Re: which side to use?
David weaver
I'd use the non printed side and glue the logo side to something, as mentioned previously.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: which side to use?
David weaver
I'd use the non printed side and glue the logo side to something, as mentioned previously.
Re: which side to use?
Steve Elliott
I use one side for work on the bevel and the other side for touching up the back of the blade. The side used for the bevel dishes faster but it doesn't matter much. Since the back needs very little work that side of the stone stays very flat.
a little bit the Indian and a little bit arrow
Joseph Piotrowski
the synopsis: these water stones are awesome.
my new gear Shapton 320,1000,5000,12000.
the old gear wasn't bad, Duosharp(X,C), duosharp(F,E), Diasahrp D8EE(800) grit and green honing compound on leather.
some of my issues are technique( free hand sharpening) .without a doubt! but given i didn't just up my skill level in one session, these stones provide two things:
1. a little more messy, need to wear gloves next time.
2. they are way more user friendly. I was able to get better feedback from the shaptons during the entire process.
i don't think i ever produced a burr so quickly and evenly on my DMT setup.
i did a plane blade. flatten the back and sharpen/hone the bevels. i didn't spend enough time to get the very best edge but just a quickie at lunch to see how they work.
sharpened up a low angle block plane. did a before and after cut on some mahogany end grain. it was a big difference. huge!
it was best sharpening session to date.
i sure when i master free hand sharpening, this gap might get smaller but for now my DMT are getting regulated to clean up work. the shapton are my go to set.
i look forward to spending the time i need to fully tune the blade up and get a real good edge;
thank you all for the tips and suggestions
Re: a little bit the Indian and a little bit arrow
Patrick Chase
Glad it worked. A couple remarks:
Now you see why a lot of us only use diamond plates to flatten stones. Diamonds are a terrific medium, particularly for working "difficult" steels, but diamond plates in particular (as opposed to diamond lapping films or diamond compounds) are compromised in several ways.
First, the Nickel-electroplating process used to bond the diamonds to the plate makes it difficult to achieve uniform cutting point height (though some makers do better than others). In contrast with a friable stone like your Shaptons a point that sticks up too high falls out quickly, leaving a uniform surface. Also Shapton seems to do a better job of abrasive-grading (ensuring that all particles are similarly sized) than does DMT, and the result of both is that they cut a lot more smoothly.
Second, plates only have a single layer of edges, and they start to wear out fairly quickly. In my experience that's when the plate starts feeling "dead". In contrast the stones are continuously exposing fresh abrasive and tend to maintain a better feel, though obviously this is totally subjective.
One note on your specific stones: The Shapton Pro #320 has a notably hard binder, and doesn't expose fresh abrasive very quickly. It works well on HCS, but glazes over and stops cutting in short order on more difficult/exotic steels in my experience. I'd recommend PSA sandpaper on glass for those situations.
Sandpaper Flattening & Shaptons
Steve Elliott
One thing is worth mentioning - no diamond hone should mean no shaptons, because they don't get along with sandpaper flattening (drywall screens mentioned above, notwithstanding - no experience with those).
I've used wet/dry sandpaper on a granite plate to flatten Shaptons for years. I'm not saying it's better than a diamond plate because I haven't tried that, but it works fine for me.
Re: Sandpaper Flattening & Shaptons
david weaver
It's possible that the binder or how the paper is put together may make for different results.
I tried it only once, but had strange accumulations of sticky spots on my stone, and i'm not sure what it was (but stu told me I'd find them). The spots felt similar to what you get if you use the stone for really abrasive resistant HSS (you may know what I mean, I know you've tested a lot of stones). The stones get little spots of stuff all over them.
I'm not sure of the brand of paper that I used or what type, but #220 grit and I remember the word "shark" or something on it.
Re: Sandpaper Flattening & Shaptons
Steve Elliott
Did you use wet/dry paper, and if so was it wet when you flattened the stone? I always flatten when the stone is wet (not such an issue for Shaptons but other stones soak up water) and rely on a layer of water to hold the paper down to the granite plate.
I've used grits from 120 to 600 and generally match the coarser grits to coarser stones.
Stearate coating
Patrick Chase
Was the sandpaper you used stearated ("no-load" coating)?
What you describe sounds like what I would expect if the stearate coating transferred to the stone. If you use cheap, uncoated paper that isn't an issue.
I prefer loose SiC grains for stone flattening FWIW, but there's nothing magical about sandpaper, either good or bad. It works as well as anything else provided you understand what you're using and select the right type.
