Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

CrushGrind peppermills...

Posts

CrushGrind peppermills...

#1

CrushGrind peppermills...

GaryG in MD

There's been a lot of talk, on and off, about the shafted CrushGrind peppermills. Some people like them and some have had bad experiences.

I've followed this closely because I prefer the idea of them (no button on top, fixed grind setting, ceramic works) to the traditional kind. (And I hate those little screws on the latter.) After some serious study of the "instructions" (i.e., written materials from sellers, manufacturers, etc.), even before I begain turning, I came to the opinion that these writings range from useless to wrong.

Others on WC have written some good tips for how to avoid some of the potential pitfalls. The bottom line is that there's nothing at all wrong with the grinders, just the worthless instructions for their implementation. There are tricks -- right and wrong ways of doing things. (Don't cut off the tabs!!!)

So why am I going on and on? Two reasons:

1) The current issue of Woodturning Design has an excellent article on the subject that brings most or all of the pitfalls to light and tells how it should really be done. Thanks to the editor (and WC member), Joe Herrmann, for that. I've been a dedicated reader for many years, and this article is worth the price of the whole issue.

2) I just made a pair for my kids for Christmas. They're 12.25 inches tall. Thanks to Ed Karch for the walnut/cherry/maple glue-ups! The photo was shot before I rubbed out the finish. They're smooth as a baby's butt now. [Jamie -- sorry about the poor photo quality -- I invoke the old "I was in a hurry" excuse.]

C&C welcome!

...Gary

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#2

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

Ed Larson

Gary, I also have been interested in using the CrushGrind mechanism and for the same reasons you stated. I studied the Woodturning Design article and purchased Chris West's book. I just completed a prototype (from pine) being careful to get the two critical demensions (depth holes for the top and bottom mechanisms) correct. I then split it in half to see how well the mechanisms fit. They fit perfectly, the lugs had expanded into the slots and the vanes on the side had penetrated the wood. By following these directions I'm convinced that this is the proper installation procedure for CrushGrind. Another key is that the lips on the mecanisms set proud of the surface.

Because the lip of the top mechanism sit proud of the surface, it allows for the lip to be used as a spigot and improves grain match. Gary how did you get the good grain match.

Looking forward to making a keeper.

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#3

Ed, I'm very glad to hear what you say... *LINK*

GaryG in MD

...about the fits. That's my experience, too, although, having made only two, I'm still very much in the learning mode. The two I made are subtly different because I learned from my experience with the first one to make some minor changes.

I think one of the important things to consider is the wood. The results may/will differ depending on whether we use the softer woods (like my walnut/cherry/maple) or if we use some of the very hard tropical woods (or even harder local woods like osage orange, mesquite, dogwood, hickory, etc.) BTW, everyone should take note that there is an excellent pair of wood hardnesses tables, by hardness or by alphabetic name, at http://ejmas.com/tin/2009tin/tinart_goldstein_0904.html. I've read about the inserts causing cracking in woods prone to it.

Here's what I feel is an important point that you mention. The lip of the top mechanism is definitely meant to be proud, in effect, a spigot. In my design I used that fact to center the top on the bottom without turning a separate wooden spigot, as is done in the article. I have some tolerance problems that I have to work out (I got a bit more "slop" than I would have preferred on the first one, and the second one was slightly misaligned when I went really tight), and, as a result, would recommend the inclusion of the wooden spigot in addition to (or actually in place of) the lip for registration purposes. This, of course, makes it a bit harder to get a grain match, but, at this point anyway, I think it would be worth it. I'd have to write another post on that subject.

Regarding the grain match: because of my laminated blanks, I knew that would be very important, and I designed my process from scratch to be very different from the worthless "instructions" that are available. To keep the grain match, I first turned the entire outside of the mill in one piece and parted it with the thin (1/16") parting tool (using a thin saw to finish the cut). I made jam chucks to hold the pieces as needed, but a critical requirement was the use of a spindle steady. I'd have to go into more detail on the procedures than I can here, but I think you understand. I've written up my plans, but I think I'm going to hold off on releasing them until I try another one (with the spigot centering the top into the bottom).

