Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A Nifty Shooting Plane

Posts

A Nifty Shooting Plane

#1

A Nifty Shooting Plane

david weaver

I'm struggling to figure out what kind of beech planes to make since I don't really need any more of the standard designs, but I've got a bunch of irons left.

I found this sometime last year and put it off, because it's not very practical (I still think it's not very practical), but it's interesting and that's good enough reason to build it.

https://s22.postimg.org/4g2t557i9/shooting.jpg

It looks to be single iron, and I have two matching single irons that would work (the "Kenyon" rounded top type that were on Ebay a couple of years ago), but both of those do not have a hollow in the back, but rather a hump. I've got no interest in fighting that - it's a defect, and just another example of how the art of things has gotten lost over time = at least in some cases.

So it will be double iron. It should be, anyway, in case it's used to shoot edges.

I haven't gotten any further than to size the blank. I've been lacking energy recently, to say in the least - not sure why. But going slow instead of trying to wham this out in a weekend or two is not a big deal. (Ignore the smoothers. I took this picture to say something about the norris in another post, but other than to say that it works as well as my favorite stanley, that's about all I could come up with! That, and for all of the press about the earlier norris planes being so much better, I fail to find anything at all wrong with this one after lapping the bottom - it may not be clear from the picture - it's a later type with beech body).

https://s3.postimg.org/j92f37twj/20170415_190927_1.jpg

By the way, on the shoot board picture above, if someone has an idea of why there is a wide groove under the shoot plane, I'd like to know. Is it a dust catcher or something like that to keep stray shavings or chips from bumping the plane off course?

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#2

Only a guess, but...

Ron in Sterling, CT

could it be for reduced friction?

Ron

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#3

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

It appears to me that the groove, which looks to be the exact width of the plane, is intended to eliminate all lateral play, as the plane is pulled or pushed through its stroke by the vertical handle. The groove that the plane runs in holds the plane in the cut.

That said, I would prefer to (a) omit the groove, (b) omit the vertical pull, and grasp the plane by the top of the iron, pulling it through its stroke. The hand on the iron not only is pulling, but also applying sidewise pressure to hold the plane snugly against the curb as it makes its stroke.

You could judge this for yourself by using one of your regular try planes as a shooting plane, and see how you like it. I used to use a 22" wooden try as a shooting plane quite often--worked great.

One other thing about leaving off the knob. You then end up with sort of a 'strike block' plane, which is a handy thing to have around. For example, when fitting a short or small piece, I find it handy to just upend a plane and run the piece across the blade, rather than fix the piece and run the plane over it. Sometimes upending the plane in a vise. Either way, the plane is handier without the knob, I would think.

Well, just my 2 cents. One other thing: if you come across a narrow iron, you might make a long narrow edge jointer--my very favorite is a 2" x 26" edge jointer. Well, that makes 3 cents.

Finally, I got my medical degree in the engineering department, but would suggest you see a doctor about that tiredness. Low thyroid comes to mind, as does Lyme disease depending on the exact symptoms. Not something to let slide. Maybe Dr. Pan could chime in.

Wiley

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#4

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

david weaver

Thanks for the suggestions, Wiley. I often do as you say, turn a plane upside down in a vise and then run parts over it. Poor man's cooper's jointer, I guess.

re: the health, I've had the full battery run and everything checks out OK. MRI, too - also clear (fortunately), as I've got a history of migraines and nobody in my family does. Hopefully, it's just a little bit of burnout.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#5

Re: Only a guess, but...

david weaver

Could be, not sure. It looks like it's just shy of the plane's height, so you could be right. I'm sure it's there for a reason.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#6

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

Brian Holcombe

Looks like an interesting project! That cutout is bizarre, I am thinking it is possible that a replaceable piece was inserted into that and replaced when worn.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#7

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

William Duffield

I see a fence, separate from the indentation in question, all along the near edge of the shooting board, held to the edge of the board with ~ 6 screws. I can just make out both ends of the fence. Two of the assumed screws are hidden behind the irons and wedges.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#8

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

One afterthought....If the plane runs in that channel, it is standing off the mitering fences about a 1/4" or so. Which means that the workpiece is unsupported where the blade comes across it. Which means that you'd get spelching on the exit side of the cut about half the time, and more than that on quartered material.

