New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

ordinary carbon steel

Posts

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#26

Re: David's Try plane - the hatred of sharpening

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

When one hears people talk about edge longevity it sounds like they are tied to the bench, thank goodness they have the means to do an extra 10% of work. With a few notable exceptions, I don't think people like that have the time to post here.

Tom, an illustration - this is my situation, which I try to emphasise. I do not expect that one size fits all ...

As I have mentioned on many occasions, the woods we have in Western Australia contain a high level of silica, as well as being hard and interlocked. Maintaining a sharp edge has been important to deal with the reversing grain, especially when using high angle planes. I am not sure if this is still the case with a double bevel, which is now my preference, but my mind set is still with "sharper is better".

Let's take a common angle LN #3 smoother I enjoy using. I have three blades for it. The first is the A2 that came with it. I get a good sharp edge that is held for a decent time, and overall the plane works well. Then I am curious about hammered O1 steel, and so I obtain an older Clifton (not the current version) blade for it. It hones really easily, and it takes sweet shavings ... however, it is dull within a couple of dozen strokes (where the A2 went twice as long). Eventually I started using a PM-V11 blade (a multi-national effort! :) ), and this lasts fifty percent again as long as the A2.

The above points may be even more of an issue when it comes to the lower bed (40 - 42 degrees) BD Custom Veritas planes I use. A sharp blade and chipbreaker are the defence against tearout in interlocked grain.

Now the point made is hopefully obvious: no one is talking about steel that lasts forever (well, I am not). I also do not see the more abrasion-resistant steels as a way to avoid sharpening ... it is not sharpening that is where the effort lies; it is partly this and the associated hassle to reset a chipbreaker more frequently. More importantly, I know that the plane's performance will be optimal for longer with a better blade, and this is important when working woods that demand the sharpest edge.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#27

Re: David's Try plane - the hatred of sharpening

david weaver

I'd like to be able to say I use all cast steel, but probably at least half of the irons I find (I try to get unused or nearly unused irons with good clean cap irons) are oil hardening steel, and one piece. Maybe slightly less than half.

If I recall, the iron I put in Brian's plane is solid steel, so it is probably oil hardening steel. No matter, though, the two are almost the same in use if they are at the same hardness level.

A catalog reading beginner might figure out that iron is softer and immediately assume it's some problem, but I figured even if Brian thought it was soft when he got it, it would grow on him - especially since he's grinding by hand.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#28

Re: Wrong on both counts

david weaver

For those of us with backward western understanding of measurements, that would appear to be between 1 and 1 1/2 ten thousandths. I know I've never approached that.

I think they have a planing contest for the longest shaving lengths taken, too, or maybe that's somewhere else. I remember reading about togo reigo taking a thousand feet of thin shavings or something, but being bettered by powder high speed steel (no surprise). I don't know how thin the shavings were for that, though, which has a lot to do with how long you can plane.

When I tested some A2 irons long ago when I was into that, I got about 1600 feet or so of 2 thousandth thick hard maple shavings out of a lie nielsen iron. The finish was terrible by the time I was done with that, and I had to lean on the plane long before that to keep it in the cut, but it was still cutting. 90% of the time that I thought the iron was getting too dull to cut, it was just that the sole of the plane needed wax and the friction was making me tired.

I wouldn't do a test like that again, but if I did, the shaving thickness aimed for would be thinner than 2 thousandths, because an iron can be very dull and still take a fairly thick smoother shaving like that.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#29

skeptical

bill tindall

I have not done the test, but i'll bet if you ask a quality heat treat company whether they will have a problem heat treating this vs that tool steel they will laugh. I know that when we used BOS they could not care less what it was. Price was the same. Hence, I doubt there is any cost advantage of heat treating A2. I believe A2 was promoted because it is more abrasion resistant because of the high Cr content. That is the obvious advantage for some in marketing and using..

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#30

That isn't what I hear from other fields...

John in NM

My machinist at the day job says that air hardening tool steels are vastly easier to heat treat - if I remember correctly, it is not the process so much as the minimal deformation resulting from treatment.

I suspect that heat treat shops don't see that because they deliver you a hardened and perhaps drawn piece and coping with any deformation is your headache.

