Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Pictures of Various Honing Options

Posts

Pictures of Various Honing Options

#1

Pictures of Various Honing Options

david weaver

(in response to someone's comment on another forum about "what should I get to go a step up from autosol)

First, two edges as calibrators. On these pictures, focus on the edge, and what you can see of the foil, and not the scratches. This is at 200x optical. All edges except for the diamond hone edge are bright and shiny without flaw to the naked eye.

Everything is given a light leather strop to make sure no trash is left on the edge. The diamond stone is stropped briskly, but it would take a minute or more of heavy stropping to remove the entire foil, so I stopped at about 20 seconds.

Kitayama 8k - a slightly nicer version of the king 8k, and slightly finer.

https://s8.postimg.org/5t2diyf6d/kitayama.jpg

Ezelap 600 - settled in - a new one would be a lot more brash - this is brash enough.

https://s8.postimg.org/x3noqv2np/ezelap.jpg

A large ohira suita (a nice stone - it's sort of a rumor that the japanese finish stones are super ultra fine - they're dependent on the hardness of the steel to achieve a really really fine edge that's beyond something the kitayama. Their abrasive isn't as strong as modern heavy concentration al-ox stones, which is why the wider range that's hardness dependent)

https://s8.postimg.org/o8mugcll1/ohira.jpg

Formax green compound - this is the one where we field comments often about its spurious nature. Used on balsa. It's 70% al-ox, and some part of 30 is chrome ox. It's an extremely useful wax stick. Soft, and applies easily if you don't apply it too heavily and you use a drop of mineral oil. It cuts almost as fast as a finish stone but leaves a fine edge. The speed eliminates impatience mistakes or mistakes of repetition on a soft surface (rounding over edges).

https://s8.postimg.org/d91n4rib9/formax.jpg

Hand american 0.5 chrome ox on balsa. This is a powder that's no longer available easily in the states from shaving suppliers. Hand and a shop called star shaving sold it *cheap*, like $9.99 for 125 grams of powder. Danger if you have a shirt that you like - it's a pigment. The line for this stuff in the razor community is that if you want to get the most out of it, you need to bring an already finished edge to it. I'm not sure what preceded the powder, but probably the suita or another similar stone. You can see it smudges what's there, but it would take a lot of repetition to really remove everything (this kind of thing would be a complete waste of time - that could perhaps be 2 minutes of swiping it around after an edge that already shaves hair).

ttps://s8.postimg.org/w1di8awp1/0.5_chrome_ox_powder.jpg

And the autosol. This is why I said it's a waste of time to go beyond autosol. This is done on smooth horse butt leather that's clean. I probably stropped it on bare leather afterward, and the dots on all of these edges (if they are there) is just tiny tiny oil droplets from my strop, which I scrape and oil from time to time to make sure it's not got contaminants, and that it's smooth. Dumbest thing in the world is bringing something to a strop and nicking the edge on it.

https://s8.postimg.org/uz3bpso6d/autosol.jpg

The forgiveness of the horse butt (which isn't much, but a little) makes the autosol cut more finely than it would, as does the lubricant with it (i believe it's 3 micron al-ox). The edge is wonderful, good enough for anything. The larger particle size than a micro compound makes it faster to use, which is also good. You have both a better chance of completing your sharpening job, and a better chance of eliminating errors of overrepetition.

Autosol on horse butt can have a tiny wire edge, as can the formax compound, and the others. A very light strop on a clean smooth strop is never a bad thing.

(I chose not to waste my time finishing a chisel with chrome ox after already finishing with something like a sigma power 13k, which is a 0.73 micron abrasive sized stone, and I chose not to do the same and follow with .09 micron iron oxide, though if you wanted to spend ten minutes, you could make a bevel look like a window pane.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#2

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

Patrick Chase

On a tangential note, I love 0.5 micron Cr-Oxide (the pure stuff, not the green compound that LV etc sell).

As you say it's a very "soft", slow abrasive that's only suitable for cleaning up an already-honed edge, but it does that very well indeed. When I use it I use 3M 061X lapping film (I know, now your thing), mostly for convenience and because it's reasonably inexpensive.

I suspect the reason you don't see Cr2O3 lapping compounds as you do with diamond and AlOxide is because it's so soft-cornered that it won't embed into the surface of a lap.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#3

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

david weaver

I've long been curious as to whether or not the slowness is due to its abrasive properties, or just due to the fact that it's actual 0.5 micron grading.

IIRC, the kitayama stone is about 3 micron size, and it's a strong cutter for a soft stone, but it glazes over without the use of a slurry. You have to chase the slurry around the stone and use it to keep it cutting finely and fast.

