Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Need a circular saw recommendation

Posts

Need a circular saw recommendation

#1

Need a circular saw recommendation

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Other than to avoid them, that is. I finally torqued my 20+ year old junky Skil saw (or was it a B&D? whatever). It makes dreadful noises, shakes, and I don't feel safe using it even for approximate cuts. I have been making do with my jigsaw, miter saw, tablesaw, and handsaws. I figured once I finished the RAS station (pictures to follow in a later post), I could use that for cutoffs and crosscuts. But that isn't exactly portable or helpful on the rare sheet of plywood I use. A circular saw would be handy to have again. Since I don't use one often, I cannot justify the price of a Festool. I am only 5'2", so a worm drive type of circular looks too long, heavy, and scary. The one in HD just picked up its head and said "I will take off your leg!" The rest all look similar, some are 12A some 15 and more rpms (I presume more power), most around 10 lbs. Anybody have a preference? Any warnings or caveats? TIA.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

Clint Searl

I've been using my new Rigid to break down multiple sheets of 3/4, 1/2, and 1/4 birch ply for my library wall project. It walks through a double thickness of 3/4 with ease. It's light, accurate, and easy to handle, and has a long cord. Good guarantee, too. I also have a Bosch top handle helical drive for heavy duty stuff, great for framing and construction, but I prefer the Rigid for the shop.

Clint

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#3

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

James Watriss

I use Festool for plywood, solid wood, and other things... there's something about the rail that really opens up one's options. Because it lays across the wood, it's good for miters and angle cuts, etc, in a way that the clamp-across saw guides aren't. That's my plug... take it or leave it.

That said, if you're going to go with another kind of circ saw, it's worth buying one of those (clamp-across saw guide) too.

There's a half-way, which is the hypoid style. It's basically 'worm drive lite.' I'm told Dw and Makita make good ones. Haven't tried one myself.

I have an 8 year old Dw 369CSK from the Despot that came with a 'composite' base plate... essentially, a fancy but very durable plastic. (my shop-mates have bounced this one around a few times, with no visible damage, so I can attest to the durability.) I bought it when I was just starting out, and I really liked the fact that the case had a good way to store extra/other blades without letting them rattle around in the case. If weight is a concern, you might want to think about this one.

I also have a Bosch worm drive, with 'light weight' magnesium parts. Yes, it's still heavy. But after the torquey start-up jump, it's very, very smooth. I've used it to cross-cut a bench top, buried to its full depth in soft maple. Even with that load, it was still a VERY smooth operation... and a lot less noisy than a sidewinder would be, even if it could make that cut without bogging down.

Alternately, the Dw 364K (7 1/4") or 384 (8 1/4") are very solid, professional level saws. I say this to distinguish these from the 'contractor grade' stuff that the Despot sells. You won't typically see one at the Despot, but I know carpenters who have owned and used theirs for years, and the saws are still solid, and running strong and smooth. My uncle in law's a carpenter, has had his for 10 years, and though he's had to replace the cord once or twice, the saw itself still spins like a top, and runs very smoothly.

Given that I currently own and use both Festool saws, and prefer the Bosch to the Dw, I'd be open to selling the Dw. PM me if you're interested.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#4

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

Barry Irby

I am also looking for a circular saw. I have a 30+ year old B&D that has been a faithful friend, but its on its last legs.

I was walking through Lowes and they had a Porter Cable display (I think). In it was a card board cutout of a "coming soon" saw. It appeared to have a long slender body sort of like a Multi Tool and a circular blade about 4" or less in diameter. It said it would cut through an inch or more. Not sure how soon it will be available, but for busting down plywood it might be just the thing. No idea what they will sell it for. I am in Lowes nearly every day. If you have any interest I will pin the details down a little better.

Warning: This is a post about a saw that does not exist, that might be available at an unknown price, maybe made by somebody or other, whenever.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#5

look at a PC SawBoss

roger lance

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#6

Re: look at a PC SawBoss

Ron Jones

I love my Saw Boss, but I'm not sure it's the same saw now that it was 5-8 years ago. It's sad to see the Porter-Cable name being compromised.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#7

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

I am only a couple of inches taller than you. but with a badly damaged neck and arthritic hands. So I know about weight, balance, small hand issues, etc. That said I have a no longer made ~5" Skil saw, made when Skil made good circular saws.