One may not worry much about it with a chisel or two for one's own use, but a vendor like LN, supplying expensive, pretty tools to rather picky clients, probably has to grind those plane blades after treatment. With A2 they might be able to skip that step - this is, I think, what David is referring to.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#31

Re: skeptical

david weaver

Why would BOS care what the warpage is on a finished part? They're not the ones who would have to correct it.

Half of Lie Nielsen's customers (or more) have no clue how to prepare anything, so it falls back on lie nielsen to do post heat-treatment correction.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#32

Re: That isn't what I hear from other fields...

david weaver

That's it exactly, John. And it's what George relayed to me, and probably relayed to them, about warpage (which they had trouble with with W1....and so would anyone else, W1 is not well behaved in thin pieces).

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#33

I have to wonder...

John in NM

Has anyone done a composition analysis of vintage tool steels that are so revered in some quarters.

I would speculate that they are mostly carbon and iron, and that their desirable qualities (including being able to be abraded by quartz stones) comes almost entirely from being fine grained rather than alloying agents used in modern steels. This would account for the similarity seen with powder steels - excepting that of being abraded by quartz stones of course.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#34

Re: Wrong on both counts

Brian Holcombe

IIRC So mentioned a Usui Kengo custom steel (based on blue steel) that was able to take 3600 ft of shavings before becoming to dull to cut (and was probably hell to sharpen afterward). Just crazy, IMO.

I've been curious to find out what the alloy of togo reigou is, I saw some people pointing to some of its contents on another forum, but nothing especially specific. I also wonder what its like to sharpen (not that I plan to buy a 2k plane anytime soon, hah).

Those guys apparently hunt down the wood for the competition as well, some of it looks like alaskan yellow cedar, it must be something that looks like plastic to be able to work that thin.

All told its incredible, and done with most of them using natural stones and whatever steel that can be worked on natural stones. Presumably a very very fine high carbon steel.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#35

Re: I have to wonder...

david weaver

I have seen various speculations that they're pretty plain and around 1% carbon or a little less. It's uncommon to find one that's low 60s hardness and that doesn't work well on an oilstone, but you can find something like that sometimes. I had a very hard ward iron that was hard to sharpen on anything - the previous owner must've found the same to be true, because it was in a fantastic plane that didn't see much use. Some other ward stuff that I have is a click harder than most vintage, but not so hard that it doesn't sharpen well on oilstones.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#36

Re: Wrong on both counts

david weaver

http://www.toolsfromjapan.com/store/index.php?main_page=page&id=10&chapter=5

The alloy is almost the same as super blue. I didn't find that much to like about super blue steel, though. Very very high carbon, but had more small edge failures than regular carbon steel, so it didn't make a very good smoother iron. With a little bit more blade angle, it probably would've worked fine, but I couldn't see the point.

I would guess that rarity helps its reputation. (a couple of times a year, a plane made of it shows up on ebay. It looks like a tsunesaburo top-make plane went unsold at $895 two months ago, which would scare me as a buyer - there's really no secondary market for that stuff so you're stuck with it if you don't like it, and if it's really high hardness, it won't like the same regimen that you're accustomed to semi-finishing and finishing with natural stones).

Super blue worked fine on synthetic stones, but not natural stones, even though the composition of it really isn't that complicated. If reigo worked easily on natural stones, then it would probably be because it was a couple of clicks off of claimed hardness (which is probably better for the user, anyway).

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#37

Re: Wrong on both counts

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! All of my searching and it was on Stu's site within arms reach this whole time, hah.

I find it odd that I always see it compared to tamahagane, which I would expect to be fairly easy to sharpen being carbon and iron, and yet these are fairly complex steels which I would expect to be a bear to sharpen. Total opposites I would imagine.

I have one thing made from super blue, that is a matsui gauge, and that gauge is tough to sharpen....pretty much have to use synthetics as you mention as well. I have a plane blade in blue 1 and its nothing like it, its tougher to sharpen than white steel, but overall fairly easy.

I've seen a few planes I would have thought would sell fast linger on eBay for a while and they were listed at relatively low prices (like 900 when elsewhere it is 1800).