The rest of the stuff creates a better edge, including the microfine bar.

re: where to get the graded stuff, I'm going to get a bag of pigment from kremer, in the hopes that maybe it'll be slightly larger. I've seen it marked in bags up to 3 microns, but that's bigger than I want. I would assume painters, polishers and soap makers are probably the main customers (as opposed to diamonds and al, ox, as you say, which have a lot of lapidary and industrial use).

MSDS for autosol says <30% "alum earth" and gives a number that confirms that that's aluminum oxide. A seller who I won't name once told me it's 3 microns, but I'm wondering at this point. Another seller just told me it's not abrasive at all, so you just never know. Of those above, for cheap and easy, I'd go with the Formax stick and a drop of oil or the autosol. Autosol's knock is that the film that it leaves on a tool has some serious staying power. The first stroke of a chisel always seems to leave something black on the work. No problem on plane blades.

At some point, I'll have to take a picture of whetstone powder on jasper. I took that picture for the japanese chisel, but these are stubai and AI MK2 chisels.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#4

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

Patrick Chase

Cr2O3's slowness is well known to be due to its abrasive particles.

I have diamond and CrOxide films from the same supplier (3M), graded to the same standards, and there's no comparison in speed. The diamond is many times faster. For that matter 3M's 0.3 um 265X AlOx film is much faster than their 0.5 um 061X CrO film.

The main benefit of CrO is that it's an extremely gentle abrasive, that does a good job of cleanly removing any residual foil edge. It also tends to "smooth out" the scratches left by previous sharpening steps, though I can't find any SEM shots online that show that at the moment.

Another interesting option for a gentle abrasive that I personally don't have much experience with is tempered or "calcined" Aluminum Oxide. Tempering allows the maker to obtain a wide range of material and abrasive properties. The AlOx in the common green compound is a low-hardness tempered variety, and that's probably why it works as well as it does (Brent Beach's "outlier" results notwithstanding), despite containing those nominally large alumina particles.

Autosol may be playing similar games with the abrasive. There are many more factors than just the size distribution.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#5

Re: Razors vs. Chisels

david weaver

Patrick - recall when I put the first razor pictures up? I mentioned that the edges look ragged because they always give up something to the strop. These edges are somewhere around 28-30 degrees (I didn't measure these specifically, it's just where my final bevel ends up with chisels unless I'm adjusting the very tip of a chisel to be used for mortising).

The edge holds up miles better after the strop, and it looks much better. Razors are somewhere around 16 degrees for most standard proportions, and above that by a couple of layers of tape (the standard method of increasing bevel angles on a razor if an edge is troublesome) that probably brings the angle to 20 or the low 20s - the edge starts to feel smooth but blunt at the same time.

It probably makes more sense to look at chisels with these edges because the issue of steel quality and (qualities of a particular razor) is much less important and much less variable.

There's a whole gaggle of other things that go into making a razor really good above and beyond these points, though - and that includes use of a linen in the long term, which is a completely foreign concept to many, including a lot of folks in the shaving community.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#6

Razors are for shaving, not woodworking

Patrick Chase

The retention of isolated carbides along an edge is strongly dependent on edge angle. As you implicitly acknowledge, straight razors are very much an edge case (pun intended) in that regard, in that they use angles so low that any exposed carbide will come out in short order and likely during stropping as you say. You can't generalize from that to the ways in which woodworking tools are sharpened and used, though. You also can't draw any valid conclusions about WWing from the fact that a given alloy or sharpening method works well for straight razors.

While you could never use A2 (relatively coarse structure, lots of carbides) for a straight razor there are some tool applications where it works OK. Steve Elliott's studies did a good job of showing this. A2 had micro-chipping problems at anything less than 32 degrees edge angle, but once you got above that threshold it started to perform reasonably well. His data demonstrated that at higher edge angles diamond abrasives *were* capable of sharpening carbides in situ, and that those carbides had sufficient matrix support to stay along the edge for many hundreds of BF.

So while I acknowledge your point that a lot of the points that I raise about metallurgy have debatable practical relevance to WWing, the same is very much true of your overgeneralization of straight razor results. It's a completely different regime with very different behaviors and tradeoffs, and your observations there have no relevance to WWing tools other than perhaps paring chisels (insert my usual snarky remark about Blue Spruce's choice of A2).

