Re: My memory, Bill
Bill White
Warren, must have been another Bill. My old Butcher and 750 Stanleys don't chip. WHEEEEE.
Bill
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: My memory, Bill
Bill White
Warren, must have been another Bill. My old Butcher and 750 Stanleys don't chip. WHEEEEE.
Bill
How are you looking
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I know the chisels I use don't chip either. But unless you have the microscope to examine reflective metal surfaces at high magnification you don't know whether your edges are chipping of not. But, it is unlikely that the steel you are using microchips. The only case I have seen is with an experimental chisel fashioned from an M2 jointer blade (see PIC).

It is not a desirable dulling mechanism. It is harder to recover by sharpening because metal is missing. Hence, steels and heat treatments that lead to this dulling mechanism are to be avoided. A more common mechanism for dulling is deformation at the blade tip. The deformation can largely be straightned by the sharpening stone.
A further thought
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I do believe that tearout is prevented by a downforce at the tip of the blade. What else can be occurring? However, it is unclear whether this is the same mechanism for the high cutting angle and the double-iron.
A thought did occur to me later.
The main mechanism occuring, as we know, is that the wood splits (becoming a shaving) when it is struck by the blade. As it enters the blade, it bends. The double-iron/chipbreaker is understood to bend the chip at its tip. This is where downforce is seen to occur. A plane with a high cutting angle does the same thing, and the higher the cutting angle of the blade, the greater its ability to mitigate tearout.
Both set ups bend the chip. This bending action, it is seen in the K and K video, restricts the length of the wood splitting ahead if the blade. The shorter the split, the less the tearout. Hence the higher the cutting angle, the greater the bend.
The difference in bending the chip is that this occur a fraction later with the chipbreaker than it does with the high angle single blade. It may be that this is responsible for the chip bending differently. Perhaps the high cutting angle bends the chip a fraction further away from the blade? That would account for a slightly higher level of tearout as the splitting would be a fraction further out.
If this is so, then downforce is not at play. Even if downnforce does aid in mitigating tearout (which it can do), the amount of downforce from a closed mouth would be too little to make a significant difference. Rather it would be bending, and where it takes place, that is the main mechanism at play.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Don't agree
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
A higher angle of attack simply results in a smaller force lifting the shaving. In the extreme, 90 degree to the wood, there is no force lifting the shaving and hence no force to create a split ahead of the blade tip.
Try pulling a shaving through a mouth tight enough to restrict passage of the shaving through the mouth. That substantial pulling force will be translated to an equivalent pushing force in use. Because a significant pushing force is only achieved when the shaving thickness closely matches the mouth opening, this approach to tear-out mitigation is not practically versatile unless one finds adjusting the mouth versatile.
To understand tear-out and its mitigation one has to analyze the forces acting at the blade tip. The only way to prevent tear-out is to counter the lifting force created by the blade tip as it wedges through the wood. While a bent shaving is a consequence of the downward force created by the "dam" of the cap iron I fail to see how bending itself results in the force necessary to hold the wood fibers together ahead of the blade tip.
Re: Don't agree
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia) Try pulling a shaving through a mouth tight enough to restrict passage of the shaving through the mouth. That substantial pulling force will be translated to an equivalent pushing force in use. Because a significant pushing force is only achieved when the shaving thickness closely matches the mouth opening, this approach to tear-out mitigation is not practically versatile unless one finds adjusting the mouth versatile. To understand tear-out and its mitigation one has to analyze the forces acting at the blade tip. The only way to prevent tear-out is to counter the lifting force created by the blade tip as it wedges through the wood. While a bent shaving is a consequence of the downward force created by the "dam" of the cap iron I fail to see how bending itself results in the force necessary to hold the wood fibers together ahead of the blade tip.
A higher angle of attack simply results in a smaller force lifting the shaving. In the extreme, 90 degree to the wood, there is no force lifting the shaving and hence no force to create a split ahead of the blade tip.
Bill, with respect, none of this makes sense to me.
