Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Pictures of Various Honing Options

Posts

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#76

Utterly predictable

Patrick Chase

The fact that SGPS goes backwards on a JNAT is completely predictable based on its composition. SGPS has significant levels of insoluble V and Mo, both of which form very hard carbides that can't be refined on silicate media. I realize that you don't believe in carbide refinement, but there's plenty of objective evidence for the phenomenon, and you appear to have inadvertently contributed yet another such datum.

More to the point, people who've objectively measured edge sharpness have seen the same thing with similar steels, most notably Steve Elliott. See his CPM-3V initial sharpness vs media results towards the bottom of this page: http://bladetest.infillplane.com/html/initial_sharpness.html. Even alumina-based waterstones were "challenged" in his test, which is to be expected as Mo and V carbides are both harder than Al-Oxide. That steel simply isn't a good fit for silicate media.

Out of curiosity did the voids come back when you honed on the JNat? If so then that would be slam-dunk evidence for carbide knockout...

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#77

Re: Sintering

Patrick Chase

I don't know what Fallkniven may or may not have done with the formed blank. I would expect that they'd machine it to thickness after hardening but that's guess.

I don't understand why you think that sintering would leave voids like that on the surface, though. I don't know of any physical mechanism of that would lead to such "preferential" void formation in the context of HIP, though admittedly that was never my specialty.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#78

Not useful

Patrick Chase

Bluntly: Trying to understand the ground we've covered here probably isn't useful if your goal is to be a better woodworker.

As David said, refer back to discussions like this if/when you want to go off the deep end for some reason. Don't let them lead you there before that, though :-).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#79

Re: Sintering

david weaver

Yeah, I wouldn't expect it, either - I'm just puzzled as to why they were there, and they are still there at the transition layer between hard and soft steel.

I'm just completely puzzled by it, and I know little about powder steel other than that it's sintered - as to how it's done after that, no clue. I figured they may smash the blade profile together in a die and then that could cause such a problem. I was surprised to see it.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#80

Perfectly accurate...

david weaver

..it's nutball stuff. As nutty as suggesting the formax compound isn't good for preparing plane irons and chisels.

Sometimes, when I take pictures of edges like we've done here, I have a thought in the back of my head that it will center a discussion or lead to economy for some (certainly, someone using a mid stone could easily go to autosol or dursol and have a fantastic edge without buying more).

I don't think that kind of thing happens very often, though. Instead, we get into long winding discussions and ask "how did we get here" at the end.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#81

Re: Utterly predictable

david weaver

It's not that I don't believe in carbide refinement - of course I do. you cut all carbides with diamonds. You cut soft ones with abrasives that are a bit harder, or you have a chance of polishing them if you find an abrasive similar in hardness to the carbide.

a Jnat (17% alumina) should actually sharpen everything in this steel except for the vanadium carbides, but the second question to that is really "how big are they?" I have no clue. I figured they may be so small that I wouldn't notice them being rubbed off whole.

I'll have to take another picture tonight to see if there are voids, but I suspect not like the early ones. I could literally see the other ones with the naked eye, and there is no such interruption at the edge this time.

Also, those voids were in the steel before I sharpened the knife at all - the knife came from the factory that way.

The reality is, if they were only at the surface, they're doomed to be gone, anyway, as I always cut the shoulder of a blunt knife like this back and try to find a thinner edge. It's novel that it's sharp, but at what is probably 50 degrees included, it's a blunt sharp, and that's good for scraping plane handles (which I do with pocket knives), but not much else.

The washita is starting to look like a master carbide puller - I can subject it to that, but it may be hard enough that it just skims the surface.

I have seen people talking about sharpening these knives (as well as S30V) with "regular" abrasives, but I don't see any reason to not just use diamonds when I have enough to supply debeers with little bits to sinter together into big stones for a week.

...

Ok, that's not accurate, but I have about 800 carats worth of diamond powder floating around.

