Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

Posts

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#76

Another possibility presents itself......

roger lance

While looking at CBN wheels for my grinder, I found another alternative to Atoma and DMT diamond honing plates for waterstones.

Woodturner Wonders now offers various honing plates in CBN including a 4" x 10" double sided plate in 80 grit and 1000 grit.

More to consider.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#77

CBN plates

Patrick Chase

I wouldn't bother with CBN for hand hones.

CBN is softer and more prone to dulling than diamond, all else being equal ("all else" meaning mono- vs poly-crystalline, manufacturing technology, etc).

The reason why CBN is used in grinding wheels is that it doesn't contain Carbon atoms that can react with the iron in the tool to form carbides at elevated temperatures. That reactivity can destroy diamond wheels, but only at relatively high temperatures (700C and above IIRC, though note that this is surface rather than "bulk" temperature).

In other words, CBN doesn't really make much sense for hand-sharpening.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#78

Re: What a great thread this has been.....

William Duffield

How would my doctors know? They're not going to read this thread. :)

I notice Warren has commented, and I know he doesn't use water stones, so maybe there is something here of value to me too.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#79

Traditional Method

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I usually follow the traditional method of water stones for coarse work and oil stones for polishing.

I tried a diamond stone about 35 years ago; I pushed a chisel about an inch and a half on the stone and instinctively withdrew. It could not have been a quarter of a second.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#80

Re: Not making sense..

david weaver

I'm not sure if there will be much difference with dulling, but it would take someone using all of the plates to figure it out. On the monocrystalline plates, I doubt any ever come close to wearing down due to the diamonds themselves, but rather because the diamonds are pulled from the surface. They're certainly ineffective when they're no longer on the plate.

The reason CBN doesn't make as much sense from a producer's standpoint is that it costs more than diamonds, and offers no ad.

My first question with Vince's CBN plate (and I have a lot of respect for Vince, because he pushes to make stuff more affordable without making junk, and that means it gets into more peoples' hands) is how flat is it? there is a market for a diamond hone among turning enthusiasts to touch up or finish skews, etc, but we'll have to wait until a few people buy them and report on flatness when doing something like flattening a new iron.

I think I probably have somewhere between 8 and 10 full sized diamond hones, and I haven't bought one in a long time. It's going to be a while before I have an excuse to buy anything similar - esp. given that the Atomas get a little slower each year, but they aren't giving up.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#81

Re: Traditional Method

david weaver

The feel of diamonds is not great, and if you have ever looked at steel under a microscope, in the back of your head is the idea that you will need to remove everything to the deepest scratch to get rid of the damage. That's not an issue if you have a progression, but they are completely unnecessary unless a steel requires their use, and the fact that they're functionally slower for "regular" steel than two arkansas stones (or one) isn't attractive.

If you chase them down to small sizes so that the edge is strong (which is doable), then the edge itself is very keen feeling at first, but very transient at the same time.

I think it's probably natural for most experienced users to float to natural stones if they do any significant amount of work by hand (not talking about smoothing and joinery, but more significant than that), but the magazines and instructors of beginners will never do it because their beginners can't grasp the idea of something more in depth than just getting a purchase list and making a purchase. Let alone the subtleties of natural stones and the realization that they have a wide range of use and may need to settle in if they're new.

(diamond on laminated stuff is even worse. Diamonds through soft steel, soft iron or wrought iron is just gross).

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#82

Re: Traditional Method

John Aniano in Central NJ

Warren and/or David,

Can you better describe the traditional water stones that might have been available/used by craftsman of the past? Sandstone in a rotating wheel comes to mind, but what other waterstone types were used in a flat form? I'm sure there were many, but I assume there were best types for coarse work.

Thanks,

John

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#83

Diamond wear

Patrick Chase

It makes perfect sense if you've actually looked at it in any depth.

Monocrystalline diamonds (and CBN) do wear at the tips. Look closely at this monocrystalline particle from a broken-in DMT #325 for example:

https://scienceofsharp.files.wordpress.com/2015/09/dmt325_brokenin_03.jpg

There is a "before" shot in that blog post as well, but the short version is that the exposed corners do break down, and quite dramatically. That's one of the causes of the dreaded "diamond plate slow-down effect". CBN is known to be worse in that regard than diamond, due to its lower hardness (about 2/3 the hardness when comparing synthetic monocrystalline diamond to synthetic monocrystalline CBN).

They key thing to realize is that "monocrystalline" doesn't imply a single perfect diamond lattice. It just means that the bonds between regions are metallic (crystalline). Synthetic monocrystalline industrial diamonds are both softer and more friable than natural ones, though far less so than resin-bonded polycrystalline ones.

