New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

ordinary carbon steel

Posts

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#51

Re: skeptical

JDK

Like I said before, you don't know a damn thing about Lie Nielsen customers. Your supposed evidence ("I think I've bought 6 or 8 used Lie Nielsen planes") is absurd and laughable.

Generally you are insufferable and tiresome, and I ignore you. This time, however, I chose to say something about it. When you are talking about Lie Nielsen customers, you are talking out of the place the sun doesn't shine.

Stop embarrassing yourself.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#52

Re: skeptical

david weaver

Maybe this is a truth hurts sort of thing, but I'm sure you're reading a whole lot more into the comment than I intended.

If I were making planes, that's the market I'd serve, too. though I don't think I'd advise people to avoid dry grinders and use of the cap iron. And I probably wouldn't suggest to people at events that a #8 makes a good smoother because the weight makes it work well.

They do make a fine plane, but the bulk of their buys are not long term users, let alone professionals.

(Of course, I was a buyer of new planes, too (maybe another half dozen of them), though I stopped that when they demanded their retailers sell at list price - still do have a small scraper plane and a couple of spokeshaves).

I do get a chuckle that you think I'm that far off about the average buyer and user (or maybe just buyer, often the use part is never converted to any extent) of the planes. It's sort of naive otherwise, unless you think maybe I'm underestimating the percentage of buyers who buy a plane and just set it aside because they were impressed by a demonstration or recommendation that they buy a plane or six.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#53

Wow...

John in NM

You sure touched a nerve! :D

I agree with you on the two basic points - LN is providing what best sells, I do that too within my own much smaller market. No one is blaming them for that.

Second, that market is more of a collector market than a user market, in my honest opinion - I believe you would agree with that. I know this because it is not unusual to see empty LN boxes sold on ebay, and tools themselves sell for 95% of retail... that there is a collector driven market.

You originally posited that the general collector market was less adept at sharpening than the user market.... well, maybe. It makes us users happy to think so, but really JDK has you there, you and I don't know that.

Of course, I too have plenty of LN tools around, and will likely buy more of them one day. Its not because I find them so much better, just that I like them. Call it shallow and foolish, I will certainly agree. But we like what we like :D

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#54

Re: Wow...

david weaver

I'm trying to recall exactly the context of the conversation, because I don't think I'd say that half couldn't sharpen, but I would say half couldn't prepare an iron that wasn't in ideal shape (especially as it pertains to the back of an iron with some warpage, which is what the conversation is about). I do think that's probably true. Or more than half.

That was the topic that Leonard Lee (if I'm remembering correctly) was discussing, too, that people were talking about irons being out of flat and needing a certain amount of correction, quoting numbers that they probably couldn't measure (this or that number of thous). I don't think Leonard was too much dissing the users making those claims as much as he was saying that people want really flat irons so they were going to make really flat irons. (that predated the current familar super flat lapped irons that LV makes).

One thing that the collector market should be able to do well (and probably does) is sharpen things when they are in good shape to start (like the LV lapped irons), as there are a million paint by number sharpening schemes out there these days, and those methods work - whereas preparing a warped iron is a combination of elbow grease and subtlety.

I guess I was taken aback by how upset that made JDK because the emphasis I was making was that for LN, making near perfect tools is important - a very large part of their market can't correct them, and they will come back, or turn into negative word of mouth advertising.

They are successful, I think they and LV are doing exactly what the market wants. I've never talked directly to TLN or Deneb (I can't think it would be important for me to for any reason, either, I'm just another amateur like anyone else), but I think the world of Rob Lee whether or not I use my planes more than his. He is attentive to his market, never evasive (and neither is LN) and they follow the needs of their customers.

LN has done me right every time I've done business with them, too. Even at one point refusing to allow me to buy boxes for planes I bought used. They sent them and wouldn't accept anything in return. Its sort of a shame I couldn't turn those planes into what I want when I started hand dimensioning.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#55

Re: Wow...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

Not sure how this relates, but will share the thought anyway, since it's a little slow. There was a time years ago when I thought I was getting to know a lot, and got into the habit of forming narratives in my mind about this or that, and making assertions. And without fail, what I discovered was that the minute I would make reference to something absolutely--like such and such can't be done, or always requires thus and so, or this is the best way to do X....flat statements in other words....someone would come out and prove an exception, or else prove my point entirely without merit.

