Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Sawstop Saga

Posts

Re: Sawstop Saga

#51

It will be interesting

Dick Coers

what the tech says. We brought a Sawstop into the model shop at Cat, right before I retired. It struck me as being one of the best machines I had put together in a long time. Kinda like the old days of solid engineered American machinery. We had zero electrical problems. So looking forward to the report on the repair. I've been on the negative side with machinery, so I know how you feel Thomas. There's always been the negative guys on this machine, disliking the idea of loosing a blade when it hits the brake, how the technology came into use, etc. But after loosing a part of a finger, I'm on the side of appreciation of the technology. I was working at Cat when I had my accident. If I had been self-employed, the two surgeries and minimum of 8 weeks with use of only one hand would have been devastating. Loosing a couple of days to technical issues is still a small consideration if you ever have a finger save. Hang in there a couple more days Thomas.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#52

Re: Easy people.....

Syd D.

Spot the sawstop shill ^^^^

Re: Sawstop Saga

#53

A shill.....really?

Brian Roberts

"A shill, also called a plant or a stooge, is a person who publicly helps a person or organization without disclosing that they have a close relationship with the person or organization."

Really Syd ?? What a guy.....

I have no connection to Sawstop....or Mr. Skaggs for that matter.

I have, however, seen manufacturers.....and forum posters....... hung in the court of public opinion......by people who are expert at condemnation prior to investigation.

I asked....twice now....if the warranty that came with Thomas' machine states that the purchaser can return the saw for a refund?

I am simply trying to ascertain if the company has changed their warranty since Thomas purchased his?

Thomas stated "But I have requested them to honor their warranty and allow me to return the saw for a refund".

If that is indeed what his warranty states then I am behind him 100%.....all other issues aside.

I (we) have gotten no reply.......other than your accusation that I am a "Sawstop shill"......and I repeat....what a guy.

Brian

Re: Sawstop Saga

#54

Re: Sawstop Saga

Ken Krawford

I've been reading this topic with a great deal of interest. My Unisaw just left my basement yesterday and today I will begin assembling my Sawstop. Fingers crossed (pun intended).

It's too bad Tom is using this saw for commercial purposes. I believe the "Lemon Law" that we typically associate with defective cars also applies to most other consumer products but they must be for personal use.

http://www.divinecaroline.com/life-etc/career-money/lemon-law-it%E2%80%99s-not-just-cars

Re: Sawstop Saga

#55

Re: let them have a chance to repair the saw....

Bill Howatt

I agree. They should have a chance to make it right. SS technology is no longer new, it has been out for years and there seems to be a high level of satisfaction with the quality of the saw and even positive comments on dealing with Sawstop.

If the saw still continues to be problematic then that's another issue but if the words about returning it are not in the warranty then it's unlikely to happen.

Bill

Re: Sawstop Saga

#56

I e-mailed LeeValley customer service..

Mark Nowicki

.. asking if their 3 month return postage paid policy applies to SawStop products.

I will share the response.

Mark

Re: Sawstop Saga

#57

Re: A shill.....really?

TomD

The warranty from SS is on their site and makes no mention of a return policy, not even close. It looks pretty unexercisable. It is more a, here is why you will never get any satisfaction from us document. Not necessarily a bad thing since ultimately how they treat customers remains in their hands. And then there is whatever the dealer may have promised.

That said, the return policy on a chisel is not going to be practical on a product that weighs 500 pounds. SS is probably more often than not subject to buyer's remorse, it is like trading in my car to get a safety belt, at the end of the day the experience is actually worse. Say you swap out your Inca saw for a SS, are you actually going to be happier after the shine wears off, and the cartridge triggers a few times for no reason? If someone invented a table saw that made no noise during operation, that is something one could enjoy with every use, but the SS isn't like that, there is no immediate improvement in the user experience if you already owned a premium saw.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#58

Re: A shill.....really?

Brian Roberts

I read the SawStop warranty online.....as I stated in my first post.

Sorry Tom...but all the rest of your post does not address my question to the original poster......

Re: Sawstop Saga

#59

Sawstop Saga  Review

BrianMonumentCO

At this time I have a few questions and points.

1. Several readers of this thread have asked the important question of Mr Skaggs;

"Is there an actual written money back guarantee from either sawstop or the local dealer?"

Thus far I have NOT seen Mr Skaggs state that there is one.

2. After seeing the SS demo, Mr Skaggs must be aware that the SS stopping mechanism is blade destructive.

3. After seeing the SS demo, assuming it is the one with the hot dog as a stand in for a human body part, Mr Skaggs should be aware that the SS should fire on a hot dog but might fire for other things.

