Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Pictures of Various Honing Options

Posts

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#101

Re: Josko  The King 8000

TomD

There is a lot of sharpening BS on this board because some people are into personal research that consists of buying every brand of stone, etc... they have ever heard of and seemingly developing encyclopedic knowledge of them all. No doubt possible to an extent, but beyond a certain point merely subjective. Every new purchase ends up multiplying the combinations until they become nearly infinite. It is like learning 1000 judo throws, rather than mastering the sweep kick.

You never really need to sharpen beyond the 8000 King. You can take a saving of 4 tens with a 10 dollar japanese blade, as I have been doing for nearly 40 years. When I first mentioned those numbers here they were not believed, now they are unimpressive. People aren't doing better work for the most part. Everyone reaching and exceeding these plateaus has not made a difference.

You never need a sharper blade. It will pop hair off your arm, and pare wood like it isn't there. Learn how to use the stone, and you will be further ahead than most. Now are there better products available. Not too sure. My experience in the stone purchase world, and with many other sharpening techniques is that they all add something and loose something. But that said, you can get stones that are better with certain steels, and certainly that develop a better edge than you can get off an 8000. But unless you are competing, or something, there isn't any efficiency gain, and you will find it more difficult to get to each level, as far as time and technology required to get there.

The King isn't perfect, and there may be a better synthetic point of departure. I have three complete sets of stones that were supposed to be better, I still prefer the king, even though it doesn't cut as freely as I like. They are cheap, and one of the eternal things is that end results are dependent of preparation. Over time I have a system that stays flat effortlessly, self cleans, has the right gaps between grits. Getting efficiently to the 8000 is as important as a lot of other things.

What happened over time is that people wanted answers, and a format of tests and reviews was developed in the media, and over time people came to see the tests and the reviews as the purpose of woodworking, knife ownership, or firearms review, etc... I asked a relative what team she cheered for and she responded with confusion. One doesn't cheer for a team, one goes to cheerleading competitions.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#102

Re: Josko  The King 8000

david weaver

Nothing wrong with the King, except it kind of sucks for carving tools. If you don't carve, then no big deal.

I'd say before someone even gets to a king, though, fine india and autosol sort of has it beat, and I'd say for less money, but King stones are only $80+ in the united states. They're half that in japan.

This is a hobby, though - it's not about buying one stone, climbing to the top of the mountain with one and telling everyone that you did more with less. Though there are a few notable forum folks who love to show up at threads and say "tage frid never needed that".

Apparently, Tage needed to teach to make a living, though. George Wilson never did. George also made his rounds with sharpening materials as part of his job (40-45 years ago), and while he gets tired of the "how to sharpen" threads, I know he likes the sharpening materials (he's got a lot more problems to solve than most of us, though. From jeweler type stuff, to engravers, to machine cutters).

None of us here will be George.

But I'll always play with sharpening stuff. It's aside from the work. For the work, I just really like carbon steel and a single set of oilstones.

4 ten thousandths is plenty fine, of course, as you say, but what will you complete with a 4 ten thousandths shaving? When I started touting the double iron, it was clear that it was far superior for shaving thickness and finish in combination. I have fielded quite a bit of criticism about the usefulness of a thicker shaving, including from people who purport to be hand tool only experts (nobody here at the moment).

Anyway, separate from that, not everything on here is about necessity. Lots of it is about curiosity. For most people here, all of woodworking is the latter - we'd be money ahead if we didn't woodwork, but just sought to work the hours we're woodworking instead and were satisfied with utilitarian furniture.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#103

Thin shavings are a means, not an end

Patrick Chase

Mostly agreeing with David here...

When I see somebody tout achievable shaving thickness as a measure of edge quality I sort of mentally discount their opinion (unless they're specifically talking about setting up a plane for Kez, a la Brian). Thin shavings are sometimes necessary as a means to achieve a mirror-sheen surface or to mitigate tearout with single-iron planes, but other than that there is really no point to them.

I've achieved sub-half-mil shavings with edges that left fine-but-noticeable tracks all over the stuff. I'd much rather have a (hypothetical) setup that can only go to 1 mil but that leaves a smooth surface, so for me the resulting surface quality is the determining factor.

I don't doubt that a King 8K can do perfectly well in that department as well. I think most of us know that there are serious diminishing returns once you get beyond a certain point, and the King is good enough. As David alludes I'd much prefer a harder stone for anything that has a tendency to gouge, but even that can be overcome via technique.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#104

Re: Thin shavings are a means, not an end

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I understood Tom’s point to be that a King 8000 would get an ordinary plane iron sharp enough to take a 4 tenths shaving. So therefore it’ll do fine as a finish stone.

In other words, the 4tenths shaving was the test of the stone, not the woodworker. Tom is an accomplished long-time woodworker.

Wiley

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#105

Re: Thin shavings are a means, not an end

david weaver

Wiley - That's what I'd gathered from Tom. It's enough to do anything in woodworking.

I made my comment about that because once in a while, someone comes along and says "this is all a gimmick, all you need is X".

