New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

ordinary carbon steel

Posts

ordinary carbon steel

#1

ordinary carbon steel

eliot feldman

I read somewhere that this material will take a sharper edge than HSS --even if it won't stay sharp for as long. Is this true? Oh, and that both carbon steel and HSS will take a sharper edge than carbide steel. Still true?

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#2

Re: ordinary? carbide?

William Duffield

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cementite

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbide

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_steel

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_steel

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stainless_steel

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tungsten_carbide

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#3

Re: ordinary? carbide?

eliot feldman

I suppose these links are meant to let me know that the issue is complicated. And , indeed, I didn't find the answer in any of them. I did much better by just googling, "Which is sharper carbon or HSS? From those answers, it becomes apparent that HSS is much sharper than carbide. Not so clear about carbon steel vs HSS.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#4

Re: ordinary? carbide?

Roy Girolami

Eliot, I was told once that HSS takes a mediocre edge and holds it forever. I don't think knife makers use it that often.

Roy

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#5

Wrong on both counts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Or resident woodworking researcher Steve Elliot thoroughly studied this topic some years ago. He may still have the data on his web site. The tool steels that have vanadium and/or tungsten (which make exceptionally hard carbides) will not sharpen to as high a degree with sharpening media that is too soft to cut these hard carbides. With diamond abrasive, for example, Steve achieved equivalent sharpness on all the steels he studied.

I use plane blades and chisels made from a steel with 3% vanadium. These tools sharpen just fine with diamond abrasive. I have no problem getting M2 steel sharp either, and a friend uses M4.

Professors Kato and Kawai did research in support of Japanese planing machines. One of their studies was to test various high alloy tool steels to see if they stayed sharp longer. They were able to get all these steels sharp and they stayed sharp longer.

So, the problem is not that these steels can't be sharpened; the problem is that softer abrasives will not sharpen them. If one is not willing to employ modern abrasive my recommendation would be to avoid modern steel.

I have a friend that makes knives for knife competitions. The high alloy steels have such superior performance that they must compete in a class devoted to them...he tells me.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#6

Re: ordinary carbon steel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Sharpening is an art. Sharpening steel is not something a technician can test at the higher levels.

I use 19th century English chisels. Rather than ordinary, I would call the steel extraordinary. A person who does not see the value in these tools might not have the knowledge and experience to use them.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#7

Re: ordinary carbon steel

Hank Knight

Eliot,

I think the report you got about Carbon steel getting sharper than HSS and other modern alloys came from people who have had the same experience I've had with some of the modern steels. I've used carbon steel chisels and plane irons for years and sharpened them to a razor edge on oil stones. Some years ago, I decided to give A2 steel a try on some of my hand planes. The alloy is famous for its wear resistence and edge holding qualities. I ordered some A2 irons, honed them up and put them in my planes. I was disappointed. They didn't perform well at all. They acted like they weren't very sharp, but I had just sharpened them. After struggling with them for a while, I put them back on my oil stones and spent some time on the edges. They were better, but not great. Had a little better luck with Norton water stones, but I never felt like I got my A2 irons really sharp. I went back to my 01 carbon steel irons that I could get razor sharp with much less effort. I was convinced that A2 alloy just wasn't capable of getting as sharp as good old 01.

I have since learned the lesson that Bill explained above. It's not the steel that's the problem, it's my sharpening media. My classic Arkansas oil stones just weren't cutting it - literally. I've learned that there are real physical limitations on the effectiveness of some media. My oil stones ran into those limitations with A2 steel. Some of the new steels are just too hard and abrasive resistant for traditional sharpening media. They need a sharpening medium that is capable of cutting them.

For years I had a pretty cynical view of people who jumped from one sharpening regimen to another looking for the silver bullet that would give them hair-splitting edges with minimal effort. I was, and still am to a large degree, convinced that any media will sharpen steel if you take the time to learn it and master it. Jumping from one media to another looking for Nirvana is pretty counterproductive because it wastes time that would be better spent learning and mastering one system. Having learned, however, that there are, indeed, limitations on my traditional oil stones, I am about to embark on an adventure: sharpening with diamonds, something other, less hard-headed woodworkers have been doing for a while now. If my understanding is correct, I should be able to duplicate the edges I am accustomed to getting on my carbon steel blades on just about any steel that exists with diamonds.

