New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

A Call To All

Posts

Re: A Call To All

#26

I can't either

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Michael Brady writes

It is my impression that many of the participants in hand tool forums do not necessarily apply their knowledge to the working of wood.

Does he actually read this forum? I can't think of any regular contributor who does not work wood.

Re: A Call To All

#27

Language is something of a moving target, eh?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Trying to pin down the exact meaning of a word for all time is impossible. There are countless words in English that now mean the exact opposite of what they meant originally.

"Disinterested" has been useful in legal terminology for years as a term referring tot someone with no interest* in the subject, in the sense of no dog in the fight. This is different from "uninterested," as in doesn't care (think teenage apathy).

But the vernacular meanings of those two words have been headed toward collision for a while now. Darn it, as the distinction between the two can be quite helpful.

----------

*"Interest" itself has a distinct meaning in the law.

Re: A Call To All

#28

Re: Language is something of a moving target, eh?

TomD

That is the PG version, very nicely said, of what is happening. I like to ask whether one use or the other will rob the language of the ability to convey meaning it might otherwise have. But usually the dumbing down continues and one may have to dive in if one wants to remain heard. I find that very "concerning", not to mention "ironic".

"Very concerning" is a particular gem as it seems to orignate from the need of a dullard to talk above his brain grade. Based on the reality that if what you say can't be understood, and you hold a prominent job, then you sound intelligent. I got a just desert no doubt when a very smart great aunt told me she had seen me interviewed on TV on some financial mater. She said I was great, though she didn't understand a word I had said...

Re: A Call To All

#29

Re: Disinterested

TomD

"It is my impression that many of the participants in hand tool forums do not necessarily apply their knowledge to the working of wood."

Hard to say. I think there are a few things that contribute to that:

One is that this is the most narrowly focused forum. The main forum is just called Messages. Even Turning, and Photography are wider in scope. This is a place to come talk about hand tools.

When I started out the idea was that one used whatever tool would do the job, and it was exciting to know that hand tools were actually superior in many but not all realms. While now the idea is more that hand tools are an exclusive set, though most of us actually use all kinds of tools. On Sawmill they have the neanderthal forum. It is like joining a group that re-enacts battles. I like the idea of FKs that hand work is production. Or of Krenov and others that hand tools allow results that can't be had with other tools. I don't know whether even people so inclined would post here if they ran most of the project through machines also.

Projects on the other hand, don't really tell us about people's skills. There are spectacular first projects, all over the place. That is the promise of the hobby, make professional looking stuff without any skill.

Re: A Call To All

#30

Re: Disinterested

TomD

Actually, now that hand tools are better understood, that is also the promise of hand tools, if you can sharpen, you can leverage an edge so that it will do almost anything, and you will not require skill. Freehand carving excluded.

Re: A Call To All

#31

Re: Please

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'd really like to see some close-up details on your pieces. Wondering how you stabilized the legs on the "coopered" side table without a stretcher.

Hi Mark

There were many, many details in the build-alongs I did a few years ago. It is an interesting issue, one that I alluded to in my previous comment. The details of a build drive the presentation on the forum and, by the time the piece is complete, all those who watched and commented were intimately involved enough to see past a poor photo. I have many pieces but few photos of them that display/capture them as I would wish in one frame.

The question why one posts build alongs is another matter altogether. I think I will deal with this in a separate post.

The end table legs began life as doors I was building for a long cabinet. Along the way I decided to change tracks. The coopered panels were held by curved frames ..


They developed to ...


The build starts here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/Sideboard-EntertainmentCentre.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Call To All

#32

Got That But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Having done a few coopered pieces myself, I understand your method, but was asking how you keep the legs from racking side-to-side without a stretcher. Is the curved joint with the top enough to hold the leg sets rigid or is the drawer actually part of the structure?

Re: A Call To All

#33

Re: Running Most of the Project Through Machines

david weaver

If I had to run my projects mostly through machines saving only the joints for hand tools (which is a popular thing), I can say for sure I wouldn't be doing any woodworking. It's completely uninteresting to me. I would definitely then not be posting.

