Re: You have a point on the steel but not the brea
david weaver
It's not so much elderly, it's a combination of things:
Amateurish:
* as hard as possible, edge retention as long as possible, especially despite abuse
* heavy blades, sometimes copies of construction chisels. The weight in the blade is touted implying it adds durability (and it does if the user is an abuser)
* absolute perfection in flatness (old chisels were finished well, actually better than current chisels, but the geometry wasn't as great)
* socket chisel handles, leaves the newbie with "options". Often described as more expensive because of the socket. An experienced user can turn and burn in a new handle for a tang chisel very easily, but it's not something an amateur would covet doing. Sometimes the handles are too short to grip and hammer at the same time, leaving the user gripping further down the tool.
* perfect width for measurement ("tool slaving"). If it says a quarter of an inch, get out the micrometer.
* steel that is very favorably behaved in hardening and tempering (A2, for example)
Older version (for the elderly, as you say), like 150+ years old
* edge retention and sharpness are considered in combination, how they fit in the work flow. Except for japanese chisels where the work flow is *not* to include being seen sharpening, it means a tool should sharpen well on medium and fine stones, a dry steel feeling, and still have good edge retention. It should also sharpen on natural stones or other mediums that don't require constant lapping, upkeep, etc.
* the blade of a chisel is well finished and light, but not geometrically perfect or caliper checked. There is no need to make a blade fat for abuse
* The chisels are intended to be gripped at the handle, something most will come to prefer if they work on something long enough.
* If there are bevels, they are cut cleanly and to a fine edge. generally over a wide flat area (see an old ward chisel).
* tang design with forged bolster. If the chisel is later or even current, the bolster may be a tang/mock socket design, or a round die forged bolster, but an octagonal flat faceted forged bolster would be nicer. chisels of this type with plain steel are hard to harden to perfect flatness, and there is wastage as some will crack, thus we don't see them at all that I'm aware of.
Stubai makes a larger version of modern chisels, as do others, where the blade is reasonably thin, but their chisels are quite long, and the bevel work isn't great. The handles are very machine-made feeling, but for $129 for 6 of them, they're not too bad.
I mentioned the iles chisels above because they have the gradual bevel that the better finished old chisels did (they're not finished as well as an old ward, but for functional purposes, they're great), their blades are light enough that they are great handle grip chisels (they're quite light, actually), the steel is amenable to quick sharpening but holds an edge well, etc. If I had only one set of bench chisels, they'd be my choice hands down. And they can be had ex-vat from England at classic hand tools for about $160 with shipping (much cheaper than the US) for the set of 6. I couldn't imagine making the set of them for that price.
Chisels that are amateurish for bench chisel work:
* Barr -fat and heavy/bulky design
* Lie nielsen (sorry to the partisans), socket which is of little functionality, terrible A2 steel - terrible choice in alloys I should say, LN does A2 as well as anybody and better than most - fat blades and short handle. Perfectly flat. Copied from a construction chisel. I don't think LN can handle forging something like a tang chisel and they have no tolerance for anything that doesn't harden and temper easily (note no O1 irons any longer), but there may have been a better choice.
* Blue spruce - A2. Actually nicely formed bevels on the bench chisels, but look amateurish with no bolster. Lack of bolster is inexcusable for a chisel of that price. Extremely expensive for a chisel that's not quite as good proportionally as an ashley iles chisel. A2 is a bad choice.
I'm sure I could find others. I haven't used the new LV chisels, but they are not something I would buy with the Iles chisels already covering the territory. Anything that V11 does, O1 will do with another 2 degrees of bevel angle.
The proportions of the old chisels were different, they were lighter and handle grip oriented with the assumption that the user would have no use for taking their hands off of the handle in a sequence of work. the blade and tang didn't need to be bulbous because a skilled user will drive a chisel straight into the cut and that's it. For the same reason, a skilled user doesn't need steel that will cut nails - any decent quality steel will fail less if it's driven straight in.