For the record, I only use low-alloy steels for my paring chisels for exactly this reason. I also use O1 irons in a couple BU planes that are set up at particularly low angles. I think that it's important to be non-dogmatic about steels and sharpening methods, and to recognize that there is no single right or best answer. Everything has its strengths and weaknesses, and IMO you can benefit by understanding those and choosing the right alloy/abrasive/whatever for your application.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#7

Carbide retention

Patrick Chase

I would note that carbide retention is also dependent on abrasive and edge angle in my experience. Sharper abrasives are better in that regard, as are higher angles.

The reason is fairly obvious: When the abrasive is softer than the carbide (as is always the case for SiO2) all it can do is "erode" the matrix around the carbide until it falls out. When you finish honing a tool on your Washita any remaining edge carbides will therefore be physically protruding with partially eroded matrix support. It is therefore thoroughly unsurprising that your tools "give up" any such carbides on the strop or within the first few BF of use. They're basically sticking out and "catching" on every fiber that comes along. At straight razor angles the problem is compounded by the fact that the residual section of matrix providing support to the carbide is literally razor thin.

Once again the danger here is of overgeneralization. While your results are extremely useful to folks employing your specific combination of angles and abrasive medium, they lack relevance to others who are working in different regimes. Diamond compound at, say, 30 degrees leads to radically different edge-carbide retention than SiO2 at 20. Diamonds tend to cut all materials equally, leading to less carbide protrusion (there are plenty of SEMs out there to show this), and higher-angle matrix provides more support to the carbides. Less tendency to "catch" plus more support equals better retention.

Once again being clear about what I do as a practical matter: For the most part I rely on abrasives (AlOx and leather) that can't refine carbides, and I avoid large-carbide steels for most uses as a consequence.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#8

Re: Carbide retention

david weaver

Patrick - not suggesting that you should find razor talk useful for tools. Not suggesting that a die should be made based on 30 degree bevels, and not suggesting that carbides don't have their usefulness (there are, in fact, iron carbides in eutectic steel).

Pointing out at this point that you had suspected the edges on the razors didn't look that good. These edges actually look a lot better than the razor edges, but they are, in fact, less refined.

There's a dimension to edges that these pictures don't show, and that's width.

An outside curiosity of mine, though, is that novaculite (which I understand to be some kind of chemically transformed si02) is "softer than the carbides" in A2, but you can't actually find any evidence in the level of refinement in the edge that they are not being abraded by the trans ark. I don't know where those pictures are on this forum at this point, searching is difficult, but I showed that while the carbides were torched by the washita, the trans ark made a very lovely fine and quiet edge. Some of that may have had to do with fact that LN's cryo treatment yields an otherwise pretty fine edge.

I have my doubts (but no proof) that the holes left in the edge were 100 percent carbide. They may have actually been bunches of carbide pulled out with iron matrix, but I don't know and it's not that important. What was important to learn from that for me was that if I want to use the A2 iron in my shop, the trans ark will put quite a nice edge on it and very quickly in skilled hands (better than the edge from the kitayama stone, and with no maintenance). The washita can only do pre-work or rough plane work.

I only have one A2 iron, though.

I stick by my original statement that nobody would work faster than me with wondersteel(R) and wonderabrasive(R). They might work faster than me because they're less fat, but not due to steel choice. If they choose to use wondersteel(R) and a single iron, they'll be in for a long day of watching my donut soft physique bury their efforts.

I do find the razor edge difference interesting, though. When I moved to straight razor shaving, I noticed in setting up an old razor that it was a lot harder to get the edge right. You will find the fragility of the edge with harsh abrasives unless you take them to a very fine point (for example, I think you could work from a diamond hone through diamond powder on a progression and have a damage free edge. A harsh one, but it would be improved in one or two trips to the linen). I started shaving while I was using shaptons - they weren't really the best thing for the job.

Back to the other point, though. You might be able to come up with some site work, planing plywood, planing paint, cutting staples, etc, where all of the foolishness of wondersteel(R) and wonderabrasive(R) pays off, but it's not going to be there for a dude planing in a shop with access to a sharpening stand and no overarching boss.

I will concede that there are some stanley and other irons, though, that I've found too soft for my taste. Not many, but you get one once in a while.

In terms of steel process or talking about technology, it's all fine and good, but it serves the woodworker exactly zero. To the extent that it distracts from design, efficiency or skill building, it's a negative.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#9

By the way..

david weaver

Carbides are extremely dependent on edge angle, I agree. That's why they are not in razors.

You can plane a lot of feet of surface that doesn't look that great using a steel with really hard carbides in it.

