We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
.... but it may be due to my deteriorating skim reading skills. Nothing in the review about whether all of these plane passes even produced a square end? Just the usual edge longevity stuff the bulk of which could be a cut and paste job from other reviews? I do understand that the shooting board could be out, user error introduced, etc. STILL it's possible that the plane wouldn't plane square. So, did it? No pictures of a nice, shiny kick-butt accurate square (available from Lee Valley of course) testing the end of one of these boards? How come?
You missed an opportunity for a little product placement my friend.
I guess you missed the part that anyone of the thousands of other people who had access to it could have done the same.
Derek (should you read this) - in the future - should you ever wish to comment on any of our products (and I have no idea why you would want to) could you ask Charles for an auspicious time/date to do so?
There... my work here's done....
TTFN
Rob
(zippin' closed the baggie, and putting the troll biscuits back in his pocket....)
Thousands? Really? You gave that many planes away for free? I missed that announcement. I could have used one for five minutes at a show and written a review, I get that. That's about as free as free was going to get for anybody else I'm guessing.
I must have missed Charles' remarks, but my imagination is working fine so no problem .
Just a couple things, because when things get personal, people need to speak up.
1. Derek. Derek's reviews are valuable precisely because he strives to base his comparisons on physical testing. He shows us how he conducts the physical tests, he spells out details and limitations, and he shows us very good closeup photos of the results. The physical testing takes things beyond his private views--we see what he is talking about.
It's the quantification that I really appreciate. The blade test comparisons were the heart of this current review, and I thought they were the correct tests and highly valuable. Not many of us regularly plane Janka 2200 wood, but he needed something that hard to separate the blades. We can take that into account, because he spelled out the details.
Derek is an up-front person. Everything is on the table. He spells out his position on reviewing tools and how it fits into his life in a Personal Statement at his website. That statement lays everything out. He has come a long way, has documented the journey, and his testing is useful to us all.
Rob and Lee Valley. Lee Valley is a phenomenon; it should be (or maybe is) a case study at Harvard or Stanford Business School. For its innovation, and for showing that manufacturing and invention are possible right here. I like that LV is supporting a good-sized payroll.
But what I like best about Lee Valley is the accessibility and personal warmth of everyone I've come across in that company. It starts at the top. If you email Rob Lee, something comes back fast. Usually a note from him; sometimes a note saying when you'll hear from him. But it happens quick. And when it happens, he's not selling you. I wrote him a couple years ago, asking about a pretty expensive piece for a bench, and he told me that LV could help me, but that my best bet was McMaster Carr. He was right; I took his advice. But I never forgot that--he had gone out of his way whilst on the road to get that word to me. I never will forget it.
I'm still looking for the part in the review of a shooting board plane about whether the board ends were actually squared by the plane. I'm not seeing verbiage, photos of a board being tested for square. Nada. Have I missed it?
Are you guys reading these things? Or getting hypnotized by the rehash of edge longevity of the PM steel we've already read about in a couple of other reviews by Derek, as if grinding the heel of his boot in the throat of anybody still using A-2 (you know who, of course)? Haven't we read about the wonders of this steel already? Several times? Sure seems like it. Like infomercials on Saturday when college football season ends. Enough already. Billy Mays, of blessed memory, comes to mind.
OK, the edge lasted. Were the ends square? It's always good to know that my edges will last while I proceed to plane 60 board ends to an out-of-square state. How 'bout you, Wiley?
Somebody is going to have to explain to me all the clapping and cheering for a tool review that leaves out the most basic but important information about the tool being tested.
I didn't read one plane or another coming in second, my reading indicated that it simply came down to the durability of the steel.
I've read reviews before (Brent Beach comes prominently to mind) that indicated that L-N A2 isn't the greatest. He liked the Hock cryo A2 better, as I recall. That in itself is a drag in general, but at this point, my L-N smoother is sporting S53 anyway, or Gramercy D2. So the failure of L-N when pitted against wood that some of us might otherwise use as a sharpening stone isn't entirely surprising.