You can get some idea of the factors in play by reading manufacturers' literature, for example: https://www.hyperion.sandvik.com/en/products/diamond-and-cbn/diamond/micron-diamond-cbn/diamond-micron-powder/metal-bond-diamond-micron-powder/. All 3 grades there are nominally "monocrystalline" (metal-bond) but differ appreciably in cost and hardness. The compounds I use are "SJK" grade, and I think that most plates on the market are similar.

If you look around you can find suppliers like Precision Surfaces and McMaster selling natural diamond powders for lapping super-hard materials like solid carbide. The reason is that economical synthetic diamonds simply aren't up to the task.

So with those details out of the way, what I said stands: Diamond crystals do wear out by breaking down. CBN is worse in that respect than diamond.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#84

Re: Traditional Method

Patrick Chase

Warren wrote:

> I tried a diamond stone about 35 years ago; I pushed a chisel about an inch and

> a half on the stone and instinctively withdrew. It could not have been a quarter

> of a second.

Your loss :-).

Seriously, the plates have huge particle-height-consistency problems. I don't use them on tools for anything but major damage-removal, and I wouldn't recommend that anybody else do do. They're great for flattening stones though. As you say the feel is awful and the scratch pattern isn't much better.

Lapping films and pastes are a very different matter, though. While I wouldn't recommend them for you (they wouldn't make much of a difference for the steels you're known to use) I think that they're perfectly reasonable and viable solutions.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#85

Re: Traditional Method *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Older texts have two types of water stones: rub stones and rag stones. The rub stones were coarser and may be thought of as flat grindstones. There was some overlap in function between the grinding wheel and rub stone. I think they tended to be sandstone like the grinding wheels. Nicholson mentions grinding stone (wheel), rub stone and oil stone. Here is a large coarse stone from Roubo:


Rag stones tend to be schisty stones or fine sandstones, maybe the kind of thing one might use as an all around stone, for knives or axes or as a set up for an oil stone. Rag stone can also refer to a type of building stone.

In 18th century English, fine stones are often called slates or honing slates. Not that necessarily they have anything to do with the slate we put on a roof.

Holtzapffel reprints (from a journal article) a list of stones available in England in the late 18th century. Here are some:


https://books.google.com/books?id=fDQDAAAAQAAJ&pg=PA1066&dq=holtzapffel+honing+slate&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjf-snwwvPXAhWDdN8KHTBMDY4Q6AEIKDAA#v=onepage&q=holtzapffel%20honing%20slate&f=false

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#86

Re: Diamond wear

david weaver

I would be very surprised if someone gave you a CBN plane for a 1, 3 and 5 year period and you could tell that it was different than diamonds.

I have two plates that are all mono diamonds. One is DMT (or more accurately, I have two of each), and the other is atoma. The atoma plate has about 10x the use of the DMT and still works faster, even though it's technically finer. If Atoma did the same thing with CBN as they do with diamonds, I'm sure their plate would still outlast a duosharp.

Diamond loss and plating loss are a far bigger problem than wear.

No clue how material toughness plays into these, either, because it's not as if all diamonds are 70k knoop and all CBN is 45k. There are versions of CBN that are harder than typical diamonds, and arrangements of bonds in diamonds that make super hard diamonds (unlikely we see those - not sure about CBN).

At any rate, I'm going to have to hear stories about the CBN that wears down quickly before I think it's a big issue. I haven't got a clue what's made my atoma slower, but I'd imagine there may have been some initial diamond loss in the peaks. It still cuts very deeply with pressure. Or I should say both do, I have two and have lost track of which is which. AT one point, I saved one for stones, but I like them better once they've lost the initial tooth.

Still, on the CBN planes, it's not CBN that I'd be concerned about, it's flatness and the quality of attachment to the plate - as well as consistency of CBN if one has a choice. I already saw the damage a couple of stray large diamonds can do to a watch face.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#87

Re: Traditional Method

david weaver

I wouldn't recommend any of those for someone who is going to do a serious amount of hand tool work. PSA paper is better for back flattening, crystolon stones are better for bevel grinding, and natural stones are better and faster with less maintenance for honing.

Any steel that benefits from diamonds significantly is something that makes little practical sense for woodworking, but it sounds good on a forum to talk about steel that can last x times as long in a machine.