Cliff Stamp has a LOT of good conversations about the practical side of bevel formation in knives when people start getting goofy steels. It materializes in reviews sometimes when a "guru" gets something like a tidioute knife, states that it's made of 1095, and then proceeds to discuss how surprised they are with edge life in cardboard cutting test, that it's among the highest scoring knives they have.

It's a very low wear-resistance steel, but it fails uniformly and the profile of the blade is good for the job. People could read a lot of literature about 1095 or get a low cost soft knife like Bear and Son and argue themselves right out of the conclusion, but I think I'd rather just take advantage of the knife itself.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#10

Re: Carbide retention

Patrick Chase

With regard to the question of what does or doesn't abrade what, I think that the Mohs scale is helpful as a "cognitive shortcut". Recall that Mohs defined his scale based on exactly that property. Higher-numbered minerals scratch lower-numbered ones, and not vice-versa. It's therefore safe to say as a rough rule of thumb that if two minerals are separated by a full point or more then the higher-scoring one is impervious to the lower (again, because that's how the scale was defined, not because of any magical or scientific property of the scores).

SiO2 is the defining mineral for Mohs 7, i.e. it's the specific mineral that Mohs chose to establish the meaning of "7" on his scale.

Cementite, the carbide found in pure Carbon steels like White, is Mohs 6-6.5, so it can clearly be refined by Novaculite.

Chromium Carbide, which is the "problematic" one in A2, comes in at Mohs 8.5. It can be refined by Al-Oxide (the defining mineral for Mohs 9) but not by Novaculite. PM-V11 also contains a lot of Chromium Carbides (more than A2 in fact), but they're small enough that they don't end up significantly limiting edge refinement even on Novaculite.

Vanadium Carbide as in Fallkniven SGPS is Mohs 9.5 or so. Anything less than diamond/CBN is the equivalent of bringing a knife to a gunfight.

When you look at things this way the World starts to make sense, in particular why people who use Novaculite tend to prefer HCS, why there's such a range of opinions about A2 (there are common abrasives both above and below it), and why people who don't use diamond intensely dislike steels with a lot of large Vanadium Carbides. It also explains your observation that PM-V11 puts your Washitas to sleep. All of those little Chromium Carbides are lapping the living daylights out of your stone, even if they aren't big enough to greatly compromise the edge.

Admittedly I'm skipping a bunch of factors here. Carbides come in different phases (K1 vs K2 etc) with different hardnesses, and carbide size matters a LOT.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#11

The original point of this..

david weaver

(it's a repost from another forum)

The original point was two-fold:

1) there was a user elsewhere asking where to go up from the autosol for the "next step". I gave the answer regarding the 0.5 stuff and suggested it was a waste of time (it is).

2) There is a certain user who constantly rags on Lee Valley about the green stick on that forum. It gets really old. Said user pasted a strop with the stick as if they'd melted three crayons on a 3m sticky note. Where do you even start with something like that?

I figured I'd get a picture of the actual edge using the green stuff, along with the mention that it's about three times as fast as pure chrome ox - perhaps faster. It is strong enough to use coming off of a middle stone, and the edge is quiet and extremely sharp.

It wears me out to see the quarter dozen or so trolls using this honing compound as an excuse to start badmouthing LV, who has almost single-handedly lifted the level of service that we get as customers. As if LV has staked an entire business plan on selecting a small green wax stick (one of the few that's easy to use because it's softer than normal) to defraud the entire customer base and run off to mexico with their millions. I'd bet they probably tried the compound and put the ad copy in their catalog after noting that significantly improved the edge of the norton 8000 that they carried at the time.

A pretty easy look at the level of improvement can be had opening one tab with the kitayama (a well liked inexpensive stone) and another with the formax edge. A couple of quick flips back and forth and a view of the actual edge shows the level of improvement. The 0.5 chrome ox could step it up a tiny bit, but it's not practical and it has far less range.

I was surprised by one thing in this, though. I thought I'd show an autosol edge that looked like the kitayama and suggested to the person with the original question that most people find an 8k stone perfectly fine. Those who don't usually don't use it to its potential. I was a bit shocked to see its work.

But for the various types of green stuff, if I put a chisel with the formax and the green chrome in your hands and let you pare ten swipes, you'd never be able to tell which is which.

I've got a couple of cheaper sticks that I'm curious about that I'm going to try. They're nominally 5 microns, and $9 for a kilogram.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#12

Re: Carbide retention

david weaver

I've understood all of those things for ten years. I've considered the desire to have those carbides in anything a waste of time between then and now, in seeing no actual use-utility from them.

I do like them in power planer blades, milling cutters, drill bits, etc.

