New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Finish Planing

Posts

Re: Finish Planing

#51

Re: I am so pleased...

Brian Holcombe

Thank you! The pleasure is truly mine, as my life has been made significantly easier with your wooden bodied planes.

You know this info, but I'll share with the forum so that they understand the context of my interest in switching.

I was jointing the top of a coffee table and finding it to be a frustrating experience with the LN 7 plane. The plane is nice, but it's sole is extremely flat iron, making for some serious friction when a heavy cut is taken. I did not want a heavy camber on the iron, so I had the camber set to feather the cut out to the edges and nothing more. So here I was stuck taking a moderate to light cut to flatten this table top and once it got fairly flat it was brutal to take a shaving. The process was taking forever.

David offered to make me a try plane to alleviate this issue and so the topic of plane irons came up. I believe that the maker knows best, so I requested David to use an iron that he would prefer for himself which he did. The side benefit was that it nudged me further toward plain high carbon steels.

I can put an edge on it and knock the wear off the back in a heartbeat, set it for a heavy cut with a light camber and take a beautifully thick shaving. The result is a low friction plane that takes a nice heavy cut and trues a panel quickly.

Re: Finish Planing

#52

Re: Better!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, this is what I referred to as horses for courses. There is no advantage from a Spyderco in terms of sharpening speed if all you are going to use it with is O1 steel (other than it ability to remain flat). The advantage comes from its ability to hone abrasion-resistant steels, such as A2, M2, etc.

Interesting that George prefers Spyderco to oilstones.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finish Planing

#54

Re: You can always purchase Clifton blades.

Brian Holcombe

Will do, thanks Derek I had forgotten all about the clifton blades.

Re: Finish Planing

#55

Good luck....

John in NM

I haven't seen them for sale over here for quite some time. I was looking about a year ago when considering what size plane to make out of a nice block of LV a friend gave me. Only Clifton I could find in stock was an absurdly large 2 5/8" wide.

I have a 2" Clifton that I bought maybe 15 years ago. Its a nice blade.

Of course, Hock blades are readily available in O1 also.

Re: Finish Planing

#56

Re: Better!

david weaver

Sure, I've had the discussion with george since long before he mentioned spydercos on the forum.

George experimented with the diemaker's steels long before any of the current manufacturers did, and he likes A2 a lot because it's well behaved. He's also made a lot of stuff out of high speed steels.

I didn't find the spydercos to cut anything that any other synthetic stone don't, which should make sense because the abrasive in them is no different than the aluminas in any other stone. The binder is harder, but that's it.

what I don't like about them is that the UF is too fine to follow a diamond stone and the medium is too slow to take the place of an ez lap or something of that sort.

You can re-waken them, but they quickly cut slowly again, even alumina is not impervious to dulling or abrasive breakage.

Re: Finish Planing

#57

So, it appears ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... that your mentor and our favourite guru (meant seriously - George is one I look up to as well), who was head toolmaker at Col Williamsburg for a few decades, who is one of the most talented instrument makers (hopsicords and, especially, guitars) that you and I have come across ... and, in addition, a very knowlegable and respected machinist to machinists ..... friend to both of us ....

.... prefers A2 steel and Spyderco stones (also followed by Veritas green compound). :D

Incidentally, my experience of the speed of the Medium and UF Spyderco stones differs from yours. They follow a 600 grit Eze-lap diamond stone (hey, George does that as well! :) ).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finish Planing

#58

Re: Good luck....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Highland still have some of the old Clifton blades in stick (the hammered ones ... the good ones!), and they are on special. I purchases one for my LN #3 there recently. They may be out of the #4 1/2 size. Otherwise, the newer versions are available from the UK.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finish Planing

#59

Re: So, it appears ....

david weaver

Yes, the medium follows a diamond hone.

What happens if you go without the diamond hone?

And then if not, what happens if you skip straight to the UF.

It was of interest to me because I had not been using more than 2 stones (the 1k shapton followed by the 15k is a fantastic combination, but it does require learning to lift the final step and then having the discretion not to make too large of a final bevel doing that).

I had two UFs (the narrow one and the wide one), so I'm fairly certain of their slowness compared to something like an 8k synthetic stone (which is really about what the UF is when it's new, before the surface is burnished - it's somewhere in the 6-8k JIS particle size range).

