Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

high end chisel recomendations?

Posts

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#26

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

david weaver

Well, life will go on if I lose a little :)

Don't tell my wife that.

There's an anomaly or two in going directly to japan that I'm going to try to exploit. Not to make a bunch of money, but more of the "buy two, keep one, no cost" kind of thing.

I do a lot better these days buying lots of stuff than I did 10 years ago!! All of it does far better at resale than new power tools.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#27

Hirsch steel claimed to be same as Two Cherries

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I once had an account with the US distributor of Two Cherries. He had been to the factory and claimed that the two brands came off the same production line. Different cosmetics, same steel.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#28

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Why would "vintage" steel be better than steel made today? Seems to me that a modern factory would have better control of composition and heat treating, and any other attribute that is important to a chisel.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#29

Re: Hirsch steel claimed to be same as Two Cherrie

dennis

It is possible that now they have merged, these are small operations, which you can see in the video of Dastra, on youtube. Hirsch was run by the bros. Busch, and Two cherries was Wlm. Schmidt.

There is a good web site if you know German - Klienes werkzeuge museum

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#30

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

roger lance

Except Festool.....of course.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#31

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

Brian Holcombe

...and Martin :)

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#32

Re: Two Cherry set up was not easy

Todd Stock

So slim, octagonal handles with a slight bulbous shape at end? After about 1987, Hirsch went to an oval handle that was very uncomfortable ...gave a set to my dad and he swore they were the most remarkably torturous things to use he's ever received, short of his first set of government issue combat boots. The most recent Two Cherries bench chisels are now offered with the octagonal handles which are to me (XL hands), quick comfortable.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#33

Re: question

Dennis

I am trained in a traditional woodworking trade, dominated by Europeans. My opinion is educated, I've spent the last 45 years at a bench swinging knife, plane, and chisel nearly everyday. When I recommended "vintage" I was speaking of Swedish, and German steel, to me it is their tempering that I prefer. Steels have been alloyed for a long time, but in that process the amount of chrome has been increased to reduce rust, and the resulting edge suffers.

I have a number of A2 cryo blades, that I don't care for, they work, but they do not take as fine an edge, they are noticeably gummy on a natural stone. Of the cryo A2, Hock, LN, and IBC (Woodcrafts Pinnacle), I prefer the IBC, because it acts the most like "vintage" steel on the stone, and on wood.

In fact, IBC has just begun selling to the general public, and has a new innovative chisel/handle system. Perhaps some here may enjoy these chisels. I've spoken with him, he is a very nice man, and his main work in metal, are dies for industry.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#34

Re: Two Cherry set up was not easy

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Not quite slim, they vary in size according to the size of the chisel. The largest one is maybe 9/8" and, yes, bulbous on the end.

The Berg shape is very different from the Hirsch firmers, and not octagonal.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#35

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

david weaver

Well, I've figured out something (at least on small items) that does a little better than festool.

But some of that luxury in buying things that flip that well has more to do with not needing anything and being able to wait for it.

It has more to do with finding proxy systems to bid on foreign auctions. I think you could actually make a living doing it on small items if you wanted to or had to (I don't want to, I just want to support my habit). Certain things you can buy cheap in one geography and sell cheap in another - japanese natural stones are one of those if you're willing to take a little risk or do it in numbers.

That said, I haven't sold a festool, or bought or sold a martin. IIC, festools hover around 75-90% of new, depending on their use level.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#36

At a guess...

John in NM

And speculating wildly :D

Probably it is the steel's grain texture. Early industrial steels had a fair amount of hand/semi-hand forging involved, which can result in a finer grain than today's drawn tool steels simply cut into blades. PM technology is, in my opinion, an improvement on this - getting to a wonderfully fine grain without all that heating and hammering on things.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#37

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

Joseph Piotrowski

if i was doing this 8 hrs a day, maybe more 2 hr flattening is nothing really. but when i get 30 mins here 1 hr there in my hobby, 2 hrs is a huge investment in time. i can't spend all week sharpening a tool and never cut anything. your advice is great for someone with a lot of shop time. that experience is invaluable. but right now its not as useful to get vintage steel.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#38

Re: question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Why would "vintage" steel be better than steel made today? Seems to me that a modern factory would have better control of composition and heat treating, and any other attribute that is important to a chisel.

