Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Pictures of Various Honing Options

Posts

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#51

SGPS

david weaver

I think that's the name of the steel in the fallkniven knife. (Patrick might be the only person who finds anything interesting about this).

I did touch up the SGPS knife last night on a diamond one and then something around 3 micron diamonds. To my surprise, it drew a small but very tough wire edge that I couldn't reasonably get off of the blade with my razor chrome ox lap (not worth risking hollowing it with pressure).

I ended up having to use a hanging strop to sort of round the wire edge off and hone it off. It's really persistent!

I think I can still see tiny interruptions at the edge from the bubbles, but it doesn't prevent it from shaving hair. It just makes it a bit "catchy".

It'll be interesting to see how it holds up cutting boxes, but I plan to make a small fixed blade knife to do that (out of a file or something - something very small and thin).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#52

Re: Evolution of opinion

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

The Stanley Bailey plane is a pretty slick piece of engineering. So is the Japanese plane blade—just the blade, which has zero parallel lines in it.

I enjoy Patrick’s engineering/metallurgy. And David, for a guy who eschews engineering, you do quite a bit :) . I enjoy your engineering too! Perhaps your original meaning is ‘we need people to do like I do’—is that possible :) .

Wiley

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#53

Re: to do like I do.. (!!)

david weaver

I think we need fewer people like me and more people like George!

My curiosity gets the best of me, but then it runs out (it's running out temporarily) and I must admit that I always feel better if I break through the inertia and try to do something new that I may fail at half a dozen times first (like making planes).

(ditto on the japanese iron - especially the ones with super soft jigane - they still take a while to sharpen, but the experience of soft jigane on natural stones is sort of tactile massage).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#54

Re: to do like I do.. (!!)

Patrick Chase

I agree that it would be nice to have George. Not sure about "more of them", as I have this nagging suspicion that they would end up p*ssing all over each other (metaphorically of course :-).

I think that your ledger is very much in positive territory. Re-popularizing proper cap iron usage alone should suffice to atone for any sin of over-engineer-ness.

BTW, I also don't give people advice to use uber-alloys or super-complex sharpening setups. While I think they each have their place, they certainly need to come very late in our progression after we've sorted out what's what.

One other semi-related remark in response to something you've brought up a number of times: I don't own a 'lectrical jointer nor do I use the perfectly nice one at work, so I do all flattening by hand. I do cheat and use a lunchbox for thicknessing some of the time.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#55

Re: to do like I do.. (!!)

david weaver

Even I do that!! (lunchbox planer sometimes). There are lots of times when i have to do something I don't like (building a bench isn't something I wanted to do, and I realize there are options to avoid that, but I didn't like any of them) - the lunch box planer and table saw came in handy for that. Helps that you can mostly slop a bench together like it's timberframing and still have something that works well.

I'd hate to be cheated out of face and edge jointing, though.

re: the alloys, I like listening to cliff stamp - I'm sure I talked about that ten times already. He is sort of a polarizing figure in the knife community (but there is a lot more goofiness going on in the knife community than woodworking) and he said that if he was going to do a cutting test to take advantage of S30V, he'd do a final bevel of 25 per side .

I don't know if I have anything with S30V - I don't think i do, but sometimes you find stuff you didn't remember that you had.

My large carbide knives seem to give up the very edge to the strop, but the style with them to go to micro diamonds probably doesn't involve what I do.

I'd say from what I've learned from actual objective posters in the knife world, the large carbide steels might make a great high angle iron in a BU plane.

I think I'm going to start working on that tablet that I was talking about....I need a new gimmick to work on to get away from the microscope.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#56

Re: SGPS

Patrick Chase

Yeah, Super Gold Powder Steel. You have to love the hokey steel names. I've always appreciated Veritas for going with an apropos Spinal Tap reference when it came time to brand theirs (per Rob Lee as relayed by Derek, IIRC).

Out of curiosity what 3 um diamond medium did you use? I've seen worn-in plates pull wire edges with sufficiently "tenacious" alloys, though in my experience it's much less common with films and compounds where the edges are generally pristine.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#57

Re: SGPS

David weaver

It was 3 micron loose diamonds on brass bar stock. Still pretty harsh and not a finishing step due to the harsh substrate.

The wire edge was to my. But stiff. A true false edge that sort of shaved hair, but wouldn't give itself up to oiled leather.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#59

Re: SGPS—what it is

david weaver

Thanks, Wiley. I have been too lazy to look it up. I just got into work, and it's in my pocket right now. I'll probably carry it for a while, resharpen it a few times and then check for bubbles again, but the bubbles are on practical deterrent (you can still shave a missed patch with them if you have to).

I'm surprised to see that it's really not as complex as i thought it would be, it's like turbo 440c with more carbon and a few other alloying elements. Presumably, that's part of why they can drive it up to high hardness (and the hardness explains why the wire edge is rigid).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#60

Not similar to 440C *LINK*

Patrick Chase

CTS-XHP/PM-V11 is basically a "super 440C", to the point where Carpenter advertises it as such. SGPS can't really be described that way because of the relatively high Mo and V levels. Both of those form very hard carbides, and change the behavior of the alloy quite a bit.

