We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
As promised, once Rob and Co released their brand spanking new shooting plane, I have published a review of the plane for your entertainment and education
I forget Ellis that this is British/Australian slang and may not be understood elsewhere (what about globalisation?)
A doddle is a picnic. Oops .. that is more slang, since a picnic in this instance is child's play ... no wait, that is also slang. Money for old rope! There! That was a no doddle to explain - perhaps I should simply have said, easy-peasy.
Now all I have to do is explain why we use an "s" in words that you use a "z"! Like globalisation ....
I have wanted a shooting plane for some time. Looked at the LN once with some passion, but like many stepped back thinking sooner or later the need had to be stronger to commit. Then my email popped open with Robs latest teases on what was new and so I knew in a flask St Derek must have a review. Your thoughtful review and clear focus on function and edge strength topped my need. Looking at it now in perspective I'm glad I had time to think on this one, or dear I say you did the thinking..... I see a sweet shooting Star on my bench very soon.
That's a very interesting review, Derek. It's very informative and clearly written, and the photos of blade edges and wood surfaces are especially enlightening. Thank you.
I've probably mentioned before that I prefer to use a #7 for shooting end grain. Mine is an L-N, which of course is a bedrock design. I've never seen it mentioned anywhere that the flat top serves a practical purpose, and is not just "trade dress." I guess I'm going to have to build a new chute board that captures the jointer between the bed and the flat top. That raises more questions: Does a bedrock plane fit the #52? How about a #9 miter plane?
Since I'm left handed, the left handed Veritas is very tempting (I already have their left handed rabbet plane and small plough plane). But I realize that when used for shooting, the #7 is ambidextrous, even though not as ergonomic as the Veritas.
One final comment (for Rob): Lee Valley makes replacement PM-V11 blades for Stanley and Record bench planes, but not specifically for the L-N planes, which have thicker irons (0.140"). I've never tried to put a Stanley blade in an L-N plane. Would the lever cap interfere with the depth adjuster? If you don't know the answer off the top of your head, don't fret; I think I have a way to find out.
No, a flat top bedrock (at least the L-N version) is not designed to fit the Stanley #52 shooting board. The chute track is 2-1/8" wide, according to Lee-Valley documentation, while the side of a L-N #7 is 1-7/8" high.
As I suspected, I do have a way to answer my question about replacement blade compatibilities. I remembered that I have a Veritas A2 blade and improved chip breaker stuffed in a tool chest that I purchased to restore a Type 13 Stanley Bailey #6 (that I still need another roundtuit to complete). I opened it up, put it together and dropped it into my L-N #7. Other than a gaping mouth opening (a trivial adjustment on any Bedrock), it works just fine. At least, my depth adjuster engages this blade and chip breaker without a problem.
Come now, friend. Surely, you are more self-aware than to actually believe that aren't you?
This thing always ends up Lee Valley vs. L-N and I'm not aware of a single review of yours (happy to be corrected!), in which Lee Valley doesn't ultimately get the nod, or is it the wink and nod? Maybe this is objective truth, I can't say for sure, but it certainly seems that a pattern has emerged and is fully in place.
I haven't read the whole review, really no need to, but are you disclosing whether you received a sample plane for review to keep (or return)? Or your involvement, voluntary or otherwise, with the development of this plane? Ego boosts, for someone already financially successful, can be their own, greater reward as somebody in your profession ought to be acutely aware.
What, exactly, is your association with Lee Valley and Rob Lee, if I may be so bold as to ask you to re-clarify this for the forum-o-sphere.
I haven't read the whole review, really no need to ..
Gee Charles, got all the details then, did you ..?
You may also have missed where I described my involvement with Lee Valley ... wait, that was at the beginning, so you may not have got that far Anyway, next time you visit my website (!), be sure to read this: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/Statement.html
More seriously (not that you care, but others may), any comparisons between LN and LV are born from requests I receive for this type of comparative testing as they are the two preeminent companies. The fact that LV came out a little better here does not fill me with glee. Far from it. It actually leaves me saddened, because there is a part of me that does not want one to be second. I publish the results because they are what they are, because I treated the assessment as scientifically and as objectively as possible. If there are criticisms, let it first be with my research design.
Derek is one of many people we ask to test numerous products. There are dozens of others on this and other forums. All operate under the same terms - in exchange for private feedback on everything from packaging to performance, good and bad, they get to keep the pre-production product, or receive a full production model. We do not, have not, and will not ask for reviews.
In the case of the Shooting plane - 18 pre-production samples went out at no charge. 1 went to Derek - and he's the only one who has written something comprehensive at this point. You'll also note that we released two planes at the same time - Derek was not on theat list but more than a dozen others were.
Sure he's published a lot of reviews of our new planes. Can you suggest whom else's new planes he should be reviewing??
What you also don't see - are the number of products that people like Derek (Derek too) are sent for feedback, that do not make it to market - and there are many.
People like Derek are invaluable to us for many reasons - analytic capability, writing skill, dependability, and the most important factor (something right under everyone's nose) - he actually does a lot of woodworking. Real projects, with real challenges, and using hand tools. He documents well, solicits opinions, and discusses his mistakes.
Derek publishes more woodworking related material, and shares more of his own current woodworking experiences than any non-professional I can name - and everyone else benefits from it. He corresponds just as prolifically in private, and is responsive to requests from individuals and firms alike.
From my own corporate perspective - producing products like shooting planes is virtually a charitable activity: even doubling what we expect to sell will still means years before we recoup our investment. If we really wanted to seed product reviews into groups like this one - we really should be chosing products with a possibilty of generating significant revenue. But that's beside the point....
I participate here for the same reason Derek and others like him do - to learn, to share, and to make contributions to a community. It's not what we "do" - it's what we enjoy.
