Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A Nifty Shooting Plane

Posts

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#51

Re: Shooting boards and more

david weaver

Derek, you're right, I believe what I'm saying (though I do like to do a little pro wrestling style promotion from time to time when there is nothing going on a topic, I've kind of lost interest in that lately).

re: the stones and the infills, neither of those have anything to do with woodworking. The former is a fascination (maybe it's not clear when I say it, but I've used the term "the best thing about them is that they all work", which is intended to imply that once you're sharpening something, the world will not move much if you switch). The latter is solely related to toolmaking and not woodworking. I still maintain that the best of my infills are just a a little less practical than a stanley 4.

I've fortunately never fallen down the rabbit hole of high cost marking and layout tools, etc - never saw the value in them and still don't. That's where I think the beginners get stuck, and that market has exploded since I started. When Rob Hansen started making a $99 shoot board, we balked because it's something that you can make out of scraps - or if you're less enterprising - out of $10 of new materials. Jeske turned some nice marking knives at the time, and so, too, did Dave Anderson. It took little time for there to be dozens of makers of them, though, and there are lots of makers for these things (shooting board, dovetail markers, marking knives) because they're easy and cheap to make. Not easy like turning a faucet on and off, but not remotely close to the same kind of difficulty as there is in making an infill miter plane.

As to the heavy shaving, you're right, I set it once after getting the wedge fitted and shot a video. It's heavier than I'd leave it, but after shooting things years ago with tiny little ribbons and taking many cuts, I think I'd go more for a little heavy than previous (a little less than in the video). The same rules about slow pace don't apply to this plane - I am happy about that. Doing this with any other planes that I've had would result in a board that was out of square at least one way, and two if unlucky (with a complementary trimming of the fence occurring as part of that - unwanted of course). Not so with this one since it's in a track and it is immune to tipping because of the footprint - a luxury.

Not that I'm going to go on the hunt for more irons and start making a bunch of these to sell. I'm sure a gaggle of beginners could tell me how hard it is to set the plane and how they want irons in V11. I do think I'll make one more.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#52

I am...

david weaver

..on the same page with warren about pieces in the vise, though, drawer ends and all. If they're long enough to go in the vise, I find it easier to fit them than it is to dig out the shooting board. I can't make a comment on Bill's miter picture in this thread, though, because I've not done anything like it that I can recall.

I recognize that few are going to want to do everything they can freehand, but I like it - it feels good. The first time I stood a fitted piece in the vise and ran a wooden continental plane across it to clean it up to the line (expecting it to be choppy after all of the forum discussion of the need for bevel up planes, etc, for that work) it was sort of a revelation. The end grain came off easily and the whole ordeal felt great.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#53

clarification and some historical context

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


What was not obvious is that the front of the cherry case has a bull nosed profile. For this profile and others like the double humped Chester County piece, as well as pieces with French Feet, a thin overlay is applied to the front face of the case. Because of the profile, the horizontal overlay strips need to be "darted" into the vertical overlay strips. It becomes a trivial fitting operation with a shooting board with a 45 degree fence. And I am fond of trivial.

As it turned out my first few chests of drawers had a profiled overlay, or had French Feet, and, as well, I became smitten by assembling the cases with dovetailed drawer dividers. Cases made this way self square, which is nice when fitting drawers.

I came to realized that these overlay strips would hide my pedestrian dovetailing. So rather than perfect my dovetails, if indeed that was possible with the less than 40 years available, I became skilled at covering them up with overlay. And frankly, I came to prefer the absence of even perfect dovetails showing on the front of a case piece. The overlay is cut from the case side and glued back on at the end. The joint is invisible from any distance when done well.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#54

Re: I am...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, the drawer sides I tend to make are around 1/4" thick. The drawer fronts must fit the opening exactly - no gaps. I choose to use a shooting board. Warren appears to describe anyone who fails to freehand shoot as he does as inept. I guess I must be in good company.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#55

Re: I am...

david weaver

I am inept, but I still plane things 1/2 and 1/4" wide without a shooting board unless they are narrow, too, along with being thin.

I haven't made any small drawers in quite a long time. I would probably shoot those.

I think most people will get a shoot board and then use it for that - it's going to be foisted upon them as a beginner and I remember the early days of wanting a helping hand on everything - wanting to have something set up where I needed only to push the tool.

