Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

Posts

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#151

Re: crest complete (And more dursol)

David Weaver

that's probably true. Richard mentioned in a post below that it takes longer to remove wear from the back of an iron than I suggested. I looked around my shop at lunch and couldn't find a cutter that has significant wear on it. It's not something that I generally do (put a plane away with a heavily worn iron, or take a heavily worn iron out of a plane dull and put it on a shelf).

But, I haven't brushed my teeth yet today.

:\

If the teeth get too bad, I know that I can kick it up a notch and really strip a good solid layer of gunk off of them with dursol, though.

Never knew how sticky toothpaste was and have made a note to never dry my mouth out with cotton balls and then attempt to use it on a dry toothbrush. phew.

I've only got two more stones to test that are finishers and that anyone would ever reasonably use, so the goofery is almost over!!

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#152

Tying up loose polishes - Autosol

David Weaver

I think my old tube of autosol was exhausted and pitched. All I have is a giant can of the stuff, and it separates like organic peanut butter.

But I polished the back of a blade with it, anyway (just like peanut butter, you stick something down in the can until you reach the meat).


Different stinky (more mild than dursol, a little bit of an ammonia smell - dursol smells like stinky grease) - a little more gritty feeling and less greasy feeling than dursol, but once it's pushed into the wood, the result is the same.

polish is so bright that the camera gain should've been turned down more. Iron in person looks the same - like mercury.

I've never seen an SDS of dursol, but (without going to look) recall that autosol had a light solvent, maybe some protectant, abrasive and ammonia.

I'm sure I didn't get that right, but it seems much more mild smelling than dursol. VERY fast for its fineness and easily manipulated in SYP or hardwood.

little bits on the end are shirt fibers, etc.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#153

Re: Tying up loose polishes - Autosol

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

petroleum solvent and surfactant dispersant.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#154

Re: crest complete (And more dursol)

Sgian Dubh

" Richard mentioned in a post below that it takes longer to remove wear from the back of an iron than I suggested."

David, are you referring to something I might have said in a post somewhere? I can't recall suggesting it takes particularly long to keep the flat face of a chisel or plane iron flat. I am well aware of the fact that using a standard bevel down bench plane, such as a Stanley, or a Clifton through the range of, say, no 4 to no 7 or 8 results in wear to the flat face through general dulling and as the shaving slides up the flat face until it meets the cap iron. A chisel's flat face can also get a bit rounded, convex, but the precise causative mechanism(s) is/are probably a bit harder to pin down than is the case with plane irons, apart from the obvious dulling of the cutting edge caused by use.

I have said to you privately that I usually, probably 90 percent of the time, therefore not always, sharpen a dull tool (bench plane iron or bench chisel) by working the flat face of the tool first just to make sure that flat face is flat. It usually only takes a few seconds, maybe eight to fifteen I guess - I've never timed it. I'm not sure that I've ever specifically described that initial sharpening stage I use at this forum, but I might have done and just don't recall it.

Following that bit of work on the flat face I work the honing angle, then it's back to the flat face with, ideally, the end of the tool hanging over the edge of the stone and the initial movement a backward drag to turn the burr (wire edge) away from the tool's cutting edge, a bit of swishing about follows, then something like three to six alternating single backward strokes on the honing angle and the flat face. After that, up 'til now all I've done with the tool is a bit of flipping back and forth on the palm of my hand, and back to work. However, as I've mentioned elsewhere, your 'unicorning' thing is intriguing and potentially useful; I just haven't had a real opportunity to play with the technique much, except to say I've already found it does seem to work nicely on gouges. Slainte.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#155

Wrong R

David Weaver

I had in my mind for some reason that Robert Hazelwood's name is Richard Hazelwood.

Though if we're talking about backs of irons, your suggestion to double up on the work and work the back first, then the bevel, then the back again is present again, and a good one.

I was hoping to test my 10 second (back wear gone on the washita) or 10+10 method (10 seconds to remove wear, 10 seconds light pressure to make a really fine edge) on a dull iron, but I have none at the moment and am past the dimensioning phase of what I'm doing so I won't have anything.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#156

separate, since you got caught in the net...

David Weaver

..of my poor memory for names, as I recall, you mentioned using an india stone.

I'd imagine that with a few seconds before and after the bevel work, all wear is gone. The india is efficient. Where folks run into issue with not removing back wear is going to very fine stones and polishing a large area (perhaps either or both).

One of the attractive things about the washita is that it can work fast with pressure, but for someone just starting out, I'd imagine removing back wear with an india first and then finishing the tip with a washita second would be even better.....my bloviating about the buffer on chisels is partly due to "completion". Shapening in theory only because sharpening in practice if someone actually completes the job, and a lot of people don't.

