New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

ordinary carbon steel

Posts

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#76

Been there, done that

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We seized the opportunity to eat the grilled fish at every opportunity(I don't like wine but could live on fish). I was astonished how cheap the meals were. One could eat very well for 15 eu and gourmet multi course for 30.



We hiked several of those narrow ridges above the sea (note path at edge of cliff). Spectacular.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#77

Re: Wow...

steve voigt

Well, if you read my response more carefully, you'll see I said nothing of the sort. In fact I didn't say anything about my *customers*, but rather about the folks who show up at an LN event. And just because someone can't sharpen well does not automatically mean that their planes are "for purely vanity purposes." I refer you to Brian's post below for more on that.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#78

The trouble with being overly PC

Brian Holcombe

Right, wrong or otherwise, it's nice to read opinion. Opinion is what keeps these discussions interesting.

Wiley said it well above!

Without people who go out there a little bit, the topics get pretty stale. Bill, Warren, David, Steve, Wiley, Tom, Derek and sorry if I'm forgetting anyone are generally willing to state their opinion and that keeps things interesting.

In my cabinet threads, Bill is always willing to ask an interesting question or ask about my logic and it spurs discussion, if he were always worried that I would get my feelings hurt the topic would lose interest to people reading. Same with Derek, he's usually one of few people willing to say 'You're not doing this as effectively as possible' which usually causes me a snap reaction, but it keeps things interesting and gives me something to think about as I continue.

I participate in message boards for a few reasons I guess, but one of them being that I like to read opinion of very experienced users that aren't concerned with being censored.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#79

Re: My first planes...

steve voigt

Brian and all,

I bought my first two planes in around '95 or '96. A Stanley 3 and 7, cuz some FWW guy in an article told me to. I did not know how to sharpen the irons. I was working in a machine shop and knew how to sharpen HSS lathe tools and drill bits-- at the grinder, no hand honing. Imagine my shock that these methods did not produce an edge suitable for planing oak! It was some time before I could make an edge that would cut wood, and much longer before I could sharpen to a high level. Probably many people have similar experiences, but without the head start the machine shop gave me, their lot is even tougher.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#80

Re: Wow...

david weaver

Thanks, Steve. A very reasonable response.

I'm not trying to be unfair by accusing a large part of the cohort of either being too inexperienced (and terminating their experience before learning too much) or not having interest in learning to correct less than perfect manufacturing.

I think it's a reasonable expectation. I've never gotten to the level of competence with a table saw that I've seen some others get to. If someone said I was relatively inept with table saws and relatively afraid of them, I'd tell them they're right. (my English friend who has returned two things to LN for reasons I'd say are absurd is a comfortable magician with a table saw - he thinks the same about my power tool prowess - that I'm inept...the times we've been working together on something that is tricky or dangerous, I let him cut parts for his piece and mine. It's an interesting comparison because he would return a warped iron, and I refuse to learn to do the things he does on a table saw. We could each sling barbs at each other for being lazy and inept/inexperienced at something).

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#81

Re: Wow...

JDK

Weaver explicitly claims that over half of LN customers cannot prepare a plane blade.We wouldn't be having this discussion if he hadn't said that. Given that your planes and LN planes are priced to serve (roughly) the same customer base, wouldn't his claim apply to your planes as well as those sold by LN?

If Weaver had said "over half the people at woodworking shows who stop at the LN booth cannot prepare a hand plane blade" I still think he would be talking out of his you-know-what, but I wouldn't have expressed my objections.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#82

Re: Wow...

david weaver

I said half of the customers probably could not prepare a plane iron (in the context of one that isn't perfect), not half of the people. Preparing a plane iron involves removing the iron warpage and getting stone contact at the edge on the back all the way across.

I think that's still probable.

If preparing is as I described above, all of planes I've received did not meet that standard, and that was without introducing an iron that is less than flat.

It would be very improbable that the vast majority of customers could prepare an iron properly, but I got six planes where that was the case with none - without introducing warped irons. Let's play to your preference and say half as many as I speculated could not prepare an iron properly. There would be a 25% chance then (or greater) that each plane I received wouldn't have a properly prepared iron.

That would mean my chance of getting a sample of 6 that were never prepared right is:

0.25^6 - assuming the sample I got was from a reasonable cross section of LN customers. That's 2 chances in 10,000.

Of course, you could speculate that it's likely that the sellers of the planes are the least competent users (because more competent users would be less inclined to purchase excessively or sell). Maybe that's true, who knows?

