptons).


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#50

Pic of the stone

David Weaver