Re: David's Try plane - the hatred of sharpening
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
When one hears people talk about edge longevity it sounds like they are tied to the bench, thank goodness they have the means to do an extra 10% of work. With a few notable exceptions, I don't think people like that have the time to post here.
Tom, an illustration - this is my situation, which I try to emphasise. I do not expect that one size fits all ...
As I have mentioned on many occasions, the woods we have in Western Australia contain a high level of silica, as well as being hard and interlocked. Maintaining a sharp edge has been important to deal with the reversing grain, especially when using high angle planes. I am not sure if this is still the case with a double bevel, which is now my preference, but my mind set is still with "sharper is better".
Let's take a common angle LN #3 smoother I enjoy using. I have three blades for it. The first is the A2 that came with it. I get a good sharp edge that is held for a decent time, and overall the plane works well. Then I am curious about hammered O1 steel, and so I obtain an older Clifton (not the current version) blade for it. It hones really easily, and it takes sweet shavings ... however, it is dull within a couple of dozen strokes (where the A2 went twice as long). Eventually I started using a PM-V11 blade (a multi-national effort!
), and this lasts fifty percent again as long as the A2.
The above points may be even more of an issue when it comes to the lower bed (40 - 42 degrees) BD Custom Veritas planes I use. A sharp blade and chipbreaker are the defence against tearout in interlocked grain.
Now the point made is hopefully obvious: no one is talking about steel that lasts forever (well, I am not). I also do not see the more abrasion-resistant steels as a way to avoid sharpening ... it is not sharpening that is where the effort lies; it is partly this and the associated hassle to reset a chipbreaker more frequently. More importantly, I know that the plane's performance will be optimal for longer with a better blade, and this is important when working woods that demand the sharpest edge.
Regards from Perth
Derek

), Iwasaki advocates chrome ox IV pigment, which is what's sold over here.