I would recommend a less than 7 1/2" saw. Those likely will be a 'pro' brand often used by finish carpenters. Put a thin kerf Tenyru blade on it for plywood and your will have the dream machine for busting down sheets and it shouldn't break the bank either. As for the clamp on saw guides, they are available after market or you could make your own. I came out with a track guide 10 years before Festool, so maybe I can help. Wish I would have had the money to bring that puppy to market back then, but que sera.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#8

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

Larry in NW OHIO

Joanne If you are only going to use it for cutting plywood, I think the old PC 314 4" worm saw would be just the saw. It`s small fairly light but seems to be very well built. The only thing you can only find them on ebay and some online dealers like Tool king and the like. You can still find new ones and they are around $230 but you can get them cheaper. Good Luck with whatever you find. Larry

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#9

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

steve mackay

Sorry to use the "C"-word but . . . the big Craftsman, Industrial worm-drive will do ANYTHING. I saved up for it for a year so I would never buy another one. After ten years I know I never will. It'll cut ANYTHING and, I promise, it will NEVER jump out of a cut. It never wanders (without proper supervision). I've cut 1/8th " plywood without tearing it up and 10x3" without bogging down. Heck, cutting ANYTHING is like butuh !

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#10

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

Don Orr

I'm with Clint and Carol. While I have a very nice PC 7 1/4" saw, I tend to grab my Rigid 6 1/2" saw more often than not. Light, powerful, good warranty and has a nice long flexible cord. I don't have the model number at hand-sorry. It uses thin blades like the cordless saws. I'm pleased with it.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#11

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Given your requirements (light weight - occasional shop use - easy to handle) I would look at the 5 1/2 trim" saws. The will cut 1 3/4 thick material at 90 deg. - more than needed for plywood. The heavy duty saws would not only be overkill for your use cost wise and weight wise but are a lot harder to handle. A few years ago I gave a friend a trim saw for Christmas - He is 6' 7" and at that time about 300 lb. A few months later he was telling me the trim saw was his go to saw as it was so easy to handle. You should not ever wear out even a consumer priced saw if all you do is break down plywood once in a while. Skill puts out a 5 1/2" saw (Skill HD5510-01 5-1/2" Circular Saw) at about $100 - but any should work for your purposes. I have a very heavy 8" old Professional Black and Decker I purchased at a yard sale with a bad cord for $3.00, I tested the saw and it ran well so I purchased a new cord (at about $20.00) - it is overkill, but cost little and will outlast me. There are also a lot of cordless trim saws that would work for you, if you need the freedom of a battery operated saw.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#13

Re: look at a PC SawBoss

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

The SawBoss is very light weight, cuts well and has a dust chute you can point in any direction. You can also attach a vac hose to the chute to keep down dust if you use it to break up plywood indoors.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#14

I've been happy with my Dewalt 634 *LINK*

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I have a Dewalt 634, a side drive that I have had for about 15 years. I have loaned it to several friends and two of them liked it so much that they went out and bought one just like it. It is light weight yet still very ruggend and powerful.

I mill my own wood with a chainsaw and typically start a project by cutting up slabs to managable pieces that I can resaw on my bandsaw. This means I end up using my circular saw to routinely rip 8/4 hard wood. IThe other task I use my circular saw for is to break down sheet good and for that I made a jig made up from a scrap of 1/4 ply and a 1x3. The dewalt cuts as acurately as I can clamp my jig.

The other saw I would recomend mostly based on your petite size would be the Porter Cable 4 1/4" worm drive trim saw. it is a 30+ year old design and not as flassy looking but it is a bullet proof tool that is more powerfull than its diminuative size would suggest. I don't normaly like worm drive saws but this one is a bit different because it puts the handle ofer the top of the motor and makes it very easy to use.