So, the short answer to your question is, No, it is not true that ordinary carbon steel will get sharper than HSS (or any other blade steel). It is true, however that you can't get a truly sharp edge on HSS or other alloys with inadequate sharpening media. The problem with achieving a sharp edge on modern steels lies with the sharpening media, not the steel.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#8

Re: there is a level higher...

david weaver

...than what you're tolerant of with plane irons, and that is straight razors. There was an attempt to make straight razors with more complex steels, but those efforts fell on their face.

What comes off of a 1 micron diamond lap is a pretty nasty shave. Carbon steel rules there. The only alloy steel that I can think of if the cryogenically treated 440C that henckels friodur used in razors, though I don't like it quite as much, it's surprisingly good as stainless. It wouldn't be very good for woodworking, though, as it's a touch softer than carbon steel razors.

3V looks like it is a good steel that wears fairly evenly, but most do not. Nothing wears as finely as carbon steel, at least not that I'm aware of. 3V wears slightly more coarsely, so someone wanting to finish off of the plane will still be best served by carbon steel.

3V sharpens better with diamonds (so does HAP 40), but carbon steel seems to like natural stones better, at least from what I can tell in terms of edge wear.

Brent Beach is a little off base with what he's testing, but you can see the wear profile of the edge well enough (in terms of fineness).

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/bladetest.html

Eskilstuna and Tsunesaburo are good ones to look at. I haven't noticed hock's irons to wear without chipping as well as those. The clifton sample doesn't match up to the first two, either.

3V does really well as far as alloy steels are concerned. The Muji hss does, too, but I can tell with the several that I've had (muji) that they leave more lines on work as the iron wears, whereas a good carbon steel iron will leave a uniform finish until it stops cutting.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#9

Re: ordinary carbon steel

TomD

Rather than jumping forward to levels of science few have bothered to read, the truth of the mater is those ideas about HSS and carbon steel go back a bit, and are not the product of serious experience, but they have stuck with us. HSS can be sharpened to fantastic hair popping levels, there are Japanese chisels and planes made of HSS some are a little more difficult to sharpen on regular stones, others are certainly easier than say Blue Steel. Even the plain chunks used on some machine tools like lathes, mills, and shapers, not designed to make woodworking tools, can be sharpened scary sharp. You don't actually need modern methods unless you call water stones, sandpaper, etc... Modern.

I work with quite a lot of 01 tools, that work well and are easily hand sharpened. The main advantages are that on woods of moderate hardness, up to about maple, they cycle really well, if you sharpen by hand. In other words, total downtime for sharpening is acceptable, and the experience of using them is pleasant. They don't dull too quickly, and they don't take long to refresh. (Same with 19th C. cast tools.) Other big advantage is the steel is easy to make one's own tools out of.

You can have better edge retention/cycling either for nastier woods, or if you sharpen with power, with HSS. And there are some HSS tools that are not at all bad to sharpen by hand.

It was easier back in the 80s when I bought HSS Japanese chisels because it was one of the few choices I had. Turned out great and I am still using them along with others 35 years later. But it was just what I had. About 8 dollars a chisel at a time when a big mac was maybe $1.25.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#10

How about razor blades

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The razor blades I analyzed were 440 series stainless steel. Clearly they sharpen good enough for most people and I presume they are sharpened with some sort of modern abrasive.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#11

Technical details

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

High speed steel has been alloyed to not loose hardness at high heat, and high means really high, like many hundred degrees. A broader term could be "tool steels", that is steel that has the properties to make cutting and bashing tools. Some of these tool steels like A2 loose hardness at high heat and some like M2 do not. (for grinding it is handy to have a high speed steel for it will not loose hardness when grinding it, even if it gets hot)

Tool steels contain metals beside iron that improve abrasion resistance, toughness and other properties, and carbon. Chromium, vanadium, tungsten are common alloying elements in tool steels. These elements can combine with carbon to make carbides which are much harder than the iron. To sharpen to a high degree these carbides must be abraded along with the iron. It takes an exceptionally hard abrasive to cut them. Quartz, essentially the ingredient of ARK stones, is the softest of the abrasive used for sharpening and it will not effectively cut the hard carbides. Hence, it is little wonder that persons using ARK stones report that their tool steels don't get sharp. But don't isn't the same as can't.