Your argument is predicated on the assumption that downforce is required to prevent tearout. I offered an alternate explanation based on bending. Then you refer to a tight mouth. I have pointed out that a tight mouth is irrelevant to control tearout: both a high cutting angle and a closed chipbreaker function perfectly well with a wide mouth (probably better, since you can then take a thicker shaving).
Bending is demonstrated in the K and K video. Of relevance was the differences in tearout control as the leading edge angle of the chipbreaker rose from 50- to 80 degrees. The increased angle alters the bending angle of the chip. The force to bend comes from the forward movement of the plane, plain and simple. Similarly, a chipbreaker with a too low leading edge angle (e.g. 25 degrees) fails to effect sufficient bending to influence tearout control. Change the angle at the leading edge, and tearout control increases. With this, there is no change in downforce.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Don't agree
david weaver
When you increase the angle of the chipbreaker, there is definitely a change in the force applied by the shaving column down to the point of the cut, at least what you're calling downforce.
The job of the cap iron is to push the shaving back into the surface of the board to some extent to prevent it from lifting. Bending or whatever you'd like to attribute it to, there is force holding the chip down to the point of the cut above the iron.
the shallower the cap iron, the less ability there is to push back through the column of the shaving into the surface.
Discussions like this one aren't particularly helpful.
Coupla notions
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Derek, Steve, David, and Bill and all,
Here is a notion. Apologies to David, who is weary of theory without proof, and also to Derek who made many, many points which deserve specific discussion, which I can’t get to at this point.
Caveat 1: I’m going to refer to one common type of tearout below—there are others. Caveat 2: I make unqualified statements below about Type 2 shavings and tearout which someone will surely say are incorrect in their case—they’re right, but I’m keeping the word count down by speaking ‘by and large’.
To begin….Consider a 50 degree plane, with open mouth. Bevel down. Well sharpened. Chipbreaker set back, so it has no effect. Make a 2-thou shaving into rising grain. The shaving is bent at 50 degrees, the cut begins to run ahead of the blade tip—there is tearout. The shaving is pushed upward by the blade, and acts as a lever against the uncut fibers. All the force on the shaving is upward, creating the upward levering. The mouth is open, the chipbreaker set high, so there is nothing to keep the cut from running. It is a Type 2 shaving; if we could increase the bedding magically to 60 degrees or a bit more, we would shift to a Type 3 scraping action, and the tearout would be cured. But a Type 2 cut , say 40 degrees to 55 degrees, will not infrequently run ahead of the blade into rising grain if nothing is done to prevent it.
Now with the plane at 50 degree bedding, we lower the chipbreaker to within say 5 or 6 thou (three shaving widths) of the blade tip. Say the chipbreaker has a 50 degree face. The shaving is bent upward past 90 degrees. What are the forces on the shaving now? With the chipbreaker set back, the force on the shaving was all upward. But now the shaving is in compression below the chipbreaker. The shaving was a lever pushing upward, helping the cut to run; now it is a lever flexed and pushing downward, trying to keep the cut closed ahead of the blade tip. The tight bend created by the chipbreaker has partially reversed the forces acting on the shaving. Yes, the blade is still pushing upward, creating the cut, but the compression is trying to hold the uncut wood in place to keep the cut from running.
This seems to me to be the mechanism by which the chipbreaker operates. Of course, the set distance, the face angle, the thickness of the shaving, the type of wood—all turn the successful use of the chipbreaker into an art, as Warren might say.
What about a plane with tight mouth? The near edge of the mouth presses down on the shaving approx. 3 shaving widths ahead of the blade tip. But this is not sufficient. Bending is still somehow necessary to tearout suppression. My experience with tight-mouth planes is that tearout is suppressed at 52.5 degrees (Konrad Sauer No. 4 type) and at 55 degrees (standard C&W smoother), but less so at 50 degrees (a C&W model), or 45 degrees (a Steve Knight model). Bill Clark always said they had to go to 55 degrees to get the full effect. The tight mouth itself creates a pretty tight bend, when combined with a 52 to 55 degree bed. But the bending is less than the 90 degrees we had with the chipbreaker.