See comparison in link. zknives is indeed a nifty site.


http://www.zknives.com/knives/steels/steelgraph.php?nm=CTS-XHP%2CSGPS%2C440C&ni=1100,577,420&hrn=1&gm=0

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#61

Re: Not similar to 440C

David weaver

To a guy who uses mostly carbon steel, that would qualify as a super 440c (add carbon, add some nits of other things), vs something like a tungsten hss, which is entirely different.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#62

Linked review

David weaver

http://www.zknives.com/knives/kitchen/ktknv/shun/shunsg0403santoku.shtml

I wonder if the reviewer had steel with bubbles in it. His description of its behavior matches my findings, which I'd have puzzled over without a microscope.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#63

Further thought on this..

david weaver

....T1 came to mind, because i adore the tungsten high speed steels as blade steels if you need something with temperature resistance. They are lovely and fine. At some point, razor makers tried to use steels that were part of the way there as razor steels (I really don't know why, except that they may have been easier and faster for cutlers to grind since heat would be less of an issue - the wheels most of them use are water cooled, though).

CPM-121 REX would be another material that I'd say is "not" turbo 440C.

I'd use the term turbo O1 for blue 1 and 2, or even super blue (which I never enjoyed in a kanna).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#64

follow up to that review..

david weaver

..i should manage to put all of these in the same post from the same device (which would allow editing).

Also interesting in that review was a very bad tip break off with the SGPS, which I mentioned before when I was looking at bladesmith type tests (which are relatively pointless, but a knife having a tip break off in use is not).

My two favorite kitchen knives are spec 61 and 62. Even that is already pretty hard (the former is VG10, the latter is blue 2) and a bad user on the blue steel can lead to micronotching or whatever you'd call it. I use the blue at an angle that I wouldn't sharpen the VG10 to. I wonder if the desired hardness that people push the SG2 to has more to do with tips breaking than anything else.

My personal preference would be for a knife that sharpens well on a single stone (both of the above sharpen very well on a suita, or on a hard arkansas) and can be refreshed easily where refreshing is no more than wear. If I had a knife tip break off in normal use, I'd do like the reviewer - grind the spine - but I'd curse the person who was chasing magazine specs to avoid what amounts to very infrequent sharpening with blue and VG10.

I'd imagine white 1 at an acute angle and 65 hardness would not tolerate a lot of abuse, either, but it would be a superb slicer and work at a more gradual angle than SGPS (20 degrees per side is pretty blunt for a thin profile slicer).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#65

Blue *LINK*

Patrick Chase

I'd say that the Blue family are fairly unique steels unto themselves.

The blues have notably higher levels of carbide-forming alloyants than O-1, and a lot more Tungsten in particular.

The other thing that's very noticeable are the lower levels of Mn and Si. Those alloys are both added to neutralize Sulfur/Phosphorus contamination, so their low levels in Blue are enabled by the alloy's relative purity.


http://zknives.com/knives/steels/steelgraph.php?nm=Blue%201%2CBlue%202%2CO1&ni=599,601,150&hrn=1&gm=0

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#66

Re: Blue

david weaver

If you hardened blue 2 at 60 and O1 at 60, i'm not sure that you could tell the difference between the two.

You could identify T1 pretty easily, or D2, though. Maybe not necessarily what they are, but based on their behavior.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#67

Development of Steels that Get Used for Blades

david weaver

One of the things that sticks out to me (caveat this with Cliff Stamp's comments that he found S30V to outperform low carbide steels once the knife microbevel gets to 25 degrees per side, but at more commonly used angles, the geometry of the knife is more important and that for slicing (food, cardboard, etc), the edge life of simple steels like lower carbon stainless steels in the 0.8-1% is better than S30V).

Anyway, one of the things that sticks out to me is how many of these steels were actually developed to be blade steels? V11 may have been.

It sounds like the major consumers of S30V and other similar steels are industrial die use. Same with D2, same with A2.

I'm assuming that hitachi/yasuki steels were actually developed for blades (i have heard that, but not read it anywhere). They generally don't need 25 degrees per side (!) to perform well.

that's not to say that you can't make nice utility blades out of some of the "wondersteels", where you can tolerate that blunt edge angle, but cutting cardboard, scraping plane handles, cutting food - those things are 99% of my uses. Cliff Stamp's stuff resonates with me, but he isn't completely one dimensional - he does have some tests (cutting carpet, etc) where S30V has better edge life than simpler steels. At one point, I worked for a carpet and tile guy - and cutting carpet is pretty nasty.

Cliff also has topical material that doesn't seem to be that popular in the knife community, and that is driving simple steels to thin profiles and high hardness, because in slicing, that's really what gets you the least amount of effort and the highest edge life if edge life is defined as stopping when cutting ability gets to a certain point.

