Re: "Done by hand"
david weaver
I haven't found anyone on this site who advocates intentionally leaving marks, except the issue that I mentioned (I believe the hasluck book suggested the same thing) - where it was suggested that someone not go for too much uniformity.
In the case of a plane where I do the eyes, I will make the eyes and walls as even as possible on both sides of the mortise. I have only made a plane with two mortises one time, but that was the case where the second eye wall was a different thickness - a user wouldn't look at both of those at the same time, but you would on a try plane see the cheek thickness on both sides at the same time and I would get those reasonably similar (same thing is seen on old planes).
I think this kind of subtlety is kind if pointless to talk about. If I say I will leave an eye on one end of a plane a little different than one on the end of another plane because it makes something lively, the next person to come along will suspect that I am advocating leaving marks all over something or intentionally leaving an error in something. It does little good to talk about it, and better for people just to read about what I'm talking about in an old text like Hasluck's carving text.
I do recall a decade ago seeing that someone left tearout in their pieces on purpose (I won't name them) and I wasn't in favor of that .... at all. Saw the same thing at a mennonite shop a couple of years ago. The owner used no hand tools, which isn't surprising if you've been in amish or mennonite shops. The son, however, had taken an interest in planes and he particularly liked to tear out the surface of pieces after they were finish sanded and then apply stain over the torn out surface. Whatever floats their boat (of course, I didn't get indignant and say anything rude about it).