In recent years, I've decided that there is almost no proposition that can be stated without quite a bit of nuance and qualification. And further, that what is actually happening in other peoples' lives and shops is far more complex and interesting than any narrative or generalization I might come up with in a burst of enthusiasm. In other words, I've decided that I don't know hardly anything for certain and always.

But then on the other hand, if one tries to be really, really correct, one makes so many qualifications and nuances that what you say isn't worth anyone's time to read. So with that in mind, I try to take people's flat statements and allow a tolerance or license of, say, + or - 50% or somewhere in there. Cause they're really stating a feeling or a set of values they have, as opposed to certain knowledge.

I think JDK is correct on the merits. In fact, he obviously is. And I always like his posts. But then, I appreciate David's taking the pure risk of putting himself out there (as he often does) behind a sensibility that he has. It is his sensibility that is valuable, rather than the merits of whether some particular narrative (like the LN thing) is correct or not.

There are others on this forum who also put themselves out there, and occasionally taking a beating for it. I appreciate their fortitude.

Just my 2 cents. Also, LN has been over-the-top good with me, as David noted. And LV too, in spades.

Wiley

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#56

I'm back!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Been in Spain Basque Country for two weeks hiking. Returned to find Hand Tool Forum and presidential candidates fractious as usual.

Given the two weeks of farm work that has accumulated and the need to finish 3 small chests of drawers I don't have time to read all the posts that have occurred. I glanced at a couple that might have involved me.

Warren, for the first time I can recall, your recollection has been inaccurate. A blade steel that dulls by micro-chipping is to be avoided. I have only seen this dulling mechanism in one steel, a chisel I fashioned from a M2 steel jointer blade.

David, have you ever had a batch of steel heat treated by a company recognized to do good work? I have on three occasions. In each case I was quizzed as to the objective the heat treat and told for my application that the steel would be "straightened" as part of the process. Whatever was done, the plane blades and chisel blanks were received in a state that required no more flattening than Stanley blades I have flattened. And, the cost to heat treat was independent of the tool steel, at least in the universe of the tool steels used for woodworking tools.

I was unwilling to follow the LN discussion but in my case I have some of their tools. They are of the highest quality and I use them. I don't find it relevant what others do with them for it does not affect the utility of the tools I buy from them.

Oh, and by the way, the wooden Spanish planes I saw at the gigantic flea market in Madrid were fashioned from some kind of white oak. Apparently beech is not essential.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#57

Re: I'm back!

david weaver

White oak is fine, not as good for the maker, but continental europe has so much beech that they make a lot of their better planes from pear or something similar. Not that it's any better than beech, but less common and maybe prettier and more uniform.

When I say fine, I mean not quite as good as beech, but you can make a decent plane with it, it's about the right density and there are a lot of user made tools out there (that are old, not recent) that are white oak. I had a long jointer that was white oak at one point.

A lot of users don't find stanley blades flat enough for their taste, thus the huge popularity of the LV's lapped irons. When LV started flattening irons with their lapping machiines, LN started having employees hand lap the backs if their A2 irons before calling the plane finished. The effect isn't as good, but it's easier to implement.

I find *no* quality issues at all with either plane, whatever the method. They are closer to prepared for use than anything, with the possible exception of planes I have shipped to people. The market would find my planes to be "used", I think. (there's an inside joke there, it's hard to confirm that a tightly made wooden plane is in good working order without setting it up completely and using it. The planes that aren't used usually have a very short and steep wear so that things that you have to tune are removed from the equation entirely).

I get what you're saying about steel, too, but a look at Beach's page and the edge of a D2 iron (that's not failing) vs. one from eskilstuna will tell you what warren is talking about. If you finish sand your work, it doesn't matter. If you don't, it does.

Shame that arguments on here are the only things that really get much discussion going!!

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#58

Re: Wow...

david weaver

I'll be the first to admit I don't know definites about much. We all often are speculating about what we think is probable, but maybe most of the citizenry doesn't think in scales of what's probable or likely and how probable or likely. (that's another thing I like to speculate about - especially with people when they think things are certain that are very unlikely).