4. I have not seen Mr Skaggs indicate that he has had an electrician inspect / verify his electric circuits.

It is possible that some of the problems seen are related to a faulty circuit.

5. Lemon laws apply to cars. i have never seeen one applied to other products.

6. lemon laws always involve the dealer being given several opportunities to fix the item.

7. Lemon laws are not applicable to "buyers remorse"

8. Reading Mr Skaggs posts makes it apparent that he has to some degree buyers remorse.

9. Several readers have suggested taking SS to court. Good luck..... Now you have to prove that

A. the saw is a good choice.

B. that Mr Skaggs location has met every reasonable expectation (POWER)

C. that the saw performs the job as expected...... Breaking blades is part of it.

D. Most importantly that SS did nothing about it.

Mr Skaggs indicates that he is pushing for a money back guarantee that appears not to exist.

And that he has resisted the visitation of a qualified technician.

10. It is not clear how long Mr Skaggs has owned his SS. At first I thought just a month.

But some posts of his use the term "months". How long has he had it?

11. SS has a warantee that is on their website, It does NOT mention return policies for full refunds.

At first I thought he had a guarantee..... So I think now that he should work with SS to make it work.

Have I missed something?

I hold no ill will towards Mr Skaggs..... I wish him luck in resolving this problem.

But I think he needs to have realistic expectations.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#60

Re: Sawstop Saga  Review

Larry

Sounds like Brian works for Sawstop.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#61

Re: The Technician Visit

John McGaw

I am certainly not an attorney but some of the drivel from econ and business courses sunk in; there is always, at the very least, an 'implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose'. If a company sells you a product that is purported to, for example, cut wood then it had damned well better be able to cut wood as claimed. This is beyond any written warranty or guarantee and AFAIK cannot be nullified unless you agree contractually that the product doesn't necessarily need to do what the seller claims it will.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#62

Re: Sawstop Saga  Review

Brian Roberts

Pretty sure he doesn't.....

And I am damned sure I don't.

But I will say I am getting tired of the general leaning "here" toward "the OP can do no wrong and the manufacturer can do no right"!

Glad to see someone else had the stones to say what needed to be said.....again.

Why is it that Mr. Skaggs has not answered the question that several have asked?

This "SAGA" has gone on long enough....and I WILL say that IF I were working for Saw Stop's legal department I would be in contact with Mr. Skaggs regarding his potentially libelous statement......

Re: Sawstop Saga

#63

Re: A shill.....really?

William Duffield

FYI, an Industrial SawStop weighs over 700 lbs., and that doesn't include a mobile base or the slider.

I've owned one for over 10 years, and have been very pleased with it. I have had no problems with it. It has always performed perfectly, including its sawing capabilities and its many safety features. I have tripped a brake once, but it was because of hidden metal in what I was cutting. It is not a kludge. To the contrary, it is a very well engineered and built saw with carefully thought out and implemented safety features, and in my estimation much better than any other cabinet saw, including anything produced by Powermatic or Delta. Note that I don't have any experience with European saws, but I know that, with the exception of a riving knife, none of them has the safety features of the SawStop.

I am curious about the returned dado cartridge. There is a major disconnect here between Thomas's description of the incident and what he tole us the tech told him. The only way I can resolve the discrepancy is if the tech misread or misinterpreted the codes recorded in the cartridge's processor. The following is speculation: The brake may have tripped if the gap between the brake shoe and the saw teeth was not checked and set properly. This is something that should be done by the operator every time the blade or the cartridge is changed, and that includes any time the blade is sharpened. I do have a friend who tripped a dado cartridge, but I believe it was due to a questionable operation involving a full stack, and extreme extension of the trunnion tilted to 45°.

I've sawn lots of wood on of table saws without the SawStop safety features, but now that it is available, I won't use any table saw that does not have these features, just like I won't ride in an automobile without a safety belt and air bags, and I won't use a cellphone while I'm driving. That's just common sense. I hope someone will soon develop equivalent technology for band saws, jointers, planers, routers, and even drill presses.

If I had room in my shop for a slider, I would have one, and I would have made the same modifications Thomas made to his, and for the same reasons.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#64

Re: Sawstop Saga  Review

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Mr. Roberts,

I appreciated your initial post. When I first posted, I did so because I was genuinely interested in the opinions of others about my situation. I was not soliciting support, rather, just opinions....pro or con. Your first post offered your opinions on the other side of the coin and since I sought all opinions, your views were welcome.

I do not, however, appreciate your later post. I sought information and opinions, not accusations. In every post I have made I have spoken only of my experiences. Our first amendment rights allow us to voice our experiences.