I can’t speculate on the significance of the high bedding in the tight mouth plane. With the chipbreaker, the chip can actually get ‘broken’ and straighten out; not so with the tight mouth. As Derek suggested, the mechanism seems a bit different with the high-angle/tight-mouth plane, but the tearout suppression is similar to what is produced by the chipbreaker.
Wiley
Exactly the kind of analysis....
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
...I would expect from an engineer comfortable dealing with force vectors at the blade tip. I agree entirely.
The blade tip forces the shaving up. Some force must force it down to mitigate tearout and that force must act ahead of the blade tip.
The down force of the sole ahead of the blade tip it too piddly to do anything useful.....I think. I need more mechanical data than I have to answer this question definitively.
In the case of a tight mouth ideally sized to the shaving thickness the resistive force on the shaving passing through the mouth creates a downward force on the shaving fibers. The result is the similar to the cap iron effect. The lifting of the shaving ahead of the bade tip is resisted, more or less.
Where is Kees? Hiking in Spain I think. He built a planing machine with load cells and studied these effects. I think we came to the conclusion above but even I don't trust my memory.
Re: Coupla notions
david weaver
Wiley, I think that is a good explanation, that the whole shaving is in compression. I am a little weary on the cap iron thing, I guess, because it's so easy to apply practically that for 99% of the people trying it or who should be trying it, they really shouldn't care what makes it work, but care only about how to duplicate the success.
Re: Coupla notions
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
What are the forces on the shaving now? With the chipbreaker set back, the force on the shaving was all upward. But now the shaving is in compression below the chipbreaker. The shaving was a lever pushing upward, helping the cut to run; now it is a lever flexed and pushing downward, trying to keep the cut closed ahead of the blade tip. The tight bend created by the chipbreaker has partially reversed the forces acting on the shaving. Yes, the blade is still pushing upward, creating the cut, but the compression is trying to hold the uncut wood in place to keep the cut from running.
Hi Wiley
Thanks for this. I completely agree. The issue of "compression" was something I failed to articulate (but was what I intended).
Compression due to bending is a different mechanism to downforce as a result of a closed mouth. There is some overlap in that both attempt to restrict the splitting/running of the wood ahead of the blade. However, there is a limitation to the effectiveness of a closed mouth, per se, as you describe. This is easy to demonstrate: simply use a smoother with a low cutting angle (e.g. my Veritas Custom #3 with a 42 degree frog) planing into most grain or planing into interlocked/reversing grain - but with the chipbreaker pulled back and the mouth as tight as you can make it .... and there will be tearout. Now open the mouth and set the chipbreaker forward, and the tearout will disappear. I have done this many, many times.
The question now asked is this: is the bending the primary factor in reducing splitting/running (as I first argued), or is the bending via the chipbreaker creating a high amount of downforce, and that it is the downforce, per se, (i.e. rather than the bending) responsible for preventing splitting/running (as Bill is suggesting).
My view is that downforce will always be present (Newton's Third Law - equal and opposite reactions), but that this is not the primary factor, which is bending. I am not sure how we can determine what is a sufficient degree of downforce via the chipbreaker to restrict splitting/running, and whether this is greater or less than off the leading edge of a high angle blade. And then there was the idea I offered of the position of the double action (delayed) bending at the chipbreaker vs the immediate bending at the leading edge of a single blade, and whether there is a difference here as well.
Some here will argue that we are splitting hairs rather than wood
Still, enquiring minds want to know.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: That's sad, an opportunity missed
TomD
"I'm sure bill's reference to the double iron is in respect to furniture. It's pretty useful there. Not if something is made of perfect white pine, but for most of the rest of the stuff."
Well obviously, but that doesn't entitle the myth making. There are lots of guys making wooden boats, and they aren't using burl in the keel either, there are airplane makers, musical instrument makers, rod makers, and so on. It is useful to whomever it us useful to, but if we are wondering at the uptake, it could have something to do in the hand tool segment with the fact that it is not universally necessary.