But for hand tools, they're a waste. For a knife that you're going to use and keep sharp...same.

I don't prefer plain to vanadium carbides due to sharpening media, I prefer plain on novaculite to vanadium carbides on diamond. I started with the latter and moved to the former. At some point, if you're examining the planed surface you leave behind, you get tired of tiny lines. You want surface uniformity. And you progress past taking a million thousandth inch shavings to take shavings that the plane will allow you to take with an 80% effort. Same with chiseling - perceived problems with steel disappear with experience. Automatically.

As far as the SGPS, it's not so much an issue of needing to be able to sharpen the steel - that's no problem. Presumably the carbides are small. The trouble is that it literally has open bubbles in it, and they are not torn-out carbides. They are just bubbles.

It's another issue where the approach to make a steel is touted, but the execution is poor. The knife itself fails compared to tidioute's wall street knife. You can't buy the latter at this point unless you want to spend double what new price was, but the people driving it up could probably care less about the steel - that's a collector issue.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#13

Practical honing compounds

Patrick Chase

I agree about people bashing the common green compound. When informed of the situation LV changed their marketing materials so that they no longer claim that it's "0.5 micron", and that should have been that.

I think that Brent did us all a disservice by presenting the results he did the way he did. Most people get far better practical results with the green compound than he showed. Unfortunately it seems that every couple years somebody new "rediscovers" his stuff and starts raging about it on the forums.

A lot of the people involved in these discussions seem to have a "size fixation". Abrasive grain size is critical for ultra-hard abrasives like diamond or even full-hardness Al-Oxide, but matters much less for more friable abrasives that break down in use.

The tempered/calcined alumina in that green compound falls into the latter category because it breaks down pretty quickly. When used properly the compound delivers good results. More to the point, if it's good enough for George Wilson then it's clearly workable, period.

Obviously you can get rough results if you smear a bunch of fresh compound on your strop every time you hone and then don't work it long enough to break it in, but you can mess up any honing method if you're sufficiently ignorant of its behaviors and requirements.

I haven't used Autosol much, but it wouldn't surprise me at all to learn that it has similar behaviors, and can produce a finer finish than it's nominal grain size would suggest.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#14

Re: By the way..

Brian Holcombe

This is a very interesting discussion to me, but I am really only following along.

I want to make a point about the practicality of HC steel blades, I know I bang that drum pretty regularly :D but I have a comment i'd like to make in terms of linear footage without much degradation.

I plane thin boards that I use to build art frames, they're about 40-48" when I cut them and I usually just cut up a few boards and plane the entire stack at one given time. This will usually be around 45 of these boards. I have it down to a science that from rough sawn to finished takes me 5 strokes per board of a reasonably heavy cut.

I use a HC steel blade because the quality of finish does not taper off rapidly, it does so slowly and so I can make it usually through the entire stack without sharpening if I start with a newly sharpened blade. Of course it will be in need of sharpening at the end of it.

My calculation is that I'm planing around 1200-1500 linear feet once I count all of my plane strokes. The last board is usually a little duller but once it is out of context it is no longer really "dull".

I know of blades that can cut around 3600 linear feet of material, but I can only imagine what those last few passes look like, or even the passes at the stage where I sharpen (1200ft~)

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#15

Re: The original point of this..

Bruce Mack

I agree. LV green stuff on MDF, masonite, or leather strop always improves my edge, whether obtained on Shapton 15,000 grit or 1 micron diamond paste on cast iron. I have used Paul Seller's method of 20 passes if I am too lazy to go to coarser media. This too works for a time though not ideal

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#16

Mid-priced polisher waterstone

Patrick Chase

On a semi-tangential note: I'm shopping for a gift for somebody who uses and likes waterstones but is currently relying on the old King 6K. They expressly want a finer stone, not a suggestion for a different honing system.

I've had my eye on the Kitayama 8K (which I've never used) and the infamous Metal Master 10K resinoid mystery stone (which I have and think highly of, as you used to).

Any thoughts? One thing that gives me pause about the Kitayama is that it's a Magnesia stone, so it has some handling constraints. I don't think that's a huge deal in a polisher though, as we don't soak those anyway.

Also, the Kitayama is an Imanishi-made stone, unrelated to Matsunaga/King.

I realize that I'm dragging you back to your stone-obsessive roots here, so feel free to ignore :-).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#17

Re: Mid-priced polisher waterstone

david weaver

Well, I still have some of these stones, of course.

I do get a chuckle out of us now considering the kitayama a mid-polisher (but that's probably a relevant tag to give it compared to the 1 micron and submicron stones).