Metalwork and factory production are a different story, but we don't use those. there is some merit to diamond hones for touching up router bits, but use of router bits tends to result in bland-looking woodwork (my cabinet doors and a cove on an old piece of casework that I made are good examples of that - it's not like I need a diamond hone for those things, either - sending them out to be sharpened is probably more practical).

Diamonds are quite nice for cleaning a watch face, too, I guess, but most of the consumer plates aren't up to it.

Honing films are a waste of time. I've been down that road. I could be convinced of their usefulness for a guy who hones once every two months (they're cheap), but they are a step backwards vs. decent stones.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#88

Re: Not making sense..

Clifton C

David, I'm pretty sure Vince sells DMT products and not CBN plates, I think the reference of CBN plates was from another website that sort of borrowed Vince's good name and reputation.

I like this thread, while I cannot digest all of it, I think my sharpening will benefit none the less...thanks...

cc

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#89

Re: Diamond wear

Patrick Chase

CBN plates use the same basic binding approach as diamond (electroplated metal bond, typically Nickel).

You're absolutely right that there's variation, and that from a practical perspective that's more likely to be an issue than any difference in life.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#91

Re: Traditional Method

Patrick Chase

I think that you're stating as fact some things that are in fact subjective opinions, particularly about steel selection and the benefits (or lack thereof) of certain sharpening strategies.

Your comment about lapping films don't make sense. I can procure 3M 661X (the non-PSA version of what LV sells) for the equivalent of $4 per 3x6 sheet or a bit less. At that price I can afford 16 of them for the cost of a Diasharp or Atoma plate.

I can get hundreds of sharpening sessions out of a single sheet with reasonable care and technique. The plate will still last longer than 16 sheets, but the lapping sheets will be much faster (because I get to swap in 16 sets of new/undulled diamonds) and more uniform (because resin-bonding process that 3M uses to produce those lapping sheets is almost unbeatable in that respect). If you think your Atoma left uniform scratches then you're not grading on a very hard curve. They're pretty good for plates, but they still suck in the grand scheme.

The compounds (which you didn't address) are the best of all in terms of speed and scratch pattern, and surprisingly economical with good technique, but they obviously have a big downside in the form of contamination control.

At the risk of sounding a bit arrogant, but the cost of the sharpening consumables I use is utterly inconsequential in relation to either quality wood or the value of my time.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#92

Re: Traditional Method

david weaver

Sharpen a few carving tools on lapping film, record the time that it takes to affix it to something solidly (you can use it with just water, but it's screwing around), then record the time that it takes to screw with it after you accidentally cut it or get a single contaminant caught under it.

It's just screwing around. I've been down the road of trying all of it. 3x6 sheets, 8 1/2 x11 size sheets, whatever it may be.

In terms of the steels above and beyond carbon steel, there is no real practical advantage unless someone is new and takes eons to sharpen. In that case, the problem is sharpening, and not steel.

Screwing around with all of that stuff goes away very quickly if you streamline your setup to just do work. Soaking stones, flattening stones, fiddling with powders and pastes, fiddling with films, screwing around with honing guides. All of it gets in the way of actually getting anything done.

There is merit in some of that stuff if the contest is the largest number of feet of cocobolo planed in a row with shavings no thicker than 1 thousandth, but learning to work like that is a block itself. It's far better to learn to do the coarse work as coarse work, which requires tearout mitigation, but that's about it.

In terms of uniformity, the sapphire lens on a king seiko was finished in a matter of minutes with an atoma and the 6500 diamond followed by fractional micron. If an atoma can do coarse work on a watch face, worrying about uniformity beyond that is well, way beyond pointless.

I could take a rank beginner and set them up with a washita stone, a grinder and a piece of jasper (for the few instances where a little more is good) and they would work anyone with a modern setup right out of the room.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#93

Re: Traditional Method

Patrick Chase

I attach my lapping film to my glass once or at most twice, using low-particulate mineral oil rolled out into an ultra-thin film so that it doesn't move. I'm careful about contamination control during mounting, which isn't exactly rocket science. From there on it isn't a big deal since the surface tension of the oil is enough to keep anything from getting under. Not cutting the film is similarly a matter of proper care and technique. Anybody who does the amount of messing around that you describe is a dilettante who hasn't bothered to learn how to use their tools.

As you yourself have pointed out in your videos Norton's New Hampshire mine is perfectly capable of producing new Lily White Washita stones (and was for Joel Moskowitz until 2008 or so).

