Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

high end chisel recomendations?

Posts

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#51

Re: Two Cherry set up was not easy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The large chisel on the left has the advantage that one can also use it to check their make-up during YouTube shoots of woodworking.

My set looked like what was on the left and the edges on the back were severely rounded over from the polishing. It took much grinding to correct the situation. Not what I expected from a premium price chisel. They did have good steel though but I found them top heavy for the way I chisel dovetails.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#52

Re: What the Pros use

Todd Stock

Heck...why not let everyone - not just us engineers - buy what they want? I'll tell you why...chaos! Pretty soon you'll have people thinking stuff like "Maybe I WON'T follow the herd and convert half a tree into an 900 lb bench without vises!" and shortly after that, there's no herd, and without a herd, THERE ARE NO TAKE-AWAY HAMBURGERS!

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#53

Re: Two Cherry set up was not easy

Todd Stock

I've always strongly disliked the oval chisel handles that the brand went to in the mid-1980's...but fortunately, Two Cherries in the light/short pattern are again available in the octagonal handles found on the older tools. The buffer round-over remains, but the recent stuff I've seen as not nearly as bad as the set my dad had circa 1987. Now if we can convince them to skip the buff and the lacquer on the blades, and flatten the backs a bit, we'd have us a pretty decent chisel.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#54

Re: You have a point on the steel but not the brea

david weaver

It's not so much elderly, it's a combination of things:

Amateurish:

* as hard as possible, edge retention as long as possible, especially despite abuse

* heavy blades, sometimes copies of construction chisels. The weight in the blade is touted implying it adds durability (and it does if the user is an abuser)

* absolute perfection in flatness (old chisels were finished well, actually better than current chisels, but the geometry wasn't as great)

* socket chisel handles, leaves the newbie with "options". Often described as more expensive because of the socket. An experienced user can turn and burn in a new handle for a tang chisel very easily, but it's not something an amateur would covet doing. Sometimes the handles are too short to grip and hammer at the same time, leaving the user gripping further down the tool.

* perfect width for measurement ("tool slaving"). If it says a quarter of an inch, get out the micrometer.

* steel that is very favorably behaved in hardening and tempering (A2, for example)

Older version (for the elderly, as you say), like 150+ years old

* edge retention and sharpness are considered in combination, how they fit in the work flow. Except for japanese chisels where the work flow is *not* to include being seen sharpening, it means a tool should sharpen well on medium and fine stones, a dry steel feeling, and still have good edge retention. It should also sharpen on natural stones or other mediums that don't require constant lapping, upkeep, etc.

* the blade of a chisel is well finished and light, but not geometrically perfect or caliper checked. There is no need to make a blade fat for abuse

* The chisels are intended to be gripped at the handle, something most will come to prefer if they work on something long enough.

* If there are bevels, they are cut cleanly and to a fine edge. generally over a wide flat area (see an old ward chisel).

* tang design with forged bolster. If the chisel is later or even current, the bolster may be a tang/mock socket design, or a round die forged bolster, but an octagonal flat faceted forged bolster would be nicer. chisels of this type with plain steel are hard to harden to perfect flatness, and there is wastage as some will crack, thus we don't see them at all that I'm aware of.

Stubai makes a larger version of modern chisels, as do others, where the blade is reasonably thin, but their chisels are quite long, and the bevel work isn't great. The handles are very machine-made feeling, but for $129 for 6 of them, they're not too bad.

I mentioned the iles chisels above because they have the gradual bevel that the better finished old chisels did (they're not finished as well as an old ward, but for functional purposes, they're great), their blades are light enough that they are great handle grip chisels (they're quite light, actually), the steel is amenable to quick sharpening but holds an edge well, etc. If I had only one set of bench chisels, they'd be my choice hands down. And they can be had ex-vat from England at classic hand tools for about $160 with shipping (much cheaper than the US) for the set of 6. I couldn't imagine making the set of them for that price.