Krenov built furniture; used interesting tropical and native woods; did marquetry (not sure how that fit in) , though mostly mild grained wood; last article I know of was a let's keep it simple kind of thing. Actually finished his work off the plane or file; obviously didn't do the breaker close enough thing, from the books anyway; So even in furniture you can get by without it.
Bows are interesting, Osage can be one of the more tear-out prone woods, they use toothing planes.
If the method is as unknown as it seems to have been, even though not new, it sorta follows it can't be that necessary. Which is only to answer the question why the level of current uptake. Answer, installed base doesn't need it. Many newbies are CS worshipers.
Re: Down pressure and static hysteresis
TomD
"There is only "back pressure" on a double-iron when the chipbreaker is set too close to the edge. The result is an accordion shaving. When the ideal distance is set, the shaving straightens (rather than curls). I cannot say that I have experienced any more resistance at this setting than when the chipbreaker is pulled further back (i.e. the cutting angle remains the same for both)."
That is true, I put that down to the configuration on Japanese planes which is different than on western planes. Why aren't people who got the inspiration from Japanese sources studying the japanese breaker moreso. I guess it doesn't mater since the loss is pretty small.
The pressure is actually down pressure from the close set breaker. And the felt back-pressure is static hysteresis (that is what the bow engineers call energy not transferred to the arrow due to mechanical inefficiencies of an unknown origin. Like friction. Or if you tightly accordion a shaving it takes energy to do that is not beneficial.
- In the close set deal, the angle is pretty close to the blade angle and in line with the shaving, it then buckles into the cutting area, so there isn't tear-out until it is cut.
- Steep blade set it similar deal more force applied closer to parallel to the surface.
- traditional breaker, works by reducing the lever arm
- close set, does not let the shaving lift before it is cut
- fine set, reduces the lever arm thickness to the point where the lever arm can't split our visible tear,
- cross planing with curved blade , cut the chip out along with the tear that might develop.
- scraper, traps the curl in a negative angle troth that creates back pressure till it is cut.
- Sand paper... some scraper function, micro cuts so no lever arm, cross cuts that separate grain bundles? Mixed action in short.
Re: Coupla notions
TomD
"My view is that downforce will always be present (Newton's Third Law - equal and opposite reactions), but that this is not the primary factor, which is bending. I am not sure how we can determine what is a sufficient degree of downforce via the chipbreaker to restrict splitting/running, and whether this is greater or less than off the leading edge of a high angle blade. And then there was the idea I offered of the position of the double action (delayed) bending at the chipbreaker vs the immediate bending at the leading edge of a single blade, and whether there is a difference here as well."
Not sure I am reading this correctly, but I thought the films clearly show the close breaker traps the shaving against the blade, where it is then caused to take a tight angle at the point where it goes around the corner where the surface of the wood and blade meet, and this is the main action, though Japanese planes have tight mouths also. There are two down pressures, one at the mouth were the grain is held down in what could be the tear out zone. The other is the compression of the shaving.
Re: I can't speak for Steve...
TomD
It was under consideration until I got a 500 dollar ticket for not having a whistle in my canoe. Sorry.
Re: Exactly the kind of analysis....
TomD
"The blade tip forces the shaving up. Some force must force it down to mitigate tearout and that force must act ahead of the blade tip."
I doubt that applies to planing end grain. And since we tend to agree that planing perfectly straight grained wood is lees of a problem, normal wood is nor perfectly straight. If you plane with the grain you are severing the cross grain at the cut. You are only fighting the split resistance of the fibers, not the main strength. Other factors that may affect the load and stiffness of the fibers are how cleanly the edge cuts, and whether the plane is skewed, since tear out occurs in chips and a skewed plane cuts wood ahead of where it is cut elsewhere in the chip. grain run is two dimensional, so skewing the plane cuts the grain ahead of the cut in two directions.
Re: Side Comment about the Double Iron
TomD
I am just piecing together some stripped wood I bought for tool handles for the back of a small musical instrument. It is bookmatched with wings. At the end of the day, I had to scrape it because I needed to remove the glue. The panel is about 6 inches wide, 4 strips, and the wood is about 1/10th".