Aside from all of that, what's even more curious to me is that the LN iron seems to love a translucent arkansas. Perhaps the carbide distribution is even, but there's nothing pulled out from the edge (like there is with the washita) when you use a trans ark. And the scratches are uniform depth all the way to the edge.

And one more aside - I found a natural stone that my tidioute 1095 knife doesn't like. An Ohira suita, the one I used in the pictures above. The Tidioute hates it, and the edge doesn't turn out that great (shaves hair, but the edge crumbles a little). You just never know!

(I sold the stone that I used to sharpen it in the pictures - should've kept it!)

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#82

I can't...

Tony-Memphis

And don't care, but for reference...I am a mere mortal - trust me! My last stone is a Norton 8000. I have a"strop" that is MDF charged with the green crayon from Lee Valley on one side and the Yellow Stuff on the other. I give that a few licks as the final step. I can't quote any numbers, microns, or otherwise, but that makes the edges pretty darn sharp! Does the strop make a difference? Hmmm, to be honest, I don't really know and again, don't care.

Yes, I play an engineer by day and I should be more interested in the minutia of all this, but honestly, it doesn't affect my work any. I think finding what works for you is the best course. Beyond a certain point, there is not much to be gained. Heck, I have NO idea what metal ANY of my tools are made of! ha!

Tony

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#83

Re: Either it motivates you to look further..

david weaver

..or it doesn't. So if it doesn't, then no need!

I am sort of a sharpening stone collector, so it tickles my curiosity.

FTR, what you're doing is reasonable and will improve an 8k edge. Not because the 8k edge needs to be improved itself, but because there still is a little bit of scuzz on the edge (wire edge bits) coming straight off of the stone.

You are trading them for much less scuzz or smaller scuzz when you use something to strop.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#84

Re: BTW...

david weaver

While I do like to see if there's something that doesn't fit the rules perfectly (stu also mentioned to me that he didn't see the rikizai irons being sharpenable on oilstones, but they sharpen quite well on them), when it really counts and vanadium is involved, I've always suggested diamonds.

You may recall my comments earlier about misguided knife makers trying to make fat heavy S30V razors (which is one of the dumbest things you could do, and I feel for the buyers who buy them at a very high cost, but they probably don't know). I've had several professional sharpeners ask me on the razor forum how to sharpen those razors when they get them, and there's only one answer if you have to shave. Diamonds. And then don't strop them hard, or they'll release carbides at the edge.

Horrible narrow angle steel. Horrible. Great for plastic production, apparently, and fine if you need a knife that has a 50 degree included angle, but otherwise pointless.

M4 taught me early on that when you just need to sharpen and get on with it, and it's more than A2 in terms of toughness, use the diamonds.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#85

Re: Utterly predictable

Patrick Chase

Molybdenum carbide is harder than Alumina, so 5% of the composition of that alloy produces problematic carbides.

Note also that what you want is for the carbides to be abraded flush to the edge surface (or else they're very vulnerable to chipout), and for that you need some margin between the abrasive and the carbides to minimize "preferential abrasion".

As to carbide size, it's complicated and I don't claim to fully understand it. What I don known is that PM nominally helps with primary carbides (the ones that form during initial solidification). It isn't a panacea, and there are also secondary carbides (the ones that form/grown during hardening) to consider.

SGPS is a stainless that undergoes two-phase austenitization, meaning that the secondary carbides don't go back into solution during HT. That tends to be a recipe for large[r] secondary carbides, which was the point I was trying to make many messages ago when I first remarked that SGPS looked problematic for your specific sharpening system.

Now why are we continuing to debate this when I dangled a nice, highly speculative cap-iron theory in another thread? I would have thought that would be a much stronger draw :-)

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#86

Re: Utterly predictable

david weaver

There's just not enough there in the cap iron thing (even with the labor minimization theory) to ever come to much of a conclusion. You'd also stated what I already state probably 6 times (in my habit of repeating) that the chip at its thickest point is probably the most important for holding everything down, so the thinning edges may be of no consequence if you remove the cap iron.

