New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

A Call To All

Posts

Re: A Call To All

#76

Re: Very nice, wiley!!

david weaver

Wiley, it's funny that you say that (that it has to not look like endgrain). My first thought looking at the piece you posted pictures of, was that the exposed endgrain is so smooth and sculptured that it doesn't look like endgrain.

I'll take pictures of my planes as I complete them and put them in the gallery. I just need to get a decent day so I can get some light outside. To say my lighting situation in the house is undesirable is an understatement, and backlighting just takes away the details that I think are so important (sharp lines between curved and flat parts, and reflectivity of the faceted surfaces like the chamfers, etc).

Thanks for the kind words, I'm still *learning* to make nice ones, and I'm fascinated especially by the try plane - it is so useful to a heavy user of hand tools.

Re: A Call To All

#77

Re: Shazam

TomD

Hi, I'm here, what do you need?

Re: A Call To All

#78

Re: Not a bullet caster...

TomD

That doesn't sound right to me, that you can push a cast bullet as fast as a jacketed by any means, unless the Jacketed/smokeless version is also a black powder level cartridge, like factory loaded 45-70. But while I am a member of Cast Boolits, I don't know much about it compared to woodworking.

Around here we have or used to have (this kind of stuff can be over in a breath) a very large foundry that does large scale boatwork. Getting 500 pounds from them is easy. Not too expensive, but not wheel weight, or linotype cheap. I imagine the printing source is gone?

Re: A Call To All

#79

Re: Question

TomD

If there were going to be a lot of buildalongs, I would almost prefer a separate forum. The main reason to post on both forums would be for people who don't follow the messages forum, which I didn't until the volume on the Hand Tools got so low. But I suspect most people are double readers, and don't want to have to wade through two threads, that might take of in strange directions, relative to each other.

I don't personally want the hand tool forum to become a projects forum, though it is up to the members at large what it is.

I like the idea of a separate forum but only if one had a hope that there would be sufficient volume to support it. Status quo seems reasonable for now.

Re: A Call To All

#80

Re: Question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't personally want the hand tool forum to become a projects forum

Tom, I am not sure what you consider to be a "project". My intention when I post a build along has never intentionally been "look what I'm building", but rather "let's build this together, discuss the technique and joinery, and discover something about the world of handtools along the way".

This is to me what the handtools forum is - or should be - about. It is not just discussing tools, but learning how to use them. And what more appropriate way to use them than when building something.

It does not have to be building furniture, but it could be building tools, as David recently offered up.

I think it is about time that others also commented. If posting a build along is not what the majority want, then I will not do so again. I have not considered this idea before, but I am prepared to go along with forum preferences. It would be disappointing, however, if the Handtool Forum became - literally - about tools alone. There are other forums that only do that, and they are the less for it.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Call To All

#81

Good grief........

roger lance

I suppose you could have a forum topic like music and never actually listen to music.....just talk about various notes....timing....which instrument would be best for which role in the unheard, unplayed arraignment.....and some would reinforce this approach by saying it was good enough for Beethoven and if it was good enough for the master well then.....

But given the choice, I'd rather hear music in addition to talking about it.

Re: A Call To All

#82

It's a true thing

John in NM

You wouldn't think paper would stand the pressures, but it seems to do so according to the guys who push this to the limits. In all fairness, I've not tried it yet so any info I relate is secondhand.

Re: A Call To All

#83

Not at all...

John in NM

Keep posting build logs I say. No better way to understand hand tools than through examples of their use. As many of us have found, there are some jobs that must be done by hand to be done well.

There is a good reason I'm not on any tool collecting, sit and look at 'em forums - it's because that stuff bores me to tears :D

Re: A Call To All

#84

More, not fewer

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I wish we saw more folks bringing design problems, build-alongs, proud postings of completed work, etc. to this forum. Keep them coming, Derek.

Re: A Call To All

#85

A vote for projects and some WC philosophy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Well said, agree entirely, and every other positive response one can think of.

A Forum can't be a one way street of information. Those benefiting have an obligation to provide useful to others content. Somehow, thankfully from my perspective, the WoodCental Forums have avoided the socializing flavor of others and have not become a Wood-Facebook of empty chatting. Personally I don't have time for empty chatting.

It is a demonstrated fact that picture posts get more traffic. The readers like them; it matters not why. It doesn't matter whether it is a close up of some joint made in a WC shop, or a historical shop, or professional shop, the content generates interest. Ditto other examples- new tools, historical tools, restored tools, and anything else woodworking.

Project posts are just another example of picture posts. Read the log of the Guest Chat with Lang. The emphasis of this experiment (my words, for I think it indeed is an experiment) will be in depth project posts. They know readers like in depth project posts. I like in depth projects post. I hope to learn from them. My hats off to those that do them for the are a lot of work to put together.

Re: A Call To All

#86

Re: Question

Stuart Johnson

If I have a label it would be segmented turner but I follow most of the hand tool threads at least until they start getting as long as this one. I have built a few pieces of furniture for the house using a combination of power and hand tools. I always follow and enjoy your how to and review posts. So I vote keep posting and thank you.