Re: Sandpaper Flattening & Shaptons
david weaver
Yes, wet and dry and on a wet stone.
Re: Stearate coating
david weaver
I don't think it was stearated. IIRC, you can usually see the coating for stearated paper while looking at the grains, like they're in a pool of stuff. It's possible that it was the adhesive that held the paper on.
I have to admit I really don't like much of anything else for stones other than diamond hones. Everything else is a bit of a mess. If a stone is bad enough, I take a belt sander outside and work the bulk of the bad parts off with the idler on the sander. (the only stones bad enough for that are stones I've bought and not yet used).
Re: to date
TomD
There is a rule in shooting that you should determine when you are working on form, gear, whatever, and when you are actually shooting for score. There is a lack of discipline that comes from switching back and forth in a day at the range, without any real accountability to results. Maybe a better example would be the golf course and the driving range. One is for swing practice, the other is not normally where you go to practice your swing. I'm a big believer that in woodworking you make the most rapid progress when you do some actual practice, and try to do projects in a different frame of mind.
In woodworking we would benefit from knowing or considering when something is just for the pursuit of knowledge, and when it has some output purpose. But it is far too complex an activity to really set out the parameters. Guys like Derek are great examples because he has a huge inquisitiveness, but also a considerable output. Somehow he has it all together.
I only get annoyed when the research leads to an attitude that one must have whatever the latest or greatest is, which is almost always nonsense.
Re: Stearate coating
Patrick Chase
I should be clear that I use diamond plates (mostly Atoma) for the vast majority of stone-flattening chores. As you say they get the job done quickly and at least as cleanly as any other option.
Unfortunately I own some stones that can't be allowed to interact with a diamond plate. For example, I stripped almost all of the diamonds off of a 10" x 4" DiaFlat (a $200 plate...) by using it to true up a Sigma Select II #240. I expect that I'd see similar results with coarse SiC-based stones like a Crystolon or my Sigma #120.
I use a well-worm Atoma #140 plate to flatten stones down to #320 or so, but below that I switch to loose SiC grit. It's almost as fast as a diamond plate once you have the hang of it (and figure out some tricks like using sacrificial plastic laminating sheets to "hold" the grit), though it makes a god-awful mess.
How Are You Cleaning The CBN Wheel . . .
Tom Colligan
after you've sharpened softer metals on them?
I use this wheel for my turning tools but I'm weary of using chisels and plane irons pm on it. Thx.,
Re: How Are You Cleaning The CBN Wheel . . .
Patrick Chase
Are you using laminated (Japanese) plane irons and chisels?
Homogeneous Western tools that are hardened all the way through are typically Rc59 and above, and that's enough not to clog a CBN wheel. I don't worry about it or clean the wheel at all.
Mild steels and iron can indeed load the wheel. That's only happened to me once that I remember, when I used my CBN wheel to shape some mild 1018. I ground a hardened scraper (~Rc52) a bit to remove it and the wheel didn't seem any worse for wear, though I've avoided unhardened metals since.
I don't hollow-grind laminated tools in any case. They don't really need it because they sharpen so easily to begin with, and I'm concerned that hollow-grinding slightly compromises the integrity of the weld. I don't know if it's enough to matter, but I don't take chances.
Re: How Are You Cleaning The CBN Wheel . . .
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Tom
I have avoided grinding mild steel, but am about to grind unhardened O1 (as I have some blades to make). I have done one so far and the CBN surface was fine. If the wheel done gum up, I plan to grind hardened steel to clean it.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Stearate coating
John Aniano in Central NJ
Patrick,
Could you elucidate what you meant when you mentioned flattening stones with "...loose SiC grit. It's almost as fast as a diamond plate once you have the hang of it (and figure out some tricks like using sacrificial plastic laminating sheets to "hold" the grit)...", particularly the the mention of plastic laminating sheets? Not something I'd heard of to date.
Thanks
Plastic laminating sheet
Patrick Chase
LV actually sells sheets for the purpose, so I can't claim to have invented this: http://www.leevalley.com/us/Wood/page.aspx?p=33017&cat=1,43072,67174&ap=1. For grits finer than #150 these much cheaper sheets work very well: https://www.amazon.com/C-Line-Heavyweight-Adheer-Laminating-65003/dp/B001P4VKG8/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1512235147&sr=8-1&keywords=super+heavyweight+laminating+sheet
There is one key thing to keep in mind about lapping with loose grains, that may seem counterintuitive: Softer materials preferentially lap harder ones. The loose grains tend to "stick" in the softer material, and that causes them to abrade the harder material. That's why cast iron laps work so well to abrade tool steel with diamond compounds.