Maybe it's something as simple as being able to rotate the iron and continue to use it at the left or right (I never do something like that).

Nicholson just didn't give us enough detail, but doing so in every case probably wasn't the point of the book.

There are far too many other things that affect effort more than feathering the edges of the cap, and all kinds of other complications - such as whether or not the rule of concentricity applies for all radii.

I'm leaving mine straight and suspect adjusting them as general advice is going to be troublesome for a lot of beginners who grind first and then figure out how to bring the cap into constant contact with the iron later.

(suspecting anyone actually reads any of this and would try it).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#87

Re: Utterly predictable

david weaver

Molybdenum carbides, by the way, are softer than alumina. Even the kyoto stones should cut them. It's only the vanadium carbides that present a problem.

That doesn't explain the initial voids, though - those existed from the factory.

I'm still going to have issues with the knife if I bring it down to about 25 or 30 degrees total included. At that angle, it will give up its edge to a leather strop.

Cliff stamp has already documented well that in measuring cutting effort at angles where people would actually cut, S30V performs worse than the most basic low-carbide stainless steels.

(at 50 degrees or so included, the knife does give up some of its initial edge to horse butt, but it's so blunt, that it doesn't lose much. A lower carbide steel would go up in sharpness, but it goes in the other direction).

I'm still going to cut its shoulder back, though, and give it a zero grind - if it doesn't work out, I'll give it a tiny microbevel and work up from there.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#88

The Woodcentral version  of ...

Mark Nowicki

"Waiting for Godot"

I am not surprised that Ellis seems to have given up on the "Search" function.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#89

The first stone

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Josko and all,

Not sure this will reflect everyone’s experience. I have found that durable sharp is more likely achieved on the first stone than the last. Question being, was all the old wear removed on the first stone? A good primary burr is the assurance it was. If so, 8000g is fine; if not, no amount of polishing will remove that piece of old wear hiding down below the shiny new edge.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#90

Hardness of Alumina

Patrick Chase

The hardness of "Alumina" ranges from HV 1500-2100 depending on what grade you assume. Mo-Carbide is 1900. Let's call them "about the same" and let it go?

Either way "Alumina" abrasives are going to be really challenged on that stuff. As I said before, there needs to be some margin.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#91

Depends on process

Patrick Chase

If you only work the bevel, then you're absolutely right: If the first stone doesn't get you past the wear then you're hosed.

There are other processes (like Charlesworth's infamous "ruler trick") that can get around that, though. I'm not advocating that anybody should use those, just pointing out that as with almost everything the real answer is "it depends" :-).

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#92

Re: Hardness of Alumina

david weaver

>call it even<

No, because that's incorrect. Corundum (natural) is at the very high end of that (I see 2060 given as a typical hardness vs. 1880 for molybdenum carbide and 1800 for chromium carbide). Most alumina in sharpening stones is also at the very high end of that.

We don't hear people talking about how aluminum oxide stones can't sharpen A2, or any of the chrome manganese tool steels. We also don't hear about how oilstones can't sharpen 60 hardness carbon steel even though it's extremely close to their particle hardness. It will actually sharpen 62 hardness steel (to a better edge than 60), which is nearly identical in particle hardness to novaculite.

Japanese natural stones also have no problem with A2 (because they have corundum in them, not some modified industrial alumina that's intended to be softer). They are slower on the high-chromium steels (most are), because they are 17% alumina instead of 60, but they still cut them.

The only carbide in SGPS that is problematic is vanadium carbide. I think my knife would be better if it was tungsten HSS than SGPS, but good luck finding tungsten HSS (that also sharpens wonderfully on japanese natural stones). I suspect that the vanadium carbide is good for people who abuse their knives and keep them at a blunt edge, and it also allows the maker to show a chart to potential buyers about "how tough it is", though it will cause problems at acute angles.