One of the really critical things to consider is the sizes of the holes. I have to frankly say that I think the instructions were generated to sell more Forstner bits. I used the recommended sizes in my first one and smaller ones in my second. This was NOT because of runout or slop -- my drilled holes were precisely the diameter of the bits. The 15/16" is perfect for the top, but I question the 1-9/16" for the base. I note that in his article, Chris used 1-1/2" in the base. I think that choice depends on the hardness of the wood, but I think the 1-1/2" is better in the softer woods. I can't speak to the harder ones. I'm going to have to experiment a little more on this before I can make a solid judgement. The 1-1/4" hole is also unnecessary in the top of the base. I think 1" is the way to go there. So, for many woods, I think we only need the 1-3/4", a 1-1/2", a 1", and a 15/16". But, it's probably a matter of YMMV, because there are a lot of outside variables here.

Thanks for your reply. I'd like to discuss this further. ...Gary


http://ejmas.com/tin/2009tin/tinart_goldstein_0904.html

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#4

Don Leydens

Re: Ed, I'm very glad to hear what you say...

Don Leydens

Excellent design, Gary. Very sleek and elegant. Well done.

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#5

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

matt overton

They are beautiful. I, too have some mechanisms I am about to use. I appreciate the tips. I planned to use the article as a guide. It's good to know that you recomend it.

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#6

Chuck Jones - West TN

Maybe I'll reconsider...

Chuck Jones - West TN

I'm one of the people who posted dirty words about the Crush Grinds and said "Never again". But after reading these posts I will look at the articles and rethink it. I still haven't seen anything that affects the problem with the top component losing it's tension and sliding off the shaft too easily. I have had a couple with that problem.

Gary, thanks for going to the effort of sharing your experience. I agree with all the positive reasons for using the crush grind if the problems can be overcome.

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#7

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

Chuck Engstrom

Gorgeous work! I have a few CG kits but haven't gotten to making one. I took machine shop course a couple years back from a fellow in Easton who had made up his own single-pass multi-stage bore cutter for them and sells them very successfully at the local farmer's market.

I'll have to get my hands on the articles mentioned here.

--chuck

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#8

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

Joe Herrmann

Glad you found the article worthwhile. CrushGrind peppermills are kind of a mystery to most peppermill makers and I knew Chris' article would explain the pitfalls. He has another article in the works that I'm sure will help a lot of folks as well.

I had an opportunity to look through Chris' book and found it to be very worthwhile. If you are contemplating making some peppermills, you should consider getting a copy.

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#9

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

Chris West

It was nice to hear that turners are starting to use CrushGrind mechanisms.

Just one small tip. In my book I show the hole for the shaft in the top part of the mill as being 3/8" in diameter. This was an error that slipped through. The hole should be 1/2" diameter as shown in my article in the Woodturning Design magazine.

I find myself being the 'UK disciple' trying to convert turners to use CrushGrind mechanisms.

One of the things that does put them off is their perception of the need for expensive, uncommon sized sawtooth bits. A 1/2" skew is one way of opening holes up.

If anyone wants further help or answers to what they may feel is a 'silly question', just email me.

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#10

Thanks, Don

GaryG in MD

I've seen a number of similar ones over the years and been drawn to the style. I particularly like it without the knob on top. ...Gary

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#11

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

GaryG in MD

Matt,

I had already made these when the article came out, and I used my own approach -- not the exact steps in Chris' article, but I immediately recognized that a lot of Chris' background info and techniques are excellent advice. I personally believe that the use of both 1) a groove for the prongs and 2) epoxy in the groove with the prongs are important to the long-term stability of the inserts in both the up/down and rotational directions. I used a home-made Allen wrench scraper held in a boring bar (and precise measurements) to make the groove, but if I were going to make a lot of them, it would be nice to have a more efficient, purpose-built scraper like the one Chris shows in his article.

The thing I still have to work on is the combination of perfect fit and alignment of the top and bottom sections. I haven't made one with the spigot in the bottom of the top yet, but I believe that's the way to go, even if it slightly reduces the grain match. That provides an excellent "feel" to the grinding action. ...Gary

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#12

Re: Maybe I'll reconsider...

