Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

unscientific poll

Posts

unscientific poll

#1

Keith Tompkins

unscientific poll

keith tompkins

I raised the question on a previous post...Do you use a faceplate when mounting large or unbalanced work?

Do you bring up the tailstock as a precaution?

Do you use a larger set of jaws in your chuck for large pieces?

Do you inspect/replace worn jaws on your chuck?

Have you ever disassembled and lubed your chuck?

Re: unscientific poll

#2

Yes to all except

Mike Foster

I have never replace any jaws. They all look fine.

Re: unscientific poll

#3

Re: unscientific poll

Jim Pugh

It looks to me that you are asking questions on two subjects: mounting large, out of balance pieces and chuck maintenance....

On the first: I almost always mount a large and/or out of balance piece with a faceplate. Sometimes, I have to provide a flat spot for the faceplate by using a very large forstener type bit in a drill press while holding the bowl blank in a special fixture to keep it from turning. And I always use a tail center for support until the piece is round and balanced or ready to be turned around in the chuck. Sometimes I'll even use the tail center while the bowl face is trued up as well.

On chuck maintenance: I haven't used my chucks to the point the jaws are worn or damaged so haven't replaced them per se. For larger pieces I have a Oneway chuck with #3 jaws that I use. For more normal size pieces I use a Talon chuck with #2 jaws. Also have another Talon chuck with very small jaws for more delicate pieces. Hope this is the type of response you are looking for.

Re: unscientific poll

#4

Re: unscientific poll

Richard Jones

Yes to all

Re: unscientific poll

#5

Re: unscientific poll

Bill Neddow

Yes to all -- it is a matter of common sense and safety. Be sure to keep the crud out of the teeth on the jaws. You tend to get a buildup of old glue, etc. there and pretty soon you no longer have teeth holding the spigot. You are "gumming" the piece rather than gripping it.

Re: unscientific poll

#6

Yes to all except last

Jorge Casta�eda

I think lubing will collect more wood dust and end up being more of a problem, so I disassemble and clean it but no lub.

Re: unscientific poll

#7

Leo Cuellar

Re: unscientific poll

Leo Cuellar

I don't use a faceplate very often, but yes to all the others. I have also trued up the face and edges of most of my jaws. Because I do a lot of eccentric pieces I replace the screws holding the jaws to the chuck on a regular basis. Buying them by the package is pretty inexpensive, and you don't have to go sifting through the shavings right away if you drop one.

Re: unscientific poll

#8

Denis Putland

Re: unscientific poll

Denis Putland

You ask

"Do you use a faceplate when mounting large or unbalanced work?"

Almost never any more. I can not remember exactly when I last used one.

"Do you bring up the tail stock as a precaution?"

Since I do not use a face plate the answer is yes ;) and also when in chucking mode when it is practical.

"Do you use a larger set of jaws in your chuck for large pieces?"

Yes!

"Do you inspect/replace worn jaws on your chuck?"

If you have a good chuck I am not sure how you can get worn chuck jaws when using it with wood?

"Have you ever disassembled and lubed your chuck?"

Yes

I turn a lot of large (20in. swing) natural edged pieces so most are at the least some what out of balance and I have never lost one from my spur drive when it was properly seated.

Denis

Re: unscientific poll

#9

Yes to all.

Jennifer@Indy.USA

Re: unscientific poll

#10

Re: unscientific poll

Lan Brady

Yes to all

Re: unscientific poll

#11

Re: unscientific poll

john lucas

I do use a faceplate for some things although I tend to use the chucks a lot. I use larger jaws for larger pieces. No I rarely clean my chucks, they simply don't need it. I think I cleaned one of them once. I have never replaced a set of jaws. My Vicmarc jaws are tough I guess, they simply don't wear out.

I use the tailstock any time I can.

Re: unscientific poll

#12

Ken Vaughan

Big Honking Drive Center -

Ken Vaughan

So far I have been using a big drive center from Bill Rubenstein (StubbyUSA) for balancing- adjusting and for initial turning.

Tailstock -- when ever possible

As large a jaws as the "Plan" will accomidate. I have a large vicmark with larger 4 inch jaws that feels solid.

