Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Sawstop Saga

Posts

Re: Sawstop Saga

#76

MARK is correct, 100%


Re: Sawstop Saga

#77

Re: Sawstop Saga  Review

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I suggest we lay back and see what Thomas reports from his later interactions with SawStop.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#78

Merchantability

Howard

Implied warranties come in two general types: merchantability and fitness. An implied warranty of merchantability is an unwritten and unspoken guarantee to the buyer that goods purchased conform to ordinary standards of care and that they are of the same average grade, quality, and value as similar goods sold under similar circumstances. In other words, merchantable goods are goods fit for the ordinary purposes for which they are to be used. The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), adopted by most states, provides that courts may imply a Warranty of merchantability when (1) the seller is the merchant of such goods, and (2) the buyer uses the goods for the ordinary purposes for which such goods are sold (§ 2-314). Thus, a buyer can sue a seller for breaching the implied warranty by selling goods unfit for their ordinary purpose.


Re: Sawstop Saga

#79

Amen!

Brian Roberts

and glad someone else has the stones to deal out the truth.....

Re: Sawstop Saga

#80

Well.... not really.

John in NM

It seems to me that the frustration and desire to wash one's hands of the product in this case was the direct result of prevarication on the part of Sawstop's customer service reps - in particular with regard to the misfire ruining not just a saw blade, but a dado set. For me, that would have been the straw that broke the camel's back.

While I can understand their position comes from not wanting to replace every saw blade that someone inadvertently wrecks, I can also understand that a saw that fires for no reason and ruins an important and expensive blade is going to be 100% useless for a guy in Tom's business. It is all very well for the monday morning quarterbacks like us to say stuff like "if a hot dog triggers it, the user should expect other things to as well" - in this case it was completely unexpected.

The trouble here is that the company should - for their own rep, not because I think they should - take a return on this machine, shipped on the customer's dime. That is the way I would handle it. I would have handled it that way long before it got to the point of being discussed on the internet - because that is how you keep customers happy in spite of problems. Do that right and you have no detractors - just people by whom you have done right.

At this point, were I in Tom's shoes, I would stamp something very unflattering in the top of the machine and auction it on ebay :D -- Ok, I wouldn't do that just yet :D I would give the tech a chance to truly make things right first.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#81

A quick response from LeeValley customer service

Mark Nowicki

Thank you for your inquiry. The SawStop saws may be returned within 30 days. Because the customer assumes responsibility for the delivery/pickup of the saw, they must also assume responsibility for its return it to the Lee Valley store.

We look forward to hearing from you again.

Sincerely,

Linda Macpherson

Internet Customer Service Representative

Re: Sawstop Saga

#82

Kneale Brownson

Re: After thinking...some thoughts.......

Kneale Brownson

I'd let the tech "fix" the machine and ask for a written statement of its safety from the company. I'd put it in various classifieds as equipment I no longer wanted in my shop. I'd sell it for whatever I could get with the understanding I had found it unsatisfactory for my business, but the manufacturer had declared it safe. I wouldn't hesitate to express my displeasure with whatever this approach cost me in the end.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#83

Re: A quick response from LeeValley customer servi

Howard Acheson

Is the 30 day return a Lee Valley practice or is it a practice of SawStops?

Re: Sawstop Saga

#84

Re: Merchantability

Hank Knight

These are all good legal claims in a courtroom. Mr. Skaggs' objective here should be to resolve this mess well away from a courtroom. Those who have recommended legal action have probably never been involved in a lawsuit. A lawsuit is the quickest way to turn an ordinary mess into a horror.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#85

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Question?

Jim in River Oaks, Ont

What was wrong with the Unisaw?

Re: Sawstop Saga

#86

Re: A quick response from LeeValley customer servi

Mark Nowicki

Clipped from LeeValley's website:

"Lee Valley is a family-owned business that has been serving users of woodworking and gardening tools since 1978. Our reputation is based on three principles:

Customer satisfaction: Any product may be returned within 3 months* at no cost to the customer; we return every penny you paid us, plus, for shipments within North America, we will refund your return parcel post costs.

*30 days for Festool products. "

Going by the response I have received, it appears LeeValley has a specific return policy for SawStop products.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#87

Re: Merchantability

BrianMonumentCO

But let us not forget that SawStop's main claim to fame is not a production grade with extraordinary performance as a saw BUT rather it is a SUPER SAFE saw that is designed to protect the operator from inadvertant/accidental human contact with the cutting blade.

This from a merchantability status could be interpreted in much same way that a vette is differentiated from a pickup truck in term of speed vs cargo. SawStop super safe saw vs true production grade.

Also one must handle the concept of the suitability (alot like merchantability from my seat) clause in the sawstop warrantee. They are not responsible for suitablity. The BUYER owns that responsibility.

There is also the note that William Duffield posted about how the teeth of the saw need to be adjusted for each blade change. I wonder if Thomas did this according to the SawStop specs. If he didn't then I wonder if he is not really responsible for the false firings.

Bill Tindall brings up an interesting point also about the possibility of a mineral pocket.

Could it cause a false firing? Who knows... But it looks like something I would investigate.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#88

Re: Question?

William Duffield

It will cut your fingers off, if you get distracted while using it.

The chances of a dangerous kickback are much higher, because it doesn't have a riving knife, and the splitter is such an annoyance that it is often removed and never used.

