Re: Thanks for the review
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Bit slow in getting to that one, Charlie. Burning out?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Thanks for the review
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Bit slow in getting to that one, Charlie. Burning out?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Thanks for the review
Charles Stanford
These paragraph indentations are hell on my old eyes. Yours?
Re: The Veritas Shooting Plane - Reviewed
Charles Stanford
I don't think design consultants should review their own work, especially when it involves comparisons to other manufacturers' products. The end result is entirely predictable.
I think a review of a shooting board plane should cover a shot board or two.
Quibbles?
Re: The Veritas Shooting Plane - Reviewed
Tony Zaffuto
I've known Derek, through the web for years. I've known Rob Lee through seeing him at tool sales, etc. through the years also (our talk, though, is mainly hockey). I have the utmost respect for each of these gentlemen.
A few years ago, Rob asked me if I would like to "test run" a tool or two. My reply is that I don't have the discipline to perform a test usage in the manner where usable advice could be given. I also added that I'm a "ham fisted amateur" anyways and guys like Derek have demonstrated through pictures posted online of how advanced many of them are.
I'm sure, Charles, that if you are agreeable, that Rob Lee would let you do a "test run" in the future (however, that is between you and Rob). In my humble opinion, I appreciate the posted reports Derek puts up (and I do remember the reports in years past by Lynn and Brent Beach, along with the criticism they also received). Owning a manufacturing plant, I can understand comments Rob made about length of time it will take to recoup development costs of a product such as this. My comment back is "how can you do it at this price point". We're lucky to have the woodworking community that we do, including the caliber of suppliers.
Stanford deserves a compliment here
Bruce McCrory
Without him, we would know less of our shared respect for the person who seems a tireless volunteer to amateur woodworking. That Mr. Cohen is polite in the face of adversity shows another character trait.
No apologies for the deviation from topic.
Ciao..
Re: The Veritas Shooting Plane - Reviewed
Curt Putnam
On all the websites I read that have had this review posted some troll has piped up and proceeded try and trash you and Rob Lee on both a technical and personal basis. I have had the privilege of meeting and talking to Rob Lee for quite some time. I've not met Derek in person but have corresponded with him a little and have read most or all of his website content.
Rob Lee runs a company that is incredibly wonderful to deal with. It would not be that way if were not in the core of both Leonard and Rob. Look at what hey do with some of the profit. It goes into a foundation that provides research money for some pretty wonderful medical devices. It's evident from Derek's writings that he is very much the same type of very ethical person.
Since the review is written personal opinion (rather than a peer reviewed article of rigorous scientific research) it is impossible to attack. One can carp about it, but hey, everybody is entitled to their opinion. It is the personal attack that is detestable. In my opinion, Rob & Derek are among the finest members of the woodworking community. Two people who constantly make positive contributions to our little world do not deserve the calumny being hurled at them by these trolls. I do not know why these trolls seek to hurt two of our finest but the reasons cannot stand up to reality.
I am sorry about this overlong rant; I just wanted to add my voice to the support for and thanks to the both of them - for all their contributions.
Re: The Veritas Shooting Plane - Reviewed
David Silverson
Usually when I see the name Charles Stanford attached to a post I realize that is the end to any reasonable discussion of the thread's content and move on.I'm surprised many still bite.
Re: On arrows
Tom
Charles, some of my first work was in retail, and back in the 70s-80s hiring retail clerks was about as easy as reforming heretics. They paid 3.50 an hour and people willing to work for that and having any product knowledge to speak of, were normally highly critical of products and looking for reasons not to buy stuff. We were the front line workers for the industry and projected our dislike of buying stuff to anyone we met hoping they would trust us, and maybe buy something... I remember one of my mentors passing on the idea that some people actually wanted to spend money and buy stuff, something I though of as a radical idea. As time went by I realized that for many people the activity was the buying of the stuff. Though most people were somewhere between need and shopoholic.
I'm sure it has other origins, but the LV store layout where you don`t run into a clerk until you have made your product selection would have served us well.
