One Last Go at Sharpening Materials
david weaver
I thought I'd do a couple of things and then close the deal with the easy diamond sharpening, but it didn't quite work out that way.
You can feel the effect of the carbides on novaculite, which the SGPS steel grades to some extent but the edge finish isn't that good. That's traditional knowledge (it was probably a combination of carbides and low hardness with the original stainless steels that gave it a bad reputation in hunting knives).
I went to the washita to see if it would "pull carbides" like we figured it would. It does a little, but not much. I expected the edge to look more burnished. I think the scratches look deeper than they are, but the edge isn't good, anyway. Easily shaving good and push cut paper test (without any slicing), but not what I'm used to from carbon steel.
https://s13.postimg.org/be1eoaj07/washita.jpg
Following that, I thought I would put some 6500 grit diamonds (probably 3 microns or so, the bag isn't marked. The steel didn't agree with this at all. I could feel some grabbiness - I have no clue what the deal is here - not sure if the grabbiness is something that matches with ripping out carbides, but it's inviting to think something easy like that. The wood used was just a cherry offcut - nothing on it, and it was planed flat.
https://s13.postimg.org/vy68mu3x3/6500_on_cherry.jpg
So, I went back to the IM313 to redo the edge, because it is surprising just how fast a medium crystolon cuts this steel - it shreds it, and a fine india does the initial finishing work very well. Two minutes, you can remove just about everything and raise a giant wire edge with the crystolon and refine it with the fine india.
I followed the india with a charnley with the same 6500 diamonds on it (I had attempted to use this combination for watch polishing, but it was too slow. I have a lot of novaculite, so no rush to clean this stone off). It actually works great for this steel. The edge still lacks a little refinement, but it is probably sharper than 99.9% of pocket knives in peoples' pockets, and it shaves hair (all of these edges do - even the one with the pits). the diamonds are nicer to use on this stone than any other substrate I've used. It feels like a stone, not like a cheap imitation.
https://s13.postimg.org/99h1nfuav/313_then_diamonds_on_charn.jpg
and then just a bit of 0.1 micron diamond to try to remove any burr (no enough to completely refine the edge), but again, the feel was off on wood, so I stopped while I was ahead.
https://s13.postimg.org/876v4xthz/fin.jpg
The picture below is what I'm used to after about 1 to 2 minutes total on a reasonable japanese finish stone (with slurry, not chasing it any finer than that). This is the tidioute 1095 - not to be confused with the poorly done or soft 1095 that exists in 95% of the 1095 knives out there (ontario, bear and sons, etc).
https://s13.postimg.org/4c3h23utz/Still_Cap200.jpg
Given how the steel behaves on the washita, I can understand why the SGPS would make a better blunt edge or plastic die steel, but it'll never match the tidioute knife at the 35 degrees or so included that both are at - in around the house type stuff, at least.
The carbides just seem to be ready to come out of the SGPS any time something inviting comes along.