Re: Josko The King 8000
TomD
There is a lot of sharpening BS on this board because some people are into personal research that consists of buying every brand of stone, etc... they have ever heard of and seemingly developing encyclopedic knowledge of them all. No doubt possible to an extent, but beyond a certain point merely subjective. Every new purchase ends up multiplying the combinations until they become nearly infinite. It is like learning 1000 judo throws, rather than mastering the sweep kick.
You never really need to sharpen beyond the 8000 King. You can take a saving of 4 tens with a 10 dollar japanese blade, as I have been doing for nearly 40 years. When I first mentioned those numbers here they were not believed, now they are unimpressive. People aren't doing better work for the most part. Everyone reaching and exceeding these plateaus has not made a difference.
You never need a sharper blade. It will pop hair off your arm, and pare wood like it isn't there. Learn how to use the stone, and you will be further ahead than most. Now are there better products available. Not too sure. My experience in the stone purchase world, and with many other sharpening techniques is that they all add something and loose something. But that said, you can get stones that are better with certain steels, and certainly that develop a better edge than you can get off an 8000. But unless you are competing, or something, there isn't any efficiency gain, and you will find it more difficult to get to each level, as far as time and technology required to get there.
The King isn't perfect, and there may be a better synthetic point of departure. I have three complete sets of stones that were supposed to be better, I still prefer the king, even though it doesn't cut as freely as I like. They are cheap, and one of the eternal things is that end results are dependent of preparation. Over time I have a system that stays flat effortlessly, self cleans, has the right gaps between grits. Getting efficiently to the 8000 is as important as a lot of other things.
What happened over time is that people wanted answers, and a format of tests and reviews was developed in the media, and over time people came to see the tests and the reviews as the purpose of woodworking, knife ownership, or firearms review, etc... I asked a relative what team she cheered for and she responded with confusion. One doesn't cheer for a team, one goes to cheerleading competitions.