Chisels that are amateurish for bench chisel work:

* Barr -fat and heavy/bulky design

* Lie nielsen (sorry to the partisans), socket which is of little functionality, terrible A2 steel - terrible choice in alloys I should say, LN does A2 as well as anybody and better than most - fat blades and short handle. Perfectly flat. Copied from a construction chisel. I don't think LN can handle forging something like a tang chisel and they have no tolerance for anything that doesn't harden and temper easily (note no O1 irons any longer), but there may have been a better choice.

* Blue spruce - A2. Actually nicely formed bevels on the bench chisels, but look amateurish with no bolster. Lack of bolster is inexcusable for a chisel of that price. Extremely expensive for a chisel that's not quite as good proportionally as an ashley iles chisel. A2 is a bad choice.

I'm sure I could find others. I haven't used the new LV chisels, but they are not something I would buy with the Iles chisels already covering the territory. Anything that V11 does, O1 will do with another 2 degrees of bevel angle.

The proportions of the old chisels were different, they were lighter and handle grip oriented with the assumption that the user would have no use for taking their hands off of the handle in a sequence of work. the blade and tang didn't need to be bulbous because a skilled user will drive a chisel straight into the cut and that's it. For the same reason, a skilled user doesn't need steel that will cut nails - any decent quality steel will fail less if it's driven straight in.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#55

Re: What the Pros use

david weaver

Bill, I don't think the type of chisel ultimately makes that much of a difference in the work product. However, there is something to learn from a group of people working at the trade 200 years ago when they had to do it to survive. They weren't teaching at colleges, giving classes or selling books. The demands of those workers were much higher, and we'd be wiser to learn from them than to find straw examples describing why we shouldn't.

As to your comment earlier about the proportions of the chisel being more important than whether or not it's wonder steel. I agree. There is a limit even for my taste, though, in that a chisel that is a little soft is fine. One that is defective (as sometimes something like a marples chisel will be, or one of their counterparts, the stanley 5001) is something that I can't tolerate, but re-hardening is always an option for anyone with a paint can full of oil and a few heating options.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#56

Re: What the Pros use

david weaver

Well, if you're doing mostly machine planing, mostly sanding and a little bit of beveling with a smooth plane, you won't need a 900 (400) pound bench.

You'll have to figure the vises out on your own. My bench has a row of dog holes in the first board for about 2 feet. I'll bet most people don't do that, but they'd quickly figure out they wished they'd have done that if they like to build planes.

I'm not sure which is more foolish, though, the person who wants to work a lot by hand but doesn't invest in making a stable bench (I learned the hard way), or the person who treats their bench like a couch covered with plastic and who does little hand work, anyway, but had to build a decorative-looking bench. Aesthetic shop furniture is something I don't really get. It's like a wall of vintage guitars in a house where the owner doesn't know how to play anything harder than smoke on the water.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#57

Re: What the Pros use

Todd Stock

Just an example of herd behavior - not a specific complaint!

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#58

Re: You have a point on the steel but not the brea

Todd Stock

Ah...I understand...your preferences lie elsewhere. So do these amateurish tools produce - by definition - amateurish work?

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#60

don't even bring up workbenches!

Joseph Piotrowski

i'm in a facebook group for workbench builders. when i went to the dark side, i started with a cheap 129.00 harbor freight bench. i didn't know what i didn't know yet so figure id go cheap and learn what i need. you learn quickly!

so in my quest to learn what options are out there, I'm reading a few books and any forum/facebook group that make sense. and one thing i learned is that 99 pct of the time, when someone ask what type of wood or vices should be used is a religious exchange.

there are two types, one that think it should last for 1000 years and be made of walnut,cheery and white oak. and should cost as much as a used car. no other options are correct.

the other is type is more practical., a workbench should be heavy, flat, and allow solid clamping/holding of work in as many side as you need.

and when these two sides talk about wood for the top, it gets very intense.

i'm all for making it as fancy as you like but when someone says they have a small budget, walnut leg vices and solid hard maple tops are a little extreme to recommend as the only option .

