New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

A Call To All

Posts

Re: A Call To All

#101

Re: Not a bullet caster...

david weaver

It depends. I have load for the 1895 marlin (26" octagonal barrel, i'm not into the modern looking stuff) that is in the range of 2400 with 300 grains.

Paper patch should give me the option of using regular soft lead, which I'd not get away with more than half of that.

I'm thinking 400 grains for a single shot around 1500-1700 fps, that's a low pressure loading. Maybe low side of that for 500, which is suitable for trapdoor springfield type stuff (which is weaker than a sharps, IIRC).

I'm very early on with anything other than what comes out of the marlin, and maybe I'll stick to that. It's probably more accurate than I can be offhand, but the sights are undesirable for much beyond 50 yards.

I'm sure I'll shoot open sight on a bench, though, too, and I'd be thrilled if I could get it to group at the limit of what my eyesight can do.

What I described above is a listed load, more of a deer load. I don't know why it's listed though, it's a bit sticky at extraction, but without any signs on cases.

I'm done with deer, though. I'm too lazy to hunt, thus the fascination with getting away from the practical and going more toward the fiddling.

Re: A Call To All

#102

Re: ***By and for each of us***

TomD

"I just see no reason for anyone to feel crowded or obliged to go along with someone or some group's idea of how it should be. We're all ourselves, plain and simple. That's what communities are about. If you can learn from someone, do it. If you can teach something, there will be a lot of folks eager to share in the bounty."

I didn't know that was the motto. But it is certainly there in this wonderful place.

I think the bigger issue for people who are leaving their kids unloved and unfed due to time spent on the net is, what is the Zeitgeist at this moment. Presumably somewhere well beyond twitterland, but as far as forums are concerned... The internet is always changing. Not surprisingly people want free content better than what FWW provided in it's hayday of paper or VHS, for pay. If that is really what they want, and not just some crowd that showed up for this particular clam bake, well, there are those here who are working pretty hard towards being able to provide it. Derek, Bill, and David. What say we direct some of this stuff to a premium content area where it can be given it's due. It could be a VIP chat worthy. I look at some of the names there, and maybe the guys with the pitchforks should be asking some of those guys when they last made a Wegner chair and posted pictures. The reality is probably that none of my fears of over projecting, or none of the desires for a word free landscape are actually likely to come true, but we could loose a valued participant to another format, and that would be sad. Maybe the home grown talent, should have something to shoot for, and people, like Derek Bill, and David should be recognized. And anyone else who gets there also. There are guys who got star status off the website because the won a prize and may have never contributed before or since. Doesn't seem fair.

Re: A Call To All

#103

From what I've read...

John in NM

You can get over 2600 fps with paper wrapped lead.

The difficulty is in accuracy at that point since cast bullets are not of a spitzer shape so it tends to be much harder to come up with a stable and accurate load at high velocities. Limiting factor is bullet shape, not composition or jacket composition.

Re: A Call To All

#104

Re: ***By and for each of us***

TomD

"I want to say to guys like yourself and Warren (I apologise by not naming others) that reading some of the builds must be extremely frustrating since, design aside, the techniques and skill involved must appear obviously clumsy and immature. I must make it clear that I do not consider myself anything more than a Weekend Warrior. I am not posting to show how it is done, but how I have done it - and this is presented for discussion and critique."

Most of the stars in the woodworking firmament are good communicators (or first communicators), their technical level is rarely the issue. And you are a good communicator. As well as being a technical person. I did a dovetail seminar around 2000 where one of the the attendees was an actress with a sideline DIY show. Probably youtube is the only thing that has stopped it going 100 percent Nick Offerman, and Ed Begley Jr. Even FWW didn't seem to know they had published a book with "Nick Offerman's Jig" in it before giving him a cover story. I don't know where you find the energy, though having once had a demanding career, I can guess.

