Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

Posts

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#76

Re: Sigma Power 13k

David Weaver

The washita and its variable magic has made me so lazy. I just works so fast, so fine and there's nothing to do with it, though the learning curve is a bit steeper.

In the winter, my bench area can drop to mid 30s - I've never had water freeze in that space (it'll get there when the temperature outside dips below zero - known as beech-checking nights here)...but man, I remember the early days reaching into the water to pull the kings out. If your hands are already stiff and have that little bit of a burning feeling on the outside and then you give them a little bit of that.

Eek.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#77

Extra Fine India Stone

David Weaver

This is a big 8x3 stone that I got from japan in a lot of used stones.

The lot also had an 8x2 of the same, but someone begged it off of me as these are wonderful stones for setting up straight razors that haven't been used in a long time and have some damage.

Cuts like a middle stone but doesn't wear quickly. This one has only been used with water (the india stones in japan appear to be left unfilled - as in, not pre-filled with oil).

It would be nice if this grade of stone was still sold here, but it would also be hard to get it past the giant marketing machine of much more expensive resin stones. It's at least as good as any resin stone made - vitrified, fine aluminum oxide.

You can see from the picture that it leaves tight fine rows. It's aggressive and the small size of the grooves belies the fact that they're deep and it will leave a wire edge to deal with, but it would be a great secondary bevel stone (better feel than diamond, hard, strong surface, but not skippy feeling and doesn't load easy). Because it's not as coarse as a typical india, it doesn't get material pinned to the surface as easily, either.


It's not a good finish stone, but it's a great pre-finishing stone.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#78

Picture of the stone

David Weaver


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#79

Picture of the stone

David Weaver



The stamp appears to actually be original in a sea of recently stamped stones where the association in japan gives members the right to add stamps that are no longer protected to unstamped stones.

Nice, green, uniform, strong cutting. Green is a funny thing in japan. A dark green stone like this that looks like it may have come from nakayama will be valuable. If the stone is very light, it may be. if it's more of a grass green tone to it, then no (that color is more often seen in ohira tomae stones, etc, like the one that hida sold in droves. I know at least one other person was selling those in large quantities, too. They're triple the price here that they are in japan, but that's the nature of being in the states. This stone is on a completely different level and the auction drew no attention - the only real "steal" of any type that I got from the japanese auctions.)

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#80

Re: Sigma Power 13k

Curt Putnam

Water sits on top and as much rolls off as slowly sinks in. I put a scribble of water on, spread it with a finger and then another scribble when I get going. Seems to work rather well. I have gouged the stone once or twice.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#81

Re: Picture of the stone

Hank Knight

David, because of her connections with Japanese tool makers, Kayoko had access to a wide variety of natural stones. I asked her to find a good natural finish stone for me and she sent me this one in 2007. It looks very similar to the stone you pictured. It is very hard and makes a fine slurry. It puts an unbelievable edge on my laminated blades and leaves a matte finish that shows off the laminations. When finished with a fine man-made water stone, the polish is bright and obscures the laminations. I can't read the kanji. Can you shed any light on this stone?

[url=https://flic.kr/p/2jyEChQ][/url][url=https://flic.kr/p/2jyEChQ]D16CDF13-39AD-4D40-AC12-EB318DAD1DB2_1_105_c[/url] by [url=https://www.flickr.com/photos/158680038@N03/]Hank Knight[/url], on Flickr

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#82

Re: Pic of the stone

Orlando in So. Fl.

I have the same stone which I also got from Stu but mine has the box prior to Sigma putting it in the Select II box. Sigma called it the 13000 Sigma Power Tamago-iro Ceramic.

This is what Stu had to say about that:

Also know that Sigma Power have, in their wisdom, tagged the 13K with the Select II label. A purple one to be exact. Same stone, new label and I think it's so they can get things out there based on the reputation of the Select II and the kind of 'corporate face' they show. I won't call them a Select II though.

I don't know why exactly (but I did say it was ok). I do know that the dang things are in a purple box (and cost less than half the Chosera 10K or Shapton 30K) and a speckly yellow colour (which is what tamago-iro means, egg colour).

