Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

Posts

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#26

Re: A different perspective

Joseph Piotrowski

I wish i read your site before i bought the water stones! well next year, maybe.

if anything the only good advice that transitions is: to use a system and use it for at least a year before deciding to use something else.

well this will be a good learning experience on water stones. i picked that because it would be probable to bring the house during the winter. your system sounds good for my cold weather shop.

thanks for the info.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#27

Atoma - $64

david weaver

Can't remember roger's price on the diastolic diatoms for people with diastema, but there's no great reason to buy anything other than the Atoma. The nuclear version (Atomic?) is necessary only for wundersteels.

One thing is worth mentioning - no diamond hone should mean no shaptons, because they don't get along with sandpaper flattening (drywall screens mentioned above, notwithstanding - no experience with those).

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#28

Not universal preference

david weaver

I also have a bunch of sigma power stones (fewer than I used to have). I don't find any favor for the SP 13k over the shapton stones, and the middle stone can be anything from any maker, as it's not really necessary for anything other than cosmetic knife polishing.

The SP 13K is simply too soft, and it's slower than the Kuro 12k because it's finer. But the fineness is not functionally useful - only the kind of thing you'd notice if you're trying to take wide 2 thousandth pared shavings off of maple (even then, it's transient). More clearly, I believe the 12k kuro (without looking it up) is slightly north of 1 micron in particle size, the sp 13k is something like 0.73.

The SP 13k also absorbs water, which is a real pain if you're using a dry stone and you want it to be a wet one without having to keep spraying it. Not a big deal if you're in the shop all day, but the day you're in for two hours and sharpen one thing or two, it's kind of a pain.

There is a slightly higher learning curve with the kuromakus, but it'll be worth the trouble to get through it.

For a little while in the mid 2000s (to late 2000s?) there was a thing going where every subsequent stone introduced was supposed to be better.

King, to shapton, to naniwa superstones, to chosera to sigma power. All of them work fine (I'd prefer to avoid the softness of the first and third mentioned, and chosera are not low-maintenance stones, and for the price...I just don't know what you really get). I don't think anyone has improved on the shaptons, and that includes shapton themselves (when they started introducing glasstones, then two types of glasstones).

All of these have some sort of alumina in them, and the binder differs a little. I developed a preference as follows after trying way too many stones:

* shapton 1k pro or bester 1200

* chosera 3k or shapton 5k (the 5k gets some bad press, but you have to learn what it does and what it likes - the chosera is expensive, but good)

* the shapton 12k or 15k.

Various stones have different feels, but economy of use is hard to beat in the first and third bullet point (I rarely used the middle). Keeping the shaptons neatly dressed and with a bit of wet slurry on them makes them much easier to use. They should last several decades - at least.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#29

to date

Joseph Piotrowski

I starting out with this configuration as it was all my budget i could do right now:

shapton kuromaku:

320

1000

5000

12000

i do have a DMT diamond plate at 8000 i can slip in there if need be but i like to stick the same media. the shapton have a few more grits i can slip in if not happy with my edge. i look froward to trying them out. they should all be hear by this weekend.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#30

Re: to date

david weaver

You have a setup pretty much for life if you don't drop any of them.

Anything that another stone would promise is something that can probably come from those (for example, if you find them sticky, it's avoidable - you just know what to do.)

The only thing you might ever do that they won't handle well is carving tools, but of the synthetics (other than pure ceramics like spyderco), they are most tolerant of that kind of stuff. You can always sharpen gouges on the edge of a stone like people did before they had piles of stones to use for various things.

Even if you're sharpening a full flat bevel, the cutting strength is there in that progression such that anything between the stones would be a waste of time.

Use them and enjoy, and if you have any technical hurdles (stiction, etc), post a message - it's easily solved with very minor technique changes.

I liked the shaptons so much that after I sold mine off, I went back and bought a 1k and 12k kuromaku. I'm so far down the road with stones that I like the oddballs now (vintage superfine india stones, foreign synthetic barber hones, etc - stuff that I can find really cheaply and that comes along with better stuff that I flip), but the shapton pair is just something I'd like to keep.

