Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Sawstop Saga

Posts

Sawstop Saga

#1

Sawstop Saga

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Friends, I have a table saw dilemma. Late last year I finally had enough money saved up in the kitty to buy a new saw. My old Unisaw had served me well for 20 years. But I felt it was time to upgrade.

I had never looked at a Sawstop saw before. So I went to the local vendor for a demo. The technology seemed to make sense and the saw appeared well made. So I plunked down my money for an Industrial model.

I also bought the new sliding table that replaces the left extension. I like the slider but had all kinds of issues with Sawstop's prescribed method of installation. So I did a modified install that I think is better and safer.

Once up and running, the saw worked well. It was just in time for a time crunch in my shop. I needed to knock out 3 pieces of furniture for Grovewood Gallery to meet a delivery deadline.

Well, no sooner did I plunge into that work, I started having some problems with the saw. I do not want to trash Sawstop or their products. But I have requested them to honor their warranty and allow me to return the saw for a refund. So I hope to find out today if that happens. I'll keep everyone posted!!

Meanwhile, it looks like I might need a new cabinet saw. You see in an earlier post that I am looking at the Powermatic 2000 5hp saw. Anyone know of any problems with that saw? Other suggestions?

Thanks!

T.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#2

I'd save some money on the motor

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have no trouble ripping 8/4 lumber with my ancient 1 1/2 HP Delta saw. I do use a few tooth rip blade for the task when needed. Unless one is production ripping heavy lumber I don't see the need for 5 HP on a cabinet saw. Costs more to buy and more to run.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#3

Yeah but....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

...the 5hp comes with chrome exhaust pipes and flames painted on the sides!

Re: Sawstop Saga

#4

Art thou a woodworker or a dragster?


Re: Sawstop Saga

#5

Regarding Sawstop........

roger lance

I do wonder if Bruce Jenner contemplated doing a commercial for them......could have been the first pay-per-view commercial.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#6

I'm getting pushback.....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I had a feeling this would not go well. I might end up getting hosed here.

I have had various problems and malfunctions with the saw. They have resulted in lot's of down time and frustrations for me. As a woodworker, I have lost faith in this machine. As a businessman, I am concerned about the cost of down time.

So I contacted my local vendor. He, in turn, has dialogued with Sawstop. They are totally resisting my returning the saw. Rather, they want to send technicians to inspect it. Nothing wrong with that, except I have made my desires known. I simply want to return the saw.

I spoke to the local vendor and they indicated they would lose money if they allowed me to return the saw. I presume that means that Sawstop will not step up and make the vendor whole.

I don't want the vendor to lose. Rather, I'd prefer to see Sawstop simply step up and honor the return of the saw. Am I out of line here?

T.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#7

Re: Sawstop Saga

Mike Circo

You do not indicate or even hint toward what the problems were.

Can't make a judgement without at least a few details.

"Problems" could mean everything from a funny noise to blowing breakers... depending on the person deciding what a problem is. I know you've been here for years and are quite the professional and artisan, but playing devils advocate, I'd wonder what problems are so utterly dramatic that it requires a complete refund and switch to another tool. Why do you consider this unfixable and therefore the only resolution is to dump it?

Details please.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#8

Re: I'm getting pushback.....

TomD

If you have a satisfaction guaranteed type return policy then shove it back at them. As you know, you paid for the guarantee, not just the saw. You paid for it, you get to exercise it, it is up to them to figure out the financing on their end. All the above assuming you have a guarantee.

Buying another saw, I would look at euro. Spend money not on a kludge that makes up for a bad design, but on a good design. Saw stop is sorta like buying a ballistic parachute for a plane without landing gear. Ballistic parachutes are cool technology,but the money spent on wheels first, is the better course.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#9

Not out of line at all...

John in NM

A friend of mine makes jeweler's tools, he told me a couple weeks ago that he always keeps a cash reserve to do exactly what you want SS to do for you. All he requires is that the unhappy buyer pay return shipping - because it can be steep with some of his heavy tools.

