New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Finish Planing

Posts

Re: Finish Planing

#76

I'm thankful....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....that there are people performing useful evaluations of new technology and reporting on it. While I have become largely set in my woodworking ways, and others seemingly far more set than I, someone new has the option of starting anywhere on the technology timeline. Someone new to sharpening may prefer to adapt a past century's practice or a particular culture, but most want the best currently available at the price they can afford. Personally, if I had no means of sharpening I would look to Derek for current advice on what to buy today. What he recommended in 2006 would not be relevant to me, nor what was used in 1920.

As abrasive technology advances it is certain that better abrasives will become available. One way these abrasives are better is that they are effective on modern abrasive resistant steel, or they stay flat or whatever is important. It should not be a surprise that the seeded gel ceramics that have taken over abrasive choice in the tool rooms of machine shops have appeared in woodworking stores. Anyone motivated to keep us with these developments is obviously going to report on some new product every few years. It is not going to take years of experience to know that some new rock cuts some steel better or worse than some other rock, or stays flat, or whatever. Most woodworking ain't that complicated.

Derek, keep up the reporting of new stuff that is readily available for purchase by anyone with the money to do so. I don't have a fully stocked antique store to shop at.

Re: Finish Planing

#77

Re: I'm thankful....  L.V. is sneaky smart

TomD

"While I have become largely set in my woodworking ways,"

I think that is an achievement. You have arrived (or arrived many years ago). That is what mastery looks like. But it also feels a bit like death because we live in progress oriented societies. But Elon Musk is making the real progress, we are still working similar woods, in old designs. Real progress would be if there were violent discussions over how to use epoxy hardware bonding to push the limits of furniture design, but then we would have to live with the stuff.

"Someone new to sharpening may prefer to adapt a past century's practice or a particular culture, but most want the best currently available at the price they can afford."

"As abrasive technology advances it is certain that better abrasives will become available."

All that really begs for machine sharpening. I don't get why people don't get that, I think to some extent they are scared to get hurt, or hurt the tools, which is a possibility.

Our craft exists in a weird place where we adapt all kinds of technology but still maintain a Robinson Crusoe attitude as though all 19th century craftsmen lived just beyond that guy in Dancing With Wolves, with no social context or power machinery, which was all over the place in the 19th century. The steam power revolution actually started in the early 17th century, and before that there were water powered mills.

"It is not going to take years of experience to know that some new rock cuts some steel better or worse than some other rock, or stays flat, or whatever. Most woodworking ain't that complicated."

Nice thing about belts is they stay flat all the time, and when a belt needs replacement you have at a low cost the option to upgrade to a whole new abrasive technology if it is available. Lee Valley is kinda sneaky smart about things because they make stuff and not just sell stuff. They have had a cheap belt sander (and a pretty expensive disc sander), in the catalog for decades with some pretty nice quality belts.

I actually do almost all my sharpening by hand, because if you do it at the right time, a thing that is more likely for me to do if the plane is stupid simple to get into, A quick swipe on the whatever is super fast, and familiar. But what I never waste time on any more is the 600 grit King stone. And I am somewhat fed up with diamond stones, unless I am cutting carbide. And I use power diamond for that. I use loose paste to polish carbide.

My big belt sander, that I get out only a few times a year (space issue, if I had more space I might use it every day) has a 1.5 hp motor on it. I wish it had a 3hp. I can do without 3hp cutting wood, but for metal the ability to feed steel like paper into a shredder is invaluable.

Re: Finish Planing

#78

Re: Just to say

TomD

By the way, I think hand sharpening in a simple way is totally viable, even very low cost alternatives like sandpaper, and some diamond paste. I used sandpaper for about a decade in the winter in my cold shop. Even though I have a hundred weight of stones I preferred paper in the cold and in an area without water.

I got started early with power sharpening through wood turning, where one needs to be able to turn around very hard tools or a turning day is really a day of sharpening with brief intervals of turning. Turning and sharpening on a wheel are different sides of the same coin, you hold something against something that spins, and in one case you shape the spinning thing and in the other case the held thing. Or you could say in both cases you are shaping both. But this practice leads easily to tool making.

Two situations where I advocate power is where the discussion changes from hand sharpening to high efficiency high cost sharpening, and tons of 100 dollar stones. Minute examinations of wear and cut advantages. I can cut steel for hours using a 2 dollar tool, and a touch up on a 60 dollar grinder. There is nothing wrong with being curious about hand methods, I have the stones and jigs in memorial of my interest. At some point progress is in another direction, if the motivation is actually to accelerate results.

The other situation is tool making. It is a lot more fun if your steel disappears as if your grinder were a sword swallower.

Re: Finish Planing

#79

Re: Prices