The reality of sharpening all things, by the way, is that economical technique will ultimately lead you to a grinding apparatus of some sort (could be a stone or power), a single medium stone and then something ultra fine. The 5K stone is in the neighborhood of 3 microns. It often gets abuse because it's not fast and it's not ultra fine, but it bridges the gap, and when you flatten the backs of things, you might find it useful. It prefers a small soak if you're going to use it a good bit. If you strop the edge that comes off of it, you'll be surprised just how sharp it can get - and with the fact that it can raise a polish (quickly) as well as a lot of softer 8k stones.

The best thing about the stones that you got (since you didn't go through a US distributor like is common with the "pro" labeled stones) is that they're relatively inexpensive.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#31

Re: A different perspective

roger lance

Derek....I followed your article on CBN grinding wheels and I've been considering making the move to these wheels. I'd appreciate your recommendation on grit choices....since, I am both a flat woodworker and somewhat a turner, I'm thinking of getting both a radius edged wheel for turning and a mega-flat wheel for hollow grinding chisels and plane irons.

Woodturners Wonders offers the option of combining these type of wheels into a single package. I have one grinder and don't want another.....so this combination of CBN wheels needs to be able to serve both sets of tools.

Thanks for any insight and also for writing your reviews.....they are most helpful.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#32

Re: Atoma - $64

TM Stock

Drywall screens and concrete worked on cheap King stones, but I'll let someone else donate their Shaptons to find out whether they work on the more expensive stuff.

CBN 8" crowned face grinding wheel: $140

Low speed Rikon grinder: $100

Grinding Rest: $2 worth of hardware and scrap?

DMT DuoSharp 10" C/XC: $102

Atoma: $64 (hence David's post title)

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#33

My Opinion...

david weaver

...Just kidding.

Whatever you get, you'll be pleased with it. As much as I like traditional, I cannot deny just how good a CBN wheel is, regardless of the grit chosen. I also purchased form WTW.

Wait, that was an opinion. Can't resist.

Here's my other one. You'll have functional trouble getting an iron to sit flat and contact an entire wheel (I have the 1" wide wheel with radius edges, not sure if it's still current). The radius is nice to have, but getting continuous spark along a straight line from left to right is secondary to relieving the hollow evenly.

Derek egged me on, too. I liked the pink wheels a lot, but they're expensive, and CBN will be more economical in the end. The stuff that flies off the wheel will just be metal dust and not abrasive particles - another nice perk.

(my thoughts on grit size - I got the 80 grit wheel. It's fairly brash, but it settles in and is great for hollows. Any of the wheels in the 200ish and down will do fine with hollows. If you're going to dedicate a wheel to hollows, though, 80 is a good choice. Up from that some would be a better idea for turning tools if you don't stone the edge after refreshing). After settling in, the 220 wheel would probably be really fine.

One side thought if you ever make tools, I doubt you're supposed to grind mild steel with these, but I have from time to time when making tools. They are more precise than a conventional wheel, but mild steel and other metals have some grip, and I'd imagine they could shorten wheel life. If you don't need a sharp corner, one of the radius wheels that also has a flat on the side would probably be fine for everything. If you need the corner, though, then the corner wheel it is. The radius is handy for things like wider hollows and rounds.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#34

Re: Diamond plates

david weaver

I don't think the lapping problems are confined to the ezelap. DMT hones have a reputation for "breaking in" quickly, but one of the bloggers (science or sharp or something) actually took pictures of the plate surface years ago and the "breaking in" is the release of absurdly large diamonds. What's left after the break in is still some mono diamonds that should never have been on the plate in the first place.

My ezelap feels very fine to the touch with metal (probably because metal doesn't provide any resistance to the diamonds cutting). You could feel the pull on the watch face, and by the time you figure out what it is, too late, the damage is done.

I don't have a newer DMT or I'd take the edge picture of various tools on each brand of hone.

As far as the flattening issue, make sure you're using the entire surface of the atoma. I've used mine for both sharpening and flattening (more stones in the long run than tools, now) and they have no issues with flatness. They are the only two diamond hones that I have (my duosharp is beat and without diamonds in the middle) that can be used interchangeably.