You are correct about it being used after the pre-finishing or finishing stone and not the medium stone. I use it after the 8K Tamago-iro Ceramic which is the hard ceramic.

Here's a couple of pic:


BTW, kudos to you Winston, Wiley, Bill, for the tremendous, and pertinent, effort you put into the Unicorn Profile. It is a job well done and appreciated by many. I also enjoyed reading the article because it made things clearer. However, I do have one question and that is, what do you mean by accommodating a chisel and the rules of accommodation.

Again, thanks for the great job you have done on this method.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#83

Re: Picture of the stone

David Weaver

(i typed all of the below- going off on a tangent, and I'll leave it because hate post editing - but the short answer is that the green stone here is harder, finer and a lot more rare. Your stone is an ohira (mine) stamped and graded tomae finishing stone - as in a legitimate graded mid-level tool and knife finisher that's of more recent or current mining. The green stone I showed is more like nakayama characteristic and it is so fine and hard that it can leave an entire tool mostly polished - but it's rare in that it has that fineness and hardness, but with a tough surface that doesn't get scratched or damaged by the corners of tools in heavy use. Your stone's paper stamp is imanishi - the distributor, the left translates to selected or first quality and the right side says it's a finishing natural stone from ohira-yama mine. I can't read kanji, either, but I can recognize some of the mine and cutting grade stamps, and then look up the rest).

Hi, Hank - that's an ohira mine stone, probably tomae strata. I had three of those - two from japan, one from the US. They are more mellow and more of a middle of the road finisher whereas the green stone that I posted is probably from nakayama or one of the older mines.

Ohira mine may be old, that's maybe not the right way to put it, but the mines like nakayama and narutaki were, to my knowledge, completely shut a long time ago and now their stamps are unprotected.

The three stones that I had were type 30, and I got the first from hida, who I believe bought the stock from imanishi, and then also bought kayako's remaining stones. Perhaps all of hida's stones didn't come from imanishi, but the label bottom left on that stone is imanishi's distribution label, and when you look at sellers like aframestokyo or hardware stores in japan, you can tell they're imanishi was the distribution channel.

The shorter stamp on the left side says ippon-sen, or specially selected, which just means the stone is first quality.

The stone on the right identifies the stone as something like honzan ohira-yama awase do, translating to a true finishing natural stone from ohira mine.

The reason that I bought three is the first one that I got from hida was about $400. It was OK. It didn't self slurry (using a japanese tool - with lamination, the jigane/soft lamination should wake up a good tool stone a little bit with a smooth feel when splashed with water, whereas all hardened steel tools may not). The first one I had, I used a lot - it was my personal stone before I started buying stones in droves from japan, and once it had been wet for a while, then the surface got a little bit loose and it would slurry a green slurry instead of making a black iron flower.

(all three of these had the same stamps and imanishi label as yours, but I think hida's may have had imanishi co in english at the bottom and the ones I bought through yahoo japan had it in japanese).

I think before web browsers translated things easily, we were fish in a barrel a bit for dealers, as the reason I got two more when I was selling stones was to see how consistent they were, and they were about $165 each at retail from a dealer in japan. At one point, chef knives to go was also retailing stones and they sold a gob of ozuku, ohira (with those stamps, as well as some with less select stamping) and maybe some atagoyama stamped stones. Those are current or recent mines, so that's where large runs of clear stock comes from.

The two that I got for $165 perhaps become $200 by the time you get them here, and they were the same as the ones sold in the US. It's just a sign of the difference between someone acquiring stock in the US (Be it kayako or hida) and selling to a smaller group with personalized service vs. someone operating a hardware stone and getting the same stones and selling some on site and some through the equivalent of ebay.

IT could also be that in time, once those stones are no longer being sold in large numbers (I haven't seen them for a while), the value will go up.

But since i'm doing a poor job answering your original question - what's the difference? The stone I have listed is more like an old stone, and less like a lot of the newer clear stamped material. It has a lot of tooth, but is extremely fine. It's borderline unsuitable for tools as it will polish both the jigane and the higane (leaving just a slight haze to the jigane on a chisel - one that looks more like a polish with no matte qualities). On water it will be a bit slow, and while it can be scuffed with a diamond to create a faster slurry. I prefer a stone that slowly releases its own in use for tools. So I wouldn't use this particular stone for tools other than to round over the tip.