I saw a fun thread on the blue forum recently about the woodpecker's guide (soap opera type) where the resolution to sharpening problems was to use an expensive guide and a large number of stones. Since you're actually making things (TM), you have to complete the job of sharpening, and not in 8 minutes. I have no such requirement to do the job quickly, but fast and complete results in satisfaction and continuing the hobby. I think beginners would be far better off with your method than starting with guides and working themselves into ever longer routines just to avoid understanding removing wear at the edge and then refining the edge a little bit. You can always spot someone who doesn't get it with those things because they will assert that a freehand edge will never match a guide. Usually, the guide edge won't match a freehand edge (in practice) because the person using the guide often won't complete the job.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#157

Re: separate, since you got caught in the net...

Sgian Dubh

David, my sharpening kit is pretty simple, and what I use depends where I'm working and what bits of my kit I have handy. When I go out doing contract or freelance work in other peoples' workshops I carry a combination oilstone. It doesn't take up much room and does the job, and it's generally all I need to get by ... well, not just get by, but be productive.

The only other stones I use on a regular basis are my ceramic stones in my own little workshop at home, a medium and a Spyderco ultrafine. Primarily because of the lack of oil in their use I do prefer the ceramic stones to the combination oilstone, but I can't be bothered hauling the whole ceramic stone caboodle about to different workplaces involving as it does the stone holder thing and the skooshy bottle of water - it's too fussy for me to bother with.

I can't be bothered with guides myself. I didn't learn to sharpen that way, and from what I've seen when people use them they're fiddly and slow, they get in the way quite often, and they can't be used on non-standard chisels, e.g., gouges and the like.

I know I've said the following before, but I'm in that group of woodworkers that operate on the 'Sharp'n'Go' principle, i.e., sharpening has to be quick because while you're sharpening you're not working wood, which doesn't at all diminish the importance of using sharp tools. There's nothing wrong if it takes you ten minutes, or even twenty minutes to sharpen a plane iron or a chisel, generally just so long as you're not involved in making a living as a woodworker, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#158

Re: separate, since you got caught in the net...

David Weaver

agreed - i missed or forgot if you've mentioned before that you've gone to the dry ceramic matrix stones.

Beginners are often battered with suggestions that they need a lot of steps or really fine stones, presumably in an effort to help them find success without understanding what's going on, and probably in some cases, because the instructor is selling stones (at least one that I can think of).

ritualistic routines just point people away from using hand tools, though, or such things as choosing a skew rabbet plane over a square one (which is a functional improvement of vast amounts, and no harder to keep sharp freehand, but with jigs, it becomes a debacle).

When people say they can't freehand sharpen, I suggest that they buy a washita stone, put a fresh grind on an iron, and freehand the tip of the iron only and work the back and then strop on leather. When the response is that they have better edges than they've gotten before, it's not because the stone is fine (unlikely that they'll have that touch yet), but rather because the get a quick method that they'll actually *do* and can do less than perfectly and still get good results. It's better to go from there to finer than to try to troubleshoot why a fine stone "isn't working right" when it's not touching the edge in the first place. Very easy to add fineness to an already well sharpened iron.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#159

Re: separate, since you got caught in the net...

Sgian Dubh

Oh well David, sharpening is one of those things that in some circles seems to have taken on almost mythical elements of complexity and difficulty. As you say, there may be teachers out there who instil on their learners some sort of deeply involved and complex process for getting an edge on a tool.

I've lost track of the number of furniture and joinery students I've taught, including teaching them how to sharpen. My guidance has never involved anything more complicated than pretty standard kit such as an oilstone and freehand, plus maybe a bit of leather and buffing compound if that stuff is to hand. Abrasive papers work, as do ceramic stones, diamond stones and Japanese stones, and I imagine that just as good after a bit of practice and developing an understanding of how the stones work are Washita stones and coticules, neither of which I've had reason to use, or remember even seeing in a workshop situation.

If the learner(s) I've taught how to sharpen subsequently decide(s) to make their sharpening routine more time consuming, finicky and involved with guides and multiple stages, or any other wrinkles they want to come up with, that's their choice. Slainte.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#160

Chinese Agate

David Weaver

The slowest stone that I have. In fact, I don't know that it could finish an edge after a washita and it seems to almost not cut at all. I tried to prepare an edge with a diamond hone and then microbevel off the wire edge from the diamond hone and install a tiny very fine microbevel with this stone. After a few minutes, I couldn't get the entire edge to leave the stone.

The edge in this picture is very fine looking, but don't let it fool you, it took a minute or two of an almost finished edge to get to this point.