Re: A Call To All

#87

Re: Question

John S

Derek, I would just like to say that I enjoy and appreciate your project posts.

Re: A Call To All

#88

Re: Question

TomD

Derek, I don't consider most of your things to be buildalongs. Your stuff is usually very focused on what we do here, and the quality is excellent. I was talking about 2 very particular things that came from Bill's post (who also does great buildalongs).

1) should they be cross-posted to Hand tools if started in messages (and by logical extension to Photography and turning (if anything is turned). Shoot me with your glue gun, but I don`t want to read the same dang thing in three forums only to find I should have read the 4th, because that was were the real juice was squeezed. If there was a huge problem of this type I would prefer a nifty solution where the forums might have a sidebar that had hot threads, or buildalongs in other forums so they wouldn't be missed.

2) the other issue was what to do if there where "too many". I was talking about a non extant situation in which large volumes of the material were buildalongs. On a cycle touring forum I participate in, you are welcome to post whatever you want including tour reports, but most people choose to use Crazyguyonabike, where reports from all over the world can be found. It is a mater of taste, but there is something to be said from having things in an organized rather than random setting. At the moment. the random format within forums works fine because there isn't an imbalance of volume that fundamentally changes the nature of any of the forums.

Re: A Call To All

#89

Re: Question

TomD

As long as people only post in one of the forums, I think it is up to them to define what kind of tool user they see themselves as. I have something like 30 stationary tools, probably 40, I have no idea. I consider myself primarily a hand tool user, in matters woodworking, that is how I started, though I do not consider the distinction necessary. And the vast majority of my time spent on projects is hand tool time, which is likely to be the case whether one uses power tools significantly or not. In my second shop we harvest material from the surrounding woods, and work it almost entirely by hand.

There are impacts on hand tool use that are specific to whether one uses hand tools exclusively, or uses power tools in part. For instance I was thinking of breaking 3 necks out of a piece I was planing to use for a lute guitar neck. I was thinking about David's recent double bit evangelism because in running the process through my mind, I was thinking that it would only take a few passes a side to get the planer marks off, so where was all this efficiency from a double bit going to come from. I expect the surface to look like marble when those cuts are done, so much so I will probably have to dull them before I put finish on, to get a uniform coating thickness. I will check this as I go. I will not be taking photos, or providing reports, the daughter who announced she wants to play guitar is a fickle one and cares only about "yesterday" as a time frame. She is also incredibly careless, so I am not wasting time on mother of pearl or fancy perfling. Making three travel instruments is enough. I will be doing stuff like cutting the fret recesses by hand, it goes fast, and will be properly compensated.

Re: A Call To All

#90

Re: It's a true thing

TomD

I don't doubt it. There is more in the world than is including in my philosophy, or however that goes. It Seemed a noteworthy thing, about the paper patch. I once made a jig to cut arrow fletching from turkey feathers. The jig held the feathers tight, and they were to be profiled by a router bit at 20K. The bit would not cut the feathers, they just bent out of the way. I was amazed because we all know what happens to flesh in a bit. Similarly hard to believe paper does what jacketing in copper would do. But one never knows.

Re: A Call To All

#91

Re: More, not fewer

TomD

Can someone show the post where it was suggested Derek should post fewer projects? Then we can match it up with the post where you said we should hide them from other people by only carrying them in the Hand Tools forum.

Re: A Call To All

#92

Re: Good grief........

TomD

I know what you mean. On the F-150 forum I never give a straight answer to a question about what oil filter to use, without including a 20 page entry of me pulling stumps with the truck.

Re: A Call To All

#93

Ellis Walentine

***By and for each of us***

Ellis Walentine

That's been our motto here since 1998 and it ain't changin'. Everyone is entitled to their own relationship to this website, and absent some flagrant violation (of which there are precious few proscribed), we all get to say and post whatever we want to bring to the conversation. The rest of us get to accept, reject, discuss, or ignore whatever we don't find relevant and/or useful. This policy has given rise to one of the longest-running, well-respected, commodious groups of folks you're likely to find on the Internet. We teach by our thoughtfulness, we guide by our own example, we resist the impulse to preach or judge (well, most of us anyway:). If you stop posting your build-alongs, Derek, it would be against your instinct and decidedly against the best interests of this community.

Nobody has to post pictures, and nobody has to lay guilt on people who don't want to, for whatever reason. As a magazine editor, I understand that communication is best accomplished by some mixture of elements -- text and art usually -- and that both types of communication are interesting and valuable to different people in different ways. We don't discriminate. Post what you think is best. If I would benefit from additional information, whether visual or textual, I can easily ask for it, and you can respectfully comply or decline.

I just see no reason for anyone to feel crowded or obliged to go along with someone or some group's idea of how it should be. We're all ourselves, plain and simple. That's what communities are about. If you can learn from someone, do it. If you can teach something, there will be a lot of folks eager to share in the bounty.

Onward, eh?