I just worked a chisel on the stone in this picture (I generally only use it for razors) and the surface is also tough - it doesn't scratch under a tool and release particles (shoubu stones often do that, so do some ohira). When the surface of a stone is scratchy or easily scratched, it's hard to use on anything but razors and often those stones aren't fine enough.

I have seen so many stones that it's hard for me to give a straight answer, I guess, and sometimes my answers are colored by being disappointed about finding the price of things in japan once I started buying directly from there vs. what we pay. Most of the good-labeled ohira tomae stones are good middle of the road usable stones, same with atagoyama stones (which was large uniform somewhat slow, and very fine material - resulting in some cases in 7 or 8 pound stones that were sold at retail in japan for about $250 - I bought one of those, too, of course- that was new price). I saw Maksim (a dealer in europe) selling those for $700-$900 at the same time. It was disheartening.

Once in a while I buy things from Tomohito Iida, but one has to be careful what they're buying from Tomohito as something inexpensive may be very expensive through him (Stones are a bad idea from tomohito based on what I've seen). For example, the iyoroi kamaji chisels that I bought from fujibato for $60 each and that fujibato sold for a long at that price, Tomohito listed them for $115 each. Why? Ogata planes for a long time were very moderate price, but he supposedly retired and most of the plane makers seem to have gobs of left over stock when they retire that they couldn't sell. I got a blade and subblade new from alex gilmore years ago while ogata was still making for $225. It was this http://japantool-iida.com/plane_smoothing/2008/05/nami-no-hana-by-hideshi-ogata.html

Japan woodworker bought a bunch of ogata's blades, too - how they can keep coming up with so many while he's retired, I don't know, but what do I suspect is going on here? With no proof of course - I suspect the remaining stock was inexpensive, but the dealers see it as a real opportunity. There must've been a lot of it and the odds seem to be against the gain going in much amount to the maker, but rather every one between the maker and the buyer, and if the maker is no longer making, there's no threat of seeing $300-$400 listings to make people go ???. Iida at one point had a bunch of ogata planes for $475, his website was redesigned and when it reappeared, they were all $700-$800. Same with Nakano's planes. About double going rate.

We're somewhat captive because we don't speak english and the highest price dealers usually work on the friend model. They're very friendly, and if they're in japan, they may sell in japan for a fraction of what they charge for listings in english (that's a third dealer experience, or fourth, or whatever - none of the dealers mentioned above - but the prices in english on a dealer's site in japan were 60% higher than if you switched to japanese and paid in yen).

Sorry to trouble you with all of those details. I'd imagine if your stone was like my three, it's an honest finisher for tools. There is some variation in labeled stones (but my three were much the same), so it's hard to say for sure without using a stone in work context and looking at what it does under the microscope. The ohira tomae stones that I had were in the ballpark of a 6-8k synthetic finish and coarse and loose enough to leave a nice aesthetic on a chisel. There are faster stones that do the same thing, but you have to go through a few to find them, and there are finer stones (like the one that I pictured) - and everyone always thinks they want finer, but finer often means slower and a prefinisher needs to be used. I would have to diamond slurry this old stone or use a prefinisher before it, and nobody would like the aesthetic without the slurry - it's too fine and too bright of a polish. But great for razors or just working the tip of a tool whereas I didn't get a step up in sharpness over an 8k stone with the ippon-sen labeled ohira tomae.

The essence of being a good dealer is finding out exactly what someone thinks they want to do, explaining the boundaries of reality and then picking a stone that does exactly that. What I found from experience because I priced things at even cost from japan was that people didn't necessarily trust I was giving them straight advice until they would buy stones from me, then go spend 8 times as much buying aesthetically rare stones from another dealer some time later. They'd come back and mention that the expensive stones were about the same at best (depending on whether or not someone listened to exactly what they wanted in cutting qualities - pretty stones are nice, but if you're looking to sharpen a razor and you want a light tan colored stone that's as fine as a more typical green razor stone, the odds are that you'll get a very expensive very pretty stone that's a little bit coarse).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#84

Re: Sigma Power 13k

David Weaver

Things may have changed over time in the composition of those, one never knows, but I'd say the balance of things has more to do with me trying to use the stone the same way I'd use another.

