Re: Thanks!
david weaver
Yes on the imanishi. I've had a bunch of those. Actually, I've had one of everything you said there.
I think that Naniwa had the snow white before the choseras, but I don't know the history that well. All three of their main lines were around when I started buying. I never went backwards into the more primitive stuff like the omura and lobster (but I have bought large coarse stones, just didn't like any of them that much because they are either too porous and hard or too soft).
I didn't like the arashiyama/takenoko 6k stone, but it would've been decent for knives.
(i'm going to go all over the place, my mind is disorganized this afternoon - it always is, but the turbo disorganized button must've been pushed by someone else).
I think the thing with naniwa, speculating, is that they found themselves in high end knife shops in japan and they created a progression that is just about the most ideal that I've seen for doing a knife with a bright polish cosmetic goal. The choseras are dreamy if you can keep them in continuous use, they're uniform and fast cutting. the 10k stops shy of super fineness, but that kind of super fineness is not useful sharpening knives - the 10k was chosen deliberately, I'm sure, and it's about perfect.
Before the choseras, my understanding is that the snow white was a low cost and extremely popular stone (for good reason).
When all is said and done, I agree, most of the modern stuff is a bit more user friendly than the old stuff. I think the old stuff was made hard to retain flatness because there would be more pro users who were used to learning a stone and who would be more annoyed by flattening. We've flip flopped that and switched it around.
825 frictionite is still my dream hone for feel, but they're only about the size of a shapton and probably $250 if you could find one. The feel is divine, but the shapton is probably more practical, same with the chosera. If one finds an unused 825 (I got one from george, and eventually sold it - I just didn't think I wanted to waste it sharpening tools, and razors don't need honing that often - it was designed to be a bench stone for razor factories according to the literature attached to it), it's probably borderline sin to waste one at this point. The lady who baked the frictionite stones is long gone and I don't think anyone has had luck duplicating it. The market would be small, anyway.
re: the naturals. $500 or so is probably the upper end of cost in utility. That's about what it costs to get a really lovely type 30 suita that is fine and hard. I have a short fat one, as well as a type 24 shiro, and ...well, i have a whole bunch of others, but the ones typical of what you could find are those. the seller I referred to selling ohira mine stuff, and some shobu and others, got $230 for the 1.8kg stubby ohira stone that I used above. nicer shape, it's probably in the 400-500 range.
I don't want to offend anyone, but I probably will. I have been through about $30K of japanese natural stones now (I sell them to undercut dealers who are not honest), and the stones that get well above $500 are either collector stones - and I can't debate their collector value - or just as often, they are overpromised and oversold stones that should be cheaper.
Or they're sold to people without discussion of things like color and its effect of fineness. Kiita japanese stones are seen as extremely desirable, but they usually aren't finer. I will get a buyer from time to time who sends me a message that they have a $1500 kiita stone and a white suita that I just flipped at cost (perhaps $400) and that the suita is better. They're offended.
My point being, if you do ever get into natural stones, send me a message. I won't sell anyone on here anything - i'm not trying to make money - but I can help you find reasonable natural stones on buyee that would let you get a taste. Decent swipes at tomae stones that are a bit undersized can be had for $100 or so. Suita, just above that. The bigger stones aren't necessarily better, they're just bigger and the market pays for shape, color, attributes and size.
I'd advise staying away from most other naturals (agates, etc.), because they really aren't practical. Same with la lune and other rare birds from europe. they're not that great. Add coticules to the list- capable, but variable and bad capability for the price.
Idwall from the UK are nice, but not always easy to find and you have to like a trans ark (that's what they're similar to) to appreciate them. Charnley - same, except they are variable. Some are soft, some harder, some coarser, some finer. They can border on being mildy friable and softer feeling, which is undesirable.
Hone slates - stay away, especially for woodworking. If they're any good (water of ayr, escher, etc) they've gotten way overpriced.