I'd love to see what went on in a cabinet shop 200 years ago, but I am too lazy to read about it (I'll admit). I doubt it would look too much like what we do with hand tools now because the users would all be of a more reflexive skill level.

Reminds me of a story that George told of someone setting saws in an alley in the UK (I'm sure I'm going to butcher this story) - that the guy was hammer setting saws in a minute or two and doing an excellent job (and doing it for very little money). We rarely have a chance to get reflexively good at anything these days.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#56

Drawers, 10 at a time on a crude shooting board

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



It will not surprise many that my shooting board was assembled in minimal time from scraps in the burn barrel shortly after someone here on WoodCentral introduced me to this handy device. I don't remember what it was that I was doing that I thought a shooting board would help with, but once made it has become an essential fixture to my work for adjusting the length, angle and smoothness of ends.

For years I made drawers from parts sawed on the table saw. Great care setting the miter was essential, as well as a blade change to get a smooth enough cut to see scribe lines. In my hands, it will be much quicker to dash out the 20 drawer sides and 10 backs for the chest of drawers coming up, and then ensure they are square, with a smooth surface for scribing, by taking a few quick passes on the shooting board. I know this to be true from experience doing it.

When it comes time to fit the 10 drawer fronts I can shim the fence and adjust the length and angle of the drawer front ends a few arc minutes as needed, or not, to get that perfect fit.

If I only did an end occasionally, screwing the part in a vice and having at it from each end to avoid splintering out the back would be efficient enough. But I don't anticipate that even with years of practice this approach would be faster or more reliable than using a shooting board, for me.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#57

Teenagers and Pensioners

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was shooting endgrain in a vise and sharpening freehand 55 years ago. The truth is that it is a lot easier to learn this stuff as a teenager than as a pensioner. I have taught 12 year olds; I have taught 62 year olds; there is no comparison. It might be easier to teach a kid with learning disabilities than an old man. It doesn't take 40 years to learn these skills. But a guy who has sat behind a desk for 40 years is at a great disadvantage.

What we don't need is pensioners telling us what skills are within easy reach and what skills are not worth pursuing or what jigs are "essential". It is like an old man saying you can't reliably walk across the room without a cane, or you can't climb steps without a handrail. His perspective is compromised.

Last month a young teenager came in my shop and wanted to turn some dogwood (Janka 2150). I did the first piece while he watched. Then he came back two days later and turned another. I had expected to give him some instruction in use of the skew chisel, avoiding catches etc., but he did the work very nicely without any verbal instruction. A middle aged guy just could not do that.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#58

Re: no thought about what could go wrong

david weaver

I spend all day at work thinking about what could go wrong. I would imagine that a lot of older folks do, too, when it's their job to be a watchdog for something, or if there is a requirement to do things without mistake.

I think this mentality carries over to woodworking rather than people backing up and saying "this is my chance to work on neuroplasticity and ignore what could go wrong" (sorry for the neuroplasticity, but it's a word that is easier to understand than its definition, I think).

I was relatively old before I started this (30) - but maybe I wasn't 60. I didn't go mostly hand tool until about 6 years ago, and the terrible capabilities of single iron planes in dimensioning are what set me off trying to figure out how to use the double iron. I think someone 60 could do what I did if they had the right mindset - and if they had retirees time, they could sure do things a lot nicer than me - especially when it comes to furniture, turning or carving. Maybe not all people who are 60, but some. Not saying I do anything exemplary by any means - but I know I can learn something if I have to.

The older folks I know are as Warren describes, though. They want safety from a bad result in their work. In sharpening, planing (jointing or shooting, drilling, assembly, all of it...). Can't even discuss design, because they think they're too old to scrutinize design elements. They have full shops and they don't often work in them or try much new, and trying anything new is arduous and requires enormous amounts of planning. My father is 69. I can hardly get him to look at the things I've made when I start to talk about how they're made. "Ew, Tedious" is the response I get. He won't even change his own oil any longer, let alone learn to do something new on cars to save a few bucks.

Kids do things the opposite way. They have little or no thought about what could wrong, and they try what's natural first, and only plan or think things out later if they have to.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#59

Re: clarification and some historical context

Kees

Now I understand. Yes, mitering is the foremost shooting board application. Or even better, the miter jack.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#60

pensioners and others......

roger lance

Wow David.....you have become a peace maker who is practicing a little tact and sensitivity......where it is needed.

How about them apples??

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#61

Re: pensioners and others......

david weaver

You know what they say....It all evens out.