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#61

Re: What the Pros use

William Duffield

Hey, I've got a couple of those clear yellow handled chisels like the ones on Will's bench in your picture. Does that make me a pro? OTOH, I much prefer using my Lie-Nielsens, unless I'm doing carpentry or restoration work where I might encounter a nail or a loose knot or bark inclusion.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#62

Re: don't even bring up workbenches!

david weaver

I don't think you were that unreasonable on the first bench, at least strategy wise (haven't used the HF bench). I used an inexpensive sjobergs bench for almost 10 years and got by with it by ballasting it and boxing the legs in with plywood so that it would be rigid. I still broke it eventually, but I knew what I needed by then and the total cost to make a 400 pound bench with two vises was $800, made out of ash. I spent about 30 total hours on the bench, which included milling the lumber, some by hand and then ultimately just surfacing the lumber with a thickness planer and no jointer when I decided I wanted a bench more than I wanted to build one.

And I got a QR vise and an erie leg screw kit, so I didn't go cheap on vises - the rest of the stuff was only about $425.

The next time I built one, I would do the same thing. Go find what's cheap on the hardwood market and use it. Perhaps even if it's red oak. I so much like having a substantial bench that's now been set up based on what I found I enjoy after 10 years, but also like that it didn't cost that much or take that much time, so I am not afraid to use it for something abusive (building an infill plane and getting metal swarf, etc, all over the surface) and then just scrape off the filth and re-oil it anew.

Everyone has their wants, though. The only issue is with folks who think their wants are yours because they just haven't told you about them enough.

Cap iron, anyone?

Regards - POTP (Part of the Problem...at least sometimes!)

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#63

Stanley's yaller-handled chisels

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I can't speak for the new ones - what's the marketing name, Mad Max? - but the older Stanley yellow-plastic-handled chisels are fantastic carpentry chisels: tough steel that holds an edge and allows for serious abuse (not, not opening paint cans, but prying out chunks of wood and suchlike).

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#64

Re: Stanley's yaller-handled chisels

Todd Stock

One lives in my bags...they sharpen easily, I can hit them with a Douglas framer without fear of waffle-printing, and they still cut at the end of the day when my cordless craps out.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#65

The story on the Yellow Handles

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The material is cellulose acetate butyrate a combination of cellulose, acetic acid and butyric acid. On a hot day you can get a whiff of "rancid butter" from the butyric acid. The material was invented by Kodak and manufactured by Kodak for decades, and now Eastman Chemical Company that spun off from Kodak. My neighbor was the department head where this stuff was made.

It is exceptionally tough and can be dyed any color. In the past any quality screw driver or carpenter chisel had this handle(Sears, Stanley). It is expensive to make. Stanley came under cost pressure from Walmart and the like to lower cost and these handles were a significant cost. Only premium tools, or old tools, are likely to have these handles now days.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#66

Re: The story on the Yellow Handles

david weaver

I think the buck chisels still have those handles. They're $20 for 3. The handles are incredibly heavy.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#67

Re: What the Pros use

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It is always weird to have amateurs tell us what the "pros" do. In the picture you can see a guy with a very cramped style of work. I would call it poor technique. If you want to see good technique, look at Brian Holcombe's chisel work.

I inherited a one inch Stanley #60 yellow chisel from a girlfriend around 45 years ago. It was adequate , but it was short. These chisels were designed for a carpenter to carry around on his belt and have a steel cap so he can hit it with a hammer. After about eight years I replaced it with a Marples boxwood handled chisel.

Then on this forum in 2011, Bill Tindall asked me what kind of chisel I would recommend. When I said 19th century English, Derek Cohen objected that it was not appropriate to talk about these chisels because they were not freely available.

The next morning I replaced my Marples chisel with a $15 19th century example, which I have used ever since. I am thankful to Bill and Derek for spurring me on. I found out later that my friend Rich, professional cabinetmaker, bought a similar chisel that same month for $1.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#68

Re: What the Pros use

Todd Stock

I don't see cramped - I see controlled. The same technique with an overhand grip is commonly used for paring of bindings and purflings...absolutely no room for error there in professional-grade work, and often done in abrasive exotics that are not as well behaved or as kind to tool steel as NA domestics.

While i applaud the work of talented amateurs and agree with Krenov on their role in the craft revival, any one making his or her living with a fair degree of hand tool content embedded in their work is someone to watch carefully...quick, accurate, and to budget is way beyond just accurate.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#69

Re: What the Pros use

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The chisel grip is not so bad, it is the holding his arm rigid against his body. It is just not a fluid technique and would be very tiring in any full time work.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#70

Re: Hirsch steel claimed to be same as Two Cherrie

Dennis

I've done some reading, and in January of 2009 the firms of Wilh. Schmidt (Two Cherries), Bros. Busch (Hirsch), Jacob Busch (Spannsage), and Heinrich Bracht (Bracht) merged.

Ulmia's trademark, and part of the factory was purchased by Anton Kessel GmbH in 2002. Anke (Anton Kessel) make benches.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#71

Re: What the Pros use

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am pleased that I could be of assistance to you, Warren. I do motivation on a professional level. :)

I still maintain that the chisels you recommend are unobtainable ... perhaps in your neck of the woods, but hardly the fare that I or others can purchase as easily, or at all.

I do, however, have several vintage Ward and Sorby bolstered mortice chisels with laminated blades. These are indeed wonderful chisels, and I would love to own a set of bench chisels made like these. The closest I have are Koyamaichi, which I rave about for use with a gennou. I also have a set of Kiyohisa slicks/paring chisels, and these have superb steel. If your chisels are like these, then you are fortunate.

To repeat, as good as vintage steel may be, it is not an option for the vast majority. Could Lee Valley, Lie Nielsen, Blue Spruce , et al manufacture them again? Possibly. At an price similar to existing fare? Unlikely. The modern equivalent is the Japanese chisel. Unfortunately, not in a Western format. Perhaps someone should speak to the Japanese.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#72

Bill/Todd

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Warren!

One thing I've learned, especially as a professional...if Warren gives you advice, take it!

Hunt down a 19th century English made chisel, buy it, restore it sharpen it on proper oil stones. At which point when you return to these arguments you might find yourself on the opposing side. One of my friends recently tracked down an early 19th century hand made draw knife for me, just in sharpening I could tell it is a really wonderful blade and certainly not bested by a modern full steel knife.

Repairing and setting up an older chisel might be a few hours of work but well worth it.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#73

Re: What the Pros use

William Duffield

It is very difficult to tell from one still photo, especially when he is working in an unfamiliar shop with borrowed tools, but I've seen Will Neptune work on several occasions, and his style is very professional, quick while very precise, and with no wasted motions. He obviously understands the tools and the properties of the wood.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#74

Re: What the Pros use

steve voigt

Derek, ebay.uk is a good source for vintage, 19th/early 20th c. chisels. Dave has also linked to some UK sellers (non-ebay) who seem reasonably priced. And postage is cheaper than it used to be, no longer a dealbreaker. I disagree that they are not readily available…I'd say anyone who wants one can find it with a bit of looking, in either the UK or USA.

I'll be the first to admit that vintage chisels can be inconsistent and hit-or-miss propositions. A small percentage of the ones I've gotten were too soft to become regular users. All of them require one to four hours of work to be restored to tip-top condition.

Having said all that, I only use vintage chisels (except for two japanese I use for heavy mortising), for all the reasons that have already been stated here (ergonomics and ease of sharpening being the biggest ones). I like tang style the best, but I use a number of old socket chisels as well, with no complaints. If someone made new chisels like the ones Larry Williams and Don McConnell made, I would buy them. Until then, I"ll stick with vintage, or make my own if I ever get the time.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#75

Wil's tools

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

He was working with his own tools. His body of work speaks for itself. I judge his (and other's) skill by what he makes not how he stands to make it or what tools he chooses.

Wil has been occupied with a multiyear commission of Period Furniture. If he ever resumes doing classes I encourage anyone to take one. He is the most inspiring woodworker I have ever been around. Will has insights on how to make stuff that are simple, yet elegant solutions to construction. His insight on how to make a domed structure was so elegant I went home and made a domed trunk just to experience the technique. It was a novel application of geometry, but involved a table saw, something Wil does not eschew.