I assume the need for better steel anyway... given that, it sounded like Bevel up/ Bevel down was pretty much a draw.
Just want to say thanks for posting this information. I feel especially bright in that I can understand
1) That you cannot post this before the product is released, thanks for informing us as soon as you are allowed to.
2) That many others (17 according to Rob Lee) also had pre-release versions, but did not write reviews); thanks for making the effort.
3) That Rob did not simply turn over product development to you, so I imagine there are frequently suggestions you make which are not taken, and I seem to remember grumbling about some of those instances in other reviews
4) That you probably had the review written a week or two before releasing it, and that it is no big deal to cut and paste a 3-line announcement into multiple forums.
5) That anyone who thinks that "whether the end is planed square" is a meaningful comment to ask for in such a review really shouldn't be taken too seriously.
But Rob shot me down when he pointed out that most people here are able to figure out things like this.
Anyway, thanks for sharing your experiences with these tools. I don't remember ever being motivated to go out and buy a tool you reviewed, but I have felt more informed about choices out there, and that may have ultimately informed purchase decisions. In fact, I have a home-made granny's tooth plane similar to yours, but with a blade made from a hex key. I may spend $10 to $20 on a Veritas blade after reading the article on your build. Make sure to ask Rob for your cut on that sale! LOL
You seriously don't think that the core functionality of a specialist plane shouldn't be mentioned at all in a review of that plane?
Really?
The majority of the review was a review/comparison/contrasting of tool steels that could just have easily been loaded in a No. 4 as in a several hundred dollar shooting board plane. We've seen all of that material before yet we get nothing about core functionality, i.e. boards planed square or at a prescribed angle? Ease of doing so? Any weird problems creep up? Any need for tweaks to the already existing shooting board? We just assume/presume that this part was totally smooth sailing - the does it actually do what it's supposed to do part?
Derek, please keep up the reviews. I find them helpful and I also enjoy your site. I have been a regular reader of this site for a couple of years (never posted before, though) and really enjoy your posts. Please don't let a person who seems to be having a bad day stop you. I have learned a lot from you! I also really enjoy your project write-ups. I hope to build a shooting board this winter based on your write-up awhile back.
Rob - please keep Derek on your Christmas list for new "toys". Most of my tools are used that I have fixed up, but I have bought a few tools from you and like them. It was obvious from a series of posts from when Derek was in the States a while back that you are friends. Derek's reviews seem very well thought out to me. Thank you for encouraging him and I enjoy your perspective as a manufacturer when you drop by.
Yes, really. I am quite confident that anyone here who has ever used a shooting board could easily set up ANY plane with perpendicular (or even nearly perpendicular) side and bottom to create a square end on a board. If you have had problems doing this with any plane, maybe you could describe the plane and what difficulty you had with it. I am fully confident that I could get a square end using my blue stanley handyman that is normally reserved for planing the bottom of old doors that are full of grit. If you have a Holtey that you can't get a square end with, I'll be glad to set up my stanley for you and send it in trade .
Derek's article talks plenty about the experience of using the different planes, yes, even as the blades get wear. He also mentions the need for an outside fence for this plane and other similarly handled planes, which I hadn't thought of, and which makes me more likely to stick with the LAJ that serves me very well in this role (even though Derek thinks it too light for the task) .
the need for an outside fence for this plane and other similarly handled planes, which I hadn't thought of, and which makes me more likely to stick with the LAJ that serves me very well in this role (even though Derek thinks it too light for the task)
Hi Alex
Many thanks for the kind words.
Just to clarify, planes that are held near the mouth (such as the LA Jack) have a different ergonomic to planes that are pushed from the rear (such as the #51). The LA Jack is definitely not too light for use - in fact it has more momentum than a #9 and will out plane that specialist shooting plane if held in a specific manner. The #9 is more intuitive. Both do a super job. My comments are not about which is best but emphasising that function will follow form. Indeed, my review placed an emphasis on this - we all know that a shooting plane will shoot, and that Charles in now running out of ammunition.