And, I know that's true, because I saw it on Seinfeld.

Maybe I will aim to be a different Samuel Colt product tomorrow.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#62

Another red flag...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

is Knipex ratcheting parallel-jaw pliers. Birthday present to self. What kinda sissy needs ratcheting pliers? That cost freaking $47! As a red-blooded, early 18th century wannabe, wooden ships and iron men, channel lock Amurrican, I can tell you no one needs these. :) And don't even start me on vise-grips :) .....yadda yadda...oh and anuther thing.....

Wiley

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#63

Re: Another red flag...

david weaver

So, will 1 do or do you need a set of 12?

I've never heard of them before. My dad thinks that when you buy a 3 pack of channellocks (which are made just north of me), you're overextending because you can maybe find some old beaters at a yard sale or flea market.

(my father is by no means poor, but he's tight! He also is a master at allowing nice things to disappear and show up later covered in special rusty red color, so maybe the flea market types are the right ones for him).

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#64

Re: pensioners and others......

roger lance

Whatever Colt model you choose to be.....just don't go off half cocked.....like some folks.....you could shoot your eye out.

I know thats true.....saw it on the Christmas Story.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#65

Strictly OT--just stuff I like

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

I ordered the 7". Opens to 1-3/8". So it will get around faucet nuts and the like:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000X4KP1C/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o01_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

The 10" opens to 1-3/4".

This is an example of Amazon's dynamic pricing: I paid $47 delivered, as of 2 days ago. I got a tracking number ending in ...DE. Does that mean these things are coming from Germany? Anyway, I see today they're quoting $57 for the same thing. You gotta pay attention nowadays.

Wiley

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#66

Re: Strictly OT--just stuff I like

david weaver

It appears to be (coming from Germany). I ordered something from China a couple of months ago, except I didn't think I was ordering something from China.

Amazon gave me a tracking number later and the item said that it was shipped but it never showed up.

I guess that's what they do these days. They could tell us where the item is coming from, but I think they know that would reduce sales. You just can't really ever tell with them (I am a prime member also, but given that their level of service isn't great and has gone downhill - lots of "prime" things are no longer 2 day shipping, and the prime price is up), I think this will be the last prime year.

I see in their "other offerings" that a seller still has the things for $47, there is a seller at $44.30 on ebay, and HD has them for less, also (but you have to wait there).

Did I just demonstrate the race to the bottom? I did resist to buy them just to see what they're like.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#67

There is some excellent advice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you match the description Warren provided- old, had a desk job, on a pension etc- you have been informed that you are not capable of mastering the superior woodworking techniques he talks about and references from the classical woodworking literature. So if you want to build stuff you will need different techniques. I suppose the best place to find techniques suitable for your situation would be from similarly old pensioners that build stuff. To that end you might check the WC Gallery, and specifically Mayberry. He was 80 when he built the desk. He just finished a complex bow front at 83 and seems to still be learning new techniques suitable for old people to be able to build this kind of furniture. So there is hope for the aged aspiring woodworker if the means to the end is not to emulate 1720 technology.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#68

Consider another possibility

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Maybe old woodworkers that have, and do, actually build stuff have acquired the wisdom from experience to be cautious when it is called for. If you haven't faced the situation of inletting the drop front hinge on a finished desk like shown in Mayberry's Gallery piece you don't appreciate the wisdom of being risk adverse on some steps. We are our worst critics and for the next XX years I don't like living with something I screwed up. If you don't build furniture you get to live with your approach might differ.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#69

Re: There is some excellent advice

roger lance

Thank Goodness!!.....there is a glimmer (nay: sliver) of hope for us ole timers.....you know that it is possible that some of us had jobs and responsibilities that required us to solve problems and figure out new approaches to situations every day.....we actually had nimble minds and were creative.....so this woodworking thing isn't our first rodeo when it comes to challenges, choices, and decisions about how to do things.

Since I've never had a woodworking mentor (my dad schooled me about house construction), I've had to make choices about whose advice I follow.....and whose advice I discount. There are some people here.....Bill, Derek, Brian, others.....who have my attention because they show their work and I can relate to what they are saying by the connection to what I'm seeing them do.

Similarly, on YouTube, I follow the examples of Paul Sellers, David Barron, Tom Fidgen, and Rob Cosman. I know Rob Cosman is a marketing machine.....but, he is damn good in that shop.....he knows what he's doing.....its very apparent that he is very good.....great hand/eye coordination. I'm more inclined to listen to what Cosman has to say about shooting boards in the production of precise work and the value of these devices than other commentators.