Robin


http://www.dewalt.com/tools/saws-circular-saws-dw364.aspx

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#15

Another vote for smaller is better

Neal in San Jose

I have an "experienced" P.C. that has to be 25 years old, so the model number is probably not important. What is important is that it is a 6 1/2 side-winder. I bought it one day when I was trimming out windows on the exterior of the second floor. My 7 1/2 worm drive Skill saw threatened to throw me off the ladder with it's reaction torque every time I started it, so I drove over to the tool store and picked up a trim saw. I'm constantly amazed at how much power this thing has, and how easy it is to control. It has no porblem with nominal 2 by materials, and is my go-to saw. My only complaint is that blades aren't as easy to find as the 7 1/2 ones, so I tend stock up when I find them at a good price.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#16

I looked again today.

Barry Irby

Its a Rockwell Versacut. Looks handy, but still nt avialable.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#17

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

gary camp Bend, Oregon

Having grown up in the West, I've always used a skill 77 worm drive. I really hate blades on the right, so if I were to buy a new saw for shop use, my first criteria would be for blade on the left, my second would be for quality and light weight. So far the 6" Saw Boss is coming out on top. I would never buy a saw I hadn't tried for fit. I mostly hate Makita chop saws and sliders because of the push button "safety", my hand size and shape make it difficult to push in the safety and pull the trigger. So how the tool fits MY hands is the final selling point. No matter how good everything else is, if it is not comfortable it is not worth owning.

glc

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#18

Re: I looked again today.

Joseph Mulherin

Barry, Rockwell has come up with a three-way battery drill which looks very promising: model RK2510K2

selling for $125.99 + sales tax in your area. It comes with the Lithium batteries(2 of thyem), battery charger, 2" driver bit and carrying case. The batteries can be recharged over and over without deterioration over time many times...30 min for a full charge, and 75% over 15 min.

I bought one yesterday... to be deliver4 from manufacturer in about 10 days.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#19

Re: I looked again today.

Joseph Mulherin

Follow-up: Bought it from Woodcraft store.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#20

Re: I looked again today.

Joseph Mulherin

Went to Woodcraft website and looked up the drill I had mentioned....the price has been increased to 161.99...must have been a one-day sale...lucky me. Anyway, was watching Ask this Old House and saw Tom Silva using one to drive his screws and bolts on a deck and fence railing.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#21

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Thanks for all the good advice, folks. I didn't want to wait for a PC 314 Saw Boss to go over my budget on eBay, so I picked up the Rigid 6 1/2" Fuego (thanks, Clint). Not too big or heavy (it pays to work out when you are small!) and a sweet little saw. Sooo quiet! I picked up a finish/plywood blade with lots 'o' teeth and put that on (Thanks, Carol; great suggestion.)--Wow! What a smooth cut! I have one of those clamping bars that goes across the wood, so cutting a straight line was a piece of cake. There is a chute in back that spits dust at me that I didn't care for, but that could have been the breeze blowing it at me a little. Otherwise, I highly recommend this saw.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#22

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

FredD

I looked at a film of it and read the reviews Joanne, for what you would use if for , I think you got a deal.

About the sawdust blowing back , my Biscuit cutter did that until I glued a Ell to a short length of PVC and it fit the hole tightly and blew the dust sideways away from me and the work,

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#23

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Thanks, Fred. I was thinking of making some sort of chute to do just that. What did you use for the el? The hole on the saw is sort of rectangular, I think, and not very big. An awful lot of dust came out of there, considering the size.

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#24

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

FredD

Without going to the shop and checking , I used 1/2" PVC pipe and PVC Ell , the outside dimension of that size pipe in PVC was a snug fjt.

You most likely will have a slightly different situation , but that's the general idea.

I am surprised that Rigid didn't pre think that dust chute .

FredD

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

#25

Re: Need a circular saw recommendation

Joseph Mulherin

Joanne, I have the DeWalt DW682 bisquit cutter and they do have the insert you might check out.

It is sort-of-square on the end and has an ell on the other end which can also have a sock filter added to keep things clean.