New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

A Call To All

Posts

Re: A Call To All

#51

Ellis Walentine

My take on this

Ellis Walentine

Whew, what role does the forum play? Well, speaking for myself, it is the raison d'être of this website. Long ago, I grasped that there are fundamentally two kinds of people online -- the ones who relish real-time conversations, instant feedback, thoughtful discussion, and cameraderie, and those who are happy to browse the archives, read the articles and enjoy the static content more than the personal interactions. It's sorta like the difference between type A & B personalities.

I happen to fall into the former category. To me the forum is a place where people can come for a variety of viewpoints on a given topic, where they can get helpful feedback on any question in practically real time. Some people don't care for the diversity of opinion on a messageboard, but I regard it more highly than the singular opinion of a particular author or contributor, like you see with books and magazines and blogs and YouTube channels. Here, the voices reinforce and sometimes negate each other, but it gives people a "look around" as I'm fond of saying. You still have to make your own decision as to whose advice works best for you, but at least you have the option of considering other aspects of a topic that you probably never considered.

As with any community, there are people of all different abilities and experience, and they have widely different personalities and abilities to communicate -- some hypersensitive, some tone-deaf, some egalitarian, some selfish, everyone with their own demons and hot buttons. We either indulge and accept each other or not; we choose whose opinions we value. If we concentrate on being cordial and informative, it will contribute mightily to a friendly and worthwhile environment. Acceptance is key, not motives and agendas.

Ellis

Re: A Call To All

#52

Re: Bullying

david weaver

I posted that bookshelf at the urging of Bill, who to his credit was just trying to get some flow on the board. I did so reluctantly, because, well, it's not something I'm even that motivated to make let alone share.

That's not to say I haven't gotten a great deal of harassment on forums sometimes because I don't really get cranked up about taking pictures of things in process (it's really the last thing I want to do when I've had enough woodworking for the evening)

I could've shared thoughts that were more useful than the pictures, I think:

* even for commodity type home work, like a beat-up bookshelf that's going to go in a kid's room, I think it's worth making out of solid wood

* I think it's worth using reasonable joints

* I think it's worth cutting T&G boards for the back rather than just sliding in a piece of ply, which I could easily do as I've got gobs of it around for the stalled process kitchen cabinets

* I think it's worth cutting some mouldings by hand and beading the trim on the front

* I think it's worth putting a finish on that can be easily refreshed and repaired

It is a bare minimum effort that will still look reasonably handsome, especially in a kid's room.

Text means more than the pictures. It's not a gallery item, it is the bits and pieces of information that someone like me (an amateur) can glean from the Warrens, Georges, etc. about what is pleasing to the eye and without being gaudy or resorting to a bunch of external joints like the gross and grosser style or arts and crafts. (I'm sure that sentiment is not shared by all).

I worked wood for four years gawking at the pictures in the FWW gallery section, etc, before I made a saw one day and put it on a forum and George Wilson said "you made a good effort, but here's how it could be better next time". The discussion of simple design principles and training eyes, and warren's discussion of the double iron that prompted me to finally be able to make a capable wooden plane that would help me work by hand and not compromise on the accuracy of my dimensioning. I doubt many people who like to glance at other peoples' work have gotten nearly so much from these forums as I have, but I realize that I am not wired like most other people, and that's fine. I will do what I do with or without forum galleries, and when I come upon something that I think is important enough to share, I suppose I will make videos or something because, like the very long drawn out videos I made recently on a double iron plane, there are probably 10,000 people who would watch the videos if I took time to edit them and take out a lot of the details. There are probably 50 people who would watch a video that is in real time with discussion so that they can dig deep in the details. I can't do without it (the context, the discussion, the reasons), a picture just won't do.

I see many people who started woodworking while I did who are still debating things that people should be past after their first year of woodworking.

As far as credibility, I can judge that based on whether someone's advice works. Warren talks about the double iron. It works. Better than a single iron if you are willing to learn it. I can take George's design advice, it works, and not in a sense of just correcting the item I'm making now, but applying it to generalized situations.

I don't begrudge anyone who feels differently, nor do I expect anyone else to adopt my opinions, and as long as everyone else is the same way in regard to that much, I'm perfectly happy to be motivated to do other things, and perfectly motivated to not get off my rear on a sunny day just to rush my planes or case work or blanket chests outside for pictures.