As Brian said, the channel is bizarre.

Wiley

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#9

Now I can't tell

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

The plane may be rebated along its lower inside edge, so that it does reach all the way to the miter fences. Hard to tell from the photo.

Wiley

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#10

Re: Now I can't tell

William Duffield

The plane is flat on the far (down) side, and it runs in the rabbet that is the same width. The strange recess just appears to stop at the same place as the outside fence due to the angle of the photograph. Maybe the recess once held a manufacturer's name plate. Since the top of the outside fence is the same color as the original bottom of the channel, it appears to be coplanar to it, but it is not. Look closely at the ends of the near side fence to see that it is above the bottom of the channel. Something else I don't understand is the scallop out of the top of the nose on the near end, since it doesn't have the same scallop out of the nose on the far end. Maybe it was dropped and a large chip was knocked out.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#11

A Wierd Shooting Plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


I suspect that the recess/channel is for the plane to ride in - think of the Stanley #51/52 cute board. However, in this case, it does not extend the length of the runway ... which makes one wonder how it could work?

While it looks like it should be a set up for picture framing, I want to ask "what was this shooting board use for?" - is this another from the printing industry?

I do not like the double bladed woodie. I would be concerned that the impact from one end will loosen the iron/wedge at the opposite end (the strike forward would be similar to a rap with a hammer at the heel). I'd rather build a simple strike block plane.

I also do not like the fences. How does one know that the angles are complimentary? One like this is complementary ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#12

Re: A Wierd Shooting Plane

david weaver

I agree, I think a simple strike block style plane would be more practical, but I'm just looking for different. I already have a chute board and miter jack (separate, of course) and a lone remaining premium plane that is square.

If I just can't live with how this plane is, I have about 8 inches of plane to the next mortise, I think, and I can cut one of the mortises off and have a strike block plane without doing any additional work (Unlikely that I'd do that, though).

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#13

Interesting *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Looks like it was inspired by the Rogers Miter plane and jig.


img

http://home.earthlink.net/~wesg/rogers.htm

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#14

Re: Interesting

david weaver

That setup looks like it would be considerably more practical than the gadgetry I showed above. I looked on google to see if any of those are for sale or have been for sale recently, and what I find is one that sold for $1600 on ebay two years ago :O

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#15

The divot on the end..

david weaver

I noticed that divot, too. I've been sitting on this picture for a long time, just too lazy to build the plane because I really don't want to build the board that goes with it. I will probably first make a long straight "normal" shooting board before making one with miters.

I expect more realistically, that I'll make the plane and then probably not use it any significant amount.

At any rate, I don't think I'll copy the divot. I'm curious about why that cutout would've been made on the top of the plane when it really doesn't have any excuse to be hammered or dropped (I figured it was to hide damage, too).

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#16

Re:

William Duffield

it does not extend the length of the runway

Yes, it does. I explained the visible evidence for the fully enclosed channel in another post. I also offered a plausible explanation for the less patinated, shallow recess in the bottom of the channel: It is a red herring, and doesn't have anything to do with the functionality of the trimmer.

Other than the lack of adjustability of the fences, and wood vs. metal construction, it works just like the iron one in Bill's link.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#17

Yes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Once SirWm explained it, I could finally see it. As he explained, the camera shot is at the one angle where it appears the routed-out area extends all the way to the outer fence--but it doesn't. This can be seen by looking at the near end of the assembly, where the fence meets the floor or running track.

So the routed-out area is just a confusion factor. It may be that the floor of the running track got warped or damaged in some way, and so the owner at that time just routed out the middle so it was out of the way. Sorta like the ura of a Japanese iron.