The hurdle is that when you're new, changing the size and shape of wood with hand tools takes a long time, and you don't have the accuracy to take much risk (catastrophe results often if you do). So we end up getting "advice" from a bunch of people who insist that if you use only hand tools, you can't do anything because they can't.

The tone of this thread suggests that this forum is obsessed with doing something with tools that has nothing to do with making anything, which I think is pretty ridiculous. (Of course, you didn't say that, but it's otherwise being suggested). I guess it extends from the gaggle of bloggers who can't work efficiently with hand tools telling everyone else they can't. I'm reminded of a Chris Schwarz post years ago from when I read his blog for a short period of time where he couldn't even handsaw the end of a bench top off, and it was cherry and not particularly wide.

If people think they can't make anything with hand tools and thus we don't, that's fine. I wish they'd keep out of our forum if that's the case. They can continue to read blogs written by amateurs who have as far as I've seen never made anything of note, and comment in the sections of those blogs with like-minded folks.

Re: A Call To All

#34

Re: Got That But

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Mark

The ends of the stretchers were compound mitres - tapering in two directions.

These were approximately 4 1/2" to 5" deep, from memory. They were connected to the frames of the coopered panels with splines. The inside angles were then reinforced with fitted blocks.


This was very solid, and made more so when the top was connected with mounting blocks at each end.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Call To All

#35

Re: Got That

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

So the drawer-front is hiding the stretchers in the gallery image. Figured something like that but had to ask. Thanks

Re: A Call To All

#36

Re: That's Fine

TomD

I sent it to you and it came back and I just ignored it.

Re: A Call To All

#37

I got it

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

and sent you a response. Thanks for the input. Valued ;)

Re: A Call To All

#38

Re: A Call To All

TomD

Some folks really do us proud on the photos. I think I counted 8 places that one could add photos. There really isn't any downside to asking for more photos:

- In the sense that people will often comply and add a photographic detail.

- Also in the freeloading sense that if you are in the 10-1 ratio of readers to writers, why not ask for more colourful content, you aren't going to be put out to provide it.

- And in the sense that if you don't like to write, maybe you do take photographs and could include yourself in that way. A photographer should never think they are lessor than a writter, it is the photos that sell the text.

Or so I am told. I would be interested to know what the ideal content mix would be from a pro like Ellis. I know he wouldn't publish (think I know) all these dry scratchings in a magazine. What would the mix of content be in a real magazine. If we were paid "writers", what would be the percent mix of photos to text.

Re: A Call To All

#39

Ellis Walentine

Images to text

Ellis Walentine

Very perceptive, Tom. Yes, in magazine world there are many calculi regarding balance of "art" to "copy." Each book has its own formula, based on who they think (or know) is reading their stuff. This is why "who is the reader?" was always our biggest concern. It comes down to communicating what you want to communicate in the best way that will interest and edify the reader. It's not only the percentage of art to copy, but also things like attitude (don't talk down), points of entry (how and where can I enter this page of information -- photos, subheds, charts, sidebars, illustrations...), and even reading level. Most woodworking magazines are written at about an 8th grade reading level, which is common in many mainstream magazines. Scholarly journals like SAPFM tend to feature higher reading levels.

It is our job as communicators to say what we want to say in a way that is best understood by the target reader(s). Photos and illustrations can often be worth the proverbial thousand words, but every communication will ultimately be a compromise, like any design problem, with tradeoffs in efficiency, clarity and economy. The nice thing about discussion forums is that the reader can ask questions as they arise and the original poster can fill in the blanks on the fly.

Ellis

Re: A Call To All

#40

Credibility.....

roger lance

I find myself living at a time when I cannot trust the guy who reads me the national nightly news because he has a tendency to embellish and misremember events. When I'm involved in some military veteran activity, it has become all to common to find people engaging in various forms of "stolen valor" which is a sad thing to encounter.