Just based on how the thing came together I did the main joint in the vise, used dollar store bar clamps on it, it came out perfect. I did the wings with rubbed joints only. In this format you can't sensibly avoid a little excess glue. I did the main planing with a block plane, I did the joints with my Krenov jointer (18" setup like a fine finish plane). Even with that plane the final set for the rub joints is a few strokes with a level with 80 grit paper on it.
There is a neat thing in the wood, a bit like an insect hole, and if that doesn't get trimmed, I will probably fill it with epoxy. So scraping and maybe sanding is going to happen. The fastest way to fill the rather coarse grain might also be epoxy. In the real world that you note your friend may be prepping his charges for, it probably couldn't mater less what they planed the board with since scraping for glue removal and sanding will probably occur.
Re: That's sad, an opportunity missed
david weaver
Not necessary, just superior. By far.
I don't know much about krenov because when I see his cabinets, I see something I have no use for - either to make or have. I'm going to assume that he was selling artist furniture, and not producing at the rate someone historically would have done.
It sounds like he did his rough work with machines, too.
That said, I couldn't count many people working entirely by hand, but when I find such people, it's pretty easy for them to grasp why the double iron is far superior, and as worthwhile as anything as useful as such things as sharpening saws.
The rest of the folks making fly rods or sanding off planer marks, I don't have a lot of interest in what they're doing, and they're not likely to find much value in a double iron.
Re: Side Comment about the Double Iron
david weaver
The local instructor is teaching people to build furniture, not musical instruments or small boxes. It's not "the real world", it's white collar fantasy woodworking just like most people do.
I'm sure his students would find the double iron useful, if they aren't working with power tools to do everything.
He had mentioned to me that he has about five people who say they want to work entirely by hand, and asked if I'd be interested in teaching a plane making class to help them make planes that would facilitate that (of course, the answer to that is no - I can tell people how to make such planes at no charge).
If we're talking about the "real world", such a thing around he doesn't involve many people making instruments or furniture for a living. It's sort of like the argument that always comes up about how "doing work entirely by hand is stupid and slow and impractical". Generally, building things instead of buying them is that entirely, planer or whatever or not. It'd be far cheaper for me to fill my house with relatively attractive RTA cabinets and furniture that I could find at a flea market that was made centuries ago.
Talking about reasons why a double iron isn't needed does zero to explain why they eliminated single iron planes, other than some joinery or moulding type planes) until amatuers became dominant users (obviously, productivity went completely out of the window at that point). Certainly, the cap iron on a japanese plane is a lot of additional effort (if it's made to match the iron), but even on those planes, the double iron persisted.
There is a value in understanding productivity with hand tools if you're going to use them, though, and that is satisfaction and effort. I have no clue why someone would want to dimension much of anything by hand with single iron planes from rough. It works less well, takes longer, and even includes simple issues such as needing to sharpen significantly more often to remove the same volume of wood.
Sorry Bill, but you couldn't be more wrong
ian neuhaus
I refer you to Leonard Lee's "Complete Guide to Sharpening" an excellent reference.
but more prosaically to the shaving action of a card scraper which has no toe or mouth but when used properly will take tearout free shavings from the most recalcitrant wood.
Re: Sorry Bill, but you couldn't be more wrong
david weaver
It's getting hard to follow this discussion and see where prior posts are related to current posts, but I think a lot of the success of a card scraper (or any scraper) is that there is no ability for a shaving to lift after it is severed by a burr - or before.
Indeed!
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
You said "It's getting hard to follow this discussion ". Indeed.
Given that I could not "be more wrong" I thought I should know what I was so wrong about. But I could not figure it out. The critic didn't make the effort to provide any evidence. He did hint that I should buy and then study a book which I suppose would reveal to me how I was wrong. But I am lazy too. I won't buy the book, nor ponder what I said that reached the limit of wrong where I could not "be more wrong".
I'll just let folks assign my wrongness to their personal choice and I'll get back to building stuff, probably wrongly.
Re: Side Comment about the Double Iron
TomD
"Talking about reasons why a double iron isn't needed does zero to explain why they eliminated single iron planes, other than some joinery or moulding type planes)"
Right the majority of all planes in serious use.