Wiley

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#19

Re: The Nose Job

William Duffield

I have another hypothesis regarding the material removed from the top of one end of the plane. Note that the trimmer was permanently mounted to a bench. There is evidence in the side of the fence of improperly sized screws or screwdriver used to install it. I presume that it was installed and used in a crowded work space, with other permanently installed machines, shelves, coffee pot (note the ring from the carafe on the top of the base :) ), or whatever close-by. I am guessing that there was interference, and instead of relocating the trimmer, or relocating whatever it was bumping into, they removed a small amount of the nose of one end of the plane.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#20

Another possibility

david weaver

I got the sense looking at it that perhaps the bottom of the plane may have a rebate cut all the way around so that it sits in the groove. That is, the area that sits in the groove could be smaller than the length and width of the plane, if that makes any sense.

Mine will not have anything like that. I don't think I want to waste that much beech to make a board that large, though I have enough. I'll probably just get decent BB ply and use that, and then make a pine retaining piece that snugs the plane to the side of the board.

Not that it will probably get enough use for it to matter, but I wouldn't want the glue edge of BB ply wearing on the top of my plane.

The whole thing would've been better with two skewed irons. It'll probably be about a 9 pound plane and won't need skew, though.

I think the biggest challenge in building all of it will be to get the miter fences to be very close to 45 degrees and nearly perfect vertically, too. Shouldn't be too much trouble with hand fitting, though.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#21

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

Stewie Simpson

By the way, on the shoot board picture above, if someone has an idea of why there is a wide groove under the shoot plane, I'd like to know. Is it a dust catcher or something like that to keep stray shavings or chips from bumping the plane off course?

Fair chance its a Shaving Well designed to disengage any shavings that are trapped on the underneath surface of the planes stock. The option I chose was to create a clearance gap using 2 brass skid plates.

[URL=http://s1009.photobucket.com/user/swagman001/media/Left%20hand%20shooting%20plane/_DSC0247_zpseejuyqy2.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s1009.photobucket.com/user/swagman001/media/Left%20hand%20shooting%20plane/_DSC0264_zps0q9uxywl.jpg.html][/URL]

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#22

so far....

david weaver

The wedge doesn't look quite right. I hadn't planned on a wedge with a scroll, but changed plans mid wedge thinking it would be useful for getting the wedge out of the plane.

https://s2.postimg.org/eyvlugevt/IMG_20170430_182124360.jpg

Need to clean up this scroll a little bit more and then do the other one and fit the wedges (their taper is off...I may have chosen a bad wedge to trace the taper from).

I realize now that I should've terminated the bevel and left about 4 inches or so on the top of the plane unbeveled so that the handle would be able to be closer to the edge of the plane. I'm sure it'll be fine. Didn't think about it.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#23

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

david weaver

I can't remember where this discussion was left, but I think the shaving well is most likely. Thinking about it, it doesn't bother a metal plane too much if a shaving gets under the cheek, but the quartered face of beech is not that durable, and shavings would really beat it up.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#24

Re: so far....

steve voigt

Regarding the look of the wedge, you made the same mistake that I made on my first scroll-top bench plane wedge. Normally on bench plane, the main (10°-ish) ramp ends an inch or so above the plane, then we have an area of several inches where the wedge front and back are parallel. What you and I both did was to form a scroll-top out of this parallel area. What instead needs to be done is to have the 10°-ish ramp continue all the way to the top, then you make the scroll. That way, you can have a section of a circle, or something close to it, and it won't look so squashed. But it will work fine; just something to consider for next time.

Re: A Nifty Shooting Plane

#25

Re: i agree..

david weaver

It looks funny. once I get the wedge fitted down into the plane, I am going to mark it and plane that area flat for now (the area between the top of the plane and the scroll - so that it doesn't look as bad. If the plane works well, I will probably recut wedges for it). It won't look perfect, but the transition from angled to flat is the worst part.

I started off with the intention of making flat wedges, and roughed them out, and then realized I'd like to have a scroll to remove them. By then, these two blanks were too late to save to be something really nice.

I have a scroll wedge on hand (that I dug out later), the entire thing is made of a consistent angle from start to finish, which leaves the scroll much larger and easier to cut without compromising it. It's also shorter in length. I will copy it if the plane works well enough to replace the wedges (I have my doubts!)