I liked Kuroda's 10K alright, but it does enjoy a soak more than not if I recall. I think I sold that one. I also sold my chosera.

I also really liked the shapton 5k - if one can manage a wire edge a little, it's a 3 micron stone and strong. Most people want it to be either a 1 micron stone or a 10 micron stone and get dissatisfied with it.

I also liked the chosera 3k a lot - like the 10k, it's an entirely different stone when it's soaked. When it's not, it's HARD. When it is, it's pleasant. Strong cutting, but not that cheap and it doesn't polish at 4 microns (IIRC - going on memory). It almost polishes, but not quite.

I guess of all of the 8k stones that I've tried, the snow white is probably my favorite on the lower cost end. I have no idea what they want for them here now, but they're really cheap on buyee (yahoo japan). The trouble is unless you buy EMS, you won't get one here in time, and if you do, it's going to cost about $40 or so to pay buyer fees and EMS, so you're back to over here.

I think snow whites are about a 2 micron stone, and they just feel like a chosera 10K (when soaked) that didn't go through enough sieves to get as fine as it should have.

I didn't know kitayama was magnesia. I've had two, hate to say that - once in a while I sell something and I get a jones back. It's been a long time with synthetic stones, but I must've gotten a jones for the kitayama a few years ago, as I found it new in the box on my shelves earlier this year. The trouble with the kitayama is that it doesn't maintain its slurry nicely. By that, I mean once you soak a chosera, you can pretty much rub something on it all day. It'll be smooth, it won't load, it won't dry out.

I don't know if the instructions say to soak the kitayama stone, but it seems to have an ability to load, so you chase the slurry around on it, or you constantly diamond lap it - one or the other. These are, of course, workable, but we are spoiled. The cho 10K can be a bit like that unsoaked, but if you've been using it for a while, it isn't at all. Same with the snow white. Good Stone. Should be about $70, but isn't here due to distribution or lack of, either or.

B. Snow White. Final Answer.

(sample prices from buyee:

Shapton kuro 12k (cream): $60

Shapton Kuro 1k : $25

Chosera 3k (original type, still available in japan) $82

Buyer fees add some menial amount, shipping in country another $6, and figure another $20 for registered air. receipt is usually about a week after order, unless a seller is contrary.

you can combine items in packages there, but no shipping option is great from japan if you get over 2kg. EMS is exorbitantly expensive (but good), and the only other option is ground shipping, which took 70 days last I got it, and there's a fair chance of damage with ground shipping.

So, I guess if you can find it in country for something close to $100, that'd be the route I go.

Final Final.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#18

Found one...

david weaver

..that didn't take long. I was off a little on my numerical guess.

$67.35, but you have to pay consumption tax. Actually, you don't really have to, but the seller is allowed to collect it regardless, and they don't have to pass it in if you're an overseas buyer, so of course, they'll do that.

That brings the price up a little:

http://buyee.jp/item/yahoo/auction/v530411571

Other price that I forgot. $54 for King 8k with base and nagura.

Chosera 10K, $256.

Forget the comment that we have to have the new smaller versions over here because of cost, it sounds like it's due to distributors adding costs, or the manufacturer having gaijin special for price (some sellers of tools over there have two sets of prices - one on their page in japanese, and one on their page in english. Typical is something like (this was actual) about $350 if you can read japanese, $500 if you can't for a good quality smoothing plane.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#19

Thanks!

Patrick Chase

I didn't realize the Snow White could be had that inexpensively. That's a no-brainer at the price.

That's also a magnesia stone (like the Chosera and the Kitayama) but it's very user-friendly as you say. It has a fairly "hard" feel to it but I think that this person would prefer that in any case.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#20

Re: Thanks!

David weaver

Buyee is a site worth snooping. If you're willing to pay for protective packaging and wait for ground shipping, you could get some stuff really cheaply.

I've gotten some interesting old fine synthetics from there that aren't like new stones. And one thats shockingly similar...pure white alundum.

Cheap good karma and maebiki, and piles of natural stones.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#21

Snow white

Patrick Chase

In a sign that I am an irremediable sharpening whore, you motivated me to dig out my Snow White and take it down to the shop (I'm working form home today and I was waiting for somebody else for something).

I'd forgotten how much I liked that stone. It's fast and easy, gives good feedback, is reasonably hard, and as you say you can get a nice range of effects by varying volume and moisture content of the slurry. A complete beginner can get good results and an experienced user can get more. It's a nice example of clever binder engineering getting fairly unique performance out of ordinary white alumina.