You have a wonderful way of doing buildalongs where you ask for imput on stuff you surely already have an answer for, and it improves the content, makes everyone feel part of it, and quells the know it alls. It's the kind of thing more people should do.

Re: A Call To All

#105

Re: From what I've read...

david weaver

I think the ballistics are poorer, but they can be made to shoot long distances. My understanding from reading several different tutorials, though, is that you can't just get two wraps of paper, resize a cast and wrap the paper and expect the first roll out of bullets to shoot 1/2 minute.

I watched various videos following this fascination to see what people were paper patching, and some were doing it with modern rifles and doing OK, but that seems like fiddling beyond what I'm willing to do, those are not expensive to load jacketed.

I'm interested in trying this all out. My ballistic issues are not going to be a big deal because I usually shoot at a place that's got 100 yard targets max, and sometimes at a place where 200 yards is the end. There's just too many hills around here to get a good open stretch without being on a hill top (which would be an exceptionally bad place for a range).

I wonder what the likelihood is of getting into beaters and making new wood for them.

Re: A Call To All

#107

Re: Planes posted

david weaver

Not sure if it's the place to say it, but I put planes in the gallery (this is in response to wiley's request to put some there).

http://gallery.woodcentral.com/all-gallery/?gaId=83

As far as the handle styles, they are partly robbed from two planes, one being an old JT brown jointer that has a handle that leans forward (i really like it) and the other being the handle....I guess theirs a third, the other is a combination of two try plane handles, a baldwin and a griffiths of norwich.

My handle styles are a bit thick at the top, if I were making a plane for decoration, I'd thin them out, but they are thick for two reasons (above and beyond the fact that my favorite JT brown handle is a bit thick at the top and has survived well for almost 200 years):

* it's a reality that a plane that's being used heavily will have a short fall at some point or be knocked over, I don't want the horn to chip off or handle to break at the top if that happens

* the front portion of the plane is a bit thick where it's "tucked in" at the top, I also want that to be a little overbulky because I want to use the planes with as much force as I can conjure up from my feet when doing heavy work.

That thickness at the top of the handle isn't aesthetically right, but it has made them survive so far (and I have, unfortunately, dropped every plane that is mine at least once - something I never do with metal planes, and flopped the jointer over accidentally such that the handle banged into the floor).

The real joy of the try plane is something like taking a stick for a kitchen cabinet that is a tenth too thick and literally bringing it down to a thickness mark in 10 strokes. It's very physically satisfying.

Anyway, it may look like there are a whole bunch of pictures of the same plane, but there are four beech planes, a rudimentary infill and a coffin smoother.

Re: A Call To All

#108

Re: Planes posted

Bob Hackett

Thanks for posting those pics. I always enjoy looking at the end results of a job well done undertaken by someone who fully understands what they are aiming for and why.

This is very crisp work you`ve done and looks to be as pleasing to the hand as it is to the eye.

I have a few planes with very large handles that came from local boatyards. They allow all four fingers to be contained in the cutout rather than the lower three and the "pointer finger" wrapped over the top of the handle. I was once told that the top of the plane handle had that break or indent in order to give the pointer finger a comfortable and secure place to rest for heavy work. I`ve also heard others say that finger should be pointed straight forward, slightly down and parallel to the body of the plane rather than curled up and over the top of the handle. Care to tell us your thoughts on this?

Re: A Call To All

#109

Re: Planes posted

david weaver

I can't say I've done much historical study of stuff, but more picking up bits and pieces from folks like Larry (though I'm sure he wouldn't agree with this design), but primarily from the makers who were making this general double iron style of plane in the middle 1800s. I came to the style otherwise on a use basis, eliminating problems I had with the speed of dimensioning with single iron planes and the risks working at speed with them presents.

As far as the handles go, I want to avoid anything that encourages a closed grip with tension, so I always keep one finger out. Anything with a very large handle may have been made so guys could work with gloves on or something (but I know even less about that than my own planes!!). George always mentions plane designs that are set to keep you from getting a tight grip so as to not induce carpal tunnel.