This stone is hard but it has almost no sound transferrence (no tink tink like a ceramic or trans arkansas stone), and the feel is extremely soft. You can slurry them and they will cut a little bit for a tiny short period of time (like not even a cycle to hone something and then the rolling particles will make an edge that's not that fine).

If you try to focus on a tiny small area, I've found with this or ark stones, you'll get tiny failures at the edge if you get heavy handed.


The pictures make it look better than it is, there are a couple of failures bigger than that. great for aligning edges, though. I dropped my vial of 1 micron diamonds somewhere and can't find it -the soft feel of this relatively hard stone would make it very pleasant to use with micron diamonds.

These aren't that cheap - $80. There have been a lot of cheaper versions on ali express, but most of those are pressed-together cuttings or stone dust and those don't cut finely and aren't worth having at all. This one is a novelty.

For practical purposes, compared to washita and then linde a (buffer)- notice the uniformity of that system:


Sharpness off of the agate isn't that great (the pictures look nice because I buffed the bevel side to get rid of the wire edge). Sharpness off of this washita and linde A edge is otherworldy for a time commitment of about one minute.

Sharp enough to hang a cherry shaving over the lens of the phone and see this well through it:


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#161

Pic of the stone

David Weaver


passes light. These can be white or green usually.

The stones made of material smashed together don't pass light and are gritty. This is the smoothest feeling stone I've ever used, but it just doesn't do anything.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#162

Owyhee Jasper

David Weaver

A very hard (harder than novaculite in feel and musical note when tapped) slow natural stone from the west and southwest. I've had good luck with two types of true jasper - biggs and owyhee.


You want nothing to do with these unless they're a large uniform slab that's already polished to a flat gloss surface - they'll be about 1/4th inch thick and you'll need to glue them to something stable.

No clue what the price is now, but large slabs in jasper are something like 6x3. There are a lot of small pieces intended to be cut into jewelry.

Biggs - usually white and iron oxide red

owyhee - add green to the above

David Barnett told me long ago, if you get these, you'll have better luck finding a piece with less color variation. I see this as a two-fold benefit (i've had maybe 8 slices of this stuff) - first, a plain looking stone will be very even and not have any weird spots, and second, you'll be able to actually see if there are little voids or cracks.

Price for each of these when I got them was about $10.

Very slow, too slow really to be practical, but a good burr chaser. I didn't scratch the top of this stone, and i used it with a thin film of honing oil. If this stone is scratched, it is fine cutting but extremely aggressive and will raise a tiny burr.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#163

picture of the stone

David Weaver


David Barnett also mentioned that these are wonderful for cleaning up the business end of engraving tools because of their hardness and tolerance to little sharp edges without damaging the stone.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#164

Purple Welsh Slate

David Weaver

This small stone is very very fine and a little slow cutting. Self slurries - would be an excellent razor stone.

Hone slates are slower than most other stones per fineness but they very finest examples make a very even edge.

I used this one about 30 seconds after washita. I'm convinced that If I were to use it for a few minutes, most of the scratching would be gone (again, something that's desirable on razors - sharpening a razor once a year for 5 minutes is no big deal).


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#165

Norton Queer Creek

David Weaver

This stone is generally used with oil, but can be used either way. Thanks to John Aniano, I have a fresh one to test (the welsh slate is also John's). This one is free of oil, so I used it on water.

I think these stones are silica. They're slow cutting for their fineness, but once the loose particles are dealt with, I think you could manage that characteristic (wide flatter grooves) and get a "Soft" feeling edge out of it. One that's not that toothy.

Definitely fast enough to use practically, but in nearly new shape, this one does have some large particles running around making for some slurry dulling.


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#166

Pic of the stone

David Weaver


I've seen these from light brown to dark brown. Not sure what the difference is other than maybe just the color of oil on a broken in stone.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#167

Re: Purple Welsh Slate

David Weaver


A very pretty purple stone with a very smooth feel, self slurries a little but the slurry is too small to slurry dull anything.

Little green streaks in it along with the purple color gives it away as welsh slate.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#168

Re: Pic of the stone

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Queer Creek stones are a fine sandstone. They are mined in Ohio, but what we usually call Ohio sandstone is coarser and used for grinding wheels.

I bought my Queer Creek stone in 1983 for $3.50. It was kind of bluish grey or grey with a hint of blue.

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#169

Re: Pic of the stone

David Weaver

This one is a little different. I believe that if it were used for a while, the remaining particles would be locked in place and it would cut finely.

I'm assuming you use yours with oil? Can you describe what you use yours for and how much you like it?