When I first got it, what I did with it was to bias working tools just at the tip, let it dry out, and then continue to work a tool on the dry area of the stone as that makes the polish super bright. but I do that on many now.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#85

Re: Pic of the stone

David Weaver

Hi, orlando - long time no talk! I remember early on when both of us were hitting up stu for all kinds of things and horse trading with him. That's how I got most of this stuff, though I bought my fair share outright, but stu and I would have trading wars where one would try to outdo the other by showing that we could trade more to each other than we got in return. That wasn't always smart!!

I remember stu saying the same thing - I got a gok 20k through him at cost, tried it on razors and quickly sold it (it was a little finer than most stones, but it didn't move the needle on razors as what it gained in fineness, it lost in speed, and oxides on a soft backer will always outdo a stone).

I got the sp13k shortly after that, and for some reason, razors don't love it - it's definitely fine enough for them, but I never looked at why they don't seem to finish with a lasting edge off of it. I remember stu saying at the time that they called it SPII (the same line as the sintered stone) because they didn't really have a place to "put" it, and they chose to label it under that line. It's more like a typical stone, as you know - the sintered stones were sort of odd ducks in silicon carbide - friable and way different than alumina stones.

Winston gave me your email address - I'll send you an email or you can send one to me through the same address on here.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#86

Re: Thank you, David

Hank Knight

Thank you, David! I've been looking for information about this stone for a long time. You have satisfied my curiosity and I appreciate the detail in your reply. Your comment about a dealer's ability to meet the customer's needs and expectations is spot on. I had a fair number of dealings with Kayoko before she returned to Japan, and she hit the mark most every time. I've been very pleased with this stone. I recognize that we pay a lot for these kinds of Japanese products here in the states. I knew that when I purchased this stone, but I've had no second thoughts about it. Once again, I appreciate your detailed reply. I'm going to print it and save it with the stone.

Thanks.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#87

Re: Pic of the stone

Orlando in So. Fl.

Hey Dave, yeah long time no talk but it's good to hook up again. Now that I'm retired I have more time to do whatever I want. :) I remember the horsetrading with Stu. I once had bought a LN LA Jack and he wanted it so he could show the folk in Japan something about it. So he offered me a Tsunesaburo 70mm Maboroshi and an extra dai. He also got me to send him maple syrup because Akiko liked it but it wasn't available over there. But all in all, he treated us well all the time. I miss those times.

Go ahead and email me because I don't know how to access yours here.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#88

Re: Thank you, David

David Weaver

I go back and forth on what it costs to get things from dealers in the US, but I don't want to poo poo things reasonable that just don't fit my lens. The reality is if someone is running a profitable business on low volume goods, a markup of 100% (double price) is probably about where it becomes worth doing.

The benefit of those stones (ohira) is they're kind of mellow, so they're easy to use, and they generally aren't scratchy (lots of harder stones can be, and it takes an honest dealer to call that what it is instead of saying that it takes great skill to use the stones). That type of tomae stone usually leaves people with the visual polish that they want, too, and I think that's important (The tip of the chisel can be finished with something else if it's *really* important to get bonkers sharp).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#89

The rules of accommodation

David Weaver

often, tool tests are done putting a group of tools into exactly the same paramaters. Something standardized is done, and the results are reported.

But that can miss really spectacular tools that need only a little bit of accommodation. Examples of this are:

* adding a degree at a time to a bevel until the tool holds up

* taking a japanese chisel that's chippy out of its handle and tempering it a little further starting at 300 degrees F. Often an overhard chisel needs 25 degrees more tempering to become outstanding.

* the unicorn is a matter of sharpening and accommodation all in one

I think this goes in two steps - first, you examine damage and find out what it takes to make a tool hold up. Second, you have to determine whether or not that accommodation makes a tool that's tolerable to use.

One thing that comes to mind with me is that if I buy 30 used japanese chisels in harlequin lots, I will probably get 15 that are great to use, maybe 20 let's say. All they need is to be refreshed. They'll be $10-$15 each in total with shipping, but I know what to look for to get good quality chisels instead of a bunch of used coarsely ground hardware store chisels.