My sole experience reviewing something for LV was pretty basic. I emailed the magazine, and outlined my take, I wrote LV and asked for the product, which they (not knowing me from Adam) sent right out for free, only stipulation was that I send a copy of the published article. I did most of the work then the tax treatment on arrows was changed and most people lost interest in making their own and the suppliers stopped selling the stock. The article never came out. I felt like a dishonest schmuck. But I later returned the two generic size dies for the arrow specific ones, without LV saying anything about my turning in dies, years later. I guess there remained enough interest for LV to issue the dies. But my article still did not get published. It`s all pretty low pressure to say the least. Actually today, my 7 year old, got three copies of a kids mag her drawing has appeared in this issue, from 4 years ago, so one never knowns, there is always hope.
Give it up, Fellas...
Doug Trembath
Great choice of wording, Rob... Feeding the troll? I love it!
Given the body of work this person has contributed on WC, he has demonstrated that he is the penultimate negative buffoon...
We're wasting bandwidth and time wrestling with him. Let the members here apply the correct amount of credence they find applicable to their interpretation of his views.
Let's get on with it...
Doug Trembath
An OT question
Mark Nowicki
What are the tax consequences of accepting free tools in exchange for reviews.?
Thanks
Mark
Re: An OT question
cstanford
He's actually probably accepting the tool for participation in design and prototyping. Were he a US citizen the retail value of the plane would be taxable income and reported to him on form 1099-B, as a barter transaction - merchandise received for design input. It might also be construed as a compensated endorsement from a tax perspective. But the IRS would proceed under the barter rules most likely.
Australia does tax these sorts of transactions but they may be subject to certain de minimis rules or thresholds.
One should seek always seek qualified tax counsel to discuss specifics of course.
Re: An OT question
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Since I am neither employed nor paid by anyone, not generating an income of any type, and simply in the pursuit of a hobby, there is nothing to declare.
Don't you think that both of you have something better to discuss?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: An OT question *LINK*
Warren in Lancaster, PA
In the United States barter income is taxable income. The important words here are "in exchange for". Here is Rob Lee:
All operate under the same terms - in exchange for private feedback on everything from packaging to performance, good and bad, they get to keep the pre-production product, or receive a full production model.
If a widow gives you cookies for Christmas and you later shovel her snow, those are gifts. If you say to her "I will shovel your snow if you bake a pie for me", that is barter.
I sometimes have another craftsman offer to make something for me in exchange for something I make. Maybe they want to avoid taxation. I have been more interested in cash customers.
IRS on Barter
Re: An OT question
John in NM
In the US, I would report the retail value of the tools under "other income" (line 21 on the 2012 form). This is also where you report any cash income from the pursuit of a hobby. When I sell gunstocks and similar parts, this is where I report that income. On the rare, rare occasion that I sell any furniture, that is where I would report it as well. That hasn't happened in years of course 
The one time I asked a tax professional about how big hobby income can become before it is considered a business, the answer I got was along the lines of "if you need to worry about it, then it should be a business". Swell 
Re: An OT question
cstanford
In the United States, if one provides a service (a product endorsement/testimonial, design consultation, testing, etc.) and are compensated with merchandise in the form of a copy of the item you were asked to test or to help design (or other merchandise, gift certificates, etc., or cash of course) the value of the merchandise is taxable income and is reported via the 1099 mechanism. A payer is generally required to report transactions of value equal to or greater than $600, there is no threshold for the recipient - the income must be reported regardless of the amount. Some transactions reported on the various 1099 forms have different thresholds.
Most developed countries tax these sorts of transactions very similarly, though reporting thresholds may or may not vary. These sorts of transactions are no different than if a famous automobile race driver received an automobile in return for test driving it and providing his or her expert input into the design of the car. In the United States, the magnitude of the transaction is disregarded. The income must be reported by the recipient.
Anybody reading this should seek their own tax counsel if they believe these rules might apply to them wherever they are domiciled.
Not receiving a 1099 does not relieve the U.S. citizen of reporting the income.
Re: An OT question
cstanford
If you sell furniture then you need to report the transaction on Schedule C so that you can claim the expenses of the build properly - raw materials, supplies, etc.
Just furniture?
John in NM
Soooo tempting to start!!! Not going to though 
Suffice it to say, there are three ways of approaching this in the US. Two are legal, one is not. Of the two legal options, one costs more in income tax due to lacking the ability to deduct expenses from income.
