Development of Steels that Get Used for Blades
david weaver
One of the things that sticks out to me (caveat this with Cliff Stamp's comments that he found S30V to outperform low carbide steels once the knife microbevel gets to 25 degrees per side, but at more commonly used angles, the geometry of the knife is more important and that for slicing (food, cardboard, etc), the edge life of simple steels like lower carbon stainless steels in the 0.8-1% is better than S30V).
Anyway, one of the things that sticks out to me is how many of these steels were actually developed to be blade steels? V11 may have been.
It sounds like the major consumers of S30V and other similar steels are industrial die use. Same with D2, same with A2.
I'm assuming that hitachi/yasuki steels were actually developed for blades (i have heard that, but not read it anywhere). They generally don't need 25 degrees per side (!) to perform well.
that's not to say that you can't make nice utility blades out of some of the "wondersteels", where you can tolerate that blunt edge angle, but cutting cardboard, scraping plane handles, cutting food - those things are 99% of my uses. Cliff Stamp's stuff resonates with me, but he isn't completely one dimensional - he does have some tests (cutting carpet, etc) where S30V has better edge life than simpler steels. At one point, I worked for a carpet and tile guy - and cutting carpet is pretty nasty.
Cliff also has topical material that doesn't seem to be that popular in the knife community, and that is driving simple steels to thin profiles and high hardness, because in slicing, that's really what gets you the least amount of effort and the highest edge life if edge life is defined as stopping when cutting ability gets to a certain point.
Where I read that a lot of people see 154CM as a starting steel to move up from, I'm going the other direction, and will be dumping the 154CM buck hunter that I have. It's a nice knife, but I see no practical use for it (given that I'm not a hunter, and if I was to do it again at some point in the future, I'd take the 110 in 420HC instead). I just can't get on with the idea that there is a good reason to increase a microbevel to 45 or 50 degrees total to get the most out of a steel, unless you're literally scraping aluminum with a knife.
Stamp's videos on Joe Calton's 1095 driven up to 65 hardness are pretty interesting. I'm not going to buy anything from Joe, but I'm going to take a shot at making a few knives of the style that joe does (hard and thin).