Where I read that a lot of people see 154CM as a starting steel to move up from, I'm going the other direction, and will be dumping the 154CM buck hunter that I have. It's a nice knife, but I see no practical use for it (given that I'm not a hunter, and if I was to do it again at some point in the future, I'd take the 110 in 420HC instead). I just can't get on with the idea that there is a good reason to increase a microbevel to 45 or 50 degrees total to get the most out of a steel, unless you're literally scraping aluminum with a knife.

Stamp's videos on Joe Calton's 1095 driven up to 65 hardness are pretty interesting. I'm not going to buy anything from Joe, but I'm going to take a shot at making a few knives of the style that joe does (hard and thin).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#68

One more grind and bubbles gone...

david weaver

...maybe someone can enlighten me about how the powder layer is made. Is it "blown out" as a layer and then never machined? what about the layer on top of it, is that layer folded on, or is it also blown on?

I worked the edge of the knife over one more time, and the bubbles are gone, except at the tip of the knife (which didn't get as much work).

There are still a few bubbles up from the edge, but they are at the transition line between hard and soft steel.

I was confused by the bubbles at first, but now I'm even more confused, because they're gone.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#69

Sintering

Patrick Chase

PM steels are sintered (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sintering).

The basic process is as follows:

1. The liquid base stock is atomized into a large number of small droplets, which dry instantaneously and uniformly into a powder, without forming significant internal microstructures. This is what gives PM steels their ultra-fine structures, as the droplets dry faster than dendrites etc can form.

2. The resulting powder is packed into a die, and heat and pressure just short of melting conditions are applied to form it into a solid. For PM steels the sintering process is typically carried to full density, i.e. they keep "pressing" until all of the voids have been removed.

IIRC the leading makers use Hot Isostatic Pressing (HIP, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_isostatic_pressing) for the sintering step, which produces very low porosity.

What you saw certainly could have been caused by incomplete/imperfect sintering. It also could have been caused by subsequent processing, such as welding the laminate "stack" together.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#70

Re: Sintering

David Weaver

Do you think they machine the hard layer at all after sintering, or is the die pressing final, and they just form it and go with it. If the latter, that would explain the bubbles.

Now that I've got the bubbles out of the edge, I need to grind the shoulder back. It's probably well over 20 degrees per side. I like it a lot more without the bubbles. It is a strange agent when touched last by a natural stone, though. Just not quite sharp. I'll have to scope it tonight to see if the natural stone looks like it is pulling particles off whole.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#71

Please translate for mere mortals

Josko Catipovic

Could someone please summarize this thread for us mere mortals? I keep reading it and getting lost in the trees.

I guess my latent question is: should I think about honing my plane and chisel blades? I take them down to an 8000 grit King, and that's it. They are sharp, but I have no idea how much sharper they could be.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#72

Re: Please translate for mere mortals

Brian Holcombe

I think it's better to use this thread as something to refer back to as you progress in your studies than to ask for the quick and easy.

The overall debate is around levels of hardness WRT steels and purpose (chisel or plane), types of steel, level of refinement in steel and effect in both sharpness and durability of sharpening media types on various steels.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#73

Re: Please translate for mere mortals

david weaver

Any of the options in the pictures are fine. When you're at your bench, you do what pleases you.

The kitayama stone is very similar to a king 8k in fineness.

The rest of the commentary and comparison are for two reasons:

1) it's been suggested several times that the "LV" compound (which is actually Formax microfine) is full of nefarious stray particles. Indeed, it has aluminum oxide in it (which makes it more useful for woodworking - it speeds it up). You can see from the pictures that the quality of the edge is a significant step up from 8k waterstones.

2) someone on another forum asked what next level they should go to after autosol. So I scoped it (because I have used the "dursol"/"autosol" edge before and found it quite fine). The answer to that is really nothing, there's no need to go to any more steps - it's already absurdly fine.

The rest of the significance of the pictures is that you can see what the result of the various mediums is, and of highest importance is the edge and not the scratches on the bevel.

Without the pictures, people will not believe anything you say. Discussion of autosol focuses on particle size, and "what is it" rather than how well it works, so the pictures sort of squash that diversion.

If you like the 8k, then there's really no reason to add extra time to sharpening. There's no way it's limiting your work in any way.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#74

Re: Please translate for mere mortals

david weaver

I forgot about the underlying discussion of small vs. large carbide steels, or even another dimension - iron carbides only, or lots of other stuff.

I didn't scope any fine diamond edges, but may do that. If someone is into wondersteel, there's no great reason to finish with anything other than diamonds.

I noticed last night that the SGPS knife that I'd worked up with diamonds went backwards when I put it on a very fine japanese stone. That's not something that should happen, but a scope of the edge will probably tell the story - I just haven't done it yet.

I have a severe distaste for diamonds (or silicon carbide) on very good carbon steel, though - especially as it gets very very hard.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#75

Mere mortal to mere mortal......

roger lance

It seems that you could hone beyond a 8,000 grit stone......but realistically, you have to ask yourself just how long will this sharper edge hold up in use??

That sharper edge durability seems marginal.....relatively short-lived in practical use.

Honing up to a 8,000 to 10,000 grit stone appears to be the upper-end sweet spot for people using their tools and concentrating on their work more than sharpening to some extremely high standard.