Unless you're using hap40 or something, though, I can't think of any good reason to sharpen with diamond hones. A grinder is better for grinding, and stones are better for honing. And if you're using hap40 on a regular basis, I hope you're cutting through staples - otherwise, it's sort of a nuisance that still drops its initial edge pretty quickly and then holds whatever is left for a long time.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#35

Re: to date

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you read Derek's site around 2010 you would have seen that he was recommending Shapton at that time. His ideal set up went through four different iterations in maybe eight years.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#36

Re: to date

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well, I used Pro Shaptons for several years, and was not happy with the 5000. I found it glazed over easily, which made harder work for the 12000. I contacted Stu (at Tools from Japan), with whom I corresponded often at that tome (he is a fellow Aussie). He recommended a Sigma 6000, and sent me the 1200/13000 combo as a gift. In comparison, the Sigma 13000 was superior to the Pro Shapton 12000. The 6000 was just way better than the PS 5000. The Sigma stones seem to work better on the more abrasion resistant steels, such as A2 and PM-V11.

Generally I find a system and stay with it for as long as it does the job. The Spyderco were an additional system, purchased on the recommendation of George (who remains mythical on this forum)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#37

My thoughts

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'd appreciate your recommendation on grit choices....since, I am both a flat woodworker and somewhat a turner, I'm thinking of getting both a radius edged wheel for turning and a mega-flat wheel for hollow grinding chisels and plane irons.

Hi Roger

You've read my warning about the radius wheels, that is, the ones I had had a slight hollow in the centre. I cannot state that all are like that, but it is interesting that David found the same on his. I suspect that the radius machining process creates some heat and stresses that alters the profile (for those unfamiliar with radius and flat wheels, the radius is on the corners of the wheel face).

My recommendation is to get a flat wheel in 180 grit, which is all you need for flat woodworking chisels and plane blades, and a radius 360 grit for the turning chisels.

The CBN wheels (that is, the solid aluminium or steel wheels, and not the new composite wheels) act as a large heat sink and as a result manage to dissipate heat very well. I have a 80 grit pairing the 180 grit, and I do not find much difference in heat build up. A 360 grit, however, would likely create more heat. A light and quick touch (it is to be used to maintain an edge, not create one) would ensure a safe grind. I am sure that the resulting edge would be ready for turning.

The reason I do not recommend an 80 grit as the only straight wheel is that the finish is coarser than off a 180 grit. It is possible to grind safely to the very edge of a blade without heating it, and this creates the least amount of steel to hone ... which promotes very fast sharpening. A number of people will argue that the edge created will be vulnerable to chipping. That is not my experience, and including with laminated Japanese chisels, which are chopped into Australian hard woods.

The advantage of a hollow off a 180 grit compared to an 80 grit is that the edge is smoother, and this then requires less work to straighten when honing. I can go directly to a Medium Spyderco or a 6000 Sigma straight off the wheel. The 1000 Pro Shapton may only need to be used after 3 honings as the micro bevel remains so small. I use the 180 grit 95% of the time, and the 80 grit is only used when there is a significant amount of steel to remove.

For clarity, I grind at the angle I hone, so plane blades are all 30 degrees, as are BD bench chisels. BU plane blades have a primary bevel of 25 degrees and then a high secondary micro bevel.

Where a radius wheel is useful is with turning tools, and only when you are grinding/sharpening a curve. If this is unimportant, then get a flat face. I can present a blade to the flat faces of my wheels and they cut evenly.

There are several advantages to the CBN wheels: They do not wear (some turners have used them for a couple of decades now), which means that the wheel remains the same size and settings are retained. The wheels never need to be dressed. The dust is metal particles from the blade and not from the wheel, itself. There is a smoother cut that is also cooler. My Tormek get used very little these days.

My bottom line: I am not fascinated by sharpening, and generally avoid sharpening discussions. I have not had many sharpening systems over the years, because I stick with them for as long as they work well. The system I have is efficient. Beyond machines and media is hand skills and techniques. It is these that continue to improve, or need to improve. It is a circular issue: when you have developed enough technique, then look at the media, and once the media is the best possible, look at the technique.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#38

Re: to date

TM Stock

This simply confirms my low opinion of Derek: excessively open-minded, far too inquisitive by nature and habit, and absurdly ready to embrace contrary evidence - even when it flies in the face of his previously expressed positions.