One answer would be they needed something to attach the adjuster to. Though not on wooden planes. The traditional answer is probably wood got worse over time. Though Morse did comment of his Japanese travels that he thought the western users would do well to adapt japanese planes, I don't recall whether the ones he saw were single bladed.
Another option is that the trades were falling apart and they were hiring less skilled makers, or barely had them in the US to start with.
There is a modern day fallacy that everything people did in the past (or today) was driven by efficiency experts and scientific enquiry, while for a good deal of the period, if the product had screwed up efficiency it probably would have been more likely to have been adopted. There was so little interest in all that that Deming had to move to Japan to find his audience, and that from post war USA. When the sewing machine was introduced in France for making clothes and uniforms there were violent riots.
"until amatuers became dominant users (obviously, productivity went completely out of the window at that point). Certainly, the cap iron on a japanese plane is a lot of additional effort (if it's made to match the iron), but even on those planes, the double iron persisted."
Could be, there are lots of single blades, and the rumour that at higher levels they still liked the single. Japan had a lot of imposed from the top rules, the breaking of which drew criminal penalties, so I would have to know a lot more about their situation to know what drove it. Exposition is not the strong point of the Japanese craft either.
"I have no clue why someone would want to dimension much of anything by hand with single iron planes from rough. It works less well, takes longer, and even includes simple issues such as needing to sharpen significantly more often to remove the same volume of wood."
No clue what you are talking about there, this is the new speak. The ever changing learning curve. Sharpen more often, huh? Certainly slower to cycle. I can cycle a Japanese plane in 10-20 seconds. When you say dimension, do you mean reduce or bring to some line, don't see it in either case.
I assume this is the idea that you can take a fractionally thicker shaving which means you can take less cuts and remove more material. But a 5 thou shaving would come up against a 30 thou shaving, and a few remedial passes. Or whip out the axe or saw.
Sounds like an interesting conference stunt with props going to the guy who can remove the most wood cleanly with the fewest passes. But then some guy with real skills comes along and just splits it off.
Re: Side Comment about the Double Iron
Brian Holcombe
Tom, currently the majority of planes I see sold by shops like Mandaraya (not geared toward westerners or even hobbyists) in Japan are double iron, even for most of their joinery planes.
Top level Yokoyama Kunio planes even feature chip breakers made by the smith, and someone like Kunio would probably turn his nose up at that if it were for inexperienced or unskilled.
Splitting doesn't elimate the need for a jack and try plane but I'm sure it does require one to chose better wood.
The double iron is forgiving of imperfect circumstance which includes so many situations.
probably should just let this go, but
ian neuhaus
any discussion of tearout, shavings and "force vectors" needs to reference the Type I and Type II shavings that Leonard Lee talks about in his book on sharpening.
These shaving types are also associated with how close the chip breaker is to the cutting edge and hence how the shaving curls and breaks after passing through the plane's mouth.
Re: Side Comment about the Double Iron
david weaver
Nobody is splitting wood off of a 5/4 board to get to 7/8ths.
As far as efficiency goes, when the contest is survival and meager success, efficiency counts. If you tie up an apprentice for 40 hours a week doing various grunt tasks, and then the market comes up with a way for an apprentice to do them in 30, you adopt it or you go out of business. It's not necessarily the modern day efficiency engineering (optimization, whatever) thought that drives efficiency, it's necessity - survival will drive efficiency. The same as it has driven the family farmer types to need things like satellite mapping, etc. That's not something most of those guys want, to have to spend that capital - it's necessary to be able to make the thin margin between expenses and rent and yield. If you can't compete, a larger operator will talk your renters into switching.
The idea that the double iron plane was developed for less skilled users is bunk. It works better for skilled users and they'd have adopted it in the first place. Only more recently have we found that if you drop the skill level low enough, people can't seem to make use of the double iron. It's not as if skilled users of the 18th and prior centuries would've turned down a better-working tool, they just didn't have it available in most cases.
As far as the adjuster goes, the double iron was popularized before adjusters were common.