Wonderful -- do you have a links to others' reviews so that we may compare them to Derek's?
I have to be honest when I say that I admire Thomas Lie-Nielsen's apparent restraint in not setting up his own version of Derek. Or maybe he has and I missed his or her posts.
"So, please feel free to disagree with the research design, and question my interpretation of the results."
Thank you, consider me feeling free today to do exactly that.
It not so much a matter of pure bias, per se but a matter of independence in APPEARANCE and independence IN FACT. You fail the first test miserably and I'm worried the second one as well.
Your reviews more or less become self-fulfilling because for someone else to challenge your review, in what amounts to real time, they would have to go out and purchase the tool itself, first -- an expenditure of funds with which you don't appear burdened. So your review is posted in the first few days of market release (if not pre-release) of the tool in question when probably less than two dozen planes have been sold and shipped to independent purchasers. This front-running is a bit disturbing along with the general lack of appearance of being a bona fide independent purchaser/reviewer with a bona fide need and bona fide expectations for the tool in question.
Your 'review' also presumably follows the input that you lent during development and prototyping and so ultimately becomes nothing more than a validation of your own, earlier input into the process. If you wrote a 'bad' review (you never do) you would be criticising your own earlier work it appears to me.
What, exactly, is the purpose behind reviews being timed the way they usually are? Is this just a coincidence? A munificent and charitable gesture on your part? Are there any other posted reviews on this plane by anybody else? I find it amazing that as a man with a professional practice, a husband, father (?), member of your community in Perth, worshipping community, etc. that you have no other commitments that prevent you from consistently getting your reviews done and posted to a half dozen forums at least and "on time," almost as if you considered them to be a professional commitment. Are they? The fact that these things hit every major woodworking forum on the same day and within the same hour in itself seems odd.
"So, please feel free to disagree with the research design, and question my interpretation of the results."
Thank you, consider me feeling free today to do exactly that.
It not so much a matter of pure bias, per se but a matter of independence in APPEARANCE and independence IN FACT. You fail the first test miserably and I'm worried the second one as well.
Charlie, you'd make a lousy researcher. You have not yet managed a criticism of the research design, in fact I am not sure if you know what to look for in this regard. It is obvious, however, what you are looking for has nothing to do with research. Your own bias is evident and repetitive. Unless you can defend your thoughts with real information, and not spit out unsubstantiated insinuations, there is no point in attempting a discussion with you.
Pot, meet black kettle. Your methodology is meaningless if you are compromised from the start. It's just window dressing at that point. You're reviewing your own work done during R&D and prototyping aren't you?
Derek - you are likely about as independent as those doing research on grants from major pharmaceutical houses and other lobbying interests, you know the guys -- the ones that told us tobacco was healthful.
I appreciate that and didn't want or expect you to comment on L-N.
The question about reviews from other reviewers, though, was not a rhetorical device.
Are there any? If not, why not?
Were we discussing another company in a different industry would you personally put much stock in a market release review provided by somebody who was involved in a product's development and prototyping?
The question about reviews from other reviewers, though, was not a rhetorical device.
Are there any? If not, why not?
Charles, the answer to that is quite simple.
I am about the only one to take the time and effort to write in-depth reviews on hand tools. There are others, such as Chris Schwarz, who write mini reviews. There were two others, Lyn Mangiameli and Alf, who wrote similar reviews to mine (but better!). Wonderful writers. I miss Alf's humour. I miss Lyn's insights and attention to detail. But they stopped writing because of boorish attacks on the forums.
I would love to see you pen a review. I wonder how you would go about it? Do you think that you could create something that not only informs, but educates? Perhaps I can send you something to review. Perhaps Rob might do so and you show us how a review should be done?
There are 48 reviews on my website (which total a tiny proportion of my scribblings on tools and furniture). Just under half these reviews are LV products. The remainder are a variety that take in LN, Gramercy, Brese, HNT Gordon, Koyamaichi, Knew Concepts .... Why do I continue to write these when there is the constant risk of being abused for the many hours that go into them? The answer lies in the many hours I spend writing on this (and other) forums - writing constructive and, hopefully, thoughtful presentations that will stir others to respond equally thoughtfully. And they do.
At the risk of feeding the troll (I feed chipmunks too...)....
The question about reviews from other reviewers, though, was not a rhetorical device. Are there any? If not, why not?
Since we do not solicit reveiws - I have no additional insight to offer. I do know we send far more product out for comment, than we receive comment back.... I'd be surprised if you didn't know a few of those people yourself...
Were we discussing another company in a different industry would you personally put much stock in a market release review provided by somebody who was involved in a product's development and prototyping?
Yeah - I believe everything I read on the internet... especially if it's at the top of a google search....even better if it's in the shaded beige-y part... NOT.
"market release review" - Really?? That's what gets your knickers in a twist - that we don't want our testers disclosing anything substantive about products before release dates???? I don't have a black T-shirt, and we're not the size of Apple anyway... so there's not much chance we're going to move to formal release events. Derek posted when he saw the plane was put on our website... not before.
We've shown this plane in public at at a few shows over the past few months....even sold some at FWW live. You yourself could have attended a show, tried it out, taken pictures - and written whatever you wanted about it.... as could anyone else. Derek, and others who had access to pre-production planes as testers, were prevented from saying anything until now...
Seriously - give people some credit. Do you think people reading these boards have no judgement and aren't capable of independent decision making???
Really, the answer to the question would be either a "no" or a "yes" with a link to the other review(s).
That there are none only a few weeks into live sales of the plane is not necessarily a surprise which brings us back to the points I mentioned in earlier posts.
Asking this question WAS essentially a rhetorical device because I knew that there are none -- how could there be? Nobody has had their hands on these planes other than you.