The reason it is not is simple: In the real world the total cost of operations like sharpening is heavily driven by the value of operator time. Washitas have near-zero amortized material cost as you love to point out, but they're dreadfully slow and that makes them noncompetitive even when used by low-wage workers (never mind somebody who has a day job and better things to do with their time). Faster abrasives like diamond, CBN, and AlOx have long since won the war for cost-driven applications. The steels you use aren't terribly unique either, so I don't think you can argue that your/our situation differs from the market.

It's fine to have and advocate a subjective preference for one thing or another, but please don't tell other people that what they're doing is invalid when doing so is at the very least objectively debatable. Doing so makes us no better than the "bevel up posse" circa 2010.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#94

Re: Traditional Method

david weaver

The reason people don't use something like a washita is lack of skill. Honing films are not better in any practical way, they aren't robust against contamination, they don't last as long, they require you to pretty much hone flat edged things or close, etc.

What they are good for is a beginner who doesn't know which way they're going yet.

A washita, on the other hand, takes some skill to get set up correctly, and then it takes a bit of skill to learn to set a plane so that you're not dependent on trying to take tiny thin shavings. In terms of edge quality, it's not a big deal to get a half thousandth shaving from a V11 iron that's sharpened on a washita. I'm not sure about A2 (having seen the voids at the edge), but most of my time sharpening with a washita has not centered around using A2.

I can't really tell a practical difference with V11, but that probably has something to do with not taking a million little shavings. I'd certainly rather have a ward iron, the iron that I made (which is just simple O1) or a good vintage stanley iron than V11. I couldn't convince a beginner of that via email (nor would i try), because they'll have all kinds of problems related to getting tools sharp and in how much time it takes. I personally am always gassed before the try plane or jack plane run out of sharpness, and the smoother is just a short wisp of time.

If it's chisel work, the washita will probably match an 8k waterstone on a japanese chisel, but it'll do it in a matter of seconds. It takes a little bit of skill, and I'm sure the subtleties of it that are relatively easy to manage are the kinds of things that a significant fraction of beginners could mangle in a course.

"better" than a washita, a stack of honing film or a modern synthetic stone? Definitely not. Cheaper? No. Maybe over a three day period, but in the long run, no. But cheaper really isn't the objective here, anyway, better is the objective. If you have a modicum of skill, the washita is miles ahead of honing film. If someone thinks they need honing film or SP 13k or something to achieve anything with woodworking, then lack of skill is an issue.

I'm aware that you can baby honing film. I tried it, both for tools and razors. If you want to screw with it and have a "clean area" or a sharpening setup that you get out and put away each time you use it, you can do it. If you have a fair amount of work to do with a carving tool or narrow chisel, you stand a fair chance of damaging it, unless you really poke. I'll be done with either of those in half a minute on the washita, and if they need something more, either a trans ark or jasper will take care of it pretty easily. Without damage, without worrying about whether or not something may land on them or a *substrate* if I'm working in the shop and chips are flying.

I don't think you'll see much of that kind of stuff in a professional shop. On the UK board where there are more hand tool using professionals, you tend to hear more about india stones, arkansas stones and charnley stones, and a whole lot less about "seeded" this or that or "extra tough new ceramic alumina". It's poo unless the end is something unrelated to woodworking. Actually doing more woodworking, and sharpening gouges and small cutters, and jack planes, and try planes, and scissors, and knives, etc, helped me see it pretty quickly, despite a half decade before all of that of searching through the latest and greatest, reading about the technical data, finding irons that hold an edge longer planing silica. It was all a waste of time, but I didn't have the right person to teach me about it locally.

I'd pay $300 for a washita if I had to (of course, nobody does), and I'd pay extra for a ward iron over anything newly made. Of course, I paid almost $300 for a chosera 10K, but it was pretty easy to sell because it's not as fine as it's described, and it's less practical for anything other than show sharpening on a japanese knife. Interesting to try, but not functionally better.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#95

Re: Traditional Method

david weaver

I didn't read this the whole way through the first time. If you think it's slow to sharpen with a washita, you just don't know what you're doing. You haven't been around long enough, you're too mired in theory of one thing versus another and you haven't mastered much as far as subtlety goes (I've been there).

If you keep at it, you'll move on from your thoughts at the end of this that the cutting speed of stones per grit size actually has something to do with sharpening fast. It doesn't. I sharpen faster with slower stones. Harder and slower. If you do this long enough, you will, too.

That aside, if the washita isn't fast enough for something, a fine india is far faster than most 1k synthetic stones. It's pretty uncommon to need to use a fine india in the regular course of work, though.