Re: A Call To All

#53

A little light humor...

david weaver

>>a "serious" armature photographer<<

Does this guy work in a factory where they make electric motors? :) :b

Re: A Call To All

#54

I've said it before......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I should not type early in the AM without my glasses. But, I don't take my advice. Its too good to correct so I will just leave it as mis-written (putting on my glasses to see that this effort might be correct.

PS I don't do dovetails in early AM!

Re: A Call To All

#55

Resizing

John in NM

Wiley, I use gimp for resizing, it's quite easy.

The only caveat now is, if you do want to install it, beware of un-official downloads, get the windows port only from the gimp.org site. There was discussion on the main board last week about malware sites hijacking some of these opensource downloads.

Alternatively, I'll do it for you if you run into trouble. I'm sitting at a desk for another six full days, so I'd have plenty of time for it :D

Re: A Call To All

#56

Taking issue with one statement

John in NM

I have to say, it strikes me as laughable that anyone is spending an inordinate amount of time making things for the purpose of gaining status on the forums. That is just my opinion of course, but I don't think any of us are doing this.

We build because we enjoy it and either desire the end product or desire the income from it (if one is so lucky or good at marketing). Raking in kudos from an internet forum has little to do with motivation for building stuff for me, and I assume it is the same for others. Perhaps this is some motivation for posting pictures of work, but not for building it in the first place.

There is certainly a personality conflict or two around here, but I won't criticize those disagreements, having been guilty of such behavior myself now and then. All I can say is that perspective and regret over past disagreements leads me to make more of an effort to avoid them in the future. It requires effort.

Re: A Call To All

#57

For what it's worth...

John in NM

Like Bill H, I've been doing things that seem less appropriate to the gallery, so I only have a few pics of furniture from before I moved in 2005.

I do have a scan of one of the most aesthetically hideous pieces I ever made, maybe I'll post it with the back story as a cautionary tale :D I wish I had a pic of the most technically hideous piece I ever made - it was the workbench that always came back to haunt me, a conglomeration of 2x4's, plywood, and bad ideas :D

Up until 2009 or so, I was mostly doing carpentry work, almost no furniture. Since then I've been making gunstocks of one particular pattern that I sell. Maybe I'll post a pic or two of those, though I'm often a bit wary of doing so in a broad audience.

Re: A Call To All

#58

Re: I don't know about the forums..

david weaver

...but there are definitely bloggers and writers who never let the opportunity to paste their stuff everywhere.

I recall talking to George about the same thing, but I mentioned a tractor writer who I won't name, vs. an expert of the highest order, JR Hobbs, who spent most of his time researching and only wrote absolutely definitive material. Hobbs would have writers try to buddy up to him just long enough to write a book, get it factually incorrect in picture captions and comments, and then move on to something else. (i missed the point of mentioning George - George described a few writers to me who make things only to advertise courses or to try to sell books).

I do think that there's certainly reluctance from people to post their stuff because they feel it's not good enough, and I recall a while ago that Pam mentioned that she was not going to post further pictures because of the way she felt after other people offered their two cents. I think either of those is fine. Pam is not inexperienced and has been around quite a while, but others might be inexperienced. There is the promise now, and Tom touched on it, that you can take a class or buy something and make something great because of it, and I think that does woodworkers a disservice in terms of recognizing where they are on the scale of learning. The only thing I can think of where I'd like to get good at building things is planes, and I will pick up guitars in a year or two, and at the 8th bench plane, which is really about my 20th plane in general, I still don't have one the way I'd like it to be 100%, but my fiddles with issues are small. I have made better planes than I can generally buy without spending hours to find one in vintage unused condition, and then some more hours to correct fit issues due to age.

I'm getting off topic here, I've posted some pictures of planes and when I was making saws, those, too, knowing they weren't that great, but knowing also that they were a necessary step in trying to build some that are great (I hope I can build great ones soon - I have no clue what to do with them, but I know I like to build them).

There is no shame for anyone who wants to share things in posting pictures when you are trying to get better at something. Receiving advice, especially on aesthetics (the mechanical things come just with experience), is the best thing about this forum.