My personal thought about having that tuck in at the top of the handle is that you have serious aesthetic problems if it's not there. I had to go watch a video of myself to see where my fingers go, and my index finger does just touch the topline. Maybe there's something to that.

The four most important things to me about the handle are:

* the cutout at the top fits the web of the hand

* the middle of the palm meets the hump comfortably on the back middle of the handle

* the angle of the handle doesn't cause you to flex your wrist

* the handle is tall enough that the outside of your palm doesn't contact the top of the plane

If everything is sized right, you never have to squeeze hard. It's a situation where you get tired before anything is sore, and that is ideal to me.

I haven't offset a handle yet, but I will offset the next handle a quarter of an inch. I had a tendency when I made my first jointer to cut the side of a jointed edge toward me a little more than the far side, which argues for the offset handle, but it didn't take much use to get the right feel and eliminate it.

Thanks for the nice comments, by the way. I hope to make at least another 15 or 20 planes (whatever the beech pile yields) and get everything a bit cleaner on them in the mortise (and make a few continental smoothers).

Re: A Call To All

#110

Lots of new stuff has showed up....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I enjoyed looking at the planes. Plane making is a universe I know nothing about and your pictures were an opportunity to learn. I trust your bookcase will show up there soon.

I notice some other new pictures.......for example the handsome table by Mr. Duffield. One now wonders what else remains to be revealed from his shop.

The Gallery can be a source of inspiration. The value of seeing that someone has made a plane, or a bookcase for their child, should not be underestimated in providing motivation for someone else to make something similar.

Re: A Call To All

#111

Re: Lots of new stuff has showed up....

david weaver

I'd say something about furniture being nicer, but I have nothing nicer really than the book shelves for furniture, because I only build furniture and cabinets as needed.

I have more tools, though. Maybe at a later date.

I don't want to make any suggestions about what other people should put in the galleries, but any of the similar shelves I've made aren't what I'd put in the gallery.

Just the same, if someone takes pine from the lumber yard as my dad did, screws on some fixtures to hold boards along the sides of the case and then screws boards to those (or nails, those things were probably all nailed with finish nails), then stains and puts things together in 4 hours instead of 15, I don't begrudge that. In fact, that design is a concoction of the minimum I want to make, but I don't want things "country", I grew up in a house where everything was country or folk art and I don't like it.

The planes are kind of not indications of presentation type work, either. I had a stipulation that I wanted the proportions to be right, but if you look closely at them, you can see that I pared the back curves and never sanded them off (some of them i filed), and I didn't sand the handles, etc, they are just straight off of a card scraper and the edges where the transitions are may be filed. I think they look nice, but that's because they have the proportions I wanted, others may not agree.

But I made them first so that I could have a set of planes that I made like I wanted them to be made, and second so that I could learn to better make planes - I never had even a passing thought that they'd be posted somewhere in high resolution. I aspire to eventually make better planes - cleaner versions of the ones posted, as well as planes with more decorative work on them, small carved elements, but only tasteful. Woodworking is like music - if you can play something well and slow, but not well and fast, then the world appreciates well and slow a lot more. I'm doing plain work well, I'd be ecstatic if someone wanted to talk shop about making functional planes, but as I make them and put up a set of videos, I'm aware that most people aren't going to be inclined to spend the two weeks or so that it takes to get used to using planes like I've made because they don't have the need to do anything other than smooth. Anyway, I'm getting off on a tangent..

There are many super pieces in the gallery made by people who I had no idea what they make. I aspire to do better work. I only wish George Wilson had good photos of his work and was a member here, I can't think of anyone more inspiring. Even the pistols, rifles and cannons that he has made are superb, but the tools, instruments, jewelry, etc...all of them sharpen our eyes and design sense. George doesn't have great pictures of everything, though, he was too busy making. I'll see if I can get him to make a gallery.