New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

A Call To All

Posts

A Call To All

#1

A Call To All

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Ellis established the new Gallery for Wood Central “people” to post the results of their work and respond to what others show. Other than a few early adopters the site has gone about as silent as the back room of the Smithsonian that houses their collection of hand-carved button holes.

Why?

A gallery website, to succeed, needs traffic, comments, discussions, and, most importantly, a stream of new work postings. Not only are we not getting new and more work posted, comments on current content are about nil. Is anybody here even looking at what’s up?

Is this gallery section something people here are just not interested in?

Is the format not to your liking (proffer suggestions!)?

The idea was to foster display and interaction between wood artists and woodworkers at all levels. What can we do to get more participation and some dynamic interaction going?

You can (if you wish) post suggestions here, or e-mail Ellis to let him know. The Gallery has been an investment of time and money for Ellis. If it’s to continue, there needs to be a demonstrated real willingness for people to participate in some way.

Re: A Call To All

#2

intimidated


Re: A Call To All

#3

Re: A Call To All

TomD

The gallery is a good thing, and I always go to the gallery sections in the magazines. But there is also a divisive zippy undercurrent, which is what it is.

Re: A Call To All

#4

Don't Be intimidated

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It's not a contest, Jerry. Be proud of what you do.

Re: A Call To All

#5

???

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

expand on "zippy undercurrent"? [ Here or in PM ]

Re: A Call To All

#6

Re: A Call To All

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well I posted a few items. There are more I could post but the problem is - and this may be how others feel - is that I do not have "Gallery Quality" photos. Mine were fine when they were posted as a build along, but now I feel more exposed as the context has changed.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Call To All

#7

Please

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

get a better camera! :D I'd really like to see some close-up details on your pieces. Wondering how you stabilized the legs on the "coopered" side table without a stretcher.

Re: A Call To All

#8

Photos..

david weaver

...getting decent photos is a problem for me, too.

Not a lot of us like to spend a bunch of time taking pictures of our stuff when we've sort of made the stuff and put the activity aside.

the two least interesting things to me in woodworking are taking pictures of your work and editing videos.

Re: A Call To All

#9

a solution?

Bill Tindall, E. TN.

Maybe a solution to the Gallery quality picture impediment is to post a picture taken in an informal setting, like the shop bench for example, or outside. Maybe the informal setting would be more compatible with a "snap shot" picture.

I recall that the Mack Headley shop does there photos of record out on the grass. In this setting the less than studio quality pictures look fine.

Re: A Call To All

#10

for example

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

nice bed from Headley shop in an informal setting


Re: A Call To All

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Gallery Quality Photos

Jack Guzman from Maine

If "gallery quality" photos were required I would never get a single picture posted. I just take as good a picture I can with my cell phone. I've never learned anything about photography. Just take a picture so others can see what you do in your shop.---Jack

Re: A Call To All

#12

Find a Friend

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

who likes to take photos (we're everywhere :D ). They'll (usually) be tickled to be asked to play with all those gadgets they've bought over the years. If there's anyone worse than woodworkers for buying the latest wizbang framus, its photographers. ;)

Re: A Call To All

#13

Disinterested

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been a regular respondent to this forum since March 2005. Few weeks have gone by without my participation in both reading the comments of others and contributing my own thoughts. I have not been interested in Galleries or Shop Shots; I do not know the distinction.

This is a serious forum on hand tools, usage and techniques, both historic and current. I realize that there is an element of Show and Tell here, but I don't think that is the main part or the important part of what goes on here. Some people seem to want to elevate their status on the forum with pictures of their work. Some people will post pictures of their work in lieu of argument, daring you to say "yes that looks very amateurish", but I think this tends to dampen discussion rather than encourage it.

Over the last ten years many important correspondents have posted little or no documentation of their work, either commercial or private; this omission has not diminished their contribution.

Re: A Call To All

#14

Re: Disinterested

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Then by all means, Warren, you shouldn't waste your time on those pages.

People with galleries are not putting up their work seeking arguments, let alone belittlement.

Mark Mandell

F&M '69

Re: A Call To All

#15

Re: ???

TomD

I don't think I can PM, but the mods can give you my email.

