New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Finish Planing

Posts

Finish Planing

#1

Finish Planing

Hank Knight

I'm preparaing the carcase/frame of my double chest of drawers for finishing. Rather than sanding, which I hate doing, I'm planing the shop grunge, pencil marks, dings, etc., off to get it ready for the finish. I was prepared to do some final sanding, but find it is not necessary. Planing is a lot more fun.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Chest%20of%20Drawers/image_zpsmwco7wbq.jpeg.html][/URL]

Re: Finish Planing

#2

Re: Finish Planing -The Pile grows

Hank Knight

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Chest%20of%20Drawers/image_zpsjad0jtn5.jpeg.html][/URL]

Re: Finish Planing

#3

Nice!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hank,

I much admire the little unhandled smoother in the middle, surely by Konrad Sauer. Can you tell about the handled smoother at the top of the group?

Thanks for sharing.

Wiley

Re: Finish Planing

#4

Re: Nice!

Hank Knight

Thanks, Wiley!

Yes, the little smoother is Konrad's. It was a Christmas gift from my wife the year I retired. She and Konrad struck quite a friendship collaborating over the plane. She had a great time with it.

The handled smoother is a Norris A5. My daughter found it on Portobello Road in London some years ago and gave it to me, again for Christmas. It's a post war model with a walnut and beech infill. It was in great shape except the old dark stain/finish on the tote was in very poor condition. I stripped it and refinished it as you see in the photo, and supplied it with an after-market iron. It is a wonderful smoother. I have a Bedrock 4 1/2 and a L-N 4 1/2 with a high angle frog. Neither one could do much with he curly/tiger maple today. The Norris handled it with ease, including one board with a large knot that my tailed planer tore out badly. I thought I would have to apply tinted filler to repair the tearout; but to my surprise and delight, the A5 took care of it with a couple of passes.

Re: Finish Planing

#5

About the performance

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Hank

What do you believe accounts for the difference in performance by the Norris? Are you setting it up in any particular way? Do you use the chipbreaker, or rely on a closed up mouth? Are the blades equally sharp? How reliable are these differences, and can you rank the planes?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finish Planing

#6

Re: I know nobody likes this...

david weaver

but something is wrong with the setup, or part of the plane is not being used if the bedrock can't handle curly maple.

I did a little experiment lately with stanley planes, to find out if any really need more than a half an hour of work when new, and the newest plane I got was a stanley 12-904, which is the current plastic handled plane.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1q1H7zdTfyk

(skip through to 12 - I did have to spend about 35 minutes preparing this plane that was new, unused - partly because stanley couldn't have been bothered to make the hole in the cap iron big enough to allow the cap and the iron to rest on the frog).

But I get where you're coming from. If using the cap iron on the bedrock is what is needed, and the infill will smooth without it, then go with what you like.

(strangely enough, the nicest and smoothest to use of the whole bunch is a blue modern stanley that has beech handles - I keep 2 stanley 4s at any given time, in case I drop one. I thought I'd buy these modern ones and go up the ladder to crappier and crappier and then sell the new ones on ebay once done experimenting. I ended up keeping the modern blue one because it is as smooth operating as any plane I've ever bought - the iron is a bit soft, but that's not a fatal flaw - I've got an old iron that I cut out of O1 stock by hand and hardened in a weed torch that I've been looking for an excuse to use).

The sentiment for sanding (or not doing it) is shared 100%. If I can't plane it, I usually scrape and then burnish with shavings to blend in with planed surfaces (in terms of finish absorption - it may be true that some people can't tell the difference between a sanded or planed board, but if you put two right next to each other and put amber shellac on them, the sanded board requires a lot more finish to get a sealed surface and they end up different colors).