GaryG in MD

Chuck, I understand exactly what you're saying. These things can be unforgiving, particularly with bad/wrong instructions such as we get. I don't know what to say about the loose top. The two I got from PSI were very tight. After reading your previous comments, that's one of the first things I checked. In fact, mine were so tight I was concerned it might be too hard to put the top back on. Turns out it's just right. They have a very tightly wound short spring holding the collet closed. My only surmise is that you must have gotten defective ones. I recommend that when people buy these mills, they first check to make sure the fit of the top mechanism on the shaft is extremely tight. If they're not, send them back immediately and post your experience here on WC so we can see if there is, indeed, a QC problem with these units. A little feedback directly to CrushGrind would be in order too.

Give it another try and let us know how you fare. ...Gary

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#13

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

GaryG in MD

Thanks Chuck. I owe Ed Karch for the glue ups, and, although I've since seen a number of similar forms online, I owe Mike Twenty for sticking the design in my head with his beautiful, smaller one in buckeye burl (even tho it was a trad style with the knob on top).

I'll have to talk to you about the drilling... I think I know how to do it, but I have to do one more to get my notes in order. I believe the key to the ultimate fit is refining the outside shape of both sections to match concentricity with the inside holes after the latter are drilled. That eliminates any runout in the earlier steps.

We've got to make a time to share a libation or two. ...Gary

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#14

thanks, Joe...

GaryG in MD

Keep 'em coming! ...Gary

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#15

Hi Chris,

GaryG in MD

Welcome to WC. (I'm not sure if you've been here before because the search function doesn't work right, but you don't have a Profile.)

Excellent article on a very much-needed topic.

I'm also interested in buying your book, but the mills on the cover appear to be the traditional kind with knobs on top. Would you say that at least half of your mill coverage is for the shafted CrushGrind style?

We'll look forward to your future efforts, and please consider checking in here with your work. ...Gary

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#16

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

Ed Larson

Just got back to the computer. I drill the hole in the bottom from both ends. This lets any drill wandering be inside the mill. This has not been mentioned and I believe it helps reduce aligenment problems. I found with traditional mills wandering of the bit when the 1/4 inch hole in the top is drill lead to misalignment. This shoud be eliminated with the crushgrind mechanism. You will have a center point mark on the top of the top from when you roughed out the blank. For the prototype I made I used the 1 3/4, 1 1/2, 1 1/4 and 7/8 forsner bits (all standard sizes). In the future I plan to use a 1" bit for the hole through the bottom and drill it to within 1" plus or minus of the end and then use the 1 1/4 bit when I drill from the other end. I had a norrow waist on the prototype and nearly came through the side. I believe a 1 1/4 hole for the top spigot give more meat to the spigot.

Great thread, now to shop to make a mill

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#17

Chuck Jones - West TN

btw Great Design; beautiful mills


Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#18

Re: Maybe I'll reconsider...

Tony - Memphis

Me too, but my issue was that the grinder just didn't work. I tried a couple of them and they would not grind peppercorns. They just got locked up. Actually, I'm finishing up a grinder now with a deluxe grinder that I had lying around from many years ago to replace a crush grind I made as a gift. I felt bad that I gave my brother a gift that was faulty (it sort of worked for me, but he never did get it working well).

Tony

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#19

Beautiful Mills Gary!


Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#20

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

david

I have read this thread and can say that most of the issues discussed are contained in my post on how I make my CrushGrind mills. Please scroll through the posts until you find the two that are about the mills. kawikahuliwood.com

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#21

it may have been set too coarse...

GaryG in MD

If they're set "wide open", they tend to bind up.

Setting it for a slightly finer grind may improve the performance. ...Gary

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#22

Thanks, David.

GaryG in MD

I'll take a long look at that.

BTW, love your work. ...Gary

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#23

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

Terry Scott

Lovely work Gary

Re: CrushGrind peppermills...

#24

Thank you, Terry...

GaryG in MD

Coming for you, that means a lot.

I swore I'd never turn a pen, but our Club got into the Pens for Warriors project, so I wanted to do my part.

My very first one was made from the little piece of black maire you sent me. I love it! Looks and feels great. Very special to me. ...Gary