Ellis

Re: A Call To All

#94

Re: ***By and for each of us***

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

I take your - valid - point about having to find all the information posted to make sense of each presentation. While the devil lies in the details, context is everything. This is why I have restricted myself to posting on the Hand Tools forum. As to the fear that the forum will turn into an outpouring of projects, well I doubt that - this has not occurred to date, the reason being that each takes a large investment in time and energy. You have to be a little nutso :)

I want to say to guys like yourself and Warren (I apologise by not naming others) that reading some of the builds must be extremely frustrating since, design aside, the techniques and skill involved must appear obviously clumsy and immature. I must make it clear that I do not consider myself anything more than a Weekend Warrior. I am not posting to show how it is done, but how I have done it - and this is presented for discussion and critique.

Everything is relative. If I could build as well as you or Warren, I would still want to be improving. When I look at what is on my website, I want to remove most of it as I know there are many mistakes over the years as my skills have evolved - as everyones skills evolve. I frequently visualise a grand Spring clear out. The only reason the information stays is because there is something pitched at a level for someone. I receive emails from readers to thank me for this or that. Inside I cringe.

Ellis .. thank you.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Call To All

#95

Re: Not a bullet caster...

david weaver

I missed this when it came up. Paper patch, full pressure full speed.

Lead soft, slow speed, lead hard not quite as slow, but still fouling if I understand (I've never shot lead bullets at high speed when jacketed and plated are as cheap as they are....or were....but I have a jones for a sharps which is normally shot with heavier bullets, and a lot of the original cartridges were paper patch).

What I don't know about paper patch is if it was done as a crutch? (like were rifle bores inconsistent, or was it hard to get precise moulds), or if it was done because it kept the bore clean, or if it was done because it was easier to tune loads and hit buffaloes at long range.

Re: A Call To All

#96

I believe it was done for longer ranges...

John in NM

The higher velocities required for long ranges with a soft lead bullet caused excessive leading, and copper jackets were not invented yet.

So not really a crutch so much as the earliest method of jacketing, when most cartridge loads did not reach the pressures that required it.

Then, as now, it was a pretty specialized technique. These days it's largely pointless except to those of us who like esoteric stuff, because copper jacketing works just fine and is not at all expensive.

Re: A Call To All

#97

Re: I believe it was done for longer ranges...

david weaver

I guess expensive is a relative term. Copper plating is cheap, but I don't know of too many cheap 500 grain jacketed bullets in .458 (or really even copper plated), and then you still have to have a good barrel and bullet match.

I've got some homework to do before I get anywhere with it, and top of the list will be to decide whether I can part with the cash for a shiloh sharps or newer c sharps (they are out of my sensibility both in price and waiting list times for new ones).

I've been out of the hobby for a while, but I always liked loading, so the fiddling of paper patch has some appeal above and beyond the ability to use really cheap soft lead bullets.

(I got into woodworking about the time my shooting was curtailed. I'm not surprised to find that a lot of woodworkers like the involvement of loading their own, etc. It's got a very similar feel to me, to woodworking. You're trying to make something, improve something, etc, without just paying someone else to do it).

Re: A Call To All

#98

Cheap is relative of course...

John in NM

In the previous post I was thinking more of the historical trend in component pricing, ever downward as manufacturing efficiency increases.

Our view of current pricing is swayed a great deal by the sudden jump in metals prices just a few years ago. Taking that into account, 500 grainers are still pretty cheap, just not as cheap as in the 1990's when lead was 30 cents a pound or less.

Either way though, it still hurts when you have to buy those big heavy ones :D - knowledge that it is inflationary doesn't really help much.

Similarly, one range I use fairly often has had to ban lead pickers. Never used to see people scrounging lead there, just a few obsessively cheap casters would pick up what lay on the ground. Once lead got expensive around 2007, people came out just to scrounge and sell, and would flatten all the dirt berms doing it.

Re: A Call To All

#99

Re: Never saw a lead picker...

david weaver

..don't know what local lead price is, but I see a lot of cast available of the 405 grain variety for about 25 or 30 cents and that's something I can certainly live with.

I'll have to look at the dies that are available, because they'd need to be squished about 8 thousandths to be OK for paper patch, and a lot are pre-lubed.

I've also seen some postings about the marlin 1895 CB being bored a little oversized, so it might also be a good candidate. When I was younger, I was obsessed with flat shooting and tiny groups, which aren't very practical in the field (well, flat shooting is), but our land is woods with some opening - long shots are rare.

As I get back into it, I'm looking for something more along the lines of shooting off hand and polishing personal skill as a challenge that comes down to me and not the machinist.

The only thing that rubs me the wrong way with the hobby is that I'm often hesitant with hobbies where money turns into nothing.

I'll have to look around some more. Back when I was a regular, there were a lot of steel cases on the ground, but there were often guys picking up brass sitting around with a bucket and not shooting. I picked up my brass for obvious reasons, so did most people if any had any value (the rules there suggested that was a requirement to begin with, for everything except .22). Too busy for any lead pickers...fortunately.

Re: A Call To All

#100

Re: Not a bullet caster...

TomD

What full speed are we talking here? 2600 and up, or 45-70 full speed. If we are talking smokeless bottleneck levels, that is news to me, and something to take on board.