Re: A Call To All

#16

"PM"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

click on the email after my name and fire when ready ;)

Re: A Call To All

#17

Re: Disinterested

Michael Brady

It is my impression that many of the participants in hand tool forums do not necessarily apply their knowledge to the working of wood. As I said, that is an impression, if not necessarily a fact. It may be that they come here mostly for the sharing of tool knowledge and go elsewhere for inspiration about actually making things. Regardless, the OP seems to have answered his own query. For reasons unknown, this particular forum is the most prominent example of what I am suggesting. That is not meant to be a put-down at all. To me it suggest that the focus of this forum is more seriously devoted to tools and techniques, rather than products of same.

Re: A Call To All

#18

Tom doesn't have a profile; can't see your email

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

With your permission, Mark, I'll send your e-mail address to Tom's last known e-mail.

Re: A Call To All

#19

Ellis Walentine

Fair enough

Ellis Walentine

I appreciate Mark banging the drum for our new gallery, and I recognize that this particular forum isn't generally as much about the output of our own hand tool work as it is a celebration and often quite scholarly discussion of woodworking tools, historically and currently. If you happen to have photos of your tools or your work you would like to display for public consumption, you can either show them here on our forum, or upload them to a personal gallery in our gallery section. Otherwise, please carry on. Your erudite discussions are contributions enough and much appreciated.

Onward,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: A Call To All

#20

Re: Disinterested

JDK

Just as an aside, and forgive me for being a grammar stickler, but "disinterested" means "impartial."

I think you meant "uninterested," which means, well, not interested.

Re: A Call To All

#21

Understood

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Michael, I've met several gents who were avid, perhaps fanatical, tool collectors, and who, while fully able to go on and on about a particular tool, it uses, and provenance, would recoil in horror if you asked them if they ever used the thing or actually made something.

My post here was not meant to make a value statement about whether or not anyone on this board should be putting up work on the gallery site. I was merely making sure on all the WC woodworking boards that people know about the option. Warren and anyone here is certainly free to be not interested ["dis" or "un" or whatever works for them] in the galleries with no pejorative implication ascribed to their preference. There are many people for whom creating/making something is a very personal act which they have no intention of sharing with anyone. That too is their free choice.

Peace?

Re: A Call To All

#22

That's Fine

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

He'll get a spamBlocker notice so he should just ignore it.

Re: A Call To All

#23

Re: Disinterested

Warren in Lancaster, PA

JDK, you might study up if you really desire to be "stickler". My use of disinterested is meaning 1a in Merriam Webster. Yours is meaning 2.

According to that dictionary use of senses 1a and 1b will incur the disapproval of some who may not fully appreciate the history of this word or the subtleties of its present use.

Re: A Call To All

#24

I can't think of...

david weaver

...anyone here who doesn't make things with their hand tools, some of us do most of the work with hand tools (me) and some do all (warren), and some do all professionally for a living (warren again).

The forums that have tool collectors on them are more the types of sawmillcreek and woodnet where there are droves of beginners and some known collectors who regard themselves very highly for their curatorial knowledge (I don't personally think much of that if nothing's being made, but to each their own).

Personally, I can't think of much that motivates me less than taking pictures of what I'm making. I guess i'm about as motivated by things other people make, not really at all. We all tick for different reasons, but so far this year I have made two planes, taken video of making one of them, made a book case, and part of a kitchen cabinet. The only thing keeping me from making more is time in the shop and sleeping kids overhead.

Personally, I'd like to go ape and make a plane a day for 6 months, but reality doesn't allow. Why am I not motivated by what other people are making? I make things like cabinets and cases to meet needs, and I make planes because I am head over heels enthusiastic about them, but I don't take a picture of every one of those, either, because....who else shares my enthusiasm about making various double iron planes?

What I appreciate in droves is talk from Warren and folks like George Wilson (George doesn't post here because he has trouble following the format, which is a real shame), and I don't know about Warren's productivity (if he's able to pay the bills, I'm sure it's fine), but I've never seen anyone close to the volume of fine work George had done before George retired. Like I mentioned, no offense to people who like to take pictures of their work, but advice from George and warren is worth more to me than seeing furniture that people made. The only furniture that has really struck me was the gorgeous stuff that wiley presented not long prior, and that is rare.

Re: A Call To All

#25

Re: Disinterested *LINK*

JDK

Sorry, but I don't agree. This is a very controversial subject, and we are on opposite sides. Here is a site that supports my position. There are many others as well:


Disinterested vs. Uninterested