The beauty of the washita isn't that it's cheap. I clean labeled stone is about $175 now. An unlabeled 8x2 stone is about $100 if it's clean and sold as a washita. the economy of the washita is in time, not in money. I can find them cheap, because I've bought about 50. People who frequent flea markets may be able to find them really cheaply from time to time, but that never happens to me, because I don't spend a lot of time going to flea markets. It's false economy.

If you're rolling your eyes because you think you could strap two chisels into guide and show that something "modern" is faster, then you're on the wrong road. Put down the MSDS, the guides, the named techniques, get three planes, 250 board feet of wood and work it. Learn to observe what a tool needs to be sharp, learn the feel of intentionally biasing things freehand so that there is no chance the tool won't be sharp and ditch the idea that the modern stuff is "better" or "faster". It's neither. It's just convenient for beginners. It was available a hundred years ago and most users never reached for any of it unless they had to grind an iron. High speed steel has been available for eons. there's a relatively popular vintage make that you can find in spiers smoothers (I can't remember the name of it). It never caught on because it really doesn't have any practical benefit.

I sense from your posts that you're at a fork in the road. You can do like I did and get tired of evaluating all of this stuff and find something efficient, or you can keep looking for methods that are crutches and that will prevent you from developing efficient techniques.

Personally, I doubt that most people who set everything aside and used three planes instead of thirty, and who forced themselves to use a washita for a couple of months would ever go back to films, diamond hones, waterstones, guides, etc. They'd quickly figure out it was getting in the way of actually getting something done. We used to believe chasing sub micron was practical for surface preparation, but that's not even the case now. If that's the way someone is tackling surface prep, they've lost the race before they've started.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#96

My apologies for being a bit too harsh..

David Weaver

I could've been a lot more brief and less harsh,band should have.

The case here about the sharpening is still true, though. The website, or two oilstones, or whatever else ....They are functionally superior to all of the modern techniques. Both with flat tools, and especially when you get away from flat tools into gouges, nickers, etc. All of that stuff is relatively simple with a single method.

To sharpen with speed and be able to do it with speed the next cycle, we are looking to prevent damage and remove only what we need to. Once you get to there, things move a lot faster. It just takes a month or so to perfect the skill and learn the feel of the stone.

It's worth troubling through the learning curve and finding out why a typical washita stone has far more miles on it than the average synthetic vintage bench hone.

As to why Norton won't mine and cut, I guess they can't sell a skill based stone to a mostly unskilled market. If Dan kirchner had access to the perryn formation, stones would be pouring out of it. Norton has become hit or miss with their fine Arkansas stones, and I wouldn't be surprised to see them stop those, too.

Aside from that, if someone has ever gotten a tool from me and found it to be dull or poorly prepared, I'd be surprised, but I'm sure open to honest criticism. I lay a washita edge on all of those tools before they go out the door.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#97

Re: Traditional Method

David Weaver

Warren, am I correct that you do your rough work with a crystolon stone?

I haven't looked particularly hard, but haven't found a stone like you're showing in the rough picture. I realize that was the standard in wheel or bench form, though, both for shop work, and for production work.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#98

Re: Diamond wear

david weaver

If you've ever tried to do anything with nickel plate, you find out quickly how hard it is. I have no idea what spec it is, but I just picked up another #4 this weekend to replace a record stayset that I could never get along with, and it had rust issues and spotting on the lever cap. The nickel plate that remains firmly attached is almost untouchable by a deburring wheel.

Which makes me wonder why the quality of the plating from one brand of plate to the next is so inconsistent. Why can atoma affix their diamonds so well, and DMT so poorly. The center of my duosharp lasted less than a year...it's completely blown out, and i didn't use it that much.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#99

Re: Traditional Method

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I used a Carborundum stone for about 20 years, but around 1983 I switched to a King stone as the first stone in my routine. I have worn out four or five. I still use a Carborundum stone for turning gouges and sometimes narrow chisels that would gouge the water stone.

I have a Queer Creek sandstone which I could use as a first stone instead. I would probably like it better if it were a little softer. I also have a 22 inch Ohio sandstone wheel but I do not use it for day to day sharpening; most of my woodworking tools have not seen a grinding wheel since I acquired them.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#100

Re: Washita vs soft Arkansas stones...

John Aniano in Central NJ

David,

Can you clear something up for me - what are the exact differences between a Washita stone and a "soft Arkansas" stone. I have always thought they were the same beast, but I think I need to be straightened out. Are they really two different stones, or just differences in grading?

When I find what I think is a soft Arkansas stone at my local flea market, how can I tell if it is instead a washita stone? Density? Porosity?

I'm sure you or others have described this distinction before - perhaps you can just aim me in the archives as to the details...

John