The bottom line of it all is that tools, materials and techniques were highly refined by trial and error in past periods in time. When one combines tools, materials and techniques from different times there is no guarantee that the result will be optimum, or even work. Keep this fact in mind when motivated to try something new, or when evaluating someone else's report on trying something new to their experience of tools, materials and techniques.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#12

Agree

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have plane and chisel blades that are O1, A2, D2, M2, M4, 3V, White and Blue steel, W1, PM-V11. All get hair-popping sharp with the right media. Anyone who complains that one of these steels does not get sharp is using inappropriate media or inappropriate technique.

The real question is whether these steels are worth using, that is, does the steel keep its promise of a longer edge in the specific task for which they are used? For some, even a 10% increase in longevity is enough. If the steel does not require any more effort to hone, that is a significant benefit. The only issue is whether one wishes to adopt a sharpening strategy that is aligned with the complex steels. For example, do you want to use diamond paste? If you want to use oil stones (or even a number of older waterstones), then you may be limited in the choices you can make.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#13

Re: How about razor blades

david weaver

They are not resharpenable, at least I've not heard anyone who can resharpen them. Plus, they are coated. I would assume they're 440 just so they aren't rusty by the time they get to market, or rusty because people don't dry a razor.

Not sure how they'd work if they were 440C only with no coating, and at near maximum hardness.

The old carbon steel DE razor blades could be touched up, but I don't know how many people would've developed the skill to do it. There were a lot of semicircular glass devices to realign the edge of a razor blade (a novel idea), but no clue how well they worked.

At any rate, of all of the things that have been presented to us as new wondersteel, the 3V irons look like they're the closest to behaving like a good carbon steel, but at a much higher cost for an iron, and for me, at a loss of my favorite sharpening method.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#14

Re: Something Missing for Carbon Steel

david weaver

(and I think what's missing is the skill of being able to make it inexpensively)

I just don't know where there's an actual improvement in the context of work. Probably 98% of us are working materials where there is no real gain above decent carbon steel, and if there is any, it's like 10% of the gain that we get from just increasing experience.

Yesterday, I was flattening door panels as my roof was being replaced - the roofers wanted access to my shop for electricity and water, so I just stayed in it and worked. I sharpened my smoothing plane once over a couple of hours, and I didn't sharpen the try plane (it was sharpened the last time I was in the shop). Certainly a lot of my time otherwise was spent sawing, etc, so it's not like I was planing for a couple of hours, but off and on over those couple of hours.

I really have no clue what I'd gain with an iron I had to sharpen half as much.

The mujingfang irons that I have are very similar to 3V in Beach's wear tests, both in wear rate and fineness as wear occurs. They are novel, but not enough so that I favor using them over something more plain - I don't lack for gear to sharpen anything, so the time sharpening isn't a whole lot different - I just don't like the media used for them as much.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#15

Re: Wrong on both counts

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Last week, Bill, when you were asking about adjusting tenons with a chisel, I was left thinking that maybe your chisels just are not very sharp. Certainly paring cross grain with a chisel is clumsy unless the chisel is in fine shape.

Some years ago you insisted that a chisel used for dovetails or mortises would inevitably develop chips on the edge. You even went so far as to insist that if I looked at my own chisels closely, I would see chips. Pure fantasy. I have sharpened at 30 degrees my whole life and never had chipping on a chisel.

In reading things like this, I am not at all encouraged to even try the materials or methods you mention. What causes this chipping on your chisels? Is it the diamonds? Is it the steel? Is it sharpening technique? Chiselling technique? I have no idea.

I don't see where you have the experience to make judgements on this question.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#16

Re: Something Missing for Carbon Steel

Hank Knight

David,

I agree with you that the wood most of us work here in the U.S. and Canada doesn't tax our edges very much, at least not like the stuff that seems to be the norm in Oz. Consequently, O1 or similar carbon steel should suit our needs for a great majority of our woodworking. I have certainly found it to be very adequate for my needs and pleasant to use. But, for several reasons, I have ended up with a bunch of A2 plane irons that have plagued me to the point that I've invested in the equipment necessary to convert from oil stones to sharpening with diamond paste, I.E., a couple of plates and the diamond compounds - not a great expense, but not trivial either.

