I'm thankful....
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
....that there are people performing useful evaluations of new technology and reporting on it. While I have become largely set in my woodworking ways, and others seemingly far more set than I, someone new has the option of starting anywhere on the technology timeline. Someone new to sharpening may prefer to adapt a past century's practice or a particular culture, but most want the best currently available at the price they can afford. Personally, if I had no means of sharpening I would look to Derek for current advice on what to buy today. What he recommended in 2006 would not be relevant to me, nor what was used in 1920.
As abrasive technology advances it is certain that better abrasives will become available. One way these abrasives are better is that they are effective on modern abrasive resistant steel, or they stay flat or whatever is important. It should not be a surprise that the seeded gel ceramics that have taken over abrasive choice in the tool rooms of machine shops have appeared in woodworking stores. Anyone motivated to keep us with these developments is obviously going to report on some new product every few years. It is not going to take years of experience to know that some new rock cuts some steel better or worse than some other rock, or stays flat, or whatever. Most woodworking ain't that complicated.
Derek, keep up the reporting of new stuff that is readily available for purchase by anyone with the money to do so. I don't have a fully stocked antique store to shop at.