Re: Finish Planing

#7

Knowing nobody likes something......

roger lance

never stopped you before !! :D

Re: Finish Planing

#8

Re: About the performance

Hank Knight

Hi, Derek,

I agree with David's post below; there's something wrong with my setup. I'm pretty sure it's the fact that I've never been able to get a really fine edge on A2. When I got the Norris, LN was selling after market A2 blades for them. I ordeed one. They were out of stock, but sent me a W1 as an interim until the A2s came in. They sent the A2 later. I was never able to get it to work in that plane. I sharpened it countless times, but I never felt like I got it as sharp as it needed to be. Also, it was thicker than the original iron and was prone to closing off the mouth and the plane would jam. I tried the W1 they sent and had much better luck. It was much easier to sharpen and it was a little thinner than the A2 iron. I've stuck with it and I'm happy. I'm sure I'd have better luck with diamonds on A2, but I'm not set up for that. I have the original Norris iron. It's whatever tool steel Norris used back in the day. Easy to sharpen and works great. I have stored it away for safekeeping.

My Bedrock 4 1/2 is a standard angle plane. It did O.K. on the curly maple, but I had some tearout. I used it for the initial passes and switched to the Norris for the finish. It has a LN A2 iron, so It probably suffers from sharpness issues too. Same with my LN 4 1/2. I'm pretty sure the problem with that plane is that I don't have it sharp enough. I need to address the A2 sharpening issues. All are very good planes. The problem is mine, not the planes. I'm cognizant of the chipbreaker issues and always set my chipbreakers close. There are no issues with sole flatness on either of the planes, so I'm certain it is a sharpening issue. I probably erred when I said the Bedrock and the LN "couldn't handle" the curly maple. what I should have said is that MY Bedrock and LN 4 1/2s couldn't handle it. My Norris works great and I'm comfortable with it. It's too easy to reach for it for projects like this. I need to get off my duff and fix my sharpening problem. Otherwise, my two very nice planes are wasted.

BTW, I have LN A2 replacement irons in all my other bench planes and thy seem to work fine. They would probably work better if I got the sharpening issue straightened out.

Re: Finish Planing

#9

David, see comments to Derek above.


Re: Finish Planing

#10

Re: David, see comments to Derek above.

david weaver

Thanks, hank. I don't think you have a sharpening issue if your infills work that well. (your planes are probably sharper than the one I videod - that one saw only a washita stone and a bare strop. The geometry is good, but the sharpness is not what a modern stone addict would want).

And I'm certainly not going to disagree that those are beautiful infills - and if it gives pleasure to use them and they provide what you want, it's not as if you even need to solve the issues with the other planes.

Knowing what I know now, I still covet one of Karl Holtey's A13s, but it would be irresponsible for me to buy one at this stage in my life. I still would love to have one!!

Re: Finish Planing

#11

Re: About the performance

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I agree with David's post below; there's something wrong with my setup. I'm pretty sure it's the fact that I've never been able to get a really fine edge on A2. When I got the Norris, LN was selling after market A2 blades for them. I ordeed one. They were out of stock, but sent me a W1 as an interim until the A2s came in. They sent the A2 later. I was never able to get it to work in that plane. I sharpened it countless times, but I never felt like I got it as sharp as it needed to be. Also, it was thicker than the original iron and was prone to closing off the mouth and the plane would jam. I tried the W1 they sent and had much better luck. It was much easier to sharpen and it was a little thinner than the A2 iron. I've stuck with it and I'm happy. I'm sure I'd have better luck with diamonds on A2, but I'm not set up for that. I have the original Norris iron. It's whatever tool steel Norris used back in the day. Easy to sharpen and works great. I have stored it away for safekeeping.

My Bedrock 4 1/2 is a standard angle plane. It did O.K. on the curly maple, but I had some tearout. I used it for the initial passes and switched to the Norris for the finish. It has a LN A2 iron, so It probably suffers from sharpness issues too. Same with my LN 4 1/2. I'm pretty sure the problem with that plane is that I don't have it sharp enough. I need to address the A2 sharpening issues. All are very good planes. The problem is mine, not the planes. I'm cognizant of the chipbreaker issues and always set my chipbreakers close. There are no issues with sole flatness on either of the planes, so I'm certain it is a sharpening issue. I probably erred when I said the Bedrock and the LN "couldn't handle" the curly maple. what I should have said is that MY Bedrock and LN 4 1/2s couldn't handle it. My Norris works great and I'm comfortable with it. It's too easy to reach for it for projects like this. I need to get off my duff and fix my sharpening problem. Otherwise, my two very nice planes are wasted.

BTW, I have LN A2 replacement irons in all my other bench planes and thy seem to work fine. They would probably work better if I got the sharpening issue straightened out.