As you know, a lot of what you get out of a stone is what you make of it. I recall folks trying to squeeze QC into being razor finishers, and they would be fine with classic razor sharpening (keeping the bevel thin), but they won't match something like the purple slate below if working all the way to the edge, and a fair number of trips to the linen and leather would be needed to establish a smoother edge.

The purple slate that John sent to have checked over with this one is a special stone, though, and in its format, I believe it was intended specifically for razors.


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#170

Very dense....

David Weaver

Density of this stone is around 2.8 SG. I haven't measured slate before, but surprisingly, they can be slightly heavier than novaculite or pure silica stones (not sure what's in slate that's that dense).

Silica, IIRC, tops out around 2.67 SG.

I won't go into detail about how I overshot the measurements on this one a little bit, but I did to make sure that I didn't understate volume and then overstate the density (we're talking fractions of a percent).

In inches, this stone is 1.55 x 0.91 x 4.97 inches. About 7.0102 cubic inches.

converting to CCs

7.0102x(2.54^3) = 114.877 CC

Approximate SG = 325/114.877 = 2.83

Mass of the stone in grams - 325 (surprising because it's almost the same mass as a significantly larger stone that John sent).

Online references show slate in the 2.7-2.8 SG range. This little stone is much different than most of the slate that we're used to in the US (it is solid with no flakiness).

Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#171

edge picture with a razor

David Weaver

Getting a fine even edge on a razor (this is mostly slurried on top of that) is a harder test than getting an even edge on a plane blade (especially given that I've been buffing the bevel side of the plane blades for the pictures to make sure that there's no straggler wire edge spoiling the pictures - the razor edge shown below is "off of the stone" on both sides with no stropping).

A very good edge that will have little defect after a few rounds of linen and leather.


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#172

Black Sedimentary Stone

David Weaver

Another stone of John Aniano's - the last of 3. A black sedimentary stone with small sparkles. This stone was oiled before and won't cut with water, so I used a drop of light oil and then it came alive.

2.2 specific gravity, and enough power to raise a wire a wire edge and leave a strong cutting pattern.

I've seen black sedimentary stones like this before with little sparkles in the matrix of the stone, but have no idea what they are.


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#173

pic of the stone

David Weaver

Relatively plain black looking stone. one side profile showing a sparkly bit. They're subtle, but they're there.

I have another razor hone that sparkles like this, but it's small and it's got a bit of tooth like this one. No clue if they're the same stone.

Labeled lack sedimentary stones of note (water of ayr labeled or scotch dual hones) are prohibitively expensive, so I haven't had any. Some of the razor types (there's a french type called la lune) that aren't English have collectible value but aren't that fine. The la lune will sometimes say things like "only for good razors" on the stone. They leave stray scratches compared to more widely seen natural finishers (eschers, idwalls, coticules) - I would guess they need a tough razor edge to not have significant tooth (nobody wants "tooth" when shaving).

I think these sedimentary stones work fast on water, fast on oil - if they autoslurry as this one does. But you can always make them cut slowly by using them with oil and them using water as the lubricant. They almost cease to cut and leave a very bright polish. I don't think it's a practical method, though.



Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#174

White Cretan  - Novaculite

David Weaver

White Cretan stone. A finish stone that's still mined and sold that's a coarser version of the old turkish oilstone. I believe these are actually mined in crete, and if not, somewhere close.

They are inexpensive in europe. A bit coarse on the finish compared to some oilstones, but fast and practical and buffer on the back side of the bevel does a good job of keeping the edge neat and straight.

Strangely, the buffed bevel side makes this stone leave a super bright surface (or rather, it's occurring to me that when the bevel is buffed and it burnishes the wood a little bit, the stone on the opposite side only needs to be "so so" as a finisher). On the bevel side, this stone is fast and it will make a wire edge. On the back side, it can build some slurry, and I like to let it do so, as it moderates the cutting action some.


Re: Sharpening Stone Ominbus - here we go

#175

stone pics...

David Weaver

..it's black. The label says white. When you first get these, they're sort of a dusty gray color, but with oil, the stones quickly become black.


These are friable, but that shouldn't fool anyone into thinking that they're not hard. They're very hard and would tolerate carving tools as a pre-finish stone. They don't quite have the range of a washita (they won't settle in quite as fine, they're always releasing a little something), but they are a "one stone" that I could use with touch, a lot like a washita.

The speed makes them fit my thoughts about what most people miss in sharpening. Finishing the job. Managing the wire edge properly is probably miss #2 behind that.

Stones like this and the washita are the best way to learn freehand honing because you can go straight off of a grinder and get a finished edge - in secondary bevel and back, tease the wire edge off with alternating back and forth strokes and then bare leather stropping. The most basic of sharpening (aside from single bevel all the way, which isn't practical for a beginner or really for heavy work or damaging wood).