To your point about buyer's remorse. Most certainly I have that. I believe it is a common feeling one has when they purchase an expensive product and they experience problems with it. It would seem unusual for anyone to not be remorseful when disappointed with any significant purchase, house, car, tool etc.

To your point about the warranty....I have read it. Your point about the language is valid. That said, I am hopeful that the company is willing to consider my case, examine the saw, and consider latitude. I'm just old enough to be tainted by "the good old days" when company policies were more consumer forward. I realize those days are mostly behind us.

I am not a lawyer. I make my living making furniture. So I cannot provide any informed response about my legal position. Frankly, I have not expressed any interest in any legal processes. I am hoping to simply work it out with the company.

As you do not know me personally, I would appreciate some decorum here.

Peace.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#65

Re: Sawstop Saga  Review

Brian Roberts

I believe you are confusing me .....at least in part....with "BrianMonumentCO"

Re: Sawstop Saga

#66

My Mistake

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Sorry for the confusion. I should have picked up on that and directed my previous response to both of you gentlemen. Thank you for the clarification.

T.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#67

Re: Sawstop Saga  Review

Jerry Roberts

Many, many years ago, years before I started woodworking, my loving wife bought me a unisaw from Woodcraft. She brought it home, had it unloaded in a redicioulus small place in my half garage. I had it for a few days and just knew I couldn't keep it because of space. I had my son and myself load it on a trailer and take it back to Woodcraft. I explained the space problem to them. They took it back with no hassel. Ive never forgot that . Ive bought a bunch of tools , lumber,machines from them since those early days because of that. Btw, theres no relation to me to any similar sounding names here on this forum.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#68

I dont work for sawstop.


Re: Sawstop Saga

#69

Re: Sawstop Saga  Review

BrianMonumentCO

Thomas,

You still have not answered the basic question.

Do you have a written money back guarantee on this saw?

Either by sawstop or by the dealer?

Re: Sawstop Saga

#70

Re: Sawstop Saga  Review

BrianMonumentCO

Jerry, Your situation then and Thomas's situation now differ dramatically.

ONe of the most dominant issues is time.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#71

Re: Sawstop Saga  Review

Jerry Roberts

I know. That was my point. Its sad how time can work against all of us. I wish Thomas the best but from what he says that company really doesn't care about its customers the way companies used to.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#72

Clint Searl

Terms of any guarantee are irrelevant

Clint Searl

An upright and ethical company will stand behind its product, fully considering the customer's experience, and respond accordingly, regardless of the published guarantee. In this instance it appears that the saw's problems, whether or not 100% inherent to the saw, warrant a full refund.

SS is on my SL as of now.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#73

After thinking...some thoughts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This had been a curious discussion.

I have been in your position many times in my former day job where I bought expensive equipment that sometimes arrived not working. Occasionally I got to the end of my rope on a machine and wanted it just GONE. These occasions often involved a company using my time to diagnose their problem.

If I liked what I bought I held out to get it fixed if fixing looked feasible to me. I returned/replaced equipment in situations where there was no clear path to a perfect working machine. ****Quality companies offered replacements where the path to perfect remained unclear or uncertain after an attempt to fix.

We know from many satisfied customers that this saw normally works and delights its loyal owners.

Would you be delighted with it if it worked as advertised? Personally, I would not want the saw. I would trigger the stop at least once a year in some careless, or not so careless way, and this fact would drive me nuts. I regard the necessity of using a 10" blade a fatal flaw for my purposes. If you are in this situation get it fixed and sell it. If not.........

Can it be fixed in a timely fashion? You are a professional shop. Time is money, maybe upwards of $100/hr. I would give the technician a reasonable chance to fix it. If declared fixed, I would need to know and understand what was wrong and understand that what was fixed indeed fixed it. I would want an understanding that if the fix administered failed to fix as evidenced by a future failure, that the machine would be replaced promptly.

Summary- this machine clearly does not work like most others. It is the company's job to diagnose, and fix or replace. In the mean time I would use the Internet to see if others have your problem. It would not be the first time that a company sourced a part from a new supplier or made a design change that resulted in a machine with a good reputation becoming a problem for new customers.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#74

Re: After thinking...some thoughts

Larry

Well Said!

Re: Sawstop Saga

#75

You have got to be kidding.

Mark Nowicki

If I was a decision maker atSawStop and have read your post I would say " thank you for putting me on your SL."

The OP asked for an opinion, so here is mine.

This is a perfect example of disinformation.

The initial implication that SawStop was not respecting terms of the warranty turned out to be,

after repeated requests and a delay of two days , an admission that it was just an expectation of special treatment.

Mark