I prefer chisels from the early 19th century, because they sharpen like a dream, take a fine edge and have excellent longevity. I think the reason that they are better is they were made by skilled artisans for use by skilled artisans. I think today's manufacturers might not know what to look for in a chisel. They are marketing to doctors and engineers rather than craftsmen.

Somehow bread from a hole-in-the-wall bakery using brick ovens can taste a lot better than bread from a modern factory that has "better control of composition and heat treating, and any other attribute that is important"

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#39

Re: question

David Weaver

George described craftsmen breaking steel and visually examining it to sort it into grades. The engineers on sawmill Creek thought that was horrible.

I would imagine that someone visually examining steel in a constant feedback loop could get pretty good at it.

We've gotten to the point where we've decided less variable is better. In my opinion, nobody now makes a chisel that matches a ward bench chisel with a tang, even the later wards were still fine tools. They kept the proportions and geometry the same, even as there was market pressure to reduce costs in the surface finish. They didn't completely falter until they started to incorporate gimmicks. The Ashley Iles chisels are the closest to those proportions that I've seen, and still are hand finished, which will put off some engineers, but they have a glimmer of life that's been lost in most others, and are reasonable if bought directly from England without vat.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#40

You have a point on the steel but not the bread

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is easy for doctors and engineers, and others, to loose track of the fact that steel was fabricated just for chisels in 1720, optimized to be sharpened by whatever means was available at that time. Times change.

Chisels that are commonly available today are made from a stock steel developed for some other purpose. Only the heat treating can be customized for a chisel application. However, manufacturers today are not limited to natural stones for sharpening. Modern abrasives opens up the possibility to use steel compositions that are not compatible with natural stones. It is silly to blame a steel for not sharpening "properly" on a natural stone and leave the stone blameless.

Given that the combination of steel composition, fabrication and sharpening was optimized for what was available in times past, changing any one of these variables should be expected to lead to a result that might not be optimum, or equivalent, or better, or worse.

That said, if one optimizes steel composition, fabrication and abrasive to manufacturer a chisel today, can it be made as useful as one made in 1800, or whenever past? Obviously some believe not, supported by claims, not data. If the differences are so subtle that the average doctor and engineer creating Period Furniture (check out a SAPFM portfolio some time from a recent doctor and engineer (Stanley) Cartouche winner) as good as has ever been made can't detect a difference maybe the rest of us don't need to worry about it.

I'm a bread snob. If I had a free wish it would be for a modern bread oven with precise temperature control and steam injection. But, most of the desirable attributes of a bread loaf come from the flour, kneading and fermentation, not the baking. Wood fired brick ovens are for the Period Reenactors placing style above substance. It may be there is some of this flavor in chisels too.

Personally, I have come to place the importance of the shape of the chisel and handle well above the steel.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#41

Re: You have a point on the steel but not the brea

Brian Holcombe

I disagree, chisels as a whole unit were optimized for the work at hand and craftsman's preference. Consider that the ideal form with respect to Japanese chisels is a very hard high carbon steel blade made to withstand the rigors of a full days work without sharpening as it is considered improper to sharpen on site. Blades like this have been around for much longer than synthetic stones have.

I have chisels from a few makers who still work to those extreme preferences, they are no easy task to sharpen but they're a treat to use.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#42

playing the Devils's advocate.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You state that you don't like A2 steel because your natural stones do not sharpen it to your expectations of a "vintage steel" that was no doubt optimized to sharpen on a natural stone. Why is the steel a problem and not the stone? I could as easily state that I don't like ARK stones because they don't sharpen A2 as well as an aluminum oxide water stone.