Each person can decide for themselves if a few more dollars in tax is worth the simplicity of keeping their hobbies as hobbies.
Bottom line is that you do not have to use Sched. C if you sell something you make. You have to use Sched. C if you wish to avoid paying income tax on the expense you incurred by making the thing you sold.
Re: The eagle just swooped down.....
Michael Brady
Probably late to the game and redundant, but:
Is "review" the proper term to use in this case. I am reminded more of the articles I receive from woodworking stores such as Highland Hardware that simply expand on the trade catalogue text of the manufacturer. "Infomercial" comes to mind. All this format does is justify bringing another maker's products into the mix for comparison. Somehow, I feel that the conclusion was drafted first and the methodology adapted accordingly. I have to admit that I knew more about all of the products that were used in the comparison when all was said and done.
I had to chuckle during the ramped shooting board explanations, since the ramp clearly negates much of the benefit of the skewed blade's angle of attack. One poster did a very nice job of illustrating this, to his credit.
Negates much of the benefit of the skewed blade?
Denis Chenard in Ottawa
Please explain that one to me...
DC
Re: Negates much of the benefit of the skewed blad
Michael Brady
Dennis has requested a clarification of my comment about a ramped board offsetting the benefits of a cutter skewed to the direction of cut. Look at the photo of ramped board in the "eagle has landed" post. If the skew was designed to cut optimally at say 20 degrees, ramping the board either up or down marginally changes the angle that the wood "sees" the cutter. This obviously changes the designed cutter skew angle relative to the direction of the end grain. If the skew angle is truly a calculated value determined by the tool's designers, than the maker of the shooting board has unwittingly discarded the intentions of that design by slanting the board and the workpiece. Also remember that a shooting board fails if it does not have a fence that fully supports the trailing side of the workpiece against spelching. The more slant and skew present at the point of exit of the cutter, the greater the chance for unsupported wood on the trailing side blowing out. DAMHIKT.
One thing I do like about ramped boards in that they may tend to help keep the plane perpendicular to the workpiece during the cutting stroke. In fact, I would say that is their only real virtue.
The value of spreading the blade wear over a slightly greater length of the cutting edge is negligible on typical 3/4" to 1" stock, a few inches wide, so why even bother with the ramp in the first place?
The way I see it
Denis Chenard in Ottawa
Standard shooting board. Plane with 20 degree blade skew. The blade shears the cut by virtue of its angle. I don't think there's an argument here.
Ramped shooting board, 20 degree also, same plane. The blade hits the wood squarely instead of at a skew, however, by virtue of the ramped board the blade cuts with a sideways movement. So there is still a shearing action at play. Whether the end result is different would be an interesting experiment to make, but I don't believe the benefits of a skewed blade are "negated". Reduced? Maybe, but I don't see a clear-cut conclusion, a test would be required.
DC
Not so ...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia) One thing I do like about ramped boards in that they may tend to help keep the plane perpendicular to the workpiece during the cutting stroke. In fact, I would say that is their only real virtue. The value of spreading the blade wear over a slightly greater length of the cutting edge is negligible on typical 3/4" to 1" stock, a few inches wide, so why even bother with the ramp in the first place?
Dennis has requested a clarification of my comment about a ramped board offsetting the benefits of a cutter skewed to the direction of cut. Look at the photo of ramped board in the "eagle has landed" post. If the skew was designed to cut optimally at say 20 degrees, ramping the board either up or down marginally changes the angle that the wood "sees" the cutter. This obviously changes the designed cutter skew angle relative to the direction of the end grain. If the skew angle is truly a calculated value determined by the tool's designers, than the maker of the shooting board has unwittingly discarded the intentions of that design by slanting the board and the workpiece. Also remember that a shooting board fails if it does not have a fence that fully supports the trailing side of the workpiece against spelching. The more slant and skew present at the point of exit of the cutter, the greater the chance for unsupported wood on the trailing side blowing out. DAMHIKT.
Hi Michael
mmmm ... I don't buy any of what you write.
There was a thread recently on Saw Mill Creek in which the observation was made that the ramp and the skew angle of the #51-type shooter cancel each other out. Perhaps you are taking a lead from this. It is not an accurate reflection of what happens.