Simply stated, the man is a menace. :D *

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#39

Re: My thoughts

TM Stock

My TFWW 8" radiused face CBN wheel seems to be pretty uniform - if there is a change in radius due to heating, it's too subtle to see, I'm simply not that observant, or my jigless approach to edge grinding minimizes any associated issue. I would think that any CBN wheel would benefit from a solid construction which allows uniform expansion, but I have not trialed solid versus rimmed construction against the other as of yet, so def something to look at as the technology moves forward.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#40

Re: My thoughts

roger lance

Derek......I became aware of CBN wheels because of some reference you made about them on a forum (probably here). Then, I followed up by reading your review of CBN wheels on your site and became aware of the potential issue of these wheels being slightly dished and the negative effects that would have on chisels and plane blades if these wheels were used by flat wood workers.

I then talked with a couple of my friends who are accomplished turners about CBN wheels. Interestingly, they were unaware of this technology.....so off to YouTube I went for more education on the topic. Apparently, these wheels are made for and marketed to turners.....and there is no real issue for them if these wheels are slightly concave.....other than a skew or flat scraper, turning tools can be sharpened with no indication of this dip in the wheel.

CBN wheels are a product that are mainly purchased online; so, its difficult to find examples of wheels from various makers to look at in person before making a buy. I did find a CBN wheel at Woodcraft and confirmed a little concavity there as well.

Your summary does conclude this issue with a good working solution that serves both worlds: a flat wheel at 180 grit would be useable by both flat tools and turning tools.....and a radius edge wheel at 350 grit would be usable by turning tools and round scrapers could be sharpened on that radius. This makes sense and Woodturners Wonders has this combination.....others may as well.

Thank you for your well thought out response.....you continue to give me and others information that gets a person investigating and thinking.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#41

The flat wheel surface - or not..

david weaver

I haven't ever measured / checked the flat surface of my radius wheel for flatness. Since I only have the 80 grit, maybe that tempers the following opinion, but here's what I think - any amount of hollow is so minute that it really doesn't matter.

I think the reason that it's hard to get something flat on the wheel from side to side when you're grinding something long and flat is that you're literally trying to place the center of a wide blade or chisel (which probably is flat to within a thousandth or two) on a surface that's moving. Hitting that surface on one side or another is much easier.

I have actually gotten comments from people on youtube videos (I don't know if I have a grinding video up) because they thought I was going to wear out my cbn wheel by biasing toward the left. It's simply easier for me to remove just the amount of metal in the hollow that way and not worry about placing something flat on the grinder. It's the hollow I'm removing, not the squareness or straightness of the tool that I'm establishing.

I wouldn't change the wheel I have - it's just dandy. One of the cornered wheels like Roger is talking about might be nice for toolmaking (but the reality is, I can file all of those things that need that brash corner). I've I've said the center of my wheel is out of flat (it's possible that I said that), I can't remember checking it, but I also never bother about it.

I have placed chisels on the rest before and grind the entire chisel without moving it - no harm is done by that, either, and whatever out of flatness there may be, I can't perceive any harm once I take those chisels to the stones.

You can ultimately make heat with these wheels if you really want to. I can't remember the heat transmission properties of CBN vs. Alumina - someone can look that up. Perhaps it's 80% CBN and 40% alumina or something. It's very easily detected, plus the CBN is miles sharper than a broken in al-ox wheel that needs to be dressed, or even one that has been dressed but is in the middle of use. To get an idea on durability, the first thing I ground in earnest on my wheel was a 1/2 inch mortise chisel that Mel Fulks gave me. He actually gave me a pair in exchange for something or help on something - can't remember what - good guy he is, though. He had found them and knew they were the kind of thing i liked. The back of one of them was hollow (socket chisels in this case, like framing mortise chisels) and I realized the bevel was cut upside down on it. It's a thick chisel.

I literally held the chisel in one place on the wheel and (picture this) cut the bevel from 25 or 30 degrees upside down to 25 or 30 degrees right side up in the other direction (on a chisel that's probably 3/8ths thick). It was a LOT, and other than settling in a little bit, the wheel seems no worse for the wear. There was a pile of burning red metal between the wheel and the tool rest. No clue how hot the tool get, but it didn't blue significantly from the edge because I took a few breaks - I'm sure I could've burned it, though, just as I've noticed certain things will still get hot (laminated irons - the soft steel still generates a whole lot of heat) - they just get uniformly hot and not at the edge.