So what I'm saying in terms of what I've seen in my anecdotal sampling is definite, but what I'm saying about the average LN buyer (and I think it's perfectly fair from their viewpoint) not being capable of preparing a tool that is maybe in the same shape as a vintage NOS sheffield iron is what I think is probable. As you put it, using my sensibility and sticking myself out there a little.

There isn't much I know anything about in woodworking other than sharpening stones and how to make a few planes.

You are also right about really defining what you're thinking to caveat everything or qualify everything, it becomes like regulation writing and then it's not worth the trouble. In this case, I intended to convey that I don't think half or more of LN customers could convert an iron to properly flattened (there's no reason to think they should even have the equipment to do it), which means that definitely some can - and some of the highest quality work I've seen on youtube was done with those planes (doucette and wolfe videos are pretty convincing).

It's probable that what I said was interpreted as "Lie Nielsen users are inept and can't do anything unless someone handles a working tool", which isn't what I intended by that statement. That vs. half or more can't prepare irons that are not in pretty good shape, which means:

* some are beginners

* some are people who have *no* interest in spending an hour correcting an iron (more than that if one's equipment is just a set of waterstones and a guide)

* some people might have interest, but don't have the equipment, and don't want to buy it

You're right, though, by stating what I think is probable and not providing a scale of how probable I think it is than I'm correct, it's seen as a definite and then interpreted in whatever context anyone wants to interpret it.

One last story, my introduction to Lie Nielsen planes. I have a friend who has been woodworking for a very long time now, mostly power tools. Giant hands man who I made a try plane for. He was a fine woodworking subscriber, and like 90% of the market, not into forums. 10 years ago or slightly longer, he told me that Lie Nielsen planes were the only ones to buy. Then he described them as difficult to use and said he has left them in his cabinet because of it. But, he bought 4 of them to be sure, and same conclusion with all. The width of his knuckles is 4.75", biggest i've seen making planes, but someone convinced him that a #2 is a handy plane to have, so he bought one of those back when LN used the old style cap irons and water hardened steel irons. I'm sure it is a fine plane. But it's 2/3rds the size that he needs for his hands and he can't use it. He has (probably still does) a LN #9, a 5 1/2 with a york pitch frog (back from when that was the only high angle available), the 2 and a 60 1/2.

At any rate, he gave me the charlesworth video, I watched it, I bought a Lie Nielsen 6 (of all of the planes I had from them, I wish I'd have kept that one just because it was the first one I bought) with cocobolo handles, sharpened it per david's instructions (and prepared the back of the iron just like he said, of course) and was off to the races.

I took it back to my friend (being a rank beginner) and he tried it and became irate that he wasn't given more guidance on sharpening with his tools, and we sharpened them and they're all in good use now. He never asked Lie Nielsen about them, etc.

As forum users, we don't know too much about the other 90%. Tom Lie Nielsen and Rob do, which - like above - is what makes it probable that the improvements they've made in readiness and precision have a lot to do with serving the entire market. That market being a market that includes users who are either beginners or who have no interest in using a plane that's mostly prepared that they can just sharpen to remove plane chatter.

I do like to speculate, though!! And i'm not afraid to be on the wrong side of the supposition.

Speculating on what's probable is what drove me to make double iron planes ("it's probable that they were more economical to use because they can complete a given task faster, it's probable that users knew that because they were willing to pay a lot more for them, it's probable that they're not as hard to use as they first seem, it's probable ....")

Todd Hughes used to speculate on what was probable, too...drove me nuts when it disagreed with what I thought I knew!

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#59

Re: I'm back!

david weaver

By the way, on the issue of flatness, I'm going to have to rely on conversations from George, a professional toolmaker, who suggested A2 is a lot easier to handle.

I have no clue what is possible with consistency without regrinding irons after heat treatment (except another supposition, it must be necessary because the makers still true up their irons after heat treatment - even A2).

I remember getting some irons from Hock, who often had some mill marks near the edge 10 years ago, and thinking they were totally unacceptable. These days, I'd consider them a 10 minute job, but I have more stuff on hand and more experience as I've probably flattened 250 irons and chisels, some of them horribly bad. I couldn't have flattened the majority of them back in the days when I had a king 800, 1200 and 6000 stone, and I remember dubbing a few of them with sandpaper when I first tried that, too.