Planning to keep the customer happy is just good business, and a little planning is all it takes, IF the business is viable in the first place. In this case, I can't imagine that the cost of taking care of you is going outweigh the cost of sending a tech to your shop (but maybe I've lived too long in the middle of nowhere :D )

Re: Sawstop Saga

#10

Fair Enough

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Your point is well taken. In the first month of owning it, I have had a number of occasions were the saw would not start. I'm not an electrical engineer, but in speaking with Sawstop's engineers, I have learned that the saw has an extremely sensitive electrical system. Of course I understand that the sensitivity is required for the success of the stopping cartridges.

However, at least in my case, the least little "disturbance in the force" and the saw balks at starting. That causes me delays while I go around opening and shutting things, tightening things, cutting the power and back etc.

About a month after using it, the arbor belt suddenly derailed off a wheel. The motor kept running but the blade stopped. Took me a while to figure that out.

Recently I had a nearly new dado blade on the saw. I installed the dado cartridge on the saw. I was using a cutoff of clear dry cherry to make test passes to adjust for depth of cut. (1/2" wide, 3/8" deep on 4/4 cherry) I made 2 passes without problem. Then, about 7" into the third pass (on the same piece of wood) the cartridge discharged. Yep....messed up a pricey dado set.

I sent the cartridge to Sawstop for analysis. They concluded that it was MY error and that the blade had come in contact with metal (they suggested something like a tape measure) while the blade was in slow down. That was completely impossible. In fact, the blade was in mid cut and completely shrouded by the wood. And there were NO nails etc. in the wood. It was clean and clear.

All of this happened in the first months of owning the saw. I have spent countless hours with Sawstop tech people and down time with the saw. It has come down to being a problem for my business. In the 20 years I owned the Unisaw I never had any such problems.

It's not just that I feel this saw has presented a number of operational problems, but as a result, I have completely lost faith in it.

T.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#11

The reason to dump it...

John in NM

If he isn't making product he isn't making money. Fixing a new machine is not making product.

I'd dump it in a flash too, since I do grudge a vendor of a new, premium tool the time I'm waiting on production for them to fix their new product. Many vendors seem to be used to dealing with hobbyists these days, people who can afford to wait rather than people for whom lost time is lost revenue.

Now if I've bought a used machine or a very cheap import, the cost savings makes me more inclined to do a bit of work if necessary. The savings balances time lost to some degree.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#12

The Lee Valley Principle

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

God Bless Rob Lee and his company. If all others followed their lead for customer service and standing behind their products, then things like this would never be an issue.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#13

Re: Not out of line at all...

Jesse Cloud

I'm really surprised and disappointed to hear this.

The school where I used to take woodworking lessons has had sawstops for several years now. In spite of daily abuse by newbies, the saws have served well and been very reliable.

The only problem on your list that I saw with them was the electrical system being very picky about things being set up exactly right - a loose door would stop it from starting.

I think you got a lemon, but I also think you are exactly right to loose faith in the company and demand a refund.

BTW, before sawstop the school had 5 HP powermatics and unisaws. Both were good solid machines. Only peeve I had with the powermatics was that the blade spins for a long, long time after power is cut off. Not a big deal, but I was often tempted to do something less than safe instead of waiting for the blade to stop.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#14

Re: I'm getting pushback.....

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Thomas, I just sent SAWSTOP a message stating just what you have been saying about the saw.....and for them to just accept the saw in return and to pay you your purchase cost. enough of this with companies just wanting to sell and not honor the warranties and such.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#15

Re: I'm getting pushback.....

Joseph Mulherin, sr

And, Thomas, if they continue with STIFFING you, then take them to court and get a penalty fine for your lost business costs too.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#16

Lemon's do happen afterall...

John in NM

Manufacturers are wise to plan for the odd lemon now and then, they are virtually unavoidable. Sometimes lemon-like customer service can be a fluke as well, rather than an indication of overall company attitude or the frequency of lemon products. I certainly hope it is a fluke here, as I think Sawstop does make a useful product that fills an important niche in the woodworking world. That niche can grow with the business if they are able to handle events like this one gracefully.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#17

Re: Sawstop Saga

tom sontag - st. louis

Sorry for your troubles Tom. But if I were to ever "step up" from my cabinet saw, I'd be looking at a Hammer or similar slider. My neighbor has the Hammer and it is one sweet saw.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#18

Re: Lemon's do happen afterall...