My bench planes are old Stanleys I've accumulated over the years. When I first started participating on Internet woodworking forums, A2 steel was all the rage. It promised keen edges with long life. Also, there was a lot said about the advantages of thick irons and modern chipbreakers - primarily in reducing chatter. I wasn't getting much chatter with my original irons and chipbreakers, but it sounded good; so I started looking around for replacements for my Stanleys. Lie-Nielsen was offering thick A2 replacements and heavy chipbreakers for Stanley planes. I ordered some. Interestingly, the standard Stanley replacements didn't fit my Bedrocks, but Lie-Nielsen was kind enough to machine a set to my specifications for free - a practice they have since discontinued. In any event, I ended up with A2 irons in all my bench planes. As I have mentioned in several previous posts, I was able to get them sharp enough to work fairly well, albeit with a lot of effort; but I could never get them as sharp as I thought they should be - as sharp as my original carbon steel irons. Meanwhile, the new planes I purchased from LN all came with A2 irons. As a result, most - all but three or four - of my hand planes are equipped with A2 Irons.

Several recent experiences with an English smoother I have that's equipped with a W1 iron reminded me how nice it was to work with really sharp irons. As a result, I've gotten back into the search for sharpening Nirvana and have made the decision to move to diamonds. I would be perfectly happy to return to my original carbon steel irons, but I've spent a lot of money on this stuff over the years and I hate to simply chuck it. In assessing what it would cost to shelve all my A2 irons in favor of carbon steel ones, it's cheaper for me to change my sharpening strategy.

In the long run, I think I will be happy with the advantage of long wearing edges that A2 offers, assuming I can get the things sharp with diamonds; but I agree with you completely: the wear resistance is not something I really need. I just found myself in the A2 predicament that took several years to evolve. Had I known then what I know now, I would still be using carbon steel, and I would have ordered my new planes with carbon steel irons, an option I think LN has also discontinued in favor of all A2 for most of their planes.

Live and learn.

Hank

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#17

bubinga and David's Try plane

Brian Holcombe

Doesn't even phase it. Took heavy cuts just like every other wood I use and David's plane was hardly bothered by Bubinga.

I prefer mild hardwoods but I've worked Ipe, Bubinga, Ebony, Honduras rosewood, etc with the same steels I always use and don't really experience excessive wear to the point where I would want to change to a2 steel.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#18

Re: A different view of A2

Hank Knight

I have a good friend in the edge tool business. He maintains that tool manufacturers are responsible for promoting A2 steel, not because of its edge holding properties, but because it's easier to machine than most other modern steels and it is relatively tame through the heat treating process. For them it poses fewer manufacturing risks and results in less waste. The wear resistance is simply a promotional gimmick to mask the fact that it's a bear to sharpen.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#19

Re: Wrong on both counts

Brian Holcombe

Bill,

Here's a link to Kezorou Kai 2008.

http://www.thejapanblade.com/new_page_24.htm

One thing stands out to me, the author states most users are using natural stones and the best shavings are 3 micron (thinner than a blood cell). So they're also using something capable of being polished by natural stones.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#20

Re: A different view of A2

david weaver

George Wilson has told me the same. He's relayed this already, so I'm not ratting anything out that he's not said online. But years ago, he suggested to LN that they should go to A2 because they were only hardening part of the usable area of their W1 irons. I think their response not "OK", but some time later they came out using it, anyway (probably scads of people suggested it to them). I believe he suggested it to them because it's a lot easier to harden.

Karl Holtey says he was the first to use A2 (maybe he was, he does dabble in some odd powder metals now that are reputedly hard to sharpen).

After talking to George, I'd figured the same as you said is true - that it's so well behaved in hardening that it's worth the extra cost for the raw material. And it does last for a lot of feet in really thin shavings if sharpened right. I'm convinced that when sharpening takes a beginner 5 to 10 minutes and grinding is difficult, they'll take anything that lasts longer. I bought all of that stuff, too.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#21

Re: That try plane iron is..

david weaver

...relatively soft as far as even vintage irons go. Every time George tells me about ideal hardness for irons, he says "brown" or "just able to file it with a good quality vintage mill file". Which is probably about how that iron is. No chipping!!