The boutique makers can't afford to take that chance now. I don't know what they know or don't know about heat treating and plane irons in the context of it, and finishing them after heat treating, etc, but I'd have to guess it's in their favor (economically overall) to use A2 regardless of what we speculate. Especially compared to water hardening steel, which only the japanese use, and only when it's laminated.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#60

My memory, Bill *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My memory is that you have insisted that chisels, unlike plane irons, fail by chipping and bending. My chisels have never done this. I once made 500 half inch deep cross grain chopping cuts and and had no failure of this type.

Here is some bit of history:


chipping and folding

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#62

The Madrid flea market

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



Shown is one of the streets selling new stuff and crafts. I took the picture midway down the street! The number of customers numbered in the thousands and the number of sellers in the hundreds. There were side streets with antiques and used stuff and streets of antique shops that had "spilled" some of their contents onto the sidewalk. We had no hope of covering all of it so we focused on the used stuff and the antique shop area. Haggling was expected, though I was unable to get the seller of a fine drawing compass to budge and I walked away. Few wood working tools to be found and nothing I could use. However, I scored a nice piece of thick, stiff leather to make some new strops and some salvaged tiles to turn into trivets.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#63

Re: I'm back!

Bill White

I guess that I'm just too unsophisticated or lazy (distinct possibility), but my old tried and true Stanley irons cut well, true up very well, shave hairs, etc.

I'm no metalurgist, nor do I want to become one.

I also adhere to Mr. Weaver's and Mr. Seller's philosophy of "simple works". My words-not theirs.

Bill

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#64

Re: Wow...

steve voigt

Great post, Wiley. I completely agree with all of the above.

I'll just briefly recount an experience that encapsulates my feelings on this subject. When I first started doing LN events, I worked up this little demonstration. I would have the cap iron set about 1/32" or a little more from the edge, and I'd plane a board specifically selected to produce some nasty tearout. Not a nightmare board, but definitely on the tricky side (I still have the board). Then I'd pop the double iron out and tap the cap iron down closer with my plane mallet, without removing the cap iron or resharpening the cutting iron. Then take some strokes and watch the tearout disappear. I practiced this routine until I could do it pretty fluidly.

The upshot is, I've never once actually done this at an event, and I doubt I ever will. It would be like giving a lecture on differential equations to a basic algebra (or maybe just arithmetic) class. People are not asking about double versus single irons, or bed angles, or the subtleties of camber; they are asking about how to push a plane, how to sharpen it, can it be adjusted. I would guess that more than half of the people who try my planes will take a stroke on a wide board, then repeatedly take strokes in the exact same spot, without moving the plane over. I could go on, but you get the point.

Please don't think I'm mocking these folks; I'm not, we all had to start somewhere. In general, they are very friendly, appreciative, and receptive to suggestions, and I really enjoy those events. But my experiences suggest that David is pretty accurate in his assumptions. Forums like this one are self-selected groups of mostly experienced users; even the folks here or at SMC who think they are newbies are usually more experienced than a lot of new plane buyers.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#65

Re: I'm back!

Hank Knight

Bill,

We have friends in Vitoria and we have visited there on several occasions. My daughter spent several summers there as a teenager. Did you go there? I think the Basque Country and the Rioja are wonderful. We have enjoyed it very much and the wine there is top drawer.

Welcome back.

Hank

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#66

Re: I'm back!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Not to sound like a curmudgeon, but we don't like wine and hence we did not go to wine country nor Victoria. For the most part we hiked near the spectacular coast with only one day inland. I wish we had spent more time in the mountains as we are more mountain people than sea. To my surprise while the mountains where we were at were only 1500m they rose from near seal level. The elevation gain was similar to some ranges in Colorado and indeed the scenery looked similar. Basque Country is the best kept travel secret in Europe. We saw virtually no foreign tourists.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#67

Re: Wow...

JDK

So Steve, you're saying that more than half your customers can't prepare a hand plane blade? That they buy your products for purely vanity purposes, and that they sit on shelves doing nothing?

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#68

My first planes...

Brian Holcombe

....were all LN.

