Ed, I'm very glad to hear what you say... *LINK*
GaryG in MD
...about the fits. That's my experience, too, although, having made only two, I'm still very much in the learning mode. The two I made are subtly different because I learned from my experience with the first one to make some minor changes.
I think one of the important things to consider is the wood. The results may/will differ depending on whether we use the softer woods (like my walnut/cherry/maple) or if we use some of the very hard tropical woods (or even harder local woods like osage orange, mesquite, dogwood, hickory, etc.) BTW, everyone should take note that there is an excellent pair of wood hardnesses tables, by hardness or by alphabetic name, at http://ejmas.com/tin/2009tin/tinart_goldstein_0904.html. I've read about the inserts causing cracking in woods prone to it.
Here's what I feel is an important point that you mention. The lip of the top mechanism is definitely meant to be proud, in effect, a spigot. In my design I used that fact to center the top on the bottom without turning a separate wooden spigot, as is done in the article. I have some tolerance problems that I have to work out (I got a bit more "slop" than I would have preferred on the first one, and the second one was slightly misaligned when I went really tight), and, as a result, would recommend the inclusion of the wooden spigot in addition to (or actually in place of) the lip for registration purposes. This, of course, makes it a bit harder to get a grain match, but, at this point anyway, I think it would be worth it. I'd have to write another post on that subject.
Regarding the grain match: because of my laminated blanks, I knew that would be very important, and I designed my process from scratch to be very different from the worthless "instructions" that are available. To keep the grain match, I first turned the entire outside of the mill in one piece and parted it with the thin (1/16") parting tool (using a thin saw to finish the cut). I made jam chucks to hold the pieces as needed, but a critical requirement was the use of a spindle steady. I'd have to go into more detail on the procedures than I can here, but I think you understand. I've written up my plans, but I think I'm going to hold off on releasing them until I try another one (with the spigot centering the top into the bottom).
One of the really critical things to consider is the sizes of the holes. I have to frankly say that I think the instructions were generated to sell more Forstner bits. I used the recommended sizes in my first one and smaller ones in my second. This was NOT because of runout or slop -- my drilled holes were precisely the diameter of the bits. The 15/16" is perfect for the top, but I question the 1-9/16" for the base. I note that in his article, Chris used 1-1/2" in the base. I think that choice depends on the hardness of the wood, but I think the 1-1/2" is better in the softer woods. I can't speak to the harder ones. I'm going to have to experiment a little more on this before I can make a solid judgement. The 1-1/4" hole is also unnecessary in the top of the base. I think 1" is the way to go there. So, for many woods, I think we only need the 1-3/4", a 1-1/2", a 1", and a 15/16". But, it's probably a matter of YMMV, because there are a lot of outside variables here.
Thanks for your reply. I'd like to discuss this further. ...Gary
http://ejmas.com/tin/2009tin/tinart_goldstein_0904.html