Hi Hank

If you are not getting A2 sharp enough, then you need to look at either your equipment or your technique, or both. W1 and O1 steels are certainly easier to hone than A2, but any steel should get as sharp as one would ever want if you use the appropriate media. I have A2, O1, M2, M4 and PM-V11 irons in Stanley, Veritas and LN Bailey-style planes. Some of these are very tough steels. All perform the way they are expected to. My blades are hollow ground (reducing the steel to sharpen) and worked on either Spyderco or Sigma stones.

For all this, I do not believe that it is sharpness alone that produces such differences in the performances of your planes.

I am curious why the Norris was the star. It likely has a bed of 47 degrees, and I do not see this as significant. Nor do I view the infill construction as a major contributor to performance - the extra mass can help with some planes, but then I have had equally superior performances from light planes.

I agree with David - just did not want to say this before hearing from you - that the set up of the Stanley and LN is suspect. A properly closed up chipbreaker is an amazing game-changer. I can plane interlocked woods using a simple Stanley with greater success than some very high-angled planes. 47 degrees is not high. 62 degrees is high.

Years ago I bought a LN #3 with a 55 degree frog. It could not cope with my local woods. It remained on the shelf until I learned to use a chipbreaker. Now that plane has a 45 degree frog, uses an A2 or Clifton O1 blade, and fears no timber. A Veritas custom #4 has a 42 degree frog. This is even more capable of a fine finish, and it too handles any surface into the grain.


If your Bailey planes are not hacking it, then it can only be sharpness and set up. If your Norris is using a less abrasion-resistant steel, then you are likely using the incorrect media and/or the wrong technique for honing. What do you do? And when planing with your chipbreaker closed up, do the shavings straighten up?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finish Planing

#12

Re: Knowing nobody likes something......

david weaver

Yeah, you'd think I was selling them or something. It's probably clinical. I've never done anything but lose money with double irons and the fascination around them :b

Re: Finish Planing

#13

Re: About the performance

Hank Knight

Derek, I'm pretty sure my sharpening media are the primary culprits. My sharpening regimen is: 10" slow speed grinder to establish the initial bevel (I don't resort to this often), a Norton combination medium crystalon/fine India stone, an Arkansas translucent and, finally, a rouge-charged leather strop. My technique could always use some improvement, but I've been getting great edges on other cutting tools for years, so I'm not too worried about it. I sharpen freehand almost exclusively, unless I need to go back and reestablish or flatten the bevel.

I think my real problem lies in the fact that I got discouraged with A2 when I was struggling with the A2 iron in my Norris. As I've mentioned, there was more to that problem than the steel. The thickness of the blade was contributing to the performance issues. That was some years ago when A2 was the hot item. I expected remarkable results from my first infill, and it didn't happen with the A2, but it did with the W1. It took me years to realize that the blade thickness was a contributor, but by that time my attitude toward A2 had soured and I had found other satisfactory alternatives. I also think the tedium of sharpening A2 on traditional sharpening media, combined with my impatience, was part of the problem, and still is.

I think I understand plane set-up pretty well and I read the almost endless discussion here and elsewhere about setting chipbreakers, so I think I've got that under control. Everything about the preformance problems I've had points to sharpness. If I'm going to solve the problem, I need to start there. I have thought many times about getting set up for diamonds, but I've never done it. That's primarily because I quit chasing sharpening Nirvana a long time ago and settled on the regimen I described above. It serves my needs very well and isn't complicated. In the case of my A2 smoothers, however, I believe I would probably see a significant improvement if I used diamonds on them. Maybe this conversation will motivate me to try it.

Thanks for your thoughts and advice.

Hank

Re: Finish Planing

#14

Re: About the performance

Brian Holcombe

I find A2 to be loathsome. It doesn't sharpen well, if at all, on the natural stones I like to sharpen with so I resort to ceramic whetstones that I don't much enjoy using (though they are nice stones). It also cannot be quickly brought back to life like a plain carbon steel. Finally it microchips in my experience, so the blade could on the whole be plenty capable of cutting but it will start leaving fine lines in the finish which drive me crazy.

