Re: there is a level higher...
david weaver
...than what you're tolerant of with plane irons, and that is straight razors. There was an attempt to make straight razors with more complex steels, but those efforts fell on their face.
What comes off of a 1 micron diamond lap is a pretty nasty shave. Carbon steel rules there. The only alloy steel that I can think of if the cryogenically treated 440C that henckels friodur used in razors, though I don't like it quite as much, it's surprisingly good as stainless. It wouldn't be very good for woodworking, though, as it's a touch softer than carbon steel razors.
3V looks like it is a good steel that wears fairly evenly, but most do not. Nothing wears as finely as carbon steel, at least not that I'm aware of. 3V wears slightly more coarsely, so someone wanting to finish off of the plane will still be best served by carbon steel.
3V sharpens better with diamonds (so does HAP 40), but carbon steel seems to like natural stones better, at least from what I can tell in terms of edge wear.
Brent Beach is a little off base with what he's testing, but you can see the wear profile of the edge well enough (in terms of fineness).
http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/bladetest.html
Eskilstuna and Tsunesaburo are good ones to look at. I haven't noticed hock's irons to wear without chipping as well as those. The clifton sample doesn't match up to the first two, either.
3V does really well as far as alloy steels are concerned. The Muji hss does, too, but I can tell with the several that I've had (muji) that they leave more lines on work as the iron wears, whereas a good carbon steel iron will leave a uniform finish until it stops cutting.