That's why we can only speculate. There is no law that says speculating on what's probable must include a flattery adjustment.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#83

Re: Side Comment about the Double Iron

david weaver

There is a local instructor here who has a fair number of students.

He bought my old bench (the old wobbly one I originally had) because I sold it cheap enough that a student short on cash could afford it (and I had braced it, so it was certainly better than anything else someone could get for $50).

While he was over, he saw my planes, so we had a chat about why I'd made them. He tells his students to stay off of the forums (I don't blame him) because they'll lead to confusion and unnecessary buying, and he advocates students buy a couple of stanley planes to do things that are difficult to do with machines.

I put a piece of curly maple between the dogs on my bench and planed off a layer of shavings about 5 thousandths thick across the width (using a stanley plane), and he looked like he had just seen a ghost when he examined the board. In his view, you tolerate the tearout, remove it with a scraper and then sand, which I think is probably what most woodworking schools teach (scraper and sandpaper remove what you can't remove with the plane).

He knew that I took a heavy shaving just for show, but was interested in the method (to teach to students) and I showed the cap iron setting to him. I'm sure he still teaches scraping and sanding, the learning curve is shorter with it.

I'm sure you're right about it not really being worth the time at a show. It's only useful once someone has troublesome tearout with their own plane and can apply it themselves. The popular planes at shows will probably always be of the extra heavy type planing easy wood. It makes newbies think that the plane is taking over for them and doing the work itself.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#84

Re: Wow...

steve voigt

"Weaver explicitly claims that over half of LN customers cannot prepare a plane blade.We wouldn't be having this discussion if he hadn't said that. Given that your planes and LN planes are priced to serve (roughly) the same customer base, wouldn't his claim apply to your planes as well as those sold by LN?

If Weaver had said "over half the people at woodworking shows who stop at the LN booth cannot prepare a hand plane blade" I still think he would be talking out of his you-know-what, but I wouldn't have expressed my objections."

No, the "customer base" for one-off wooden planes is not the same as that for LN, regardless of price similarities. Just as the customer base for "fixies" (bikes with no gears and no brakes) is not the same as that for 12-speeds with all the bells and whistles, though I'm sure you can find some 12-sppeds that are comparably priced to fixies. I'm pretty sure that a lot of metal plane users--beginner or otherwise--view woodies as crude and fragile. I would've when I was a beginner, if I had known that wooden planes even existed, but I thought all planes had to be metal.

I don't think anyone here (except you) is arguing about whether Dave's statement is literally true. He's already conceded that it wasn't. If your whole point is that he made a statement that wasn't precise or verifiable, then congratulations, you win. I think what everyone else is pointing out is that in broad strokes, his claim was reasonable; that the average buyer of new metal planes is probably not very expert at sharpening. That seems so obvious and uncontroversial that it's hardly worth arguing about.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#85

Re: Wow...

JDK

Weaver often expresses his disdain for other woodworkers, especially those able to afford high-end tools. His recent remark about Lie Nielsen customers didn't come near your overly-generous interpretation ("the average buyer of metal planes can't sharpen the iron."). What he said was that over half of Lie Nielsen customers can't prepare a plane blade. It's pure bunk, and you know it.

Lie Nielsen planes are expensive because they are well-made precision tools of high-quality and craftsmanship. We don't know about the skill levels of the "average" purchasers of these tools, and we know even less about the blade preparation skills of the majority of the purchasers. Even so, I strongly doubt that a majority of Lie Nielsen customers are willing to spend hundreds of dollars on a tool that they cannot use properly, and that includes sharpen properly.

Weaver is a crank whom I often find tiresome and puerile. Not too long ago he used these message boards to disparage Henry Studley and those who admire his tool chest. After the forum erupted with the opprobrium you might expect from such a ridiculous opinion, he disappeared for a while. Now he's back expressing what I consider similarly ridiculous opinions. I don't mind that you defend him - that's fine and your right - but don't pretend many of the things he says aren't offensive to what I suspect are not a few readers of this forum.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#86

Re: Been there, done that

Hank Knight

Yep, that looks like it. Spectacular place! And I'd go back just for the fish.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#87

Here because it has to be somewhere: be civil

Let's remember that civility is the first rule here. We can argue ideas all day long, but attacks on people are just not OK.

I've been holding back on this, hoping moods would settle down, but it appears there's still some high emotion; time for a reminder.

You may think someone's a total fool, with ideas that are beyond absurd. But it's a lot more effective to politely rip the ideas to shreds, without personal accusations.