The rest of the carbides are no issue, though.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#93

Re: Hardness of Alumina

david weaver

I may have picked incorrect numbers for the carbides, on the chart I just looked at, moly carbides are 1800, chromium 1735, and unmolested alumina 2100.

Regardless, it's no problem for either of them, or we'd have heard about it long ago.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#94

Thoughts

Patrick Chase

You're right about hardness numbers. I remembered the hardness of Mo-Carbide incorrectly (1800 as you say, not 1900) and also forgot that we're talking about a JNat with natural Corundum, so Alumina grade/purity doesn't come into play.

w.r.t. steel/media compatibility, carbide size matters. For example CTS-XHP has a *lot* of Cr-Carbide in it, that is unquestionably harder than Silica abrasive. Even so most people who've tried sharpening that steel on Arks/Washitas/etc think that it takes a good fine.

The reason is of course that CTS-XHP is a fine-structured steel even by PM standards, such that you can get a good edge even with an abrasive that can't refine the carbides. Some of the high-Vanadium PM steels (apparently including SGPS) don't share that property.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#95

Slippery slope though

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Patrick,

Well, you’ll never be wrong saying ‘it depends’ :) . However, no one works only the bevel side of an iron. And I will insist that a good job on the first stone is far more crucial to durable sharpness than the degree of polishing beyond the finish stone (which is what the OP was querying).

I think Mr. Charlesworth intended his method to complement a good job on the bevel side, not correct a weak primary burr. I believe he is after a quick cleanup of any burr or tags left below, not a facet which will survive the next sharpening.

Relying on a face treatment to correct a weak bevel treatment would be a slippery slope. Brent Beach was at one time, and may still be, recommending multiple facets on the face side of the iron, adding up to several degrees, as opposed to the 1-degree swipe suggested by Mr. Charlesworth.

My original post assumes a strong primary burr, plus normal working of the face side on the finish stone (and second stone if one is used), followed by a swipe on the strop if one is used, or something like the Charlesworth method. For myself, I use a Charlesworth-like method without the ruler, by just applying pressure at the edge while completing the last face side set on the finish stone.

Wiley

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#96

Picture post-jnat sharpening

david weaver

Small scope tonight. I don't feel like figuring out how to hold a stubby pocket knife with a steep rounded bevel in the bigger scope.

This is at 100x optical. You can see that the issue is subtle - it's just a little bit of hairy stuff hanging on at the edge, but this is a very fat included angle. If this edge was 20 degrees included, that scuzz at the edge wouldn't amount to much, because it would be thin on both ends of the scuzz.

This doesn't keep the blade from shaving, it just keeps it from getting to the point that the tidioute blade gets to. Regardless of the amount of stropping on leather, the edge just sort of stays like this, and will actually get a bit duller. Light strokes on the japanese stone brings it back to this.

Still relatively sharp, but not the blinding sharpness you'd get with micro diamonds.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#97

The same edge on novaculite

david weaver

...I started with a slow belt grinder and 800 grit trizact trying to relieve the shoulder on the bevel without using a coarse belt and beating up the side of the knife.

Just too slow.

Then over to the IM 313 with medium crystolon, which shredded the shoulder off really quickly and raised a huge burr fast. Not sure what the total angle is now, but I removed the crystolon scratches with a norton fine india, and then finished the edge on a washita. It was OK, but a couple of small voids from removed carbides appeared. Knives with carbides just don't like the washita, it's got grip.

So I did a couple of minutes of heavy handed honing on an old translucent arkansas stone and then did what I typicall do with poorly behaved razors, and that is finishing strokes, strop, finishing strokes, strop, keep repeating until there's no improvement. The result is the tiny dark band.


Hard to compare to prior pictures because the angle is much more acute.

Shaves hair well. Wherever the vanadium carbides are coming out, they must be small. Honing on the trans does create some black swarf, but not much!

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#98

Re: The Woodcentral version  of ...

TM Stock

There are no uninteresting things, only uninterested people.