The medium starts fast when it's new but soon slower and needs that diamond hone to do the heavy work for it. The pores make it cut faster than the white stones, but they also keep it from floating particles as the water doesn't sit on it.

I wouldn't say universally that george likes A2. He likes it from the maker's perspective because it's very well behaved when hardening and tempering. What george also says that rankles a lot of people is that he likes tools tempered to a light brown. That's about the same hardness as the vintage tools.

(george did his testing of stones several decades ago, maybe nearly 4 now. One of the types of stones he tried and then had stocked was a frictionite 00. I guess he didn't care for it too much, but one of the carvers took a shine to a variation of it called a super punjab. I can only say that the 00 frictionite fine side was the most pleasing feeling sharpening stone I've ever used of any type. No clue how they were made or even what the abrasive was (it was something natural suspended in a synthetic matrix)).

Re: Finish Planing

#60

Re: So, it appears ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)



Yes, the medium follows a diamond hone.

What happens if you go without the diamond hone?

And then if not, what happens if you skip straight to the UF.

It was of interest to me because I had not been using more than 2 stones (the 1k shapton followed by the 15k is a fantastic combination, but it does require learning to lift the final step and then having the discretion not to make too large of a final bevel doing that).

David, when the blade has a fresh hollow and the amount of steel is the ideal minimal, it is possible to use only the UF stone. I would not do this, however, since using green compound is a significant benefit.

Keep in mind that I, too, want an efficient sharpening system. I hone directly on the hollow, and will do this several times before returning to the grinder (steel is only removed from the hollow). Using other stones becomes increasing necessary when the bevel widens and/or the steel involved is hard and abrasion-resistant. It is simply inefficient to use a fine stone to do the work of a coarse stone. Equally, it is efficient, when you use the best stone for the right reason. You know that. So I am not obsessed with using fewer stones, rather with making the decision when to include others.

I had two UFs (the narrow one and the wide one), so I'm fairly certain of their slowness compared to something like an 8k synthetic stone (which is really about what the UF is when it's new, before the surface is burnished - it's somewhere in the 6-8k JIS particle size range).

All stones load. Keeping them clean is as important - more! - than keeping them flat. I spritz the stones with a tad of soapy water when sharping, and also run a 600 grit diamond stone over them once each month.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finish Planing

#61

Only the 1 3/4" I'm afraid...

John in NM

Its too bad, I like the 2" I have. It was Traditional Woodworker that had the really wide one still the last time I looked. I suspect these are the remnants of the stock they had last time some were imported, whether they will restock at these exchange rates are anyone's guess.

Re: Finish Planing

#62

Re: An often overlooked fact

TomD

+1.

Only thing I would add is it may not be purely linear modern vs old thinking. Files are still great, and one can probably find a work around with some of one's old stones. Just need to have a plan of attack. It would be unhelpful to assume that one needs all new stuff just because one has added a so called new steel. But one may need to revamp the approach. HSS steel goes back to at least 1868, and some would say 350 BC, depending on how you think about it. Or 1910, if you want to do one of those Russia invented baseball deals for the US category.

Re: Finish Planing

#63

Re: Better!

TomD

I am certainly willing, in an Oxford Union kind of way to argue for non-rounded edges. But the amount of rounding that exists with .5 micron... :) Really? Then there is the whole issue of whether rounding actually hurts anything. In most planes, not sure I would worry.

Re: Finish Planing

#64

Re: Better!

TomD

My spiderco everythings, are so non-flat, it is hard to imagine a world were that is possible. What is it with ceramic, and flatness. Remember those ceramic waterstone flattening stones. Got pulled because they weren't flat...

Re: Finish Planing

#65

Re: So, it appears ....

TomD

None of those accolades takes you that far into steel. This place spins off sharpening recipes like a squirrel on crack flaps his tail. Just develop the right technique, the right periodicity, and just bear down a little, it's all good. If you really want to do it like a pro, enlist some electrons. None of this stuff we are buying is made by hand as far as I know. I would actually be more interested in knowing how the factories are doing it. They are now expected to deliver, properly machined tools, that are razor sharp. I assume it is all done by power.

Re: Finish Planing

#66

Re: So, it appears ....

TomD

I would be curious to know how long George has stuck with the same combination. That might be the real lesson.

