Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Sawstop Saga

Posts

Re: Sawstop Saga

#26

Re: The Technician Visit

Joseph Mulherin, sr

I repeat, Tom, take this mess to the courts and get a financial settlement for your lost wages and profits....plus the aggravation

Re: Sawstop Saga

#27

You are making me ......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

......ever more satisfied with my Unisaw. In 35 years all I have ever had to do was replace belts and bearing once and it has had thousands of bdft of lumber across it.

On the "misfire" I suspect a "mineral" pocket. I really don't know what a mineral pocket actually is but I know that they are conductive and will couple to microwave radiation and set the pocket on fire if one foolishly thinks the MW is a handy place to dry a piece of wood to check moisture content. This wood feature might be conductive enough to trigger the blade stop.

I think of all the metal I have hit with my Unisaw and it would add up to a lot of destroyed blades and cartridges. My aluminum miter has many nicks and I have hit a few nails, staples, etc.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#28

Thomas, sorry to hear about this.

Keith Newton

I've got a good friend who recently bought one, and I'm glad he did, because neither he or his partner are really very mechanically inclined, and have already a couple of misfires. I've used the saw a few times, and it seems pretty good.

However, I have watched the weenier display, and even a real person slowly bringing their finger into the side of the blade tripping it, which doesn't really impress me, since that isn't how the bad stuff happens. I want to see them thump the front of the blade as hard as you would need to do to fling a bugger off it.

I'd chip in a few bucks for a replacement cartridge if your tec guy will do that. Maybe we could start a kitty here to cover the cost, if you can get them to demonstrate that. ha

Re: Sawstop Saga

#29

An alternative....

Mark Hennebury

I feel sorry for your troubles. I have had very little to do with new table saws. and wish you all the best in getting it sorted.

I buy old used equipment, sometimes really old.

You simply cant buy better equipment in my opinion.

I don't know any company the builds machines a well as they were built back in the day. Most modern machines have many compromises in quality; manufacturers never switched from cast iron to sheet metal because it was better. The whole concept of building things the best, and building things to last has changed.

My saws were made in 1951 and has been running trouble free for 64 years... so far.

My suggestion would be to look at some of the great used machines that come up for sale.

For the basic machines, jointers, planers, table saws, shapers and bandsaws, the old machines are far better quality For less money.

I started buying used machines because i couldn't afford new ones, now you couldn't pay me to have a new one.

If i had to chose i would rather pay the same price and get a good used machine and clean it up and put new bearings in it, at least then i know that it will outlast me before it needs anything else done to it.

The good thing is you can pick up good used machines pretty cheap if you don't mind fixing them up a bit yourself. For the price of a new saw like your Saw stop you could buy a rebuilt used one.

I would strongly recommend that you check out the used machines.

Mark


img

Re: Sawstop Saga

#30

No old dust collectors available? LOL


Re: Sawstop Saga

#31

Re: The Technician Visit

BrianMonumentCO

During the technicians visit you should make it clear that it is not alright unless they fixed the problem.

To YOUR TOTAL SATISFACTION.

My main point here is that you should give them a chance.

Remember that the product is technically sensitive and may have not been installed right, nor may not have been shipped intact..... What if it was damaged somehow in shipment.

The technician should speak to that.

After the tech visit, then the screws turn on them to take the machine back.

As you have complied with their request to check the machine.

By the way I don't recall hearing what type of guarantee they have.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#32

Re: Which model do you have?

TomD

Industrial, pro, I think I read it higher up...

Re: Sawstop Saga

#33

Re: Warranty

TomD

I read the warranty that SP provides, and it is pretty reasonable, but certainly not generous. It does not provide for return of the saw in any circumstance, though the dealer, or state, may have other provisions. There is no mention of satisfaction, they just say they will fix it, if it is their fult, which they get to decide, or you can pay to ship it back to the factory for service, if you want your saw to see the world.

There are also very interesting disclaimers about personal injury in there, that people who are expecting magic results should read carefully.

They also encourage you to return the cartridge to them for digital analysis if you are injured. Talking to one's lawyer about that first might be wise.

------------------------------------------------

Of course their policies are just their policies, one can often do better. Business is business. And it can happen that in the process of going through a series of problems one can find a variety of reasons one also does not want a tool, and there isn't any reason one can't take advantage of one issue to deal with one for which there is no conceivable warranty protection. I don't think there is a moral issue so long as one keep to the truth.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#34

Modification Issue

David Yoho

Tommy, do you think your modified method of installing the sliding table will become an issue for them to make the excuse for why they won't take the saw back? I could see this happening when all other reasoning goes out the window and I wonder if you aren't just a little concerned about it. They might try making the claim that not installing it by their directions has in some way caused the issues you're having. Of course it's BS but if they can't find anything else...

The bottom line here is you don't have confidence in the machine and it has prevented you from working your business. That should be enough under normal conditions for a company to honor their warranty and allow the return. If not, I think they need to see how much damage occurs to their reputation (again) when this issue is broadcast on Internet woodworking forums.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#35

Re: The Technician Visit

Chuck in Mtl.

Thomas, good luck with the visit from the technician. Hopefully he/she can make the saw work correctly and to your satisfaction. Statistically a percentage of all manufactured items will be lemons. The consumer laws in most states have a 'lemon clause" whereby the consumer is entitled to get his/her money back with no legal entanglement. I suspect the electronics for these models of saws are not entirely debugged. Some companies leave the final debugging of products in the hands of consumers. but that said they should refund all of your money no questions asked. A lawyers letter might help them to make the right decision.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#36

Warranty?

Brian Roberts

First ...let me say.....I'm with you on the issue.

However.....In looking at their warranty online I see nothing about a "money back satisfaction guarantee".....am I missing it?