5 or 8 of those chisels will be hardware store tools (and I'll keep them to do things like grind the back of a chisel round, because who cares - half of the hardware store chisels may have so so edge holding).

suspending mathematics now and pretend that I have five left (3, 5, 8 or whatever). I will probably have about 5 chisels that are overhard. They will have been used little because they're almost impossible to sharpen on anything other than silicon carbide stones, and those stones cause the edges to crumble when they're finished. You get them set up, and they never seem to take the edge that shaves until they're buffed (buff is so gentle that it will accommodate). Then, you start to pare with them and even with the buffed tip, the tip chips and leaves lines.

Out of that 5, 3 or 4, or maybe all 5 will just need some retempering and then I may leave them on the hard side, but with the unicorn, they will last so long that I can make them hot before the edges fail. Over and over.

Just as we can accommodate tools, we can also accommodate stones. If I know that I have a washita that I really love, but it's aggressive on softer tools, I can either feed it what it likes to make a fine edge, or I can take tools that I have and make them into something that it likes.

It's so much more rewarding, and more favorable for continuous work in the shop to accommodate tools than it is to try to find something that relieves us of it.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#90

Re: The rules of accommodation

Orlando in So. Fl.

Thanks for the explanation on the rules of accommodation. I appreciate it.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#91

Re: The rules of accommodation

Wiley Horne

David,

There’s deep thinking in what you just said. A possible diamond inside that piece of anthracite—well, that doesn’t really work, but looking for the gem is a great idea.

Here’s something in the same vein....Bill Carter, the English planemaker, had a piece on line where he talked about taking a chisel, grinding it blunt, heating to austenite, then quench. No temper at all; leave it martensite. He says it’s the greatest scraper ever. Like for plane beds.

Wiley

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#92

Slurried Trans Ark..

David Weaver

This is an older bone colored translucent arkansas stone. It's a wonderful stone, but I don't use it much, so it was ripe for experimenting.

Larry Williams slurries his trans ark with what may be a 220 grit DMT in his moulding plane video, and i know he's not the only one. IT does make an arkansas stone cut a lot faster. I didn't have the heart to go that coarse, so I used the worn 400 grit side on a chinese diamond hone. I don't know if this would become much more aggressive looking with a coarser diamond hone, but I was surprised how fine the edge is despite the slurry. The stone is fast cutting, and while it's not any finer than the black dan's stone, a trans white or bone colored stone, does let you see the amount of metal removal much more clearly.


note the abrasions are more orderly because of the stronger cutting, but the edge itself is still smooth and even.

I've flattened trans and black stones with a 220 grit DMT in the past and they are more aggressive than this, but by how much, not sure. I don't have the urge to scuff the surface of this stone a whole lot.

The washita stays at this cutting power pretty much all the time and finishes as finely (the finer ones), which negates the value of following up on this much further (it's kind of a nuisance to abrade the surface if it's not needed).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#93

Picture of the stone

David Weaver

Time spent on the stone somewhere around 20 seconds - quite a lot of swarf for an arkansas stone this fine (clean before the start, just slurried).


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#94

Am I understanding......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The stone doesn't cut fast enough so one makes some slurried abrasive from the stone with a diamond plate and the slurry makes it cut faster? Or the roughened surface makes it cut faster and the slurry has no role. Or both? That is surely a curious means to solve the problem of metal not going away fast enough with the stone chosen.

Thankfully, there are other means to this end.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#95

Picture of the stone

David Weaver

gray slurry on top is from many uses. This stone makes an immediate black slurry if it's cleared and used with laminated tools. It'll make a black slurry with typical solid tool steel western tools, too. I leave the slurry on it because it's not really any better or finer without it (unlike a razor stone, it won't just work without generating a slurry indefinitely if used with light pressure) and there's no need to go to the effort of constantly clearing it off.