Re: Finish Planing

#67

Re: Better?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David, this is what I referred to as horses for courses.

Courses for horses? Derek, it seems as if you change course every few years. I can remember belt sander, Tormek, bench grinder, and CBN wheels. Sets of King stones 2006, Shapton 2009, Sigma 2012, Spyderco 2014 and EZ lap, green stuff and film thrown in. I surely have forgotten some. All of them touted as the "ultimate" in their turn. I pity anyone who has followed your advice and bought all this stuff. There is breadth of experience here, little depth.

Re: Finish Planing

#68

Amazing!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren, you must have archives of every post on every forum that raises your blood pressure. Of course, that includes everyone that disagrees with you or does something differently to Joseph Moxon.

I recall writing to you once to see if we could bury the hatchet. You replied with a quote of something I wrote 10 years before. I did laugh. It was so predictable.

It's a wonder you have time for woodworking!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finish Planing

#69

Re: Only the 1 3/4" I'm afraid...

Brian Holcombe

That's my finding as well, maybe Hock is the choice then.

Re: Finish Planing

#70

Time on the stones

Brian Holcombe

Tom, I think that is a good point to bring up. Many of the advanced level sharpeners tend to stick with the same stones for years, I came across this on So's website and inquired about it with him. (Unfortunately it was spoken for).

http://www.japan-tool.com/zc/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=43_3&products_id=648

It was interesting to me that his preference was not only for a relatively inexpensive stone, but also for a stone that is very fast and not super fine.

Re: Finish Planing

#71

Re: So, it appears ....

david weaver

Oilstones don't load.

I think the difference between what you do and what I do is that stones are used at the same angle the way you sharpen - where the primary is set more or less.

I don't do that. I always hone a bit up from the primary so that I'm working less steel, and so that my finest stone (if I choose to use one) doesn't have to remove all of the scratches from the prior steels - it works only at the edge. I don't try to do the work of the coarse stone with a fine stone, I skip that entirely - it doesn't touch wood.

My coarse oilstones are in an oilbath, so I don't ever have to do anything with them. Once in a while, I will wipe off the washita, but nothing would happen if I didn't. The next time I added lubricant, the swarf would keep flowing off.

I guess it's counter to the message out there that oilstones are the fastest way to sharpen, because if you try to use them like a waterstone, they're not. But in context, they are.

Re: Finish Planing

#72

Re: So, it appears ....

Brian Holcombe

I've only ever received a handful of sharp tools from a manufacturer/maker. Blue Spruce's marking tools, Matsui marking tools, Kinshirou marking tools that were all sort of 'sharp enough' and a set of Konobu gouges that were sharpened with natural stones and incredibly sharp.

Re: Finish Planing

#73

Re: So, it appears ....

david weaver

3 or 4 decades. He used museum money to decide what they should stock for the craftsmen, and he's used the same stones since then.

He had purchased a few of the stones from the museum supply for his own use, and I sold them for him on ebay (stones other than spydercos). In that was a bunch of frictionite 00s and 821s and 825s (intended for sharpening razors).

If I'd have had access to the frictionites, they would've been my choice. They are only fine stones, though.

(the sharpening topic isn't something he particularly enjoys - I think he mentioned the spydercos because he was hounded by people asking him what he's using).

Re: Finish Planing

#74

Re: Time on the stones

david weaver

Much like okudo suita. Good suita are a lot like a washita stone. You just use them, they don't load with anything and you keep them flat with skill.

If we ground japanese tools with a power grinder, there'd be no need for much else.

Just like with a washita, when using only one stone, you can get a much better edge with it over time just based on experience and touch.

Re: Finish Planing

#75

Re: Time on the stones

Brian Holcombe

His stone reminded me a lot of the Washita that you use. From experience on the edge that arrived with the try plane it is slightly less fine than the suita that I use, So described that stone to me very similarly to how you've described the Washita, especially given the context.

Even with adding a Nakayama Asagi to my lineup, I still much prefer the Shinden suita for everyday sharpening. Really the Nakayama is for those times when you want a blazing sharp edge and not much more (I've gotten my sushi knife to cut a hanging hair with it).

Stanley Covington described his every-day stone similarly. I find it interesting, and also encouraging that both groups wind up doing something very similarly....high carbon steels and fast natural stones.