I guess there is some virtue in high hardness in a smoother intended for very thin shavings only, but irons like that are far more useful in the coarse and medium planes. Roll a wire edge up quickly, hone it off, back to work.

I had a dwight and french iron softer than that one a full step, and I learned a lesson from it. I was sure that after it hit the stones, I'd make a couple of passes and then need to be rehoned. But instead, it worked just fine on beech and maple, was very easy to resharpen and took no damage other than slightly faster wear, as you say, "you can see the wear on it with the naked eye and still keep working".

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#22

Re: Something Missing for Carbon Steel

david weaver

I think you've made a rational decision. I think the diamond setup is easy to use, especially if you do most of the work with a grinder. I've got an upside down plane with 1 micron diamonds on it, and it works well paired with an ezelap before it.

The only thing I noticed with A2 is that it required a slightly blunter final angle to avoid chipout.

I bought all of that stuff, too, it's hard to know what experience tells you without having experience, and I'm sure we all have a bit of retail therapy susceptibility...I know I do, for sure.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#23

Re: That try plane iron is..

Brian Holcombe

That iron is incredible, it's my trusted ally at this point.

It will eventually wear to the point where it won't cut but will never leave lines in the finish in the process of getting to that point, so it really never chips. It starts to leave a dull finish after a while but I can work through that as I'm always following up with a smoother.

I could probably use something similar in a smoother, but would need to sharpen more often.

For anyone who needs a medium plane that is taking a medium cut I think that this type of iron is ideal. For those unaware of the history of David having built a plane for me (two actually the other is the jack I use all the time), previously I used a 7 plane with an A2 iron for panel truing, and as the panel became flat the experience was brutal, I'd need to keep the iron super sharp and take a light cut as to not add to the friction of the super flat sole and resharpening A2 constantly gets old.

I still use that 7 plane, but I use it for shooting.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#24

Re: Technical details

TomD

"High speed steel has been alloyed to not loose hardness at high heat, and high means really high, like many hundred degrees. A broader term could be "tool steels","

Those are certainly not synonyms as tool steels encompass many steels that are not HSS.

"(for grinding it is handy to have a high speed steel for it will not loose hardness when grinding it, even if it gets hot)"

Three points relative to that:

1) Agreed

2) But, one wants to avoid those high heats for a slew of other reasons and it is no problem at all to do so. I don't want to get burned, I don't want my edges to get burned and need polishing, or look like they were handled by a nincompoop, I don't want to breath the stuff that comes off, or set the shop on fire.

3) I don't know where the term HSS comes from. But it seems most likely it comes from the ability to run the steels at higher speeds during machining operations (checked and Wiki agrees). I'm not sure since that can be dealt with with coolant. That would be the big seller as far as production is concerned, it doesn't probably cost you production having to grind tools, as that can happen while the machine is running.

I just bring it up because in wood circles the whole sharpening thing assumes massive importance, mystery and so forth. When people correctly point out that HSS allows you to grind hotter without drawing temper, they are dipping into the pot of dark fears that seem to pop up in woodworking relative to the most minor procedures with metal. But the guys who used this stuff during the 40s I guess it helped us win the war... knew perfectly well how to grind a chunk, they just wanted to make money or turn out parts.

Re: ordinary carbon steel

#25

David's Try plane - the hatred of sharpening

TomD

David's planes use cast steel right? Old stuff? That can be about as good as it gets. I have to say I don't really care what I am using for most woods. I have used High silica woods but not to any great degree. Guitar making uses a lot of tropicals and they fall down in from of O1 just like everything else.

When one hears people talk about edge longevity it sounds like they are tied to the bench, thank goodness they have the means to do an extra 10% of work. With a few notable exceptions, I don't think people like that have the time to post here. At the root of it is the hatred and fear of sharpening. I remember learning to sharpen, and the desperation at wondering whether than dang chrome rich scout pocket knife would ever come up. I remember the bruised thumbs from messing with badly designed plane parts. Not great horrors to be sure, but taken all together, the ups, and downs, people seem to want to control and put off sharpening. Even though I am well past all that, there is still a little anxiety there in the reptile brain. One just has to let it go. It's going to be OK. Really, can anyone tell when their edge is lasting 10% longer, without keeping records?