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

That's why I avoided the details. I'm not here to trash Sawstop. I'm aware that lot's of folks have them and are happy. You are right, maybe this saw is an anomaly. I am not qualified to assess the engineering issues. I'm just a business guy with a very important tool that just hasn't worked properly.

At the moment, I am frustrated with Sawstop's corporate approach. I'd rather they just honor my request and keep the vendor whole. Let bygones be bygones. I'd be happy to post that good news for them.

Maybe they have tasted enough success where good PR is no longer needed? Hard to say. I'll keep everyone updated as the saga continues.

Thanks for the support!

Re: Sawstop Saga

#19

Re: Sawstop Saga

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Yeah, but how do I tell my wife that I am replacing my table saw with a "Hammer"? She isn't very knowledgeable about woodworking and that might really confuse her! ;-) Seriously...I'll do some checking. Thanks!

Re: Sawstop Saga

#20

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Fair Enough

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I remember years ago, when I was just cutting my teeth as a painter, I would try all kinds of new tools and gadgets in the hopes of saving time, energy or money. Let's just say there were very few diamonds in the rough. But there were a few. As a result, I think I have a pretty good eye now for painting tools, and am quick to spot the gimmicks. I've also learned that my time is valuable, and if something doesn't work out of the box, I'm not going to waste my time trying to get it to work (unless my OCD/engineer side/curiosity totally take over, which still happens once in a while). I can't afford much, and downtime is definitely very expensive.

I hope you get it worked out without too much more loss on your end. I can't help but think about how Steve Gass tried to get this forced on us through the government, though.

Jason

Re: Sawstop Saga

#21

Re: Sawstop Saga

Larry

I heard the Sawstop doesn't like add-ons added to there saws that they don't indorse.

Don't know if this is true.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#22

AMEN !!!!!


Re: Sawstop Saga

#23

Re: Sawstop Saga

Gary Balcom

Sorry to hear about these issues. As a fellow professional woodworker, I can empathize. I would be firm and explicitly clear to the vendor that this defective product has cost you time and money, which you can prove, and if they don't honor your first (reasonable) request, you will be forced to take further (legal) action. The vendor should be embarrassed that they aren't stepping up to the plate. Good Luck

I too second a european saw for anything besides solid wood ripping...I don't like standing on the other side of a carriage and ripping...personal preference I suppose.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#24

Re: Sawstop Saga

BrianMonumentCO

Thomas,

You are well within your rights to want to send it back.

Is Sawstop actually sending a technician to examine the problem?

If so when?

If they don't step up and take the saw back.

Contact the president of the company.

It will take time.... But on occasion a company president may be oblivious (negligent) in his knowledge of how returns are ACTUALLY handled in his company.

On your way to the president, you might try the supervisor or head of customer service.

Escalation sometimes produces results.....

If worse comes to worse, the question of how the length of time this problem takes to resolve and its exposure on the internet messageboards/chatrooms may motivate a customer service manager or corporate type to sit up and take notice.

Question for them to answer is how does this issue of returns affect whether a reader on messageboards/chatrooms would buy a sawstop?

In any event, good luck and I hope you succeed.

Re: Sawstop Saga

#25

The Technician Visit

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

This is another frustration. Sawstop's approach, up to now, has been to have various tech guys call me to query me about the problems. Okay, that's not a bad thing. Except, the overall emphasis has been a litany of engineering rationale for the problems.

Obviously there is rationale. That's not the point. I shouldn't have to spend time running diagnostics every time there is a problem. I shouldn't have to have debates when Sawstop tells me a cartridge discharged in a manor that was completely different than the actual situation.

I depend on my tools to work....every time.

So they are sending a technician to my shop on Monday. They have as much admitted that their goal is to try and convince me not to return the saw. The technician and the vendor tried to get me to agree to then taking me to lunch before we went to my shop. I declined. It seems apparent that the technician's goal is to convince me that the problems can be overcome. But that's the problem....there should be no problems in the first place!

I have been told by the vendor that Sawstop will not even consider a return settlement unless they inspect the saw. Any bets on them declaring the saw perfect?

What the heck?

The tech comes on Monday. Once again, more shop time lost. :-(