David made a statement; JDK asked for supporting data; that's all fine. But the direction it went from there wasn't so good. Let's just calm down on the invective.

I think it's indisputable that some people don't know how to sharpen. Anyone who's purchased planes at garage/estate sales can confirm that; I remain puzzled, on some of my purchases, how the edges even got to the state they're in. The shapes of the bevels would have taken at least as long to make as it's taken me to correct them, and the plane would have been getting progressively more useless. What percentage of these folks are LN customers - I'm not altogether sure how important it is.

Maybe everyone can lay off this topic for a while. Sharing pics/stories of the work you've got in progress, or, like Bill T., interesting sights from your summer travels*, would be a nice alternative.

*Or winter jaunts, for those members on the Southern side of the globe.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#88

Re: I can't speak for Steve...

david weaver

(and seriously, I don't think any of this is a big deal, nor would I if you speculated that 90% of lie nielsen tools could hang a hair on a new plane iron with 5 minutes of prep time)

...but I doubt Steve feels that he's "defending" me. He's a tool maker who has been working his way around events and he can draw his own conclusions.

I can afford premium tools, too, I just recognize there is no gain in work productivity with them, and the conclusions that the users draw are often wrong. I just got an email on google from a machinist who told me that my conclusion about thin irons stopping you in your tracks before a plane chatters is not correct because machine cutting tools leave a better finish if the assembly and the cutter are heavier. What's his suggestion? Bedrock and premium planes. It's typical.

If I couldn't afford premium tools, I wouldn't have a cabinet full of sharpening stones that have been dug out of the ground from various places in the world. And another cabinet full of the same thing for razors.

I wouldn't have several infill planes, either, the kit cost to one being more than anything Lie Nielsen sells, and the cost of materials in another about the same cost as a Lie Nielsen plane.

Or a box full of planemaking tools that haven't made me a nickel of profit. It's a hobby, though. A tremendous waste of money because ...well, many hobbies are.

I *do* have disdain the offering of gadgetry and "specifications" not within the context of getting work done, and assertion that such things are better or more efficient than learning to use hands and eyes. But that doesn't even mean I have disdain for everyone who does that, maybe people believe it just like they believe things like "you'll need to get an infill to work difficult woods".

I might joke about wanting charity donations of some things (I'd love a holtey A13 in boxwood), but the reality is if I really wanted them that badly, I'd just buy them.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#89

Re: Inverse cabin fever!

david weaver

Is there such a thing?

Interesting comment about garage tools. I set up a plane for my FIL last year. It had been his dad's plane and the iron was worn hollow from some type of use that I couldn't even guess at to about a 32nd of an inch. The part of the iron in the middle was about half as blunt as the edge of a dime.

I have no idea how the plane got that way, but someone worked *really* hard pushing it through something to get it that far.

FIL is far from home (so no access to my stuff), but he had a dry grinder with no rests to speak of (for mower blades) and I convinced him to buy a project pack of various grits of sandpaper and chase down a tube of metal polish and we had a good working plane in about ten minutes (and soon thereafter, doors that no longer rubbed).

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#90

Re: I'm back!

TomD

By the by. I heat treat my own steel, and just shove the O1 in the forge (gas) and bring up to temp, put in oil, that is pre-heated. I have some tricks, but it is hard to know if they make much difference. All I know is I get good results. I have cracked at least one plane blade out of several dozen. They all come out perfectly straight. Part of the reason may be that I only do about 2 inches of the end. Experience over 40 years indicates that I am unlikely to make my way through that amount of steel. I have only one plane that has really showed some wear, and it is far from worn out. Mostly I don't grind these blades, though I have nothing against grinding the ones I make. And the other factor is that I have pursued many paths over the years, as many of us here have done. A devoted amateur might wear out a few tools if they only owned a minimal kit, but if one has experimented widely there is no hope. So two inches is more than enough steel. And in any case. It only takes few minutes to make a new blade, or to get the next few inches up to snuff. The point being keeping a blade flat is no big deal.

I think you used Paul Boss, Bill. Never used him myself, but there is no better name in the biz that I am aware of. That said if there is a consensus in knife making it would probably tip towards home heat treating. There is no special magic to the guys you send it out to. It is regarded as such a routine part of the task, that some knife makers choose not to do it themselves. Of course there are steels that can't be efficiently heat treated in most home shops. They just aren't generally used in woodworking.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#91

Re: That's sad, an opportunity missed

TomD

"Next to sharpening I would argue that learning to set the cap iron to mitigate tear-out is the most important knowledge to acquire when buying a hand plane. Way LN persists in avoiding teaching this skill remains a mystery to me."