G. K. Chesterton

This usually comes across as being a condemnation of the incurious, but there are exceptions. :D

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#99

Re: The sentiment carries across all..

david weaver

David Charlesworth does use a second bevel to remove the wear, but he's using the second bevel as you're describing a primary - a way to remove everything to undamaged steel, and then just applying a light tertiary bevel to get a finished edge. It works well, but for practical purposes, it requires a guide.

As you mention, beach likes to do this on both faces, and there's a guitar (making) instructor on youtube (brian burns) who has an arcane process similar to that.

I prefer, as you, the bias. I like to term that the craftsman's bias, because it's a sensible thing. Put the pressure or bias where you want the material to be removed.

At any rate, back to removing the bad stuff - cliff stamp does a lot of testing of knives, and his first move on a knife to be tested is to joint the edge so that the final apex will be fresh metal (without regard to whether or not a knife is a type that has been steeled a lot). And in the razor sharpening world, probably 90% of the terminal problems that are serious (as in the razor is not providing any shave, or a really terrible one if any) are related to not "setting the bevel", which is their term for establishing a clean primary bevel on a razor that is not in good shape.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#100

One Last Go at Sharpening Materials

david weaver

I thought I'd do a couple of things and then close the deal with the easy diamond sharpening, but it didn't quite work out that way.

You can feel the effect of the carbides on novaculite, which the SGPS steel grades to some extent but the edge finish isn't that good. That's traditional knowledge (it was probably a combination of carbides and low hardness with the original stainless steels that gave it a bad reputation in hunting knives).

I went to the washita to see if it would "pull carbides" like we figured it would. It does a little, but not much. I expected the edge to look more burnished. I think the scratches look deeper than they are, but the edge isn't good, anyway. Easily shaving good and push cut paper test (without any slicing), but not what I'm used to from carbon steel.

https://s13.postimg.org/be1eoaj07/washita.jpg

Following that, I thought I would put some 6500 grit diamonds (probably 3 microns or so, the bag isn't marked. The steel didn't agree with this at all. I could feel some grabbiness - I have no clue what the deal is here - not sure if the grabbiness is something that matches with ripping out carbides, but it's inviting to think something easy like that. The wood used was just a cherry offcut - nothing on it, and it was planed flat.

https://s13.postimg.org/vy68mu3x3/6500_on_cherry.jpg

So, I went back to the IM313 to redo the edge, because it is surprising just how fast a medium crystolon cuts this steel - it shreds it, and a fine india does the initial finishing work very well. Two minutes, you can remove just about everything and raise a giant wire edge with the crystolon and refine it with the fine india.

I followed the india with a charnley with the same 6500 diamonds on it (I had attempted to use this combination for watch polishing, but it was too slow. I have a lot of novaculite, so no rush to clean this stone off). It actually works great for this steel. The edge still lacks a little refinement, but it is probably sharper than 99.9% of pocket knives in peoples' pockets, and it shaves hair (all of these edges do - even the one with the pits). the diamonds are nicer to use on this stone than any other substrate I've used. It feels like a stone, not like a cheap imitation.

https://s13.postimg.org/99h1nfuav/313_then_diamonds_on_charn.jpg

and then just a bit of 0.1 micron diamond to try to remove any burr (no enough to completely refine the edge), but again, the feel was off on wood, so I stopped while I was ahead.

https://s13.postimg.org/876v4xthz/fin.jpg

The picture below is what I'm used to after about 1 to 2 minutes total on a reasonable japanese finish stone (with slurry, not chasing it any finer than that). This is the tidioute 1095 - not to be confused with the poorly done or soft 1095 that exists in 95% of the 1095 knives out there (ontario, bear and sons, etc).

https://s13.postimg.org/4c3h23utz/Still_Cap200.jpg

Given how the steel behaves on the washita, I can understand why the SGPS would make a better blunt edge or plastic die steel, but it'll never match the tidioute knife at the 35 degrees or so included that both are at - in around the house type stuff, at least.

The carbides just seem to be ready to come out of the SGPS any time something inviting comes along.