I find plain high carbon steels, or even blue steel 1 and 2 are much easier to deal with and wear evenly. They will tend to leave a dulled finish before leaving a finish with lines in it.

Re: Finish Planing

#15

Re: About the performance

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I always wondered if the "microchipping" came from the sharpening media. The brash or harsh media sharpen aggressively, but they tend to leave deep scratches which leave the edge vulnerable to fracture and chipping. I suppose that if the harsh media go hand in hand with the abrasion resistant steels, you could call it a characteristic of the steel.

Re: Finish Planing

#16

Re: About the performance

TomD

Cheapest game changer for the set-up you have, Hank, might be to charge your strop with diamond. I had this old strop from a time when the Green compound wasn't out yet and I had this box of 4 polishing crayons, the one I mostly used being the ballyhooed rouge. That is the strop I slapped my LV paste onto. I hardly ever recharge it, and the effect is pretty massive on a lot of cutters. I have some great iron, but I prefer the leather stops. Real hard leather though, not pouty at all.

Re: Finish Planing

#17

Re: About the performance

Hank Knight

Thanks for the suggestion, Tom. I've got some 0.5 micron diamond paste, and some unused horse butt leather. Sounds like a marriage made in heaven.

Re: Finish Planing

#18

Re: About the performance

Brian Holcombe

That's a good point. To add data to the discussion the stones I use, in particular are a snow-white chosera (about 8k) and a sigma 13,000. I haven't noticed one stone having a higher tendency toward microchipping or not, so now I'll have to try both with more awareness.

Re: Finish Planing

#19

In defence of A2

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I find A2 to be loathsome. It doesn't sharpen well, if at all, on the natural stones I like to sharpen with so I resort to ceramic whetstones that I don't much enjoy using (though they are nice stones). It also cannot be quickly brought back to life like a plain carbon steel. Finally it microchips in my experience, so the blade could on the whole be plenty capable of cutting but it will start leaving fine lines in the finish which drive me crazy.

I find plain high carbon steels, or even blue steel 1 and 2 are much easier to deal with and wear evenly. They will tend to leave a dulled finish before leaving a finish with lines in it.

It is horses for courses.

I would not describe my experiences with A2 as "loathsome", but I would not rave about it either. I do prefer honing O1 or W1 steels, but then who does not ... it is the easiest steel to hone. The flip side is that O1/W1 does not hold an edge half as long as A2 on my local West Australian timbers. This is the value of A2 for the user.

As an example, I have LN A2 and Clifton O1 (the old hammered versions, not new blades) for a LN #3. These blades hone up equally sharp (hollow grind, Spyderco Medium and Ultra Fine, Veritas Green Compound), and there is not much difference in the time taken to get them there. Overall, I would describe A2 as a little "chewy", that is, it does not glide across stones as smoothly as O1.

I cannot honestly say that the O1 blade works better and is the preferred steel. A2 may have larger grain and theoretically not get as "sharp", however in practice this is not apparent. Why do I have the O1 blade? I have used Clifton blades for at least 15 years (I have a few). When sharp, they work ... like any other blade that is sharp. I suspect that most of the resistance to A2 steel comes from those who do not need its extra durability over O1, and also are not optimally set up to prepare the steel.

I do not find that there are signs of more chipping with A2 than any other steel. This may reflect the hard wood I use. Still, I used LV A2 blades in a LA Jack for many years on a shooting board with a 25 degree bevel, and these did not chip. I do not use much in the way of soft woods, with Tasmanian Oak (similar to the average White Oak) typically used as a secondary wood in drawer sides (as in my current build), and the surfaces gleam after planing. I cannot tell which blade produced a finish.

LN #4 1/2 on a drawer bottom ...



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finish Planing

#20

Re: In defence of A2

Brian Holcombe

I can get a mirror from a surface planed with A2, that's not my issue with it. My issue with A2 is that the quality of the surface it produces degrades rapidly though it remains 'sharp' for quite a long time. It's OK in planes that I don't like to sharpen very often, but terrible in a smoother which relies upon a clean surface.

LN's O1 is ok, in fact I'd happily swap my A2 blade for O1 if anyone were to take me up on it.

While it is not an apples to apples comparison, I much prefer vintage carbon steels, which degrade nicely. They're still cutting a clean surface, though no longer bright and shiny, long after the A2 has begun to put hairlines in the surface.