Inexpensive because it's oddly shaped - it's very wide, probably only about 6 1/2 to 7 inches long, and the strongest cutting-for-fineness suita I've used out of perhaps 40. So, it's the one I've kept (the other expensive white suita, I just haven't gone to the effort of selling yet as its price will make it a slow seller. This stone is actually a better day to day user at 1/8th the cost. Faster, tougher surface, pretty close in fineness).

I don't use middle and coarse natural japanese stones - they are not good stones and are soundly beaten by slurrying a novaculite stone instead for middle work. Of course, the revival of selling stones to westerners has brought the supply of those stones back (binsui, tanba aoto, iyo stones, etc) from $15 to sky is the limit price. Most pre-finishing stones of any quality are for swords and leave a coarser finish - pointless for tools, going back to novaculite. Most of the coarse japanese stones are just silica stones, they aren't as aggressive as novaculite, their natural particle variance can be really large, and they're slow.

But I guess some people do like to re-enact. I kept a couple at a time when I was pushing stones through etsy because someone will always want to learn for themselves rather than following advice of someone who has seen much more (the reason I've seen so much more than most is the same - I had to try it, too).

All that said, the smooth, tough surface and fast working smoothers like this stone are practical and pleasant. I'd use this one over any synthetic.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#96

Re: Am I understanding......

David Weaver

It's a combination of both. The rolling slurry makes the stone cut faster, and the scratched surface makes the stone cut faster (it's more or less a hard milled surface then with relief - essentially the coarser arkansas stones are those with more of this "natural" milling - open pores).

I would guess that using a stone this way doesn't give up too much in fineness and the average beginner would have more luck completing the sharpening job with it.

It works at least as well as a synthetic until the steel gets *really* hard, and the edge is arguably better quality.

But it doesn't match fine diamonds or compound on wood.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#97

Re: Am I understanding......

Warren in Lancaster, PA

As I wrote on this forum in 2010, A new or resurfaced hard [or black] Arkansas will cut like a soft Arkansas for quite some time. A soft Arkansas stone is 1/5 or 1/3 the price of the black or translucent stones.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#98

Now I am more confused

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Someone recommended grinding the surface of an ARK stone to produce a slurry (every time they used it?) so it would cut as fast as a stone 1/3 the price? Help me to understand why someone would demonstrate this procedure that David reported that others also do. I'm missing something.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#99

This is sort of a loaded situation...

David Weaver

....soft arkansas stones from different vendors have a wide variety of fineness. Hard stones didn't at one point, but now they do due to some vendors selling stones that have small pores on them (they cut fast and raise a wire edge).

If there's a stone that it makes sense to slurry, it would be the soft ark for someone who doesn't want to use waterstones, diamond stones or an india stone (some of the modern stuff and softer steel pins on india stones pretty easily, especially if a wire edge comes off on the india stone).

This particular stone wasn't scuffed much, and the exercise could be repeated, so it's working finer than any soft ark that I've seen unless the soft ark is allowed to settle in indefinitely and become more like a finish stone.

At the same time, the real issue with this process is the slurrying and the fact that the stone will now raise a wire edge more easily (one that's much more persistent) due to its cutting power, but the evenness of the edge is as good (just a little bit more toothy) as it was without a slurry. Whether this would hold true under rougher scuffing on the surface would just be speculation at this point.

I prefer the stones settled in and not scuffed, and to go to a coarser stone if removal needs to be faster - it's less work, and it leaves the use of the very fine stone more open to touch and with nearly no wire edge to deal with. I was surprised by the fineness of the edge shown here and expected it to look more like a new soft arkansas stone edge with some evidence of beating/slurry damage at the edge.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#100

Re: Now I am more confused

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It is somewhat ridiculous. I think the people who use this abrasion method are unfamiliar with soft Arkansas stones.

They think that Arkansas stones are fine grit that is held together by a binder and that abrading the stone will produce fresh grit. This is a good model for water stones, which do have grit held together with a binder.

Arkansas stones are partly metamorphosed rock. The crystals are partly melted together as a result of heat and pressure. There is no binder. The various grades of Arkansas stone are differentiated not by grit size but by the size of the crevices between crystals. A soft Arkansas has larger crevices. That is why Arkansas stones are graded by density rather than by grit size.

If you abrade an Arkansas stone, you are using the scratches in the surface like a file to abrade your tool.