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt here, and believe that your intent is to keep yourself or the rest of us from 'being had.' But you've already been had: Someone has convinced you that you understood how these tools work. Or at least, well enough to pose intelligent questions.
Because this is a community, I'll make the assumption that you're here to learn. So, read on:
---
The functionality of a shooting plane, used with a shooting board, is analogous to that of a miter saw, used with a miter box: The squareness of the cut is not determined by the saw, but by the miter box. The teeth on the saw could be made out of broken glass and old beaver teeth, and the cut would still be square, as long as the guides were in good order.
The fence on a shooting board sits precisely at 90 degrees to a track. The wood is held against the fence, the plane runs in the track. As long as the fence is accurate, and as long as the wood is securely held against that fence, the blade will pass through the wood at a 90 degree angle, as determined by the track. The plane is nothing more than a blade holding fixture, it doesn't determine the direction of travel. That's what the shooting board is for, and it's why it's important that it be well made.
Even if the blade were hammered out of a trash can lid, and fastened to a plane body made of squirrel parts, the cut would still be at 90 degrees, provided the shooting board were in good order. But, the quality of the cut would suffer.
The whole point of a shooting board is to guide the plane to cut at an accurate angle. And, the whole point of buying a dedicated shooting plane is to make sure that the quality of that cut is good. So Derek's focus on the factors contributing to the quality of that cut, is appropriate.
---
I must confess, now that it's almost midnight, I begin to wonder if I've been had, and you're simply trying to establish your own credentials for the online trolling community. I simply see no other motive for going after Derek on as many fronts as you have. But, again, for the sake of being polite, I'll make the assumption that you don't actually mean to do harm; maybe you're just young and ignorant, misinformed, or possessed of an overabundance of gumption. So, I'll try to enlighten you again.
You've been whining and moaning for the better part of the day because You Don't Know What You're Talking About. You've gone after Derek to try to make your point, and to show us all just how much you really know. And while you've done a convincing job of that, it's not working in your favor.
Thought I should say something nice. However, I like your shooting board better.
Back to reviews--and no snipping at pant legs.. I was surprised to learn from Mr. Cohen's review that shooting planes, well mitres too, require a "back frame", that they are locked into a slot.
And, stupid me, I really should have known better. I have even built a few shooting boards on my disposable work surface and struggled to trim end grain. Failing utterly, for lack of a slot to hold the plane.
Now, I might bunch up my blanky, refuse responsibility, whine, and blame a certain Australian for not showing the slot necessary for trimming endgrain with a plane. But I can't. I am actually tickled pink that the bugger was exposed.
Mr. Cohen's review has provided me sufficient information to not only see that 8 pounds of iron and steel does not need to be rusting in my garage, but that I can finally trim the end of a board square.
I am really glad that Derek persists in sharing his experiences with his hobby. He is as stubborn as the wood he performs surgery on. I hope the hobby remains the passion it surely is for him. I hope he never needs new shoulders--after a kist, he knows what I look forward to for several days after swinging my fore a short while. And, yes, I have buried this complement inside another subject so he won't get too uppity.
I look forward to reading and learning from Derek's reviews; and I miss Alf's wit, too, even when she forgets..
I'm afraid I actually kind of agree with Charles here.
I too have found that Derek tends to pick the LV product as the winner of his comparison tests, and I often don't agree with his reasoning for doing so.
I also would agree that this particular article went off on a bit of a tangent in spending so much time discussing the edge retention of the steels.
I can even see where some discussion of the ability of the planes to cut a square edge would have been merited. Just as a miter saw with a curved blade or unbalanced set would not cut true, these shooting planes could have problems that would prevent them from cutting a square edge. For example, the two soles could be non-perpendicular to one another, or the soles could be non-flat.
However, I still thought this article was great, and I appreciate and value most of Derek's writing. I may not always agree with his conclusions and sometimes wish his reviews/tests were more comprehensive, but I often find that Derek manages to address key questions that other reviewers miss. He also clearly puts a lot of time and thought into each article.