Well you started from the view that it was unknown the world over, and you seem to have been more right than I imagined. So what is the evidence that a few articles and a lot of internet chat have changed any of that. It can take a lot of time to make a major change, unless some movie star makes it known. One could do worse than fill in Nick Offerman, if he doesn't know. He has managed to get covers stories on his invention of a long known technique (keeping fully in mind that others lay out the magazines, and write the stories). But seriously once the Illuminati start taking credit it will move the last few steps to the finish line.

To add one thought to the above. Even without the breaker, planes are massively useful to woodworkers. I never had the least problem with them other than getting onto the basics, we all start from nothing. The breaker may be the big news, but if it didn't work planes would still be massively useful, and how many have that message? More every day, but still. How can the whole community embrace an idea that is only a part of a larger idea they haven't got?

"On a technical note, I believe the mechanism by which tear-out is mitigated is the same for a close set cap iron as a close mouth. In each case a resistive force is being applied to the shaving which translates to a downward force on the wood at the tip of the blade which prevents lifting of the wood fibers ahead of the blade tip. Employing the cap iron is the more versatile solution when a plane is used for a variety of tasks, as is the case with my work."

Truly. I would reiterate that there is a shaving size, and there are woods that do not require any of the above. One might as well get this part straight. There are tasks that do not benefit from a breaker because the shaving is too fine to tear out, and there are woods, indeed entire crafts where the materials are not prone to tear out. Aside from nodes, bamboo rods would be an example.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#92

Re: I can't speak for Steve...

TomD

"I *do* have disdain the offering of gadgetry and "specifications" not within the context of getting work done, and assertion that such things are better or more efficient than learning to use hands and eyes."

I think this is just a rhetorical device we all rely on at times to make arguments. The only thing rarer than a free Hotley is a woodworker in the west, a hobbyist, working like producing piece work would save his family from starvation. At various times I have got a bug for doing efficient woodwork "like a pro". I spent a lot of time on a concrete floor sharpening, when I was young. But it never lasted all that long. I have done production fly tying, but I didn't have to do it, and when I learned what I wanted, I never really bothered again. When I think about these things I often think that far from hard bitten realists of the woodworking trade, we are evolving along a series of myths, and products that have some strange reality through being suspended between ignorance, skill, modern tech, and so forth. A hybrid that invents fake problems (like the inability to sharpen), and generates reams of compensatory behaviour. It's its own little world. None the worse for that. As I mention from time to time. I have a cheeleading acquaintance who seems entirely unphased by the fact that she goes to competitions and has never cheered for a team.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#93

Re: Wow...

TomD

Well one data point would be all the junk to teach people to sharpen. Almost a dead certainty of a successful product is anything that even minimally offers to improve people's sharpening.

An even more telling data point is that the plane manufacturers now offer planes ready to cut out of the box. There are probably other reasons for that, like the fact modern machinery can make stuff to a higher standard at a low enough price. But it is the same across crafts. Knives come to mind. They used to come unsharpened, now they come razor sharp out of the box. The number of people who return products to the factory to be resharpened.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#94

Re: That's sad, an opportunity missed

david weaver

I'm sure bill's reference to the double iron is in respect to furniture. It's pretty useful there. Not if something is made of perfect white pine, but for most of the rest of the stuff.

I still believe that its takeover in the world of heavy plane use (that probably only existed until the mid to late 1800s) is based on economics more than anything else (you can work faster with it, and you can also work with less risk - less risk means faster in the end, too).

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#95

Re: I can't speak for Steve...

david weaver

That's sort of a strange ramble, but I guess it means you're not going to buy a holtey A13 in boxwood and give it to me, either?

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#96

question on double-iron

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

"On a technical note, I believe the mechanism by which tear-out is mitigated is the same for a close set cap iron as a close mouth. In each case a resistive force is being applied to the shaving which translates to a downward force on the wood at the tip of the blade which prevents lifting of the wood fibers ahead of the blade tip. Employing the cap iron is the more versatile solution when a plane is used for a variety of tasks, as is the case with my work."

