Re: In these discussions ..
david weaver
Cut out the kunio and kiyotada and we're left with what came in older tools. That stuff is accessible, and cheap. I've never bought a stanley 4 that cost more than a lie nielsen iron, and the NOS double irons I've gotten have been about $25 plus shipping.
That's not the only consideration (price), but accessibility is there.
I don't know what causes people to have trouble sharpening A2, but in the case where someone like hank can finish plane with something else, why bother setting up a separate sharpening media or processes? It's probably a wire edge issue, but I don't have a problem with them, or V11 even, on oilstones - it's possible to sharpen all of them on oilstones, even without compound. Cheaper, too, which is not the intention necessarily, but cheaper is there. (washita followed by owyhee jasper removes the wire edge and creates something similar to what a synthetic stone does - it does take some skill to use those two).
There's no real benefit to those steels, except to beginners. There may be a detriment in that they never encourage you to explore taking thicker shavings, which I'm sure is far closer to history than taking gobs of 1 thousandth shavings as most boutique planes are shown to do now.
In fact, when you get down to it with the new premium planes, if you do heavy work with them and a vintage plane, you will quickly put the premium planes away. Once you compare wooden to them, the gap grows by a factor of ten. Their soles are too finely ground, and they have the highest amount of friction of anything you could think of short of a heavier plane of the same type.
At any rate, diemaking alloys became popular with makers because they're well behaved, and maybe because Karl Holtey led the way, but Karl needs a little extra something in his planes to separate them from others. They would be nicer planes to use with a blue #1 laminated steel iron, but nobody has the skill to make those in the western world. T1 (which would make a better blade steel than most of what is used now) has been available for a long time, and similar stuff was tinkered with in razors, and it fell on its face because the market would've been experienced users. It would've been easily available to use in tools, and the stones to sharpen it (carborundum corporation) have been available in everything up to razor hone fineness for over a hundred years.
Professional users didn't adopt any of that. It's marketable now because beginners are taught to sharpen things paint by numbers, often in slow processes (and some manufacturers tell the same beginners not to use a power grinder....on diemaking steel blades), and everyone is made to believe that sharpening is something difficult enough to put it off as far as possible.