In this world/forum of woodworking, there are people like me who are amateurs of minor accomplishment.....but they readily display their work as I have done and will continue to do. There are also some very accomplished woodworkers here who have shown project build after project build without ever referring to themselves as being of a higher level. When these people make a comment, they have credibility based not only on their words but also on their deeds.

Perhaps it is just me.....and I take no pleasure in saying this.....but If you are regarded as some kind of expert in woodworking, I don't understand why you would not share images of your work with us.

Re: A Call To All

#41

Here because it has to be somewhere - calming down

Folks could have a number of reasons not to post their work - maybe someone once copied a piece on which they had copyright and sold it as their own, maybe (like me for the past decade) the work they're doing is less shop work and more carpentry, could be lotsa reasons.

Yes, there are people whose shop is a shrine to the tools, not the work. As long as the person is aware that s/he is collecting, not making, there's nothing inherently wrong with this. But I don't think there are many such folks here. What I see is a community of people very busy doing whatever they do and dropping in here for a break from the doing of it to respond to questions; make jokes, bad (my hand goes up) or good; etc.

If you think someone's shooting bull, probably the best response is not to read his/her posts (I can promise, as a moderator, that none of the statements made here will be on the final exam, so you can ignore whatever doesn't suit your interests). You could be right about the bull, in which case you haven't wasted your time; or you could be wrong, in which case calling him/her out could embarrass you, and certainly reduces the civil discourse here.

So let's bring this back to Mark's original intent in posting: encouraging folks who are doing work of which they're proud, and who don't have business/artistic/personal reasons not to share that work, to put up pictures of the work. The pictures don't have to be professional-grade, although there are some simple steps to improve quality, like reducing the background to something simple and using a decent camera of point-&-shoot quality or better. But I, for one, enjoy seeing what people are doing, and am awestruck, humbled, and inspired by it.

Re: A Call To All

#42

Here Because There's No Better Place- calming down

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Thanks Bill; you state it simply.

Lest we forget, this is WoodCentral, the place on the NET where diverse interests meld in civilized manner; that carries on the experiment started by Wayne Miller so many years ago.

To be sure, all here (meaning on each board) should feel welcome and accepted regardless of how they choose to participate (or not participate, for that matter). My OP sought people to get involved in the gallery experiment. That can be done by posting images. It can be done by posting comments to others' work. It can be done by simply going and looking at what's there.

But people who go to galleries are not, somehow, better than those who don't, regardless of whether they hold their drink with four fingers.

Let's not get into the adversarial rut of the "prove it!" kind of situation. In case you forgot, nobody here has been appointed keeper of the One True Faith. We can each make our own value judgments with regard to comments made or positions asserted and expressed on these boards without feeling the compulsion to hit the caps lock to tell the world that "that guy is in need of a high colonic" or such.

Re: A Call To All

#43

Re: Here Because There's No Better Place- calming

David Dalzell

Well I guess I am one of those amateurs of no great importance who do enjoy woodworking and giving my pieces to people (mostly family) who will enjoy them. It give me great pleasure to both build one of a kind pieces and to give those pieces to those that I love. I have posted on other woodworking forums, and have, from time to time posted pictures of my work. I have not done so on this forum; and in fact have never before posted anything on this forum. However, this thread alone absolutely discourages me from ever wanting to post any pictures of my work here. This may not be fully justified, but I usually go with my gut feel.

David Dalzell (High Sierra mountains of California)

Re: A Call To All

#44

Unfortunate, David

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hope you reconsider, and consider showing us your stuff in a gallery.

Re: A Call To All

#45

Re: A Call To All

Patrick Gibbons

I appreciate having the gallery section brought back to my attention. I had planned on contributing but I've been so busy in my work and family life that I've had little time to check in at Wood Central, let alone go out and build something. I'm surprised at the increased level of animosity I notice here lately. When my schedule balances out I'm going to do something. In the meantime I want to see what others are doing. I like hand tool woodworking. Do I need any other credentials?