I clean and inspect all the chucks and jaws periodically. And I have "red tagged" some of the lesser quality ones.

Re: unscientific poll

#13

Re: unscientific poll

Richard Galloway

yes, to everything except the larger jaws.. Don't have any to change to.. or I would.

Re: unscientific poll

#14

Yes to all But the Last Question...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Re: unscientific poll

#15

Richard Allen

Yes

Richard Allen

Re: unscientific poll

#16

Re: unscientific poll

Bob Verne

Yes to all with the following exceptions:

- I haven't done a major dis-assembly for lubing; I use "Lock-Eze", (a colloidal graphite suspension with a rapidly evaporating carrier. Available in most hardware stores.). This seems to penetrate chucks rather well w/o needing dis-assembly. After drying, there isn't any remaining stickiness that retains dust, etc. After a day or so, to check dryness and to prevent spraying lube, I mount the chuck, cover it with newspaper (holding it off the chuck, of course) and spin it up a bit. I do this irregularly, probably once or twice a year... whenever they seem to be getting a little stiff.

- I haven't needed to replace any jaws yet. All seem to be in good shape.

Bob

Re: unscientific poll

#17

Re: unscientific poll

Ray - Middletown, In

1. Depends on the piece, but most of the time yes.

2. Until balanced at least

3. Most of the time but not always, depends on desired end result

4. Inspect but have never replaced

5. No need unless a major problem is encountered.

Ray

Re: unscientific poll

#18

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Yes to all questions

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: unscientific poll

#19

Re: Yes to all except last

Walt Didesch

When I cleaned mine, I lubed it with powdered graphite. Makes it nice and slick.

Re: unscientific poll

#20

Re: Yes to all except last

Jorge Casta�eda

Good idea! Why I did not think of that?

Thank you Walt!

Re: unscientific poll

#21

Walt Bennett

Re: unscientific poll

Walt Bennett

Do you use a faceplate when mounting large or unbalanced work? YES

Do you bring up the tailstock as a precaution? NO - balance it enough first

Do you use a larger set of jaws in your chuck for large pieces? YES

Do you inspect/replace worn jaws on your chuck? YES, but never had to replace

Have you ever disassembled and lubed your chuck? YES disassembled and cleaned, NO never lubed - that makes particles stick.

Re: unscientific poll

#22

Re: Yes to all 

D. Hansen

Re: unscientific poll

#23

Mike Stafford

Re: unscientific poll

Mike Stafford

Yes to all except for large unbalanced pieces. I seldom if ever turn large unbalanced pieces.

I round up with a jig all my platter blanks so that they are as round as they can be without turning. Once mounted they are supported by the tailstock for as long as possible.

With regard to jaw size I am the anal retentive Type I. I read everything that comes with my chuck and jaws. If the literature says this set of jaws is recommended for blanks up to 12 inches and I wish to turn something 14 in diameter I use the next larger size of jaws. It only makes sense to follow the directions.

For that matter I use the live center for support while turning boxes; after jam fitting the lid to provide insurance while removing waste; when reverse turning the box body while jammed on a waste block. It is cheap insurance to protect me and my work.

Re: unscientific poll

#24

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: unscientific poll

Chuck Jones - West TN

Yes I use a face plate often on large pieces if there is a flat surface that provides a secure connection.

I use the tailstock whenever possible, even if not necessarily needed.

Yes I usually use larger jaws on larger pieces.

I inspect and clean the jaws often (more often now) but I am not aware of any need to replace them.

I have never disassembled or lubricated my chucks. Wasn't aware that it was required. Wouldn't have used oil for reasons already stated in earlier posts. Graphite makes better sense if lubrication is necessary.

I know I read the instructions on my (SuperNova II) chucks when I first bought them. I have that CRS problem so I may be wrong, but I'm pretty sure it said to only take them apart if they weren't working properly and I do not recall anything about lubrication. Also, don't recall being alerted to any possibility of wear on the jaws.

Due to recent sad events I think most of us are of a mindset to learn anything that that may improve safety. So I am going back to reread the chuck instructions and I would appreciate any enlightenment anyone has on these last two questions.