Tom believes the double iron is a passing fad in woodworking. Last night, as I was pulling shop made banding across the top of a try plane, I thought about how much more of a pain it would be to make the banding without a double iron (the wood had runout in different directions - and of course, the reason I needed to do this maneuver in the first place is that I hand sawed the edge banding off of a board - it's just to cover the ply lip on my last kitchen cabinet).

I think all of this is sort of pointless - the woodworking in general, and as I finally close out my kitchen cabinet making, I'd have been far better off to spend the time in the office (half as much) seeking opportunities to increase my bonus. I'd be money way ahead.

But I've gotten tremendous satisfaction out of making the kitchen cabinets, and especially the last one by hand, even though it's plywood.

If we're going to start talking about how certain aspects of woodworking are over done or are a waste of time, we're not going to find much defense for the entire hobby itself. It's like when I talk about how much more efficient the double iron is - in reality, it's like saying that I could get from New York to Chicago much faster on a skate board than I can walking. Somewhere, someone with a car is wondering why it makes any difference.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#106

FINALLY

david weaver

I thought I'd wind through various sharpening options and end up sharpening this knife quickly and to a very good edge with diamonds. For some reason, if the substrate isn't completely agreeable, it pulls carbides off of the knife.

What I didn't expect is that I'd find that setting the initial bevel is really easy with a medium crystolon and a fine india, and the edge is 90% there. Finding something that the knife tolerates for the last 10% to get a *good* edge was sort of a pain, even aside from how much you can actually tolerate in time and nuisance to re-do an edge (a 6 step 20 minute process is unacceptable).

What I found is this, two minutes or so on the medium crystolon (again, shocking how fast it abrades the steel - faster than any of my diamond hones - it's coarser, but shockingly fast nonetheless) and fine india as a pair and a good foundation is there.

I then followed that with stiff work on a hard ark that's the third hole on my IM 313. That's maybe another minute or two, the edge isn't finished, but it's reasonably fine...

....and then.....the usual edge killer works wonders on this. A buffer with a medium hard wheel and the not so fine 5 micron gold colored buffing compound from mcmaster carr. On a knife that abrades more easily, this will just round everything off, but the SGPS is so slow abrading, that it doesn't round that much.

What's the final angle? No clue. it's a bit more steep than I'd like because the buffer does steepen it a little bit, but it's probably for the better given the carbides.

The resulting edge is an easy smooth shaver both sides, and if you put it on paper, you can stop or start regardless of the part of the paper (regardless of the grain direction). I never figured the answer would exclude diamonds.

https://s10.postimg.org/izk47nvex/buffer2.jpg

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#107

Re: Josko  The King 8000

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Tom, my vote goes to asking Ellis to create a sharpening forum. Perhaps another for posts on the chipbreaker! :) :)

I think sharpening is important, but it is an entry skill, and the preponderance of posts on this forum appears to have shifted the focus away from the posts that do interest me, namely furniture design, furniture builds (and related joinery), and some hand tool reports (and how they are used), in that order.

Having said this, I consider that it is the responsibility of all the forum members to post, and if they choose to remain silent, then do not blame those that post on topics that have become increasing obscure. Perhaps we need to begin writing our 2018 resolutions now. Hopefully these will be more build posts, or questions about builds.

A belated Merry Christmas, and an early Happy New Year

Derek (at 10000 feet above the ocean on the way to Cape Town)

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#108

Re: Josko  The King 8000

David weaver

I'm all for other topical stuff, but someone actually has to post it. In the last two weeks, I cut down an rta bed from full to twin, finished a kitchen cabinet, and nearly finished a jack plane. None of those things really rise up to interesting, they're just common stuff.

If we start segregating some of the hand tools stuff out of hand tools, there won't be any posting here. One half is rudimentary stuff like sharpening, one third is complaining about that, and probably one sixth is other topics.

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#109

Re: Josko  The King 8000

Brian Holcombe

A dedicated furniture making forum would likely be empty of posts. :D

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#110

Guilty..

Mark Nowicki

:D

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#111

Re: Josko  The King 8000

Jim Matthews

When I want for instruction, I browse "In the Woodshop" or Sashimono from NJ. Those sites are careful in presentation, thoughtful about content and showcase exquisite craft.

The threaded nature of this forum naturally leads to retreads.

Is there a woodworking corollary to Godwin's law?

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#112

Godwin’s Law (Godwin’s Rule of Hitler Analogie

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Had to look up this reference. It’s hilarious:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law

For a moment, I thought Jim was bringing up Gresham’s Law.

Wiley

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#113

Gresham's law not to be confused with Grisham' law

Jim Matthews

My education was clearly deficient.

I thought you meant Grishman's law: Somewhere there must be a movie in development about an heroic lawyer.

(Fantasy sells)

Re: Pictures of Various Honing Options

#114

Re: Josko  The King 8000

Patrick Chase

What's next, a mandatory special badge for synthetic stone users?

That's about as far as my (limited) sense of taste and decorum will allow me to travel down that road. In my day job I work on systems that serve "social interactions" for some well-known Internet platforms, so I'm acutely aware of Godwin.