Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

Posts

flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#1

flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

Joseph Piotrowski

i know discussing sharpening techniques and equipment is like discussing religion but anyways,

i'd like to keep it on topic if i can. i decided i wanted to change my sharpening routine for chisels and plane blades. i learned a lot but now i decided to get some shapton "pro" Kuromako stones.

so i'd like to know what people here flatten them with and how often? is it a routine or just when you feel it needs it? do you measure it? eye ball it?

i have yet to purchase any flattening stone so i'm open to suggestions.

thank you!

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#2

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

david weaver

Atoma 400 - cheapest place you can find it. Good for any stone in the 700-ish grit range or above (waterstones below that aren't particularly practical for tools, anyway).

Flatten as often as you'd like. I used those stones for a long time and liked them (the pros), as long as they weren't allowed to load. I'd say that even though they're spray and go, if you leave some slurry on the surface (which will help them to not load or glaze), spray them a minute or two before you use them because the slurry will harden and that's not a great thing.

Great stones. My favorite of all of the synthetics, and I'd hate to guess how many stones I've played with.

I glued mine to kingwood, which was a good idea (I got kingwood scrap for a song, not suggesting that specifically -something dense and inexpensive, whatever it may be). They are nicer to use if they're glued to something with some weight (and it has to be something stable - anything quartered and reasonably dense would be fine). Traditional bases on japanese stones are cedar (now plastic), but you'll appreciate something a little heavier with these. Contact cement, silica, epoxy - all are fine to use as the glue.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#3

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

roger lance

I'd suggest going to YouTube and watching some videos.....try "DMT Dia-Flat Lapping Plate".....there are numerous videos there that will illustrate the process in a way that is much clearer than I can write about it.

Atoma or DMT diamond stones will do the job. I've had good luck dealing with SharpeningSupplies.com.

Its relatively easy and quick....but, involves water.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#4

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

Mark Nowicki

I just flattened my water stones yesterday (Kings, 1000, 4000 and 8000) using the method I learned at a LeeValley seminar years ago; drywall sanding screen (220 grit), dipped in water and placed wet on something flat.

In my case it is a 12"x 12" granite tile on top of a granite counter top cutoff on top of an old towel on top of

of my bench.

I mentioned this method at a Lie-Nielsen travelling sales show, the rep grudgingly admitted that my method might be just as good as the $500 one.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#5

Flattening

david weaver

Somewhere along the line, I've tried just about everything for flattening, too.

There is a method to why I suggested the atoma, and the rationale is as follows:

* the atoma is extremely even gritted (I learned this when polishing the face of a sapphire lens watch. The other hones that I have, including my favorite Ezelap, marked it bad with uneven scratches. the atoma was so even that face of the watch only had an even haze that I could see through)

* It is absolutely flat to go along with those even grits

* the diamonds are arranged in piles instead of at random. It has some clearance, thus less sticking, and less random flotsam in terms of diamonds (the eze-s are relatively flat, but they can have a buildup of diamonds on the edges and they really stick - they also have foreign coarse diamonds to start).

* it's not terribly expensive (I think about $80)

* it does not unduly grind the stones you've bought (some of the coarser stones do - the DMT dia flat is a nice device, but it's a bit too coarse at even price, and the grit evenness isn't there vs. the atoma. It is, however, bigger and heavier, and probably has more use flattening wayward tools - but I think PSA roll is much better for that work than either - by miles - and cheaper in the long run, by miles)

* it's much longer lasting than Shaptons DGLP, or whatever they call their lapping plate. Shapton's plate is incredibly flat, but far beyond the purpose of practicality. It is the precision of a seiko spring drive, but the longevity of an unserviced audemars piguet (not good). I never noticed - ever- an atoma that wasn't that flat.

* separate and aside about flatness - DMT plastic, DMT dia flat, Atoma, and of course, shaptons devices - all are flat. Anything else, probably not (the eze is, but it's a bad choice here due to heavy stiction and sometimes less than perfect coating - and the price of it has gone way up in the last few years until it's little different than the atoma).

All of those things make Atoma (the 400 version) the choice, even without regard to price, for shaptons. Deep grooves in synthetic stones aren't really the problem that they are in natural stones, but you still want to preserve the stones you have.

The reason for the heavy base, aside from the fact that such stones are just nicer to use, is that it allows you to flatten the shaptons in situ with the atoma.

When I used the shaptons (my mind always races with the least effort way to do something), I would start with the 15,000 (same as the kuru cream, more or less), lap it, then go down the line to the 1000 grit stone. I would then clean the diamond hone literally by spraying it for about 5 seconds and all of the grit would dribble off onto the floor (to be swept up later - I'm in my garage, and my wife doesn't see this).

It is a fantastic system, and probably the cheapest premium system overall.