But, to each his own.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#70

Shooting in 1839

Kees

In the small book "The joiner and cabinetmaker", anonymous writer, from 1839, the shooting board is being used in the construction of a dovetailed chest. This is a romanticed description of the apprentenship of one Thomas. So, he was a beginner of course, but the fact that it was used in this book indicates that the use of shooting boards for this kind of work wasn't unusual at that time.

This is the earliest use I could find of a shooting board for anything else then mitres and veneer/very narrow stock.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#71

Re: Shooting in 1839

david weaver

I can't imagine that there weren't users using them earlier than that (especially if someone had a job that required tons and tons of fitting), but maybe they just didn't think it was worthy of such admiration as the beginner's trap community does now.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#72

Re: Consider another possibility

david weaver

I agree on the important ones - being cautious. I do have some furniture that has minor mistakes (even simple furniture). I don't like the mistakes, but when I think more about it, they are things I could still fix if I want to.

I have thrown away a fair number of planes, too. I know planemakers 250 years ago didn't do all of their work freehand (I'm sure they did a fair amount, though), and they didn't rough out all of their material shortly after that (chapin's book talks a lot about using water power to limit labor). But it feels so good to do that work by hand, and I like pieces that have a little bit of variation in them so that you can tell that they were done by hand. Not variation like gaps, but minor asymmetry in some things, or variation in normal things. It makes them seem more life-like to me.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#74

"Done by hand"

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

But it feels so good to do that work by hand, and I like pieces that have a little bit of variation in them so that you can tell that they were done by hand. Not variation like gaps, but minor asymmetry in some things, or variation in normal things. It makes them seem more life-like to me.

David, you are by no means the first to write this. Some comment that they prefer the irregularity of dovetails that were sawn without layout lines, or they like the baseline cuts to be visible on drawers.

We are a wierd bunch of people :) I believe that only handtool woodworkers care whether a piece was made with handtools. Only they look for marks on the surface, such as plane tracks .. which some deliberately leave there ... even put there to give a more handtool look! Indeed, only woodworkers in the main even look whether drawers are dovetailed, and only they care whether they are hand cut (my wife is one exception).

For myself, whether a piece is handmade or machine made is irrelevant. What determines the aesthetic and quality of a piece of furniture is the design, construction and finish. Most pieces benefit from being made - to some degree - with handtools, but I do not need "evidence" in the surface to tell me they were used.

I prefer a hand planed finish to a sanded finish, because the surface is clearer. I strive to eliminate tracks. On some pieces, the slight scalloping that remains is left, but this is not always appropriate for all surfaces, and then I will finish by scraping.

I am sure others have thoughts about this area, and it would be interesting to hear how they perceive this issue. One man's meat, and all that. :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#75

Re: "Done by hand"

david weaver

I know I'm definitely not the first person to talk about it. In one of the old carving books I have, they talk about making sure that pieces have life.

But it's not in reference to ugly things like leaving tracks, tearout, or intentially poorly done things. It's something like in the plane that I just made, one eye wall thickness was about 1/16th of an inch at the front of the mortise, and the other was a 32nd different. The mortises look sort of identical otherwise, but you could pick things like that out looking at it. I could trouble myself to try to make things more identical, but I think the plane would look less good if I did. On the flip side, it would look absolutely horrible if I left tool marks in it intentionally.

Warren made a good case about this on the line and berries discussion, having some variation in the clustering and orientation of the berries because in reality, plants don't generally grow perfectly symmetrical.

I think thoughtfulness is still essential (in not leaving gaps, tracks, etc - i'm not going for rustic), but perfection in duplication and symmetry is not - that often looks worse because it's boring.

I think you're absolutely right about who cares, though. I know I've never had a person in my shop who cared a wit about anything. usually, one attempt to push a hand plane on the edge of a board is enough for them to say something like "where again are we having dinner? are we ready to go?"

Incidentally, the only comment that I can recall about any of my case pieces is that early on, I rubbed out finish on one of them, and someone saw it and said "how did you get it that smooth?". They didn't run their hands over anything that wasn't shiny, as those things look less smooth but actually feel better. So we're pleasing ourselves, at least I am, and really nobody else. I'm sure my wife would rather I just buy things instead of making them.