Re: Sawstop Saga

#37

Re: Warranty?

Chuck in Mtl.

Probably not explicitly stated but if one makes enough noise then it can happen.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#38

Kneale Brownson

Re: Warranty?  Shouldn't matter....

Kneale Brownson

If Sawstop, which tried to force its "technology" on the table saw industry (and us, the folks who pay) wants to keep its business going, it should stand behind its products to maintain a viable reputation. The bad reports like this spread across the communication system now available in the world will kill a company. Of course, if Sawstop is experiencing a lot of Tommys, maybe it can't afford to take back a bunch of saws and will remain resistant......to its eventual demise anyway.

Tommy, I'd print out all the responses here and have them spread out on top of the saw when the technician arrives.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#39

let them have a chance to repair the saw....

Chuck in Mtl.

I would say to let the tech have a chance to make the saw good. it could be a faulty whatever but a good tech should be able to repair or replace it. Unfortunately the negative impressions of this product or any product for that matter are difficult for companies to undo. maybe the saw will now work but the doubt will linger forever and for anyone who is reading this forum.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#40

Re: Warranty?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

What else would you expect from a company founded and ran by Lawyers? They tried to use the government to force the technology on us and they certainly aren't going to give a warranty that could cost them money in court! Publicity that causes lost sales $$, is the only way Thomas is going to win - in the court of public opinion.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#41

The Modification

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Hi David,

Good to hear from you. I should better explain the modification I made.

The sliding table is a Sawstop produced add-on. I have attached a photo of the table as Sawstop prescribes it to be installed. The sliding table and fence is well made. However, I had issues with the prescribed installation. You will see in the photo that the carriage for the slider projects forward of the saw at all times. It projects forward by about 12". What you don't see in the photo is the saw fence and it's lock down handle. The handle is large. So the saw operator can literally become trapped between the projection of the slider carriage and the fence lock. In other words, they trap the operator in the danger zone. Having been a kickback survivor, I am keenly aware of that zone.

You will also see the paddle and switch box have to be relocated. They provide a bracket on which you relocate the switch. Hard to tell from the picture, but the new location of that switch is somewhat under the slider carriage. It is also turned 45 degrees to the saw. Doing that greatly effects the free access to the switch and paddle. It requires the operator to contort more under the carriage to get at the paddle.

I was stymied that Sawstop (of all companies) would create a product for their saw that actually created significant safety problems. There was no way I would set the slider and switch up that way. So what I did was mount the carriage about 10 or so inches forward of the prescribed position. I was able to use the same holes on the saw's cast iron table. That remedy eliminated the forward projection of the carriage and allowed me to keep the switch at its factory installed position.

What I lost was length of travel for the slider. I still have nearly 36" which was enough.

I had numerous discussions with Sawstop tech people about it and strongly voiced my concerns about the safety issues. Long story short they "took it under advisement"

In the end, I made no physical changes to the saw itself.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#42

Re: Warranty?  Shouldn't matter....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Hello Kneale!

Not a bad idea!!

Take care my friend.

T

Re: Sawstop Saga

#43

Easy people.....

Brian Roberts

Settle down........lol

I said I'm with him on the issue!!

In his original post Thomas stated:

"But I have requested them to honor their warranty and allow me to return the saw for a refund."

I was asking if his warranty states that....in those words........?

Re: Sawstop Saga

#44

Re: Sawstop Saga

Jim Dillon

Thomas, very sorry to read about your experience with your Sawstop and especially disappointed to hear how SS has handled this. There is an old adage about how a company deals with problems that tells you more about a company's internal philosophy than how it deals with success. I think SS has seriously failed in its handling of your issues and obligation to its customers.

Intermittent start up? Belt slipping off the arbor? Accidental discharge of the cartridge for no obvious reason? These are not minor issues that can be easily ignored - especially in your business where down-time is critical.

Given the length of time this saw has been on the market, and the favorable reviews by many satisfied users, I come down on the side that you got a lemon and it should be replaced at no cost to you, or the vendor. This assumes that SS didn't recently produce a bad batch of SSs and they are now trying to minimize the hit to their bottom line.

As someone who has experience in failure analysis, I was going to recommend that you NOT send the cartridge back to the company - despite all the assurances that they want to get to the bottom of this. SS has a vested interest in their product and those interests may not be all that altruistic. But I see that horse is out of the barn.

My bias in writing this is that I WAS a fan of the Sawstop line of products and - if I was considering buying (or recommending) a new table saw - I would have seriously considered a SS. That opinion is in serious jeopardy right now waiting to hear how your saga turns out.

Good luck, and keep us posted.

Jim

Re: Sawstop Saga

#45

My grip on my old Unisaw is tightening......

roger lance

I never had any thought of replacing it.....but, I suspect you felt that a SS would be safer for less experienced helpers or a different saw would be more productive.

I'd be interested to hear why you became dissatisfied with your Uni.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#46

Re: The Technician Visit

BrianMonumentCO

I have heard of lemon laws applying to cars.

Never heard of them applying to all other kinds of products.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#47

Re: The Technician Visit

Chuck in Mtl.

yes true enough..only to cars it seems.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#48

Re: Sawstop Saga

Larry

Does Sawstop have a Facebook page? Post this on their page!

Re: Sawstop Saga

#49

Re: Sawstop Saga

Jim Dillon

Hi Larry. I'm clueless about Facebook, Twitter, etc., etc.. Let's hope this thread is picked up by various search engines to alert other woodworkers to the problems that Thomas is having and how Sawstop is dealing (or not dealing) with them.

Jim.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#50

Re: Sawstop Saga

Curt Stivison

I guess my dream of owning a ss is over. You can tell the tech when he arrives Curt Stivison just took a ss off his bucket list.