Re: A Call To All

#46

Re: A Call To All

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

Well, after mulling it over, Mark has snapped me out of my customary inertia. Excuse #1: I always have problems down-sizing photos as I am a computer numbie. Overcoming Excuse #1: I started pulling out photos today, will scan them tomorrow, and start putting something together.

Wiley

P. S. I don't put any value judgment on anyone who doesn't want to post photos. That's their business, and they don't need to state a reason.

Re: A Call To All

#47

Re: Credibility.....

TomD

I will take a crack at that. First, why should one care if others feel one has credibility? None of us are paid. Nor for the most part known, in the sense that I would recognize anyone other than Ellis If I passed them on the street. if a person goes to the trouble of putting something out there, I consider it. Most of the stuff that is talked about here is at a level where it doesn't make any difference to me whether it is right or wrong. If I look up what is the Tylenol dosage for a 100 pound child, it would be nice if the info I found was correct. There have been masses of stimulating threads here, but not a single thing that has added a point to my woodworking score. It's just fun and educational.

I think the concern with people's credentials is limiting, because it means you don't have to think, you just have to subscribe. If someone makes a great cabinet, does that make them equally an expert on every single aspect of every single topic? Obviously not. The lazy folks who want to subscribe will still have to figure that one out, and devise new tests. Meanwhile, I remain unconvinced that one should put a large effort into appealing to the reguard of people who are unwilling to put in the effort to think for themselves.

Re: A Call To All

#48

Re: Images to text

TomD

Thanks Ellis, obviously a lot to it. Entry points. Fascinating stuff.

One other thing. And be forthright, if kind. What roll do the forums play on a website like yours? I sometimes think of it as content, in the sense a paid article is content. When I produced a lot of "content" I sometimes felt, (truly) very slightly entitled. So maybe I didn't do other things like pay for a higher membership level, because I was providing "content". But I sorta assume that isn't true. We are like unhearble cats. I think Wooden boat is a wonderful magazine subject aside. A model. But they have an off topic forum I would pay not to be associated with. Maybe if we knew our true place we would behave better, but it is probably a question that should not be aired in public. Where does one learn this stuff?

Re: A Call To All

#49

Bullying

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think there is some bullying going on here. On January 15 David Weaver posted pictures of a bookshelf after months of pitiful accusations that he never made anything. A valuable asset to this forum was actually being constantly demeaned. To anybody who read his posts seriously his experience and expertise were already apparent. On January 23 Wiley Horne's post about dovetails was met with a call for photographic documentation as if his integrity were in question.

For some of us this is a serious forum about hand tool use, not a club for show and tell. Many important contributors in the past have offered no pictures of their woodworking; David Barnett, Pam Niedermayer, and Todd Hughes come to mind. And frankly I wonder if some people don't spend an inordinate amount of time making things for the purpose of gaining status on the forums.

Re: A Call To All

#50

Picture sizing for dummies

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Faced with dealing with pictures I asked a "serious" armature photographer what to do, that a novice can cope with at no cost. He provided some simple steps, easily recorded in a notebook, that will size, crop and render crisp a photo for posting either with the 100KB limit for here, or a larger limit for the Gallery. I find it no impediment to process a dozen pictures for a progress report on a build, or to post Gallery pictures that might entertain or inspire someone to build something.

Taking the picture shown as an example:

4 clicks to size it to what ever size one wants

4 clicks to sharpen the image

3 clicks to custom crop it as desired

4 clicks to store it

The result is not as good as Ellis could do in PhotoShop but it is adequate for the need. I do not let perfection prevent accomplishing something adequately.

Only 4 decision inputs are required, specify size, decide to sharpen or not, define crop area, specify file name for storage. These are trivial tasks compared to ensuring the reliability of the LA water system.

If anyone wants to learn what was done email me and I wills send directions. The program used is Irfanview.