________

Bill and all,

What Bill says above makes sense to me. Question: Do those of you using the double-iron for chipbreaking (as opposed to simply having it installed in the plane but not set close) feel the back pressure which would be caused by the double iron applying this 'downward force' on the shaving? It would seem that if there is no back pressure, then maybe 'downward force' to flex the shaving is not the mechanism. Or else, at the shaving thickness being used, the downward force is not felt. Anyway, interested in what folks are experiencing.

Wiley

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#97

Re: I'm back!

David weaver

Simple and works sounds good to me.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#98

Re: question on double-iron

steve voigt

Hi Wiley,

I'm not certain I know what you mean by "back pressure," but most definitely I can feel a proportional increase in resistance as the cap iron gets closer to the edge. I would compare it, not to closing down the mouth, but rather to raising the bed angle. I have to disagree with Bill here, although it is a bit nit-picking: moving the cap iron close and raising the bed angle are alike because they bend the chip immediately after the point of cut, while closing down the mouth holds the wood down before the point of the cut. I think this helps explain why a small mouth is generally not used (at least not effectively) as a primary strategy for tearout reduction, but rather as an adjunct to raising the bed angle.

Back to the question of pressure: tuning the cap iron well can definitely mitigate the amount of resistance we feel in the cut. When I first started using the close setting, I tended to have a somewhat blunt edge on the cap iron. With a close setting, the pressure was like pushing a 60 degree plane. When I began to sharpen the cap iron like I would sharpen a blade (only with a 50-ish microbevel), things got a lot easier, and I could get very close to the edge without the planing resistance becoming unbearable.

It also sometimes happened in the beginning that I would set the cap iron too close relative to the depth of cut, and the plane would be almost unmanageable; it would "bull you around" as David would say. But that doesn't happen any more, because as with all things, we get better with a bit of experience.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#99

Re: question on double-iron

david weaver

Steve summarized it well. Two things increase resistance from the cap iron, how close the iron is set for a given chip thickness, and the chip thickness (assuming that the cap iron is at least doing something).

If it's necessary to use the cap iron and it's set close enough to straighten a chip, there is definitely extra resistance. The fact that the plane stays in the cut in a heavy cut and without risk more than offsets the trouble.

Working a torn out surface where nothing really good comes out of the plane is an exercise in frustration.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#100

Re: question on double-iron

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

"On a technical note, I believe the mechanism by which tear-out is mitigated is the same for a close set cap iron as a close mouth. In each case a resistive force is being applied to the shaving which translates to a downward force on the wood at the tip of the blade which prevents lifting of the wood fibers ahead of the blade tip. Employing the cap iron is the more versatile solution when a plane is used for a variety of tasks, as is the case with my work."

________

Bill and all,

What Bill says above makes sense to me. Question: Do those of you using the double-iron for chipbreaking (as opposed to simply having it installed in the plane but not set close) feel the back pressure which would be caused by the double iron applying this 'downward force' on the shaving? It would seem that if there is no back pressure, then maybe 'downward force' to flex the shaving is not the mechanism. Or else, at the shaving thickness being used, the downward force is not felt. Anyway, interested in what folks are experiencing.

Wiley

Hi Wiley

I would not compare the action of a closely set double-iron to a closed mouth. A closed mouth has only a small impact on controlling tearout. For example, a closed mouth does not improve (or alter in any way) the tearout control of a half-pitch cutting angle.

Since the theory of a closed mouth is to exert downforce on the shaving, I believe that it fails in doing so.

There is only "back pressure" on a double-iron when the chipbreaker is set too close to the edge. The result is an accordion shaving. When the ideal distance is set, the shaving straightens (rather than curls). I cannot say that I have experienced any more resistance at this setting than when the chipbreaker is pulled further back (i.e. the cutting angle remains the same for both).

Resistance occurs when the cutting angle increases. In my experience, this is more apparent with BD planes, where the bed becomes steeper. This is far less with BU planes, where the bed remains the same and the bevel angle is increased. These planes have a different centre of effort (i.e. different force vectors).

I do believe that tearout is prevented by a downforce at the tip of the blade. What else can be occurring? However, it is unclear whether this is the same mechanism for the high cutting angle and the double-iron. It is evident that the results on the surface of the wood are different, since the double-iron is effective with a low cutting angle (my Veritas Custom #4 smoother has a 42 degree frog, while my Custom #7 jointer has a 40 degree frog .... the advantage of the #7 set up this way is that it is equally at home on interlocked face grain and sides, as well as on end grain and cross grain). By contrast, a BU with a high cutting angle will produce a lower level of shine on softer woods (it is not as apparent on hard woods).

Regards from Perth

Derek