Re: Wow...
david weaver
I'll be the first to admit I don't know definites about much. We all often are speculating about what we think is probable, but maybe most of the citizenry doesn't think in scales of what's probable or likely and how probable or likely. (that's another thing I like to speculate about - especially with people when they think things are certain that are very unlikely).
So what I'm saying in terms of what I've seen in my anecdotal sampling is definite, but what I'm saying about the average LN buyer (and I think it's perfectly fair from their viewpoint) not being capable of preparing a tool that is maybe in the same shape as a vintage NOS sheffield iron is what I think is probable. As you put it, using my sensibility and sticking myself out there a little.
There isn't much I know anything about in woodworking other than sharpening stones and how to make a few planes.
You are also right about really defining what you're thinking to caveat everything or qualify everything, it becomes like regulation writing and then it's not worth the trouble. In this case, I intended to convey that I don't think half or more of LN customers could convert an iron to properly flattened (there's no reason to think they should even have the equipment to do it), which means that definitely some can - and some of the highest quality work I've seen on youtube was done with those planes (doucette and wolfe videos are pretty convincing).
It's probable that what I said was interpreted as "Lie Nielsen users are inept and can't do anything unless someone handles a working tool", which isn't what I intended by that statement. That vs. half or more can't prepare irons that are not in pretty good shape, which means:
* some are beginners
* some are people who have *no* interest in spending an hour correcting an iron (more than that if one's equipment is just a set of waterstones and a guide)
* some people might have interest, but don't have the equipment, and don't want to buy it
You're right, though, by stating what I think is probable and not providing a scale of how probable I think it is than I'm correct, it's seen as a definite and then interpreted in whatever context anyone wants to interpret it.
One last story, my introduction to Lie Nielsen planes. I have a friend who has been woodworking for a very long time now, mostly power tools. Giant hands man who I made a try plane for. He was a fine woodworking subscriber, and like 90% of the market, not into forums. 10 years ago or slightly longer, he told me that Lie Nielsen planes were the only ones to buy. Then he described them as difficult to use and said he has left them in his cabinet because of it. But, he bought 4 of them to be sure, and same conclusion with all. The width of his knuckles is 4.75", biggest i've seen making planes, but someone convinced him that a #2 is a handy plane to have, so he bought one of those back when LN used the old style cap irons and water hardened steel irons. I'm sure it is a fine plane. But it's 2/3rds the size that he needs for his hands and he can't use it. He has (probably still does) a LN #9, a 5 1/2 with a york pitch frog (back from when that was the only high angle available), the 2 and a 60 1/2.
At any rate, he gave me the charlesworth video, I watched it, I bought a Lie Nielsen 6 (of all of the planes I had from them, I wish I'd have kept that one just because it was the first one I bought) with cocobolo handles, sharpened it per david's instructions (and prepared the back of the iron just like he said, of course) and was off to the races.
I took it back to my friend (being a rank beginner) and he tried it and became irate that he wasn't given more guidance on sharpening with his tools, and we sharpened them and they're all in good use now. He never asked Lie Nielsen about them, etc.
As forum users, we don't know too much about the other 90%. Tom Lie Nielsen and Rob do, which - like above - is what makes it probable that the improvements they've made in readiness and precision have a lot to do with serving the entire market. That market being a market that includes users who are either beginners or who have no interest in using a plane that's mostly prepared that they can just sharpen to remove plane chatter.
I do like to speculate, though!! And i'm not afraid to be on the wrong side of the supposition.
Speculating on what's probable is what drove me to make double iron planes ("it's probable that they were more economical to use because they can complete a given task faster, it's probable that users knew that because they were willing to pay a lot more for them, it's probable that they're not as hard to use as they first seem, it's probable ....")
Todd Hughes used to speculate on what was probable, too...drove me nuts when it disagreed with what I thought I knew!