thanks for update
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The same person that told me he saw Hirsch and Two Cherries being made on same line told me that many, if not all, of the small shops making carving tools in Germany, Austria and Switzerland were consolidating.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
thanks for update
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The same person that told me he saw Hirsch and Two Cherries being made on same line told me that many, if not all, of the small shops making carving tools in Germany, Austria and Switzerland were consolidating.
No room for improvement
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I am at a stage of chest of drawer building where I have been chiseling more than usual which put me to thinking about your suggestion. I push my CPM 3V steel chisels across diamond particles and metal promptly goes away. My enjoyment of a day is not affected by how a chisel sliding across an abrasive feels. I push the sharpened chisel across wood fibers and they promptly go away. Crudely made as they are my home made chisels fit my hand well and subconsciously they are the chisels I reach for when I need wood to go away.
There isn't any room for significant improvement in my shop. There simply is no performance, cost or time to be saved with Warren's way. If I was starting over from scratch the only thing I would change is I would heat treat the CMP3V to 2 points of additional Rockwell hardness. In less time and at less cost I could make a comprehensive set of chisels and would be back working. Disparage as one might I do like the smaller chisel sizes from 1/8" to 1/2" in 1/16" increments . I use them all so it follows all these sizes must be useful for my work.
Now, If I took up Period Reenactment, or otherwise chose to freeze my sharpening technology to 1850 I will accept that chisels of that day could be a better match. It does seem possible that chisels of the day were optimized to be sharpened by the limited abrasives available. For me this reasonable conjecture is irrelevant for I have not limited my technology to some past time. .
Them smaller chisel sizes
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
" I do like the smaller chisel sizes from 1/8" to 1/2" in 1/16" increments ."
Me too, and I'm surprised not to see this opinion voiced more often. The sets of chisels generally offered are the very opposite, covering a wide range on a coarse spacing. I have a set of Japanese push chisels--1/8 to 1/2, in sixteenths, with 5 degree beveled sides--made years ago. And similarly, mortise chisels through 3/8. The value is in the fine gradation, as with plough irons. For example, I think 3/16" is an important size, and 5/16" is very useful. For both dovetails and mortises.
But I don't recall ever seeing a set of smalls routinely offered, so perhaps Bill and I are in the minority. Though I have seen an awful lot of beat-to-crap plough irons that looked to have been pressed into chisel service in these smaller but unusual sizes.
Just an observation..
Wiley
Re: Them smaller chisel sizes
Brian Holcombe
I have chisels in 1 bu increments through 2 sun. 
Re: Bill/Todd
TM Stock
Been there...done that...have the Old Tools t-shirt and a couple boxes of old rust that I'll get a round to restoring when I retire (again). I appreciate the advice - even when it sounds remarkably like "Hey you kids! Get off of my lawn!!!"
Re: Wil's tools
TM Stock
As a youngster, I was introduced to Murphy's Laws of Combat by a helpful gentleman with a bunch of rockers on his sleeve. One of the ones that stuck with me was, "If it looks stupid but works, it ain't stupid."
Along the same lines, if it looks awkward but works (even for an accomplished pro), it's not awkward.
What DOES seems a little awkward is the notion that we can judge a craftsman's level of skill, knowledge, or expertise based on a single snapshot.
Re: No room for improvement *LINK*
Warren in Lancaster, PA
No room for improvement? Aren't you the one who keeps insisting that chisels inevitably dull by chipping and deformation? Mine don't chip even when chopping hickory, persimmon or jarrah. I think it is more efficient to have a chisel that remains sharp during drawer work.
Yes, here we have it:
chipping
Re: Bill/Todd - 19th century tools...
John Aniano in Central NJ
Hi Brian,
I do enjoy the hunt for old English (and American) 19th century tools, in fact I found a nice 18th century British mounding plane by Phillipson (1740-1775) at the same flea market as the drawknife. By your comments, should I be looking to find you a set of 19th century chisels as well? Tanged or socketed? (I prefer the former as they are more common in English tools). Let me know if I should begin the search - nothing would please me more! As I said, I find enjoyment in the search...
BTW, the handles for your drawknife are moving along - I spent some time on the first one today. I will make a posting in the future about how I did them. More complicated than I first thought because of the domed ferrules and metal riveted ends, but I'm always up for a challenge!
John
Re: I also enjoy spending other people's $$...
Re: Bill/Todd - 19th century tools...
Brian Holcombe
Hi John,
That is quite tempting, I would like to give them a try especially to compare and contrast to contemporary Japanese chisels. Much appreciated!
How do you feel about putting together a blog post on the handles? Thanks again, very excited to see how these turn out!
Best Regards
Brian
Re: Bill/Todd
Brian Holcombe

Re: No room for improvement
Brian Holcombe
I've had a similar experience to Warren. Here is a carving chisel after carving out two arm rests in white oak. It was not sharpened prior to starting the work, because it was still quite sharp. I cannot detect any defect in the edge.

This blade is high carbon steel and it was sharpened on a combination of Japanese natural stones (for the outside) and I removed the burr on the inside with translucent Arkansas slip. These may be ancient technologies but they work exceptionally well in my experience and I have many modern abrasives in my shop to compare to some of them are in fact literally much finer than the natural stones which cannot be finer than about 8k grit.
I have one synthetic which is 12k grit which cannot produce as good of an edge as the Nakayama asagi stone. It produces a much more uniform finish, which shines more like a mirror, but it does not produce a higher quality edge.
I have blue steel 1 chisels and planes in my shop, as well as an alloy 'Tougou Kou' that take an excellent edges off of natural stones. Both steels are alloys.
I concede that we all draw a limit at some point to our interest in changing any process or procedure, but I think that you can still find improvement if such interest existed, surly. Kunimoto, for instance, inspired by Usui-Kengo has worked for 25 years to improve his sharpening.
Re: Bill/Todd - 19th century tools...
John Aniano in Central NJ
Sure Brian,
I'll take the photos while I make and fit the handles, let you see them and then decide if and where to post them, along with some commentary.
It's more the process sequence rather than difficulty with any particular step that I've had to decide upon.
John
Re: Bill/Todd - 19th century tools...
Brian Holcombe
Sounds good, I think it will make for an interesting post.
Straight beats pare...
Re: No
david weaver
Amateurish brains and hands create amateurish work.
Customers won't buy amateurish work for the same price as professional work (or more in some cases), so there's no reason to buy amateurish tools for the same price or more if you know what to buy.
Most people don't at the outset. I didn't, either. Tools that were designed with incremental improvement and for use by pros are just nicer to use.
Re: Stanley's yaller-handled chisels
Joe shelton
No, Bill, not Mad Max. I'm pretty sure it's Fad Max. But you're right about their utility. Mine do a lot of work while allowing my 750's to stay on the rack at home.