Re: Bullying
david weaver
I posted that bookshelf at the urging of Bill, who to his credit was just trying to get some flow on the board. I did so reluctantly, because, well, it's not something I'm even that motivated to make let alone share.
That's not to say I haven't gotten a great deal of harassment on forums sometimes because I don't really get cranked up about taking pictures of things in process (it's really the last thing I want to do when I've had enough woodworking for the evening)
I could've shared thoughts that were more useful than the pictures, I think:
* even for commodity type home work, like a beat-up bookshelf that's going to go in a kid's room, I think it's worth making out of solid wood
* I think it's worth using reasonable joints
* I think it's worth cutting T&G boards for the back rather than just sliding in a piece of ply, which I could easily do as I've got gobs of it around for the stalled process kitchen cabinets
* I think it's worth cutting some mouldings by hand and beading the trim on the front
* I think it's worth putting a finish on that can be easily refreshed and repaired
It is a bare minimum effort that will still look reasonably handsome, especially in a kid's room.
Text means more than the pictures. It's not a gallery item, it is the bits and pieces of information that someone like me (an amateur) can glean from the Warrens, Georges, etc. about what is pleasing to the eye and without being gaudy or resorting to a bunch of external joints like the gross and grosser style or arts and crafts. (I'm sure that sentiment is not shared by all).
I worked wood for four years gawking at the pictures in the FWW gallery section, etc, before I made a saw one day and put it on a forum and George Wilson said "you made a good effort, but here's how it could be better next time". The discussion of simple design principles and training eyes, and warren's discussion of the double iron that prompted me to finally be able to make a capable wooden plane that would help me work by hand and not compromise on the accuracy of my dimensioning. I doubt many people who like to glance at other peoples' work have gotten nearly so much from these forums as I have, but I realize that I am not wired like most other people, and that's fine. I will do what I do with or without forum galleries, and when I come upon something that I think is important enough to share, I suppose I will make videos or something because, like the very long drawn out videos I made recently on a double iron plane, there are probably 10,000 people who would watch the videos if I took time to edit them and take out a lot of the details. There are probably 50 people who would watch a video that is in real time with discussion so that they can dig deep in the details. I can't do without it (the context, the discussion, the reasons), a picture just won't do.
I see many people who started woodworking while I did who are still debating things that people should be past after their first year of woodworking.
As far as credibility, I can judge that based on whether someone's advice works. Warren talks about the double iron. It works. Better than a single iron if you are willing to learn it. I can take George's design advice, it works, and not in a sense of just correcting the item I'm making now, but applying it to generalized situations.
I don't begrudge anyone who feels differently, nor do I expect anyone else to adopt my opinions, and as long as everyone else is the same way in regard to that much, I'm perfectly happy to be motivated to do other things, and perfectly motivated to not get off my rear on a sunny day just to rush my planes or case work or blanket chests outside for pictures.