I do believe that there are plenty of people with a bit of an exhibitionist flair, though, who are itching to photograph and share their work. I'm not wired like that unless I think someone is missing out on things (I personally think the entire wooden plane market is missing the mark except for one person, but even then I expect that nobody is going to believe me that they're missing things).

I think the exhibitionist thing exists a lot more in the turning forums, though, and that's OK. A lot of us are wired differently than turners, too.

Re: A Call To All

#59

You may well be right about bloggers...

John in NM

And professional authors. I don't really know much about either, since I don't read blogs and have hardly bought books in 12 years or so. I do like books however.

Blogs tend to irritate me for some reason - like youtube vids I end up wanting to shout "sum up!" at the computer :D

But I really meant only to refer to posters around here. Really not even other forums, since this is the only WW'ing forum I frequent.

Honestly, I've not read much of this thread either - been busy trying (and failing) to fix mom's computer. Now I'm at work and thus a captive audience :D

Re: A Call To All

#60

I shouldn't have raised the alarm!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

John,

Thank you very much for the offer. It turned out that my worries were unfounded. Ellis' Gallery was very easy to use. It did not argue with my image size, which I'm pretty sure exceeded his recommendation.

Thanks again,

Wiley

Re: A Call To All

#61

Re: You may well be right about bloggers...

david weaver

I think you're right that there doesn't seem to be much exhibitionist posting on here. The discussion is very in depth and the pictures sparse.

I kind of like it that way though others don't.

I figure most of the people who look at my plane video won't make it past the layout of the plane. I have the same problem watching other peoples' videos when the topics are something I'm "not that interested" in actually seeing.

That's the watching other people work or looking for the summary kind of thing. But when the video is something I want to see, like paper patching bullets, I don't want the 2 minute version. I want to hear every detail the experienced maker and shooter of their own bullets has to give.

Re: A Call To All

#62

Interesting, again...

John in NM

I'm just the opposite when it comes to woodworking and similar pursuits - I get far more from a picture than prose. I have books that I've never read, just looked at all the pictures (there has got to be a joke in there somewhere).

In the case of something like reloading, I find written discussions to be more useful than anything else, probably because I can bookmark or even cut and paste the useful parts and refer to them quickly to find the spec or technique I want.

You must be on the Cast Boolits forum if you're interesting in paper patching :D I've been meaning to do some of that, but I have to empty some commercial brass first :D I thought I was going to snag about 500# of dead soft lead, but it's looking like that fell through. Ah well.

Videos really need editing to be watchable. All the ones I've seen that were any good were edited, or at the very, very least, scripted. Scripting at least can make for a more organized presentation, vital for keeping the viewers' interest.

I have zero patience for a guy hemming and hawing when I can't ask questions! :D Somehow it's different in conversation.

Re: A Call To All

#63

Re: Not a bullet caster...

david weaver

..but at some point soon, I'm going to be one out of thrift. Thus the need for either paper patching or hard casting, and I think I prefer paper patch.

I've had a long layoff from shooting because of young kids and no time, but I've had enough of that...and have spent the last week trying to convince my wife that I *need* one of the 1874 sharps replicas (thus the interest also in paper patch).

Re: A Call To All

#64

Um Wiley . .?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

What did you do to that poor pussy cat's ears!? You'll have PETA down on us in no-time :D

Re: A Call To All

#65

Re: Not a bullet caster...

John in NM

You can patch hard cast too, and as far as I understand it, push and un-checked cast bullet as fast as jacketed. One of my favorite rifles is a 1908 vintage 1894 in 32 special. I'm eager to see if it shoots patched lead as straight as jacketed factory loads.

I started casting because I'm cheap, cheap, cheap. Then I got distracted by life and work - clearly you know how that goes :D - and when I got back to it one of the panics was on and there was no lead to be found, no primers and no powder. That stuff seems to be all available again (at least rifle powders are), so I'm planning to do a bit soon.

Re: A Call To All

#66

Re: Um Wiley . .?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Mark,

Scottish fold cats have a genetic flaw that affects their ear cartilage. In fact, if you double up on the 'fold' gene, things get very bad indeed. So breeders breed folded to eared, and get half folded/half eared in the litter, so the folded animals are hetero and viable. Yadda yadda....I don't believe the Euros even allow crosses like this. But Scottish folds are nice creatures.