1. First of all, the ramp angle of the shooting board is about 5 degrees, and the angle of the skew on the plane is 20 degrees.
Secondly, the main advantage of the ramped board is to reduce the impact as the plane blade hits it. In a flat board with a square blade the impact would be square on. That produces maximum impact vibration. The ramping of the shooting board platform enables the blade to enter the wood progressively, that is, at an angle of 5 degrees, and this reduces the jarring from impact. A plane with a skewed blade, such as a #51-type, would enter the wood on a flat board at a progressive 20 degrees. On the ramped board this gets reduced to 15 degrees. For entry purposes this is insignificant. I would argue, nevertheless, that the main benefit from a ramped shooting board would be found for a shooting plane with a square blade.
The fact that there is a change of angle at impact does not mean that there is any change in the cutting performance of a skewed blade on a ramped shooting board. Once past the impact zone, the blade continues to cut as it always does. It is the shearing action of the skewed blade on the plane that is the strength of the #51-type shooter. The angle at which the work piece is held should not have any effect.
You may wish to read a comparison I made between three shooting planes (LN #51, LN #9 and LV LA Jack) on both flat and ramped shooting boards: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/ShootingPlanesCompared.html
Scan down to "Cutting Angles and the Effect of Skew".
2. The second point of yours was made about spelching being affected by slant and skew. Again I disagree. Spelching has to do with the trailing edge being unsupported during a cut. I do not understand how a ramped board reduces the support of the fence. Perhaps Australian geometry is different, after all we do things upsidedown.
Care to elaborate?
Further, while a fence may aid in supporting the workpiece, it is not necessary to prevent spelching. A simple chamfer at the rear of the board will have the same, perhaps better, effect. Indeed, I believe that one should always chamfer the trailing edge since the supporting edge of the shooting board will get nibbled away as one takes a deeper slice of the edge being shot. As soon as you return to a lesser projection of the blade, the trailing edge is unsupported by this difference. (This is one of the arguments for having a fence that adjusts to take up the gap, rather than a fixed fence that must be replaced).
Perhaps others will chime in as well - these were interesting points you raised. Thanks.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Chiming in.....
roger lance
Its the middle of the night....my shoulder is bothering me (rotator cuff they say)....so I'll try to add some comment.....and then get back to bed.
I built my board last year before I ever thought I'd get a dedicated shooting plane....I borrowed design elements from Derek and Tico Vogt and incorporated some things of my own.
The LV and LN 51s have a 20° skewed blade.....the board (as it turns out) reduces that apparent skew by 4° or 5° depending on the ramp.....which leaves an apparent skew of 15° or 16°.....which is still effective and is not the end of the world.....a flat board might be "better" for a type 51 which would then have a full 20° apparent skew. Someone will have to build a reverse ramped board to explore benefits of apparent skew angles above 20°.
Whatever the configuration of your board, you definitely want that "running fence" (a D. Cohen feature).....makes a tremendous difference.
You also want regular fences that can be adjusted to 90° or 45° (Cohen) and that have an adjustable sub-fence that can be moved to give support to stock and help reduce "spelching" (T. Vogt).
I also agree with Derek that a small chamfer on the back edge of boards to be shot will reduce/eliminate break out.
I'm liking that LV shooting plane....it does its job. You'll need a good board for it as well.....the plane and the board are partners.....its the combination that makes for success.
Re: Chiming in.....
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Roger
Sorry to hear about the shoulder. I have a rotator cuff problem too, but mine is quite mild now. However I know how painfull this can get. Are you getting any treatment, or just giving it some rest and time?
Just a small correction to your comments (a pride of ownership thing) ..
You wrote, "and that have an adjustable sub-fence that can be moved to give support to stock and help reduce "spelching" (T. Vogt)."
Actually, Tico began building shooting boards in 2010, and my adjustable sub-fence design goes back to 2008 (actually earlier - 2008 was when I wrote the article on my website): http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Advances%20in%20a%20ramped%20shooting%20board.html Tico does credit consulting my website.
Apologies if this sounds petty.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Not so ...
Michael Brady
No more angels to add to the head of this pin. Mr. Cohen, the floor is yours.