From this article in particular, I found the edge retention info very interesting (despite it being somewhat off topic). It was probably the best comparison test involving pm-v11 that I've seen yet.
Derek does discuss the actual core functionality of other tools he reviews. For some strange reason he's chosen not to do so here and still won't say why.
We're expected to assume, pat him on the back, and move on.
I too have found that Derek tends to pick the LV product as the winner of his comparison tests, and I often don't agree with his reasoning for doing so.
Yes, there is no question that he has an affinity for LV tools. Part of this is undoubtedly his affinity for fine tools in general, and part is the fact taht LV seems to be the maker doing the most original design among major makers. And like you, I don't always agree with his rationale or conclusions, but the important thing to me is that he states that rationale, so I have what I need to evaluate his conclusions.
I also would agree that this particular article went off on a bit of a tangent in spending so much time discussing the edge retention of the steels.
We'll have to agree to disagree there. I think his comments on the steel were in context. And my take-away from the article is that the ideal combination would be the LN 51 with a LV replacement blade.
I can even see where some discussion of the ability of the planes to cut a square edge would have been merited. Just as a miter saw with a curved blade or unbalanced set would not cut true, these shooting planes could have problems that would prevent them from cutting a square edge. For example, the two soles could be non-perpendicular to one another, or the soles could be non-flat.
No question that it would be extremely hard to get a dependably square end when shooting with this plane
And it would be hard to get square in the other direction with this plane
But I think any reader of Derek's blog is probably confident enough of LV's design expertise to know these issues (on a subtler scale) will not be a problem.
This string of posts have been interesting Charles,
I think you make some points that many of us have thought in the past but experience has taught us all many things about the character and honesty of both Derek and Rob. I have been asked myself in the past to review a prototype for a pen making jig by LV. My private experience with the design suggested it was not functionally robust to flexible for the function I saw. I had clear correspondence with the designer and support. In the end I was never left with anything but respect from the tool designer and my thoughts were appreciated. I know I am not alone in the field in being offered he chance to get real hands on experience with supporting design that makes us all better. I have also offered support in this same fashion to other tool makers, some frequent this sight. You clearly can appreciate that reviews via independent real life users make for better tools and better design. In business it is common practice to not only benchmark your work or process, but also seek out peer reviews, it's basic. Your caritas isms of the tool are not evident to me, but your personal attacks on the credibility of Derek are offensive to me.
Marketing is a complex business, marketing without market review and supporting data is very inefficient use of marketing. As Rob mentioned, the NRE and ROI on his tool would stop many from making it, but LVs marketing process is consistent from tool launch to tool launch, repeated success makes us all better and one other tool designers should consider.
The ultimate in poop having a propensity to happen: "The Narrows Bridge had been designed by one of the most eminent and respected bridge engineers in the world. Federal and state and experts had approved the plans. The bridge was a state-of-the-art structure. It had cost over $6 million to build."
Gotta take care of first things first. Will it (whatever "it" happens to be) do what it is supposed to do? Then move to finer points.
Look, given that people often successfully use an old Stanley or Record foreplane (No. 6) as a shooting board plane, and neither firm ever made more than a relative handful of them that had a sole square to the sides, sure just about anything will work with enough tweaking. But, with a specialist plane we are being asked to spend extra money to avoid at least some of these tweaks. So sure, let's see, for $hits and giggles if nothing else, if we can quickly and efficiently square an end therefore at least partially justifying our purchase and the price differential paid over a regular bench plane. That's all I'm saying. I think it an odd omission not to have covered this in a review of such a plane. Folks seem to enjoy dwelling on edge longevity. I don't really get it in a larger context but clearly it is what it is. It all seems a little overdone at this point but that's just one guy's opinion. All of these products tend to become yesterday's news at some point, the steels that is. Sometimes sooner rather than later, sometimes not. It does generate fun banter on these forums I must say.