Also, as an aside - I had kings before shaptons, and I used W&D paper on the shaptons despite Stu Tierney's warnings of potential substandard results. He was right. Some of adhesive or something, perhaps grit, must've rubbed into the surface of the stone and I had to diamond hone it out to get decent results from the stones again.

And one other aside - these stones, just like the choseras, are entirely different with a short soak. They are soft surface and firm core feeling rather than hard and sticky feeling. There is no slurry dulling with them, so there is no reason to try to run them without slurry if it's helpful.

(I apologize for my zeal with sharpening stones. It's mostly gone with the synthetics, but my memory of what I liked about various stones has never gone away, nor has my desire to find the cheapest and fastest "perfect" system with each type).

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#6

Diamond plates......

roger lance

You can get a DMT Dia-Sharp Diamond Stone (D8C - 325 coarse grit) for about $56 from SharpeningSupplies.com and get free shipping on orders over $99.

Its 3" x 8" which is the size of the Atoma 400 which sells for about $80 from Stu of Tools from Japan and there will definitely be a shipping charge on the Atoma.

The DMT stone will definitely do the job and will last and last.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#7

Re: diasharp vs. diaflat

david weaver

apologies, I got both of those confused.

I have used the bench stones, dia flat, dia sharp and the duosharp. From time to time, the diasharps have flatness issues, but the duosharps, dia flat and bench stones do not (the duos and bench stones are plastic, I guess it's easier to get flat stock moulding it).

The plastic "bench stones" are expensive for what they are, but I found the duosharps fine to use.

I have yet to find a diamond hone made in china that's flat from hone to hone. That includes the $50 plates that come from bestsharpening stones (4 thousandths hollow for both that I have, which doesn't sound like a big deal, but you will find that it can create a problem if you prepare a cap iron and iron on it), as well as the gaggle of stones that are about $20 for a two-sided stone.

I understand the iwood japanese hone can also be a bit out of flat (according to stu's stuff), and the extremely expensive apparently chinese-made trend plate that some of the retailers sell has a poor flatness record on the shaving forum. trend's flatness quote is per inch, so it's relatively meaningless for the plate.

I didn't have the ability to measure the diasharp's flatness the last I used one. If you can't get a 1 1/2 thou feeler through something, it's fine. If you can get a sheet of paper through the center of a diamond hone, it may present problems.

Apologies for confusing the diasharp and diaflat. Based on what I've seen of the lower cost DMTs, though, I'd stick with the plastic ones if flatness counts, but I'd still defer back to atoma because one atoma will last as long as about 10 duosharps. I blew out my first duosharp in about a year. Each chinese equivalent ("DMD" brand, etc), about the same. I have two atomas that have been used very heavily and both are still fine and not missing any significant patches.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#8

Revise atoma price...

david weaver

It's been too long since I bought one.

In the old days, you had to order from japan (pre stu) or wait for alex gilmore to have one for about $110.

They're on amazon now for $64 including shipping. It appears that everyone and their brother is selling them directly to the US now.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#9

Re: diasharp vs. diaflat

roger lance

They are different alright....differently made....differently sized....etc. Both are extremely flat.

I'd also suggest shopping at your local WoodCraft.....they have the DMT line.....you can inspect what you are buying.....have it taken out of the packaging and give it a good going over for flatness, etc. WoodCraft has their sales.....15% off and other promotions.....its possible to buy a Dia-Sharp stone for less than $56 which will include local sales tax.

Decisions....decisions.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#10

Re: Revise dia-sharp price...

roger lance

Amazon has the DMT Dia-Sharp stone (D8C) for $49.91 plus free shipping.

Thanks for reminding me to check Amazon.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#11

Re: I think...

david weaver

... DMT would normally exchange, at least they used to. I can't remember what the flatness spec is, but 4 thousandth hollow in an 8" plate was enough to give me problems following the diamond hone with a finer stone - the center gets polished but it takes a while to get to the edges.

At $64 for the atoma, it would be my first choice regardless due to its durability, certain flatness, and the much lesser stiction flattening waterstones. It does have a funny feeling if you hone on it - almost like a zipper, because the piles are so neatly arranged. I no longer do that with any of them, though.

The thing that made atoma plates more expensive in the past, other than exchange rate, was the necessity to pay for shipping from japan. Now that it appears amazon is stocking them and selling/fulfilling them for an overseas seller, they can get them in stock surface shipping and that wipes that out. I've never seen an out of flat atoma, but I'm sure there's a first time for everything. There is a picture of an extremely out of flat diaflat on amazon, but that has to be very atypical - the one I used was nothing like that. The amount of out of flatness was of the type where if brought to a flat stone, it clipped the ends off of the stone a little bit before fully cutting, resulting in a slightly peaked stone center (which itself isn't a problem).