There's no way to retrofit the blade brake technology to it without a complete redesign, because the cast iron trunnion and other moving parts are not strong enough to take the forces of the braking action.

Dust collection is inferior to the SawStop.

Both the fence and the table top itself are shorter than the SawStop's.

The following is only a possibility: It may have the old, pre-Beisemeyer fence system on it that locks front and back but never squarely. Delta bought Beisemeyer in 1995, very close to the age of Thomas's saw.

Thomas may have other reasons, and some of the general reasons I listed may be unimportant to him.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#89

fence disagreement

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have the original Delta fence and would not trade it for any other.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#90

Why not let Tom Skaggs answer.....

roger lance

this question was asked of him.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#91

Ellis Walentine

Recap

Ellis Walentine

Tommy, I think we all wish you well with your quest for a refund -- I certainly do -- but after all this discussion, the bottom line seems to be that SawStop isn't likely to give it to you, as it would be contrary to their expressed policy, which was no doubt craffted with exactly this sort of situation in mind.

We can all form our own opinions about SawStop's policies and customer relations and decide for ourselves whether we choose to patronize them in the future.

This has been an interesting discussion, and I'm glad that cooler heads have prevailed, especially given the emotional dimension of this issue.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Sawstop Saga

#92

Re: Why not let Tom Skaggs answer.....

William Duffield

I'm not stopping Tom from answering. The questions was, "What was wrong with the Unisaw?" It was not "Thomas, what was wrong with your Unisaw?" Are you attempting to censor me? You don't need to read my posts. If you find them somehow offensive, you should ask the moderators to delete them. However, some here would be really offended if you could manage to suppress any posts that don't agree with your outlook.

My intent was only to point out some obvious potential disadvantages of an old Unisaw vs. an Industrial SawStop, that might help someone else following this discussion make an important decision. I figured my observations might be pertinent, since I've owned and operated both.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#93

Re: Why not let Tom Skaggs answer.....

roger lance

Your speculations aren't pertinent.....you were not asked for them.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#94

Re: fence disagreement

William Duffield

I think you will find you are definitely in the minority on that preference, but if it works for you, don't change anything! I could never figure out the technique for consistently locking down the fence square, and from the number of times I've seen people pull out a tape measure to verify it was set square, I don't think I was the only one who had the problem.

Personally, I was partial to the Unifence on my contractor saw, and it was an annoyance to rebuild several jigs to fit a Beisemeyer style fence instead. I really liked the Unifence's very low fence option, and its lightness was also an advantage.

I find the fence on the Industrial SawStop to be a bit too long and too heavy. When I remove it from the saw, I usually need to set the far end down on the top of the saw, to keep it from tipping me forward until I can adjust my grip. That's not a problem with any of the other SawStop models.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#95

I've used all three...

John in NM

Unifence, Biesmeyer, and Jetlock (the one that locks in back too).

Unifence was the best of the bunch, but the Jetlock on my 1950's Unisaw really works well enough that I have never made replacing it a big priority. Perhaps I would have done so if Unifences were still easily available.

The trick with a Jetlock fence is to always set it the same way - keep the back loose when moving and always lock, unlock, relock the front to get to your measurement. Once you're used to it, it's not so bad, but I did hate it at first.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#96

Re: Question?

TomD

"It will cut your fingers off, if you get distracted while using it."

While obviously SS is designed to be better in this respect, their guarantee clearly spells out that you can be seriously injured using SS. Given a lot of safety gear contributes to carelessness and a higher injury rates, and that in this case it could also contribute to not taking more realistic safeguards, which could drive injuries up further, I am not convinced it is safer. Definitely safer legally and probably more humane if the saw is largely used by newbies and idiots.

"The chances of a dangerous kickback are much higher, because it doesn't have a riving knife, and the splitter is such an annoyance that it is often removed and never used."

Are there not some rather nifty riving knives available for unisaw.

"Dust collection is inferior to the SawStop."

I think that is fixable.

"The following is only a possibility: It may have the old, pre-Beisemeyer fence system on it that locks front and back but never squarely. Delta bought Beisemeyer in 1995, very close to the age of Thomas's saw."

Yeah, the best solutions are all in total redesign, though. The Unisaw is old metal which is good, and everything else is something that could be improved.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#97

Re: You have got to be kidding.

TomD

An expectation of special treatment pretty much describes customer service, if not the legal framework.

SS is a company that has a pretty good record of insisting that everyone should use their product, even at the point of a gun if necessary. Yet when they make a product that doesn't suit a use it is nothing to do with them. An explosive brake just went off in my head... It's the BS Stop I have that grabs BS and stops it cutting through sensible arguments. :)

Re: Sawstop Saga

#98

Re: Why not let Tom Skaggs answer.....

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Sorry Roger, but I certainly didn't ask anyone for your opinion either! You are being quite rude and obviously a fan of Sawstop. I do value others opinions much more than yours!

Re: Sawstop Saga

#99

Re: Why not let Tom Skaggs answer.....

roger lance

I'm crushed.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#100

Re: Sawstop Saga

Joseph Mulherin, sr

I just watched the inventor of the SawStop doing exactly what the saw was invented to do....with his own finger.....and it worked perfectly. The video is on YouTube.