New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

ordinary carbon steel

Posts

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#126

Re: 20 second cycle for sharpening

david weaver

...I'd like to see it. I think the entire cycle from stopping to starting with an adjusted plane takes me about two minutes. Talking about from dull to sharp.

I'm assuming that includes the actual sharpening, and if not, it's not that much faster than setting a cap iron (which adds about 15 seconds to the process, perhaps 15 more to take the cap iron apart and get it lifted off of the bench).

Several multiples of that are saved between sharpenings vs. a single iron. But not just sharpening, the plane works better in the cut the entire time unless the shaving is too thin to do anything or is entirely cross grain. That's something that's pretty easy to observe in use, but kees went to the trouble of actually measuring it.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#127

Re: Exactly the kind of analysis....

Kees

Not in Spain, France this time. Spain will be later this summer. I know I am late to this discussion, but let me summarise what I measured and what i THINK happens down there at the edge.

In high angle planes I measure that the vertical force (the wedging action of the edge, prying the shaving upwards) quickly diminishes with higher cutting angles. That alone is enough to understand how high cutting angles work to prevent tearout. Less vertical force means less prying, means less tearout. I am not the only one who measured this, it's in the literature too.

When I used a chipbreaker with a reasonable front angle between 40 and 50 degrees, I didn't see this strong reduction in vertical force. It hardly changed at all even with the chipbreaker set only 0.1 mm from the edge. So there must be another explanation why the chipbreaker is so effective against tearout. The bending theory is of course a good one, the shaving is compressed in its length because of the bend and thusly supports where the shaving is still atached to the wood. In addition to the bend I think the friction of the shaving over the chipbreaker plays a major role, otherwise I don't really see how a 90 degree bend would support the shaving a lot.

The vertical force pushing the shaving upwards is rather strong, but the bond between the woodfibers is also pretty strong. So when you do get tearout, you only need to nudge the forces a little bit in the right direction to prevent the tearing. It's a matter of balance. That explains why a tiny little bit of friction between shaving and chipbreaker can be so effective.

A tight mouth is effective IF the mouth is super tight (0.2 mm or less) and IF the edge of the mouth really presses down on the wood. In use this is an area where the mouth wears quickly, so it is not easy to make a plane like that and keep it like that over time. Even with such a tight mouth it was still not as effective as a tight set chipbreaker or a very high cutting angle.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#128

Important contribution to understanding cap iron..

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...is to be found in the Kees post above. It deserved a title that would have attracted more attention.

Kees said..."otherwise I don't really see how a 90 degree bend would support the shaving a lot. "

The bending is not the cause of anything useful, nor in itself does it do anything useful.......rather....., it is the result of a force applied along the length of the shaving. The shaving responds to this force by deflecting(bending), a classic example of the response of a stiff material under compression. The same force that bends the shaving is translated to the area ahead of the knife tip. And, as Kees said so well, it may not take much force to be added to the strength of the wood to prevent the crack from propagating ahead of the blade tip.

What is interesting is that this force straightens a shaving that otherwise would curl. This observation suggests the compression is sufficient to lessen the fracture on the underside of the shaving. In the extreme the compression is so much the shaving "accordians"(Z-folds) as illustrated in a Kato and Kawai tutorial we have been unable to get completely translated. Anybody know Japanese?

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#129

Re: Important contribution to understanding cap ir

Kees

The question then, what came first? The bend or the compression? 8)

Usually you hit upon a spot of rowy grain somewhere halfway the board, not at the start of the cut. So the shaving is allready bend over a 90 degree corner. It is not a sharp bend, according to the Kato/Kawai video but a round one. The shaving hits the capiron edge a little higher up. So the force vector of this impact is directed in a a direction that actually adds to the prying action of the shaving. Unless you also add the friction of shaving flowing over the capiron face.

The straightening of the shaving is indeed intruiging. It doesn't happen always, the shaving needs to be thick enough.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#130

Re: Exactly the kind of analysis....

William Duffield

The bevel up, high angle, tight mouth fanatics will not give up so easily! All they have to do to prove that they had the right answer all along is to braze a piece of carbide to the trailing edge of the mouth block or plate the whole block with Titanium. It worked with wooden planes and the lignum vitae patches they use to retighten the mouth that some "citizen" "stupidly?" opened up when they converted the plane from a single iron to a double iron two or three centuries ago.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#131

Re: Important contribution to understanding cap ir

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The question then, what came first? The bend or the compression?"Of course the force of the cap iron bends the shaving. How else could the cap iron influence the shaving if not by adding some force to it?

Are we talking about the "natural" curl of the shaving or the discontinuity at the dam that is the cap iron edge? Draw me the force vectors that do not translate down the length of the shaving and then resolve into a force parallel and perpendicular(down) at the blade tip from this dam retarding the flow of shaving up the blade.

As I recall the more the cap iron "worked" upon the saving the more the wear to the blade occurred just up from the tip. I'll have to review that paper but I think it hollowed the blade at this point. There has to be some substantial downward force to cause this wear.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#132

Re: Important contribution to understanding cap ir

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

"Draw me the force vectors that do not translate down the length of the shaving and then resolve into a force parallel and perpendicular(down) at the blade tip from this dam retarding the flow of shaving up the blade."

Agree! For a given bedding angle, as the 'dam' is lowered, the bend increases and the frictional resistance as well, until the shaving's upward levering is reversed and the shaving becomes 'sprung' downward (with vectors as Bill describes), counteracting the tendency of the cut to run ahead of the blade tip.

Like Bill, I think Kees' post here is most informative. Thanks to Kees for taking the vacation time to do so! The discussion of how the bedding angle increase, all by itself, reduces the upward wedging of the blade is really helpful. Among other things, it explains why a tight mouth plane still requires a high bed angle to eliminate tear out. The high bed angle reduces the upward wedging. The tight mouth crowds the bending into the space of 3 or 4 shaving widths. The high bed angle combined with the tight bend increases the frictional resistance to some critical backpressure needed to counteract tearout. I think Bill may have said this better in fewer words in a previous post he made.

Wiley

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#133

Few will know.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....the work behind the scenes in Kees "woodworking laboratory". I can't recall how much was posted but a boggling amount of work went into his planing machine and data gathering and analysis.

I have two mechanical engineer students for neighbors. What a great senior project......Hummm........

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#134

Re: Important contribution to understanding cap ir

Kees

Yes there certainly is wear on the face of the cutting blade, it usually stretches almost to but not quite to the capiron edge. There is also wear on the face of the capiron edge, according to that paper. But nothing in the corner which is logical, the shaving acts like a spring, so bends in a curve.

I'll have to think a bit more about those forces.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#135

Re: Important contribution to understanding cap ir

Kees

Just looked at the paper on Steve Elliot's website. Indeed the wear on the face of the blade is substantial. After 200 m of planing the wear is 2 um deep without a capiron and 6-8 um deep with the capiron close to the edge. There must be quite a bit of extra rubbing going on due to the bend in the shaving.

The length of this wear spot is pretty stable over the 200 m planing. It is 50 - 75% of the distance of the caprion to the edge.