For fairness I've compared to alloys, I have a blue 1 plane blade that lasts easily as long as A2 and produces a quality edge up until the point where it won't plane (lost clearance) and it does it with a 27 degree bevel.

All of this could certainly come down to sharpening medium, as Warren mentioned.

Personal preference as you mention, but for me the steel has always come up short.

Re: Finish Planing

#21

Re: In defence of A2

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I can get a mirror from a surface planed with A2, that's not my issue with it. My issue with A2 is that the quality of the surface it produces degrades rapidly though it remains 'sharp' for quite a long time. It's OK in planes that I don't like to sharpen very often, but terrible in a smoother which relies upon a clean surface.

Brian, this statement applies equally to O1 ... probably more so on my woods. All surfaces degrade when planed with a dull edge. In my world, O1 dulls quickly, and there is less room for error compared to A2 (on abrasive woods). I would not be making this stand if not for this aspect.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finish Planing

#22

Re: About the performance

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Bill Tindall must be on vacation or something :D .

I have a couple A2 irons in my LV planes, and they are an absolute bear to try to sharpen on a waterstone. A few years back, because of Bill's experimentation and discussions here on WC, I acquired a block of cast iron and a couple tubes of diamond paste. It was an absolute revelation. Now, I hollow grind like Derek and go right to a 3 micron paste on cast iron. I sometimes follow up with a 1 micron paste. The edge is as good as I've ever achieved with waterstones.

Re: Finish Planing

#23

Re: In defence of A2

david weaver

Take a look at the berg iron after 200 passes vs. the A2 iron:

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/EKtest.html

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/LVA2test.html

Simpler steels leave a more uniform surface all the way until the clearance runs out.

What they don't is hold minute clearance as long.

I think there are two groups of people who will prefer simpler steels. People who dimension by hand (because the bulk of the work is done with thicker shavings where trying to hold the initial tiny wear bevel isn't very critical), and people who want to finish plane by hand, especially once learning to use a double iron (which doesn't rely on sharpness to prevent tearout).

Re: Finish Planing

#24

Re: In defence of A2

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I am not sure that Brent's results are relevant in the case of abrasive timber. He used Douglas Fir in his tests. Hardly abrasive in my experience. This would bias the tests/results in favour of O1.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finish Planing

#25

Re: In defence of A2

david weaver

In terms of relative wear rates, probably, but the pattern of wear is what I'm talking about, and O1 does not fail any differently in abrasive wood than it does in less abrasive wood.

I think that the bulk of woodworkers read scenarios like yours and think that there will be some large amount of abrasive woodworking that they're going to do, and they assume that they'll need A2 or high speed steel or V11 or something, and then they use it on cherry or soft maple.

I know you're limited somewhat in terms of what you get locally, but the bulk of hand tool woodworking in the US and most places in the world is done with something more similar to cherry.

That said, once I abandoned the idea of taking a lot of thin shavings, a stock stanley iron proved no problem even in cocoblo, and i used it for everything other than sawing in a couple of planes.

what I found testing irons when a maker sent me an A2 iron was that some a2 irons are prone to that small chipping more than others. If you look at beach's results, the wear bevel for LV and hock A2 is the same size, but LV's iron developed a lot more defects, and those defects are the ones that would make small lines coming off of a smoother. Carbon steel doesn't do that.

I sent Brian a try plane with an iron that was very soft. It rolls up a wire edge on a washita very easily, and I'm sure it's oil hardening because the whole iron is steel (it's not laminated). I am never concerned with an iron like that, but one of the reasons I wouldn't want to sell planes is that it takes an experienced user to appreciate how that particular iron wears. You can see the edge on it, but it still leaves a uniform surface and keeps cutting well, making a continuous shaving that isn't segmented.

Most people taking a board off of a power planer and then just removing the ripples will probably never do the work that it takes to get a sense for that, there is nothing driving trying to take a thicker shaving until the last pass. Dimensioning sent me in that direction - as in, even the few times I take wood off of a planing machine, I will smooth much faster now than I did five years ago when I didn't dimension anything by hand. Only the very last pass is backed off in thickness.