Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

high end chisel recomendations?

Posts

high end chisel recomendations?

#1

high end chisel recomendations?

Joseph Piotrowski

it must be how i layout the dovetails but i'm finding myself in need a 3/8 inch chisel, which i don't have. i like my narex chisels but i would like to buy chisel with better manufacturing. i am so tired of spending my limited shop time flatting the back of tools. the last narex i purchased tool me 2 hours to flatten and even then it has as hollow spot way to close to the cutting edge. and no i don' t want a courser stone than i already have. i'd like a tool from a manufacturer that grinds there chisel flat. hollow ground like a Japanese chisel if fine if they are good enough to get flat in 10 mins.

the primary use for this tool is chopping dovetails. i'm open to big or small handcrafted manufactures.

if anything my sharpening skills have increased to the level where i can shave the hairs off my knuckles with no problems! manscaping, one chisel at a time :)

TIA

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#2

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

david weaver

The ashley iles chisels in the English pattern ("MK 2" bench chisel length) are as good as anything I've used.

If we start to compromise on the shape and weight of the chisel in order to get some other attribute, maybe something else will be preferred, but if you're just going to sharpen a chisel and you want something with a delicate profile, they are what I would get.

Tools for working wood has them, but it's cheaper to get them from England directly if you're going to get more than a few.

Disclaimer, I have probably had about 30 sets of chisels (not because you have to go through lots like that, but because I'm always curious). That's just my opinion. the only chisels I like better are vintage chisels of the english tradition - ward types, etc, but the difference is very small and the chisels I'm talking about can be hard to find.

In the event that you buy a chisel that is a little less than perfectly flat, do what you can with it, sharpen the bevel to a fine edge and strop off the wire edge. you'll be surprised how well it works. That'll give you a little time to continue to work the back over time, and eventually it'll be perfect. If it's not way off to start, you'll not notice the difference in work unless you can't remove the wire edge.

(I just checked my email history, I got a set of 6 of them from classic hand tools and with the exchange rate at the time, they were about $160 shipped - it does appear that the price has gone up about $20 though. They weren't available from TFWW at the time due to stock issues, and I like TFWW, but I would've ordered them from the UK for the price difference, anyway - it was $40 at the time. Your choice on that - spending the extra $ for a favored vendor isn't a bad thing).

If you're thinking up or down from there in price (that works out to ballpark $27 per chisel with shipping), let me and others here know. I probably have more experience with more sets of various things than most other people because I'm a tinkerer and curious. But I do use the chisels, so it's semi-productive tinkering.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#3

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joseph

The best chisels for chopping are Japanese. I can recommend Koyamaichi. In the Western chisels, Veritas PM-V11 come a close second for edge holding, but are better in the hand for paring.

Here is the test I did: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/FourChiselSteelsCompared.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#4

Re: backtrack on price comment..

david weaver

... the price at classic handtools includes VAT. You don't have to pay that if you're in the US and message the seller, it would be 113 pounds for the 6 chisel set without VAT (which is what I paid) plus about 20 pounds shipping. About $150 if you're in the US.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#5

Lee Valley

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

All their Canadian manufactured tools are ground to exceptional flatness.

That said, the thinner blade style on the Blue Spruce chisels you might find better for dovetails.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#6

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

Archie

Derek's article is an excellent guide. I've got the Lee Nielson A2 chisels, and they do a bunch more chopping than my other O1 chisels. I prefer the crisp edges of O1 over A2, but once I do get the A2 sharp, it works much longer before needing resharpening. OTOH, I splurged for some Ashley Iles chisels and their lands (edges) are the best for getting into corners of dovetails. Wow, they are terrific. So, I tend to use the LNs for the heavy work and the Ashley Iles for any delicate clean up. After Reading Derek's comparison, I'm toying with idea of purchasing a couple of the white steel Japanese chisels to experiment with. Unfortunately, I must be kin to David Weaver in this regard. (I do have a few of his former sharpening stones). :)

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#7

Japanese Chisels

Brian Holcombe

Can be a lot of work, usually highly dependent on both maker quality and user experience. I can usually set the backs up in a few minutes.

A brand such as Kikuhiromaru are consistently very high quality and easy to setup.

Brands such as Kiyohisa, Konobu and Kunikei are extremely high quality and generally easy to setup. Tasai are also very easy to setup and I believe the younger Tasai has been working in white 1 on request.

Expensive does not always mean easy, I've had a few brands that have been really awful to setup.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#8

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

Todd Stock

In terms of prep (or lack thereof required), LV, LN, or Blue Spruce bench chisels all clean up in a few minutes and hold an edge. I'm partial to the Stanley socket style after using them for since my teens, but otherwise, it ends up being what works for you in the hand and eye. Perhaps buy one of each and have your own personal chisel shoot-out...decide on a winner and you'll still get most of what you paid for the losers on eBay or the classifieds.

Despite all the new tech that's been applied to chisels, I still go to my 1970's Ulmia Two Cherries for most stuff...they don't hold an edge in exotic abrasives as well as the new alloys, but the balance is perfect and the handles comfortable...the extra trip or two to the sharpening bench goes by quickly.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#9

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

Kees

+1 for the Koyamaichi's white steel chisels from Tools From Japan. When I had a bunch of jatoba I decided to splurge on these. I bought 5 carefully selected chisels, some small ones, a 3/4" and something wide. I don't have the money for complete sets.

Setting them up was not a lot of work. Flattening goes quickly. Extra work is setting the hoops of course. The chisels are easy to sharpen and they hold an edge very well. BTW, I don't go for the Japanese sharpening culture. Mine look awfull probably because I have no qualms to hollow grind them on a high speed grinder. Then I hone them on American oilstones.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#10

Two Cherry set up was not easy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Unless times have changed since 10 years ago, the Two Cherries are miserable to get tuned. Mine were polished and the polishing rounded over the backs near the edge. Additionally there was some coating that was difficult to remove. For dovetailing I found them top heavy, at least for the way I chop. I prefer a shorter, lighter weight handle chisel for dovetail chopping.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#11

I'm curious...

John in NM

I've never worried too much about flattening a chisel back. As long as I get something reasonable near the cutting edge - say flat 1/4" back from the edge, I don't have any trouble with the tool in use.

Now granted, I don't chop a whole lot of dovetails, but it seems to me that back flattening is largely a waste of time. Can anyone explain the importance of it?

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#12

Why a flat back

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't see how a chisel can be sharpened if the black is rounded over at the edge. When I have tried to short cut this flattening process I find that future sharpenings result in ever more rounding. Eventually one will reach the point that it will be difficult to chisel to base lines accurately or orient the chisel for paring.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#13

Re: I'm curious...

david weaver

The way it's presented in modern beginner's sharpening topics, you're right.

If you can get to the wire edge from the back of an iron, then the tool will be sharp. Perfection at the edge matters for finish planing.

Very close to perfection is attainable with much less than that.

I made a crappy video a couple of days ago setting up a parallel iron from old stock (someone's old stock) using only 80 grit sandpaper and a washita. I'm sure the shavings weren't thicker than half thousandth - they didn't register on my calipers afterward.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#14

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

david weaver

If all of the tools and stones didn't work so well, it'd be easier for me to leave them with their prior owners :) I have mostly abandoned the synthetic stones for the natural types. If there is a third type I don't know about, then I'll be in trouble.

I am experimenting right now with getting stones directly from japan (natural ones) so that I can keep the ones I like and dump the others. This is a poor proposition in the US because the stones cost twice as much here, or more, but I think I can do it without any balance sheet and income statement damage by going straight to japan.

I'll report back later when I've lost a bunch of money unexpectedly :)

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#15

Re: Why a flat back

John in NM

Not talking about rounded over at the edge - the necessity of flat at the edge should be intuitive to anyone who's done some sharpening.

I'm asking about obsessing over how flat it is further up from the edge, like 1/4" to 1" away. That part has never seemed to matter much to me, though I could always be overlooking something - hence the question.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#16

Re: Why a flat back

david weaver

coarse work over most of the back is not hard, and then just biasing pressure on a stone after that won't even get you 1/4th of finished back. It will get you a flat back, though.

Two things take time:

* flattening

* finishing

I don't buy many irons or chisels where the first one takes that much time on an 80 grit sandpaper 42 inch run (PSA paper so that there's no dubbing).

Finishing to no evidence of anything but a mirror is not quite as quick or practical. Getting close to perfect is pretty quick, though.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#17

Re: Two Cherry set up was not easy

Todd Stock

Some things are worth the investment in time, but after recently prepping two full sets of NIB 1970's chisels (a 4mm-26mm set and another 3mm to 32mm set), I was questioning that wisdom. I agree - not a chisel for those lacking time or confidence WRT getting things prepped and running right.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#18

Re: Why a flat back

Todd Stock

Agree - as long as the last bit of back is flat and polished, things will work pretty well - certainly for knocking out dovetails. That said, I figure that I'll do the job once and not be bothered for another 30 years...or maybe it's just early childhood toilet-training issues rearing their ugly heads, but anything short of a truly flat, polished back keeps me at the sharpening bench. Does it make sense when I bill shop time at $100/hour? Absolutely not - but such is the nature of obsession.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#19

However, excellent steel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

On the other hand, this steel is excellent. I found that the Two Cherries (same as Hirsch) chisels held up well when chopping dovetails.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#20

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

steve voigt

I'll report back later when I've lost a bunch of money unexpectedly

Fixed that for you, Dave. ;)

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#21

Re: However, excellent steel

Todd Stock

Sets still come up on eBay and I usually have a student that wants a set by the end of the course.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#22

Re: Two Cherry set up was not easy

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have a set of Hirsch chisels and found the original handles too big and clunky, difficult to hold. I cut those off and replaced them with handles much like my Bergs. Much better.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#23

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

Dennis

By your own admission you have learned to sharpen. Do not underestimate what you have gained by spending time flattening chisels, the same skills apply, wether you flatten a board 4' long or 1" of a chisel blade, or that pesky bump that keeps you from fitting a dovetail.

I recommend vintage steel preferably Swedish, or German, but you'll have to apply your flattening skills.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#24

Re: However, excellent steel

Dennis

There is a common misconception concerning Two Cherries, Hirsch, Spannsage, Matador, and others. These are all separate tool makers in Remsheid, Germany, that all used "Ulmia" handles. "Ulmia is Georg Ott who's company is 300 miles south of Remsheid in Ulm.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#25

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

Dennis

An excellent German tool maker who is still working near Remscheid is David Strassman "Dastra"

There is a good video on YouTube if you look under Dastra it is about 3 minutes long titled "handmade" woodcarving tools