Glass and granite surface plates are both very hard, so they tend to get damaged when you use them directly to flatten sharpening stones. The laminating sheet provides a flat intermediate surface to "capture" the abrasive grains. It both speeds the process up (a lot) and protects your reference surface.
Why grind unhardened steel on CBN?
Patrick Chase
The principal benefit of CBN is that it efficiently grinds hardened metals, without releasing excessive heat that might detemper them.
If you're grinding normalized/annealed O1 then it's a "don't care" on both counts: You can get the part red-hot without damaging it (anything below 1300F is OK), and it will grind easily on conventional abrasives like AlOx.
I use a conventional wheel or belt grinder for that. While CBN load-up is easily fixed (as you say, just grind something hard) *any* grinding puts at least a little wear on the wheel, and there's no reason to do that for soft steel.
Re: How Are You Cleaning The CBN Wheel . . .
david weaver
I have ground all of the laminated irons (which often need a significant amount of correction when new to me) on my wheel and haven't noticed anything. It's brass and metal of that sort that I have more concern about. I think the laminated irons aren't an issue, and probably insurance that they aren't is the hardened steel part of the iron cleaning the wheel of anything that the mild steel part might like to deposit.
I have used them for unhardened O1 before, too, but I tend to prefer hacksaw and file for that because hitting a mark and maintaining nice geometry is much easier.
Re: Stearate coating
david weaver
Even india stones are probably hard on a diamond hone. SiC, definitely. I think very coarse stones for anything other than bevel work are generally a pipe dream (at least considering them to be "good" for that kind of work).
Kanaban with diamonds is good (and very cheap), but even the kanaban will need to be flattened after a while, which is a pain in the rear. PSA paper on glass is much faster for nearly all things, but not quite as cheap in the long run (the time tradeoff is worth it, though).
The only really good coarse stone is the crystolon type or an equivalent type for water, and they don't like to stay flat - and flattening them tends to grade them and load them.
I have bought a lot of coarse stones, but wouldn't again buy anything other than a medium crystolon below the shapton 1000 grit level.
I guess an india stone is technically more coarse than that, but they are only slightly faster than a stone of that type once they've settled in, and you can keep them flat by using them properly. There is no absolute need that I can think of for a flat stone in the shop. A skilled user can maintain the back of an iron or chisel on the end of a swayed stone, even though it may not be ideal.
What a great thread this has been.....
roger lance
Every once in awhile, you get a thread that is very educational.....this certainly qualifies.....
Re: Why grind unhardened steel on CBN?
Patrick Chase
Sorry, for the self-reply, but on a related note: Friable ("white") wheels and seeded-gel abrasives as in Norton 3X wheels and zirconia-ceramic belts are also not economical for annealed O1, though all will work fine.
Friable wheels release abrasive too easily for such soft metals, and end spraying a fine dusting of perfectly sharp, not-used-up abrasive grains all over your shop. It's simultaneously a mess and a waste of money. The abrasive in those wheels is perfectly fine, but you need a harder binder to match the retention time to the abrasive life with such soft metals.
Seeded-gel abrasives as in 3X are long-lasting because the abrasive particles shard and expose fresh points. The catch is that the metal being ground needs to be fairly hard to make that happen, and annealed O1 won't do it. You can make the abrasives in a 3X wheel or ceramic belt work as intended with soft metals by periodically "breaking the abrasive" with a hardened bar or scraper (George has described doing this in the past IIRC) but it's still an overly expensive way to work IMO.
The wheels that ship with Rikon grinders are actually a near-perfect choice for this sort of work, because they use the same white-alumina (WA) abrasive as the white friable wheels but in a harder binder. They aren't full of cheapo abrasive like the wheels that ship with most grinders.
David is right in his other post, though: With annealed steel it pays to do as much shaping as possible with cutting tools (files etc). It's cleaner, more precise, and more economical.
Re: What a great thread this has been.....
William Duffield
I don't use water stones. Was it a mistake to decide early on not to follow this lengthy thread?
Re: What a great thread this has been.....
TM Stock
Only your doctor knows for sure...and hopefully, your GP rather than your proctologist.
well then....
Joseph Piotrowski
my next topic will be more to you liking
. i have a general sharpening question that has noting to do with the type of stone medium.