When I was new to hand tool woodworking I was making larger LN orders every few months acquiring tools. Previously I had worked much more with machines.

David's point is accurate in my singular experience, my early purchases were based on the brand being trusted along with internet consensus. Most of those purchases I hung onto for quite a while but ultimately ended up selling the majority of it. I still have all of the planes but sold all of the saws and chisels as I acquired tools more suited to my personality and wants.

Sometimes things that you think are great when you are coming from another perspective are no longer great once you have developed specific preferences. Wear resistant alloys, tall back saws, extra heavy iron planes, etc had appeal to me as a transitioning woodworker, those things have lost all appeal to me currently as contending with those features on a daily basis is somewhat annoying. I prefer easy to sharpen along with light and nimble.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#69

You can buy a good plane...

Brian Holcombe

...And learn the qualities of it as your skills improve.

Do you really need a PC answer and commentary from everyone? I find these discussions to be thoughtful and I'm finding it difficult to find anything offensive outside of the your suggestions on what's being said.

Do you really think anyone is looking to insult their own user base, or the user base of very highly considered companies?

Do you really think that everyone, or even most people who purchase a product are fully aware of that product?

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#70

Re: I'm back!

Brian Holcombe

Sounds like a fantastic trip Bill!

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#71

That's sad, an opportunity missed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The upshot is, I've never once actually done this at an event, and I doubt I ever will. It would be like giving a lecture on differential equations to a basic algebra (or maybe just arithmetic) class." I could not disagree more with this premise. Why would you not teach this easy to implement solution to tear-out?

For most of my woodworking experience I avoided using a hand plane for fear of unanticipated tear-out. I thought the only solution was to buy a plane that cost more than my table saw. The Keys demonstration video opened my eyes to the possibility of employing a hand plane in my work. I, in turn, demonstrated the effectiveness of a close-set cap iron to my club where it was enthusiastically received and adapted. It is a simple solution to a problem every new plane owner encounters.

Next to sharpening I would argue that learning to set the cap iron to mitigate tear-out is the most important knowledge to acquire when buying a hand plane. Way LN persists in avoiding teaching this skill remains a mystery to me.

On a technical note, I believe the mechanism by which tear-out is mitigated is the same for a close set cap iron as a close mouth. In each case a resistive force is being applied to the shaving which translates to a downward force on the wood at the tip of the blade which prevents lifting of the wood fibers ahead of the blade tip. Employing the cap iron is the more versatile solution when a plane is used for a variety of tasks, as is the case with my work.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#72

Re: You can buy a good plane...

JDK

What I think is that Weaver has no idea how many of LN customers cannot flatten and hone a hand plane blade, and that his statements that more than half of them cannot are patently ridiculous, even absurd.

I suppose there is some percentage of LN customers who spend hundreds of dollars on a single hand plane for purely vanity purposes, but I have no idea what percentage of their customers do so, and neither does anyone else.

If you and others here find Weaver's fever dreams about LN and its customers appealing, it's no skin off my nose. Enjoy. But please don't defend them as being anything other than what they are. Pure nonsense.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#73

Excellent point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Been there and done that along my path. I'm headed a different direction than yours but the journey is similar.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#74

Re: I'm back!

Hank Knight

We once drove on a very narrow road that followed the crest of a ridge for about 20 km west of San Sebastian to a small village the name of which I don't recall. The north side of the ridge dropped straight down to the Bay of Biscay. The south side was a steep grassy slope where sheep and goats grazed. I have no idea how high we were, but the fishing boats on the Bay looked like toys. It was spectacular and frightening at the same time. The reward was at the end: a quaint restaurand that served fresh caught fish cooked on site over a long wood-fired grill and served family style with fresh local vegetables and local wine. Best fish I've ever had!

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#75

My motivation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I bought a LN plane because I believed it would work right out of the box. I believed that if it didn't then my skills were the limitation and one variable would have been eliminated, the tool.

That said, I seldom used it until Keys showed the way with the cap iron demonstration video. Since then I have become enamored with an old Bedrock #5. For some reason it has become the plane I reach for when a bit of wood needs to be removed here or there. It sits on the bench while I am building and the LN is seldom used.

note:I largely fit stuff with a hand plane and rarely surface plane show surfaces. Surface planers' results may differ.