At any rate, the wheel is a dandy, and I wouldn't exchange it for anything at this point. I never grind with water nearby, and for day to day maintenance, it's really uncommon for me to get an iron that I can't cool just by pulling it flat side slowly across my palm (including the irons that have mild steel or iron backing). I did that with the pink wheels, though, too, but you can just go a little faster with the CBN and the irons are a little cooler when all is said and done.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#42

Re: The flat wheel surface - or not..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

It is relevant to understand the context of my concern with a slight convex on the radius wheel. I wrote this up on my website in CBN article. In my case it comes down to the 180 grit wheel being used with the Tormek blade holder (the BGM -100). This runs past the wheel on rails, and needs the face to be aligned.

"The problem is that the Tormek has a friable wheel and, using the BGM-100 set up, the wheel can be trued to it. However the CBN wheels are not friable. Therefore there can be no adjustment. If the wheels are not square, then you are in trouble! On the other hand, if you are not using the BGM -100, then you have wider options".

My 80 grit wheel has a simple rest where blades are ground freehand. Nevertheless, a slight convex here means that only the centre of the face cannot be used by moving the blade across the wheel since there is a dip at that point.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#43

Re: The flat wheel surface - or not..

david weaver

I no longer have a tormek, but I had one, so I recall that holder system (except I didn't build a separate base). It should be doable to just move the blade back and forth over the part of the wheel that's doing the cutting (which is essentially what I do freehand). If someone was anal retentive, they could orient your rest setup so that both outside edges of the wheel were doing work and worry about using the middle of the outsides ever seem to stop cutting (they probably won't).

I had enough of all of the tormek bits pretty early, but I have decent (but relatively small, which I prefer) two-piece cast rests on my grinder. I think the whole setup is a detriment in this case, and a grinder with decent rests would be better and more productive. But it still shouldn't be an issue with the wheel, as your wooden bases could be reoriented however you'd like.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#44

Re: The flat wheel surface - or not..

TM Stock

The TFWW wheel is more properly a radiused face versus radiused edge (with flat face), or flat face with one or two flat sides. The TFWW wheel is much closer to the shape that I've used for wheel dressing - slightly radiused face generated by wheel or diamond dresser - so I suspect any change in shape due to heating is not an issue. For a flat faced wheel - whether square-edged or radiused edge, it seems like a bit of a traverse across the face cancels any issue, which is pretty common technique.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#45

Re: A different perspective

TM Stock

I prefer the radiused face - really gently crowned face - of the TFWW CBN wheel for chisel and plane blade use. If working both (planes/chisel & turning tools), the flat face/radius edge seems to offer some utility. Adding a second wheel and the sort of jigs that turners use to the TFWW wheel seems like a good idea for a shop that does a lot of both sorts of work.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#47

which side to use?

Joseph Piotrowski

hey,

since the instruction are in Japanese and i have no clue what they say...

one side of the stone is printed on with Shaton information. the other is clean. dose i matter which side i use?

TIA,

Joe P

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#48

Re: which side to use?

Patrick Chase

Doesn't matter which side. I often use both so that I can flatten half as often.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#49

bridger

Re: My Opinion...

Bridger

I used a cbn wheel the other day to profile the edge of a washita stone for getting into the concave curve of a carving gouge. It worked really well for that.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#50

CBN and grit

Patrick Chase

Derek's suggestion of using 180# CBN wheels brings up a key difference between CBN and traditional wheels.

When you grind a piece of metal, there are two major sources of heating:

1. Heat dissipated due to deformation of the metal that is removed. To a rough first order this is proportional to the total volume of metal removed.

2. Surface friction between the abrasive and the workpiece. To a rough first order this is proportional to the number of revolutions the grinding wheel takes to get the job done, and inversely proportional to the sharpness of the abrasive.

Fine grit wheels require more revolutions/passes to remove a given amount of material and therefore dissipate more heat into the tool from friction. That's why you generally want to do major material removal using coarse grits with conventional (AlOx) wheels.

CBN crystals are sharper and cut more easily than AlOx grains (especially worn ones) and vastly reduce frictional heating. That in turn means that the "heat penalty" of finer grit wheels is greatly reduced, and you can get away with doing significant grinding on 180# or 220#.

As to the amount by which CBN reduces heating, I've seen one study showing a 4X reduction, though I can't remember what grit # it was for. Deformation heating is relatively constant, so obviously CBN does best compared to conventional wheels when friction dominates, i.e. at finer grits.