A stone out of flat isn't a problem, either, as long as the person using it knows how to deal with that (honing flat items over the edge of a stone, you can keep the back of an iron flat with a swayed oilstone pretty easily, etc, but I think those things are easy to say to someone - harder for them to necessarily understand how to do until they create some problems that they have to solve).

Sadly (or maybe not, I don't know), woodcraft and japan woodworker are completely off of my list as places that I'll patronize under any circumstances.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#12

Re: I think...

roger lance

The DMT Dia-Flat stones (which are more expensive than the die-sharp stones) come with the following statement...."all of the DMT Dia-Flat stones are carefully machined to be flat within .0005 inches".....and that I believe was over the entire stone surface. That's pretty flat.

Its also my understanding that DMT will exchange stones if you get one that is out of spec. That's why it might make sense to go to a local store and buy in person after making an inspection so you know what you are getting.

I'm not an advocate for DMT or Woodcraft; but, I must say that I've been impressed with some of Woodcraft's sale promotions of late.....prime examples being some specific Japanese pull saws at 50% off. Like anything else, buyer be ware.....pick and choose with care.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#13

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

roger lance

One other thing.....regardless of which product you get.....if you get an Atoma or DMT stone to flatten your water stones, I'd suggest that you only use this diamond stone on your water stones and never use it on metal.....don't use it to flatten a chisel or plane iron.....just a suggestion.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#14

lapping film?

Joseph Piotrowski

i do have a nice 10 x 20 inch flat granite for lapping. could i use that 3m lapping film? at least to get by until save up for whatever stone.plate etc. i need to re-read all the advice at least twice :)

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#15

Re: lapping film?

roger lance

Yes.....that would work.....sandpaper works.....on a piece of float glass.....or a granite block.....or a granite floor tile.....all will work.

There are some flattening products to be avoided.....the Norton flattening stone comes to mind.....very poor product.....a waste of money IMHO.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#16

Re: lapping film?

roger lance

I'm afraid David and I got on the diamond stones because we've used them and also its fun to trade comments with David.....its a form of trolling a troller.

The thing is I've got a great set-up for working with water stones.....I've got a sink next to my sharpening station which has a granite top.....why wouldn't I like water stones??

This is an expensive hobby. How can a guy even try to have the best of everything in a wood shop?? There are literally hundreds and hundreds of items in my shop....tools, accessories, on and on. Try to have the best....in every thing....crazy.

I'm no turner; but, I showed my old Delta lathe on the turners forum recently to ask a question and one of the commentators referred to my lathe as a POS. There is just so much that you can do.....so taking a slower approach in the tools and methods you use is just fine. Gaining a little experience is a good thing....it helps you decide what you will eventually get....or not get.....as you build your kit.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#17

you are not kidding!

Joseph Piotrowski

it is expensive! i am guilty of over buying stuff. that is why i'm pumping the brakes on the flatting stone.

i am also trying not to buy other tools just because there on sale or i like them.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#18

Re: lapping film?

Patrick Chase

Yeah, 3M lapping film would work.

That's rated in microns, where 120 um is about 100#. The 60 or 30 um stuff should work nicely. I have some 3x8 sheets of the 30 um that I've used for stone flattening, though it ends up being a pretty expensive option.

I'd use float glass rather than a granite surface plate. The surface plates have a bit of texture, and the diamond films are thin enough (3 mil polyester) that the texture can telegraph and cause "hot spots" on the film where the abrasive wears prematurely. Glass has a much more uniform surface.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#19

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

Patrick Chase

Yep, I learned about drywall screens for stone maintenance back when I was doing a lot of ski work. I use diamond plates nowdays, though.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#20

A different perspective *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

i know discussing sharpening techniques and equipment is like discussing religion but anyways,

i'd like to keep it on topic if i can. i decided i wanted to change my sharpening routine for chisels and plane blades. i learned a lot but now i decided to get some shapton "pro" Kuromako stones.

so i'd like to know what people here flatten them with and how often? is it a routine or just when you feel it needs it? do you measure it? eye ball it?

i have yet to purchase any flattening stone so i'm open to suggestions.

thank you!

Hi Joseph

The Pro Shaptons are good stones, but I only like the 1000 grit. I prefer the Sigma 6000 and 13000 to fill out the range. These are flattened with a Shapton diamond stone, which I have had for 10 years. Before then I used a DMT Extra Coarse (in the duo format).

There are other alternatives, stones that do not need flattening - none, zip ... well, maybe once a year. The stones I use most of the time are two ceramic Spyderco (2"x8" Medium and Ultra Fine).The Spydercos are hard and retain their flatness like oilstones, but are worked dry. Spyderco do not say what the grits are, but they are reputed to be 1500-2000 and 6000-8000, respectively (it would not surprise me if the Ultra Fine is about 10000 as it leaves a mirror finish).