Wiley

Re: A Call To All

#68

Jack Guzman from Maine

Please share your work.

Jack Guzman from Maine

The only reason I posted pictures to the gallery is because I want to encourage others to. I want to see what you are building. I love the gallery section of woodworking magazines. No ulterior motives.I just like looking at woodworking done by other people.I already know what my stuff looks like. Please share your work.---Jack

Re: A Call To All

#69

Contact TomD

Kenneth Reidy

Hi,

I am trying to contact TomD regarding Mahogany Masterpiece"s catalog.

Many thanks,

Ken Reidy

Albuquerque, NM

Re: A Call To All

#70

Exactly!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Forums are filled with people of diverse interests, a wide range of skills, and different preferences for learning.

I come here for a range of reasons, not the least because of the camaraderie and the opportunity to share experiences and insights with others. My preferential method of learning is visual, and I get a lot from seeing the work that others produce. I accept that others may do it differently.

Posting work on the Gallery is a wonderful opportunity to retain a record of the work completed - where the creative juices ended up. My only regret is that there are too few build-alongs on the forum since - as David alluded to in his plane videos - it is the small details that really count. I find it interesting that some see a dark side to posting photos - what an fascinating fantasy life you must live in!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Call To All

#71

Very nice, wiley!!

david weaver

I don't usually love the look of anything greene and green style with exposed tails, but your pieces look quite nice, even to my end grain skeptical eyes! :)

Kitty seems to approve, too. Really excellent stuff.

Re: A Call To All

#72

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"My only regret is that there are too few build-alongs on the forum since "

I have a build (slooooowly) going on the main board. I presume anyone that visits the Hand Tool Forum also visits the other Forum. And, since my builds are mixed hand tool-power tool the other Forum is the place to post what I am building.

Any reason to cross post? If so, exactly what?

Re: A Call To All

#73

I am hopeful.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

someone will post a china cabinet on the Gallery. I need inspiration that has eluded me for some time.

I am not claiming that I had any influence, but for some time I have pestered anyone that might provide it to offer a place to post work. My motivation is inspiration. I keep a picture file of stuff I have seen that I like that I might want to make something like it some day ( Microscoft SNIP is a wonderful tool). I have all the design books Tauton published for the same reason. I post my stuff, warts and all, with the thought that someone might be inspired from it and do better, or just do.

Re: A Call To All

#74

Re: Question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill

I apologise ... I do not often visit the other forums on WC. I have missed your build. (Which I shall now rectify).

I imagine that there are very few here that use only handtools. I have and use power tools for basic preparation. No excuses other than I am now 65 and hoping to preserve my body a while longer. In any event, this does not prevent me from still considering myself a handtool user first and foremost. Consequently, I post on the handtool forum, mentioning where power was used, but focussing specifically on the handtool use.

I plan to begin another big build soon (it is just too hot to work in the workshop for long at present), a complex cabinet build that I will share, partly for advise along the way, and partly as there will be components that I expect to interest others - curved panels and fitted curved dovetailed drawers. I have done none of these before and, as with previous builds, there is the constant risk of sudden failure. This is part of the "fun". Anyway, I shall keep it on the Handtools forum.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Call To All

#75

Re: Very nice, wiley!!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

Thank you! I know what you mean about end grain; I feel that way myself. My working hypothesis was that it has to not look like end grain. Be that as it may, the thing is done, and it is what it is. I'm going to start a thread on some things I learned from doing that chiffonier.

On a different topic, it occurred to me last night sometime--to late to post--that it would be useful if you would consider making a gallery of your planes. I find the style very, very good, and I very much like wooden try planes and am always interested in comparing styles. Yet these objects scroll off the bottom of the page, and it's work to dig them back up again. Result being, you just don't do it. Plus, individual makers tend to change their styles somewhat over time--there are at least two styles of closed handles on my C&W planes--it kept evolving as they came across new examples. Yours likely will too. Just a thought, and you don't need to speak to it right now, but my strong opinion is that it would be a good service to the group (and maybe even for your own reference!) if you would post your planes in one place where they can be found.

Thanks again, Wiley