Thanks again!

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#22

Re: Thanks!

Patrick Chase

w.r.t. older stones, you're absolutely right that for the most part there's no rocket science in the abrasives of the current crop of synthetic waterstones.

They're mostly aluminum oxide, with high-purity white alundum being particularly common on the higher end. I think there are a few makers out there using ZTA (Zirconia-Alumina ceramic), though I can't remember offhand which brands/stones. Sigma and Shapton both use SiC for a few stones in their respective lines, but that's nothing new either.

Other than that you're mostly paying for tight grading and clever binder design. I do think that the newer ceramic and resinoid binder systems are "real" contributions and shouldn't be trivialized, though. There's more to it than just dumping a bunch of WA into a vat of shellac or mixing it with clay.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#23

Re: Thanks!

david weaver

If you go back far enough, you can guess the colors of the alumina stones and the silicon carbide stones (red and dark gray or black), but it's not universal.

I've never had much interest in barber hones because they're usually 1200FF or something like that (not sure of the grade) in abrasive, and it's the binder and surface finish that makes them cut more finely. They're not intended to work to the edge, which is a skilled user's thing and that makes them hard to sell for much.

There are (in the 100+ year old range) tan and lighter colored alumina versions, though. I'd guess some kind of shellac resin for the binder on them, and no clue on the surface treatment - but once the surface treatment is damaged, they're not usually too fine cutting.

The best feeling synthetic stone that I've ever used is a frictionite 825. It can load a little bit, but it feels fantastic. Like a harder version of a soaked chosera. Older stones relied on you using a rub stone to clean them instead of flattening the surface off. The advent of diamond hones has probably made the latter preferable, but context is important.

American hone used rhodolite in the frictionites, and a combination of rhodolite and silicon carbide in the super punjabs (George told me that someone at CW was using a super punjab as their finish stone, I think a carver - spitting on it).

They're all interesting, but the finer barber hones are too expensive unless you chance into one offline. The australian local axe-man competitions make for a strong market for any fine dry hone to touch up axes during the competition. I sold all of George's frictionites and super punjabs for him for an average of about $200 for the small barber sized stones - I sold all but one of them to a guy in australia who is distributing them locally to competitors. The norton axe man is the one you'll see from time to time selling for a grand. I don't really get it from a capability standpoint, but I understand the economics.

re: the stones I've gotten in junk lots. The old WA stone that I have is probably 8k, it's brash, super strong and fast. I have another bench stone barber hone style stone that's more like 5k, same - the equal of anything more modern, and very slick feeling, and probably not that long wearing. And I have a brown (not tan, but brown like the color of an older style alumina) stone that I thought was vitrified and is about 8k. I introduced oil to it, and that was a bad idea. Not sure what to do with it yet. They're interesting.

In the box, also, are vitrified stones that are like two to four steps finer than a fine india - 5 micron level, perhaps. They are really really nice to use, smooth working, etc. Not sure why that kind of thing didn't catch on here, but it might've been the wide availability of arkansas stones.

One more side comment - looking yesterday at stones, I saw the kitayama with base, brand new, $37 on buyee. No wonder there are so many japanese sellers trying to sell them for $70-$125 on ebay.

I lied - a second side comment. Naniwa really wrung their hands over the cost of making magnesia stones, and maybe something was lost in translation. The chosera 10k still is very expensive over there ($256 on buyee - there's a bunch on there all the time), but I tend to think it's a prestige pricing thing given the cost of the snow white ($67) on buyee, and at the time they were peddling the idea that magnesia stones were too expensive to make, fujibato had a batch of 6k stones made and sold them on ebay. They were $38. Quite nice, too - chosera feeling. The only isssue is, what do you do with a 6k stone? If he'd have had the foresight to make that stone in 2 microns or 1 1/2, I think he'd still be selling them.

if you're trawling buyee at any point and have a question about anything, let me know. I've gotten a lot of stuff off of there. One of the dealers sells new shoubu and ohira stones, and what I've gotten from him is very good stuff for reasonable - I can pass you to his store. A giant green ohira tomae is usually about $200. Not a song, but a fraction of what those stones sell for over here. Slightly smaller suita like the ohira suita that I used in the pictures can be had for about the same price. Big suita, not so much - always expensive unless they look like junk based on the slurry/iron flower picture.

You can buy a junk lot of about 15 kg of old synthetic stones on there usually for about $80, too. If you're willing to pay $15 to get the stones packed in protective packaging and then wait for surface shipping, it would probably only be about $150 for a gaggle of interesting old stuff.

Kanna with kamaji of makers now out of business, somewhere in the range of a dollar a millimeter of blade width (the current makers like tasai, usui, etc. ...those are all still expensive over there, just like they are here).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#24

Re: By the way..

david weaver

this is a perfect example of the kind of subtlety that you run into when you're planing stuff and you get enough iterations under your belt to get annoyed with little things like shavings splitting due to small nicks, etc, and being able to feel trash on the surface.

I'm sure the wear bevel on my O1 iron is longer than it would be on something more wear resistant. Not much, but a little. but it's uniform.

Just as I'm sure that some folks can put irons in a guide and sharpen sharper than I achieve with the washita and leather, but i'm looking for that uniformity in planing, and the thing that stops the planing is lack of clearance usually, and not lack of fitness of the iron to create a good even clear surface.

I tested an LN iron against an IBC when IBC brought their iron set out. Both worked appreciably long, both were new (so maybe the results would be different after a quarter of an inch), but the LN iron lasted a little longer because it chipped slower. Not the fairest of comparisons on chipping at the new part of an iron, but I wasn't going to grind a quarter of them off.

What I remember from that is that the LN iron got through about 1100 shavings before I gave up - hard maple, and the only requirement was to continue to be able to plane 2 thousandths. Somewhere around 300 strokes is where I'd normally resharpen. The IBC iron lost a few bits out of the edge around 100, and it was downhill faster from there. If the LN would've done that, probably the same durability would've come out of them. At that 100, I'd have had to go back to the stones for a finish pass, and then hassle again if the iron let go of a nick or two in regular planing.

The LN iron didn't do it, though, and started to resist clearance a little bit 300 or a little more. At 700, the surface was no longer smooth, it was fuzzy. I kept waxing it and rode it to 1100 strokes before I gave up - it wasn't practical at 700, at 1100, it was just a circus act.

I'm quite sure that my O1 iron wouldn't go 1100, but I'd bet it would go 700, and the work would be more uniform.

One other side comment - George often talks about how people want to drive O1 to be too hard now. I'd speculate my house-made iron is 60 or 61 based on how it responds to the washita. It's not harder, and it's probably not softer than that. It will easily outlast the two Hock HCS irons that I had (and have since sold). I could tell a noticeable difference facing boards with them vs. Hock's A2, but I can't with mine and A2. I am ready for a break when either of them is shot.

The biggest difference in planing, regardless of the iron, though, has been using the cap iron. I don't plane more feet, but I remove a whole lot more wood in those feet, and clearance is less of an issue for all but the last pass of finishing strokes. Even if the iron is a bit on the dull side, if it's uniform, you can still do those finishing strokes (not butterknife dull, of course, but on the bubble for when you'd take it back to the stones).

When we turn a carbon steel iron (that's been sharpened and treated properly) toward the light, we see a continuous edge of wear. When we do that with HSS and A2, we often see tiny interruptions. I hate those.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#25

Re: Thanks!

Patrick Chase

w.r.t. Magnesia stones, they're more common and cheaper than Naniwa would have you believe. Imanishi [*] were already making both the Kitayama and their own-brand 10K before the Choseras came out, and as you say you can find those cheaply if you look around. I didn't realize they could be had *that* cheaply until you pointed it out though.

To be honest I don't see the point of super-high-end synthetics like the Cho10k or the Shapton 30k. IMO they really don't bring much besides exclusivity and bragging rights to the table to justify the price. I've always suspected that the Snow White existed to plug their obvious competitive gap w.r.t. similar magnesia stones like the Kitayama and the Imanishi 10k. I can understand dropping hundreds or even thousands on a quality JNat even though that's not my thing, but not a mass-produced hunk of WA. The Sigma 13K is basically the most expensive synthetic stone I'll touch. It's not perfect, but it gets the job done nicely IMO.

You're also absolutely right that quality synthetic alumina stones are nothing new. I think there have been some incremental refinements in abrasive grading/"tweaking" (tempering etc) over time, and similar refinements in the binders, but I don't doubt that the older hones you reference work terrifically for woodworking. We are not after all doing rocket science here.

SiC is light green at high purities, though most abrasive applications use lower-purity black SiC. There's not much point trying for perfect purity in an abrasive that's *supposed* to be friable. I don't think I've ever seen a red SiC hone, though I'm sure you could manage it in a stone with a high enough volume fraction of colored binder.

[*] As an aside, Imanishi makes a bewildering array of stones under several brands: Imanishi, Bester, Beston, Kitayama, Arashiyama, and probably more.