Even more important than honing is the decision to use a secondary bevel or create a microbevel on a hollow grind. I hollow grind as I can freehand on this, and find it the fastest and most efficient way to create and maintain a sharp edge. Consequently, my emphasis is first placed on creating the hollow grind, and to this end I highly recommend CBN wheels on a dry grinder. This can safely grind a blade to the edge (as can a Tormek). Once this is possible, the flatness of a stone becomes much less important, as does using the "best" stone around (however, the stones mentioned above are excellent).

If you prefer a secondary bevel using a honing guide, then stone flatness is an issue, and I would recommend the Pro Shapton/Sigma system above along with a good diamond stone (not the Shapton I use as it is expensive and unnecessary - I picked one up at a sale).

Regards from Perth

Derek


The Ultimate Grinding-Sharpening Set Up?

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#21

Diamond plates

Patrick Chase

I've tried DMT Dia-Flat, DMT Dia-Sharp, DMT Duo-Sharp, Atoma, Eze-Lap, and Shapton plates at one time or another.

In terms of flatness the Shapton is the best (but it's a pretty pointless advantage over cheaper options, as you say), followed by Atoma, Dia-Flat, Dia-Sharp, Duo-Sharp, and Eze-Lap in that order.

For me Dia-Sharp is the bar of acceptability - it and everything I listed as better works terrifically for stone flattening. Of the others Duo-Sharp and Eze-Lap are hit or miss, with Eze-Lap being prone to occasional obnoxiously large flatness errors. I think fine-tools gets it about right with their warning "Note" (in the yellow box) here: https://www.fine-tools.com/ezelap-diasharpener.html.

Another thing to be aware of with Eze-Lap is that they're made using a combination of monocrystalline and polycrystalline diamonds. While this partially counters monocrystalline plates' tendency to "wear in" and slow down, it also means that you're cutting with a mixture of worn-down monocrystalline corners and recently-fractured "fresh" polycrystalline facets. I think that may explain the nonuniformity you saw with your watch face.

My Shapton has lasted several years with noticeable degradation, but I'm super careful with it. No metal has ever touched it other than a fine brass brush, and I generally only use it on fairly fine-grit waterstones. I can't seriously recommend it to anybody concerned about cost, though, as the incremetal performance advantage is small while the monetary cost and reduction in usable life are both quite severe.

The Atomas are IMO the best tradeoff: They're flat (second only to Shapton and not by much), more durable than any of the others except perhaps DiaFlat, uniform (again second only to Shapton), and reasonably inexpensive.

I do have one cautionary note about Atoma: If you indend to use an Atoma plate for flattening stones, then don't use it on tools. The Atoma plate consists of a 1 mm thick stainless steel plate with the electroplated abrasive, bonded to a much thicker flat aluminum blank. The bonding uses 3 pieces of Nitto 5015 double-sticky acrylic tape, one at each end and one in the center. If you work tools on the plate you will eventually cause the thinner stainless plate to "sag" between the tape strips, compromising its flatness. For this reason I prefer diamond compounds and lapping films for actual tool work, though I'm also trying to use up a set of EZE-Laps that way :-).

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#22

Yes, this

Patrick Chase

Reiterating what Roger says: Don't mix your "flattening plates" with your "grinding plates" if you can avoid it. That's particularly the case for Atomas with their tape-based lamination scheme, but for others as well.

After all, a worn-out area of diamonds is basically the same as an indentation as far as your waterstones are concerned.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#23

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

TM Stock

DMT DuoSharp C/XC, but about half again the price of the Atoma (8" x 2.77" Atoma vs. 10" x 4" DMT). Amazon and eBay both have them for around $100.

The coarse/325 side is one of the two stones used here for most sharpening (a Norton 8000 or Shapton 8000 is the second), stripping the dull edge quickly, and the XC side is useful for grinding in the field where grinder or sander is not available. Drywall screen/'flat' surface and even concrete block back a few decades for water stones, but diamond stones are quick and convenient for the job, and much lighter & easier to store than a concrete block. Not sure whether anyone has had an Atoma show up less than flat, but there have been reports of DMTs that were not dead flat.

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#24

Quick and dirty summary:

Mark Nowicki

Super-duper grinding stone- $220

Atomic plate- $120

Dia-something $115

Lapping stuff $24

Special glass for lapping stuff- $???

Special grinder (of course) to spin special grinding stone-$?????

Time to talk above all of the above $???????

Build anything yet, Joseph?

Re: flattening Waterstones- shapton pro

#25

Re: Quick and dirty summary:

Joseph Piotrowski

Hi Mark,

thanks for asking, i have built a few shop projects with hand tools they are serviceable but need finishing up, small details and an actual finish:)

i working through a real project of a end table and a few other things. i need to have 2 or 3 projects going so i can complain about the chaos. two much travel for work and now the cold weather starts. that really slows down in my unheated garage.

so the sharping is moving into the basement :)