Your comment perfectly illustrates the point that steel and the means to sharpen it can not be considered separately.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#43

Re: playing the Devils's advocate.....

Dennis

I have a cupboard filled of spyderco, shapton, sigma, norton, king, diamond, and lapping grits, and I say this in jest, and hope it is taken as such, the newer stones sure do make things shine.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#44

Re: question

Todd Stock

From what I've seen in other shops, steel and stone matter less than the ability of the craftsman and his/her standard for 'sharp' ;-)

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#45

Re: You have a point on the steel but not the brea

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It seems not to occur to you that someone who has baked bread since 1972 might know something you do not. Or that someone who has worked with sharp tools seriously since 1962 might have insights you do not.

The point about the bread baking is that no amount of technology is helpful if your vision of a good loaf is Wonder bread. And no degree of "control of composition and heat treating, and any other attribute that is important to a chisel. " is helpful if the vision is formed by people who don't know what to look for in a chisel. Many of the "high end" chisels are designed for beginners and amateurs.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#46

Re: You have a point on the steel but not the brea

david weaver

I have baked bread for about a dozen years now. I've noticed that most machine-made bread is overkneaded (tiny uniform cells) and under-proofed/raised - whatever gives a chance for the yeast to impart flavor.

I'm sure those things could be overcome with a mechanical process, and I'm sure at some point, they are done mechanically in small batch shops.

But it is like working with wood. Once you have a good process, there is also variation that is missing if everything is identical. In the days of computers, maybe someone could figure out a formula for that, too, but there is no market for the product that would cover the cost. 95% of the market for just about every staple is people who like things like Robert Palmer songs, miller lite and the next scripted reality show. They wouldn't notice the difference.

Many of the rest of the 5% are pretentious people who pretend to know the difference and prestige buy things (like someone who would buy a $300 coach purse made in china), including food at places like mcginnis sisters or whole foods, but they are just robot buying for various reasons.

Anyway, tangent. I get the gist of Bill's post, and agree that most of the flavor is determined before the bake. I value the life in the difference from loaf to loaf when baked without a computer oven, though.

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#47

Re: You have a point on the steel but not the brea

Todd Stock

It would be helpful if you explain why you feel that many high end chisels are designed and marketed to newbs. Are you asserting that there is a set of chisel characteristics which are of little interest to elderly users, but which appeal to the vigorous and youthful? Further, as I understand it, these newer chisels can be expensive, but are we sure that those elderly users cited earlier might not be a little confused by the dough versus dough discussion?

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#48

Hey, wait a minute....

Tony-Memphis

I am not a doctor, nor do I play one on TV, but I am an engineer...and while one might dispute my qualifications as a craftsman based on viewing my work, I like to think I am! not a metallurgist either, but i worked with several making race car parts. Even at that scale, it was like black magic. Most of the stuff was well understood, but applying what was known on a large and profitable scale was very difficult.

Actually, I just jumped in to be funny. I have no dog in this hunt. I like old stuff...I like new stuff...its all good.

How ironic...(I'm not making this stuff up) as I was typing this, I got a pop up incoming email from....Festool! Ha!

Tony

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#49

Re: Two Cherry set up was not easy

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I found this photo (while cleaning up Photobucket - all still working, I might add) of two sets of Two Cherries, one polished and the other not. I know which I would prefer ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: high end chisel recomendations?

#50

What the Pros use

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


If anyone watching cranks out better furniture than Will Neptune( shown in PIC) raise you hand. Note the chisels he is using. It is a collection of great variety and vintage, illustrating the point made earlier that it is not the chisel that makes the furniture but the hand holding it. It would seem that the details of the ergonomics, or simply what you got used to, drives chisel preference leading to the conclusion that any chisel you like will suffice to make stuff. The notion that one style, brand, century is preferred by "those in the know" is not supported by observation of pros at work. Hence, doctors and engineers should feel liberated to buy whatever feels good in the hand.