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#38

Re: Wrong on both counts

david weaver

Just thinking out loud, but I wonder if the idea of old tamahagane comes from samples driven to maximum hardness. Iwasaki said his tamahagane razors were 68 hardness or thereabouts. You can't test a razor, so I'm not sure where he got that guess - he mentioned he was estimating.

If they were actually 68 hardness, they wouldn't sharpen very well on most natural stones.

I'm confused as to why the andrews is described as similar to tamahagane, too.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#39

Re: Wrong on both counts

Brian Holcombe

68 hardness, he must temper it in his afternoon tea.....after letting it cool down. :D

He definitely used natural stones, so probably a good chance it isn't really 68 but probably still very hard.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#40

Re: Wrong on both counts

david weaver

Yeah, probably not 68- but it makes for good marketing. I saw someone trying to sell one of the western style iwasaki razors unused (tamahagane) for $1800 recently.

I can't remember if he or his dad wrote a long treatise on sharpening, but whichever one of them that did it went through a progression of stones, through something like maruka nakayama.....and then...

....advocating using 1 micron diamonds on a soft strop. I guess they wouldn't do much harm if the strop was very soft, but 1 micron diamonds provide a harsh toothy shave when used on honing film.

I can't remember if the context was kamisori or western straight. I never did like overhard razors, though. Medium hard is fine. Overhard razors don't respond to the strop quite right and they're chippy when sharpening if they don't like the media.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#41

OOps...

david weaver

http://strazors.com/uploads/images/articles/Honing_Razors_and_Nihonkamisori.pdf

That's the article (not that it's worth anyones' time on here who doesn't shave).

This is a more modern translation that Jim Rion did (I think he's the one who said to someone on the razor boards that kamisori are something you can't find in retail stores in Japan because they're "sold mostly to foreigners" :b ), Iwasaki advocates chrome ox IV pigment, which is what's sold over here.

In the old days, the edge left from the natural stone was removed with linen, but real linens that are treated for razor use are difficult to find these days.

Green chrome makes a lot more sense than 1 micron diamond.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#42

Re: OOps...

Brian Holcombe

Hah, thats funny but I'm not surprised that mostly westerners buy them. The Iwasaki ones especially.

The replacement for those old strops must be those Kanoyama strops? I see them listed with grits and have always wondered what they're impregnated with.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#43

Re: OOps...

david weaver

Kanayama's numbering system is strange, none of their strops are impregnated with anything, but they have them numbered, and you can pretty much figure the higher the number, the higher the price.

At one point, I had a Kanayama 80,000, but I had a good broken in horse butt strop that makes a finer edge, and the kanayama cordovan is thick and soft (where as shell from horween that you'd see in shoes is thin, slick and hard).

Naomi-san has trouble finding good linen, so the linen that is on kanayama strops is stiff and harsh. Jim Rion (or someone else) put up a routine to soften the linens with fabric softener, but it's still better to buy a vintage unused linen that's marked "silk finish". Nothing else is like them.

At any rate (you can guess where I got the kanayama strop - aoki), I sold the kanayama strop before putting a nick in it because I was afraid that it may never get better than the butt strip strop that I made (it probably wouldn't), and the vintage linen I have on the back of an old horsehide illinois strop that says "beau brimmel silk finish".

The combination of the linen and horse butt leather can easily put a year of shaves in, still easily pass the hanging hair test and who knows how long it would actually go if you pushed it. 500 shaves?100? At the rate that it would wear a razor to use it and a hone once a year or so, you could shave for a couple of centuries with one razor and never hate the shave.

After trying everything, admittedly the nicest razor I ever had was a tanifuji (who did the finish work on iwasaki's razors), but the german razors from known smiths in the early to mid 1900s are every bit as good for practical purposes. and horse butt is as good as cordovan once you get it broken in (which means a good smooth non-wrinkled piece of horse butt two feet long is a good option for a user-made strop, but not so good for making and selling where a maker can't afford to have to use a strop before selling it - it would look used).

(long way of saying I think the kanayama strops are pretty, but high priced for what you get. After buying a #2 shell from horween and making a horween strop, I don't like those too much either - they are factory treated and super slick, but the finish is not very durable and they aren't the same when even just a little of the finish starts to come off....not sure how I got sidetracked into all of these things).

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#44

Re: OOps...

Brian Holcombe

Interesting, maybe it has something to do with the fineness of the cordovan? In either case it's good that it's outdone by the horsebutt strop and Beau Brummel linen. I find it funny that they decided to mark it 'Beau Brummel', a person famous for being a dandy who went broke commissioning tailors. I guess, being a dandy, he knew a good shave.

I have the cheapest Kanoyama (with an 'o' on this one, unlike the free hanging strops for some reason) paddle strop. But being that I use it for tools and have no frame of reference I really don't know how or what it would do for razors.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#45

Re: I have to wonder...

Steve Voigt

Has anyone done a composition analysis of vintage tool steels that are so revered in some quarters.

John, I have seen various analyses, though I can't point you directly to any links. Mostly they suggest that these steels are eutectic steels, around .7-.8% carbon, and as you suggest very few or no additives like vandium, chromium, manganese, etc. So, very similar to something like 1075, a simple water-hardening steel with .75% carbon. As such, it should get as hard as something like O1 or 1095 (or white steel, for that matter), and take a very fine edge, but probably will not have the toughness of O1 or 1095.

Anecdotally, I've heard from people I respect that the 1084 sold by Aldo (the NJ steel baron) feels very close to vintage cast steel. This would seem to fit with the hypothesis above.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#46

Re: I have to wonder...

david weaver

I think David Barnett used to say the same thing, that 1084, in his opinion, was very close to a lot of vintage steels.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#47

Re: skeptical

JDK

"Half of Lie Nielsen's customers (or more) have no clue how to prepare anything"

You have no idea how many of Lie Nielsen's customers know about anything.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#48

Re: skeptical

david weaver

You're right, it's probably greater than that. I have bought some used lie nielsen tools (now sold), and while it's not a scientific sample, none of them were quite right when I got them. Some were mostly unprepared, and others had things done to them that didn't make sense.

It's not Lie Nielsen's fault, that's the market buying tools. It's not like all stanley planes have been prepared and preserved correctly, either.

I still have some LN tools.

But the point is important. Whether half of their users couldn't properly prepare an iron that needed a fair amount of work, or 75% couldn't, or even if it's 15% - those 15% would either go without proper use or introduce a flood of mailing returns back and forth and tying up customer service.

It's a lot easier to just to spend a few extra bucks (which probably ends up a savings) and try to have everything perfect to start.

Reminds me of something Leonard Lee said about customers calling and telling them that this or that was out a thou or two thou, and how flat an iron actually needs to be (less flat than they were making them at the time). Paraphrasing what I recall, he more or less said most of the people calling or writing with those complaints don't know what they actually need, but they'll make the tools precisely because it's easier to avoid the question. (Rob Lee, forgive me if I butchered what I remember of that, but I do recall the gist was that if the buying population wants something that doesn't make sense to an experienced maker, just give it to them, anyway).

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#49

Re: skeptical

JDK

You have absolutely no idea of what you're talking about. You know nothing about Lie Nielsen customers. The fact that you make such absurd and ridiculous statements says a lot more about you than it says about Lie Nielsen customers.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#50

Re: skeptical

david weaver

I can never remember who the people are who take exception with my statements, but I do have a pretty good idea of the average customer of the boutique makers. Or at least the people in various categories (some users are professionals, most are not, and it's likely a large part of the "not" are people who thought it was a good idea to buy some planes, but they'll never really understand much about using them.

Maybe you've taken exception to my statements before, because you seem unnecessarily angry about a supposition that I made.

And I can say that of all of the planes I've gotten, none were in danger of being worn out (most were not in danger of actually being used - just in danger of being massaged/prepared per things people have read online - something those planes don't need when they're new or little used - or in danger of rust from neglect).

I've never bought a used Lee Valley plane, but I think I've bought 6 or 8 used Lie Nielsen planes. A couple were unused and the rest still had their primary bevels. None had the back of the iron prepared properly and completely, and that's even with flat A2 irons. I can't imagine what would happen if an iron with some warp was sent out with those planes.

(I'm certainly open to being proven wrong - even knowing the silly advice that is given out at Lie Nielsen demonstrations - silly at least in the context of using the planes in the context of woodworking).