Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A Nifty Shooting Plane

Posts

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#76

Re: "Done by hand"

david weaver

Not suggesting that everyone should like what I like, either. Just expressing my opinion.

The guy who got me into woodworking is thrilled by nothing more than to have a very plain piece of furniture that looks like it was put together by a laser, and that has absolute uniformity in measurements. He gets a gigantic charge out of that kind of thing and seems to have a distaste for the idea that some woodworking things are not like machining and metal (he's a mechanical engineer who is more versed in metal than wood).

"Luddite" is usually something he says when he looks at my stuff. I have no interest in changing his mind, though.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#77

Re: "Done by hand"

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, I expect that using handtools will produce the slight irregulaties that aid in helping a piece avoid being sterile. I always attempt to produce the most perfect piece I can. But perfection can never be possible if using handtools. This is different from deliberately leaving "evidence" that a piece is hand made. A piece of furniture will always have the intangible warmth that handmade furniture has simply because it was made by hand.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#78

Re: "Done by hand"

david weaver

I haven't found anyone on this site who advocates intentionally leaving marks, except the issue that I mentioned (I believe the hasluck book suggested the same thing) - where it was suggested that someone not go for too much uniformity.

In the case of a plane where I do the eyes, I will make the eyes and walls as even as possible on both sides of the mortise. I have only made a plane with two mortises one time, but that was the case where the second eye wall was a different thickness - a user wouldn't look at both of those at the same time, but you would on a try plane see the cheek thickness on both sides at the same time and I would get those reasonably similar (same thing is seen on old planes).

I think this kind of subtlety is kind if pointless to talk about. If I say I will leave an eye on one end of a plane a little different than one on the end of another plane because it makes something lively, the next person to come along will suspect that I am advocating leaving marks all over something or intentionally leaving an error in something. It does little good to talk about it, and better for people just to read about what I'm talking about in an old text like Hasluck's carving text.

I do recall a decade ago seeing that someone left tearout in their pieces on purpose (I won't name them) and I wasn't in favor of that .... at all. Saw the same thing at a mennonite shop a couple of years ago. The owner used no hand tools, which isn't surprising if you've been in amish or mennonite shops. The son, however, had taken an interest in planes and he particularly liked to tear out the surface of pieces after they were finish sanded and then apply stain over the torn out surface. Whatever floats their boat (of course, I didn't get indignant and say anything rude about it).

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#79

Lots of people like irregularity!

Kees

Not just woodworkers. Why do you think so many people love antique stuff? Noyt just because it is old, but also because of its quirkyness, it's non perfect nature, the obvious toolmarks, the obvious hand of a human being.

Likewise, we have some designers overhere, probably in Australia too, who make things from very rough materials. For example mill sawn boards are only partially planed, so the rough saw marks are still visible, on the OUTSIDE! In plain view, and their work is highly praised.

Lots of people are sick of perfection. (Me included, but I am just a romantic old fool).

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#80

Re: Lots of people like irregularity!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Not just woodworkers. Why do you think so many people love antique stuff? Noyt just because it is old, but also because of its quirkyness, it's non perfect nature, the obvious toolmarks, the obvious hand of a human being.

Likewise, we have some designers overhere, probably in Australia too, who make things from very rough materials. For example mill sawn boards are only partially planed, so the rough saw marks are still visible, on the OUTSIDE! In plain view, and their work is highly praised.

Lots of people are sick of perfection. (Me included, but I am just a romantic old fool).

Kees, you romantic fool - you have misunderstood what I wrote. :)

I did not argue against quirky or imperfect furniture. I was commenting on builders who deliberately add in such features to advertise their work as "hand made". "Imperfections" are built into the work by virtue of furniture being fashioned by hand tools, even when the work is well done.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#81

Re: Lots of people like irregularity!

david weaver

"Better a diamond with a flaw than a pebble without"

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#82

Re: Lots of people like irregularity!

david weaver

I can't remember anyone ever advocating any of that stuff (like the folks who put down a new floor and beat it up horribly to give it a certain look - one that looks fake to us).

I do remember putting up pictures of authentic drawers that had nice proportions, but that the dovetails appeared to be laid out and cut by eye. The sentiment here was that they were ugly because they weren't perfectly even. I think the word "sloppy" was used.

Except they have a level of authenticity and nice proportion that is rarely seen on drawers where the maker is focused almost entirely on whether or not the pins and tails are all perfectly identical (often those drawers are made with fat 3/4ths material).

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#83

Re: Lots of people like irregularity!

Kees

Yeah, I also don't think that adding some of these features make the stuff obviously handmade. Machine building something and then trashing the surfaces with a dull plane, might fool some, but isn't quite what makes the handmade look. And I think (hope) that many people recognise the look of a truely handmade piece, even if only intuitively.

I don't quite know what makes this piece so attractive to me. It is not just the ravages of time. It's also in how it was build.


img

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#84

Re: Lots of people like irregularity!

AZ in Colorado Springs

I'm building a few pieces just as you described for a friend. Weathered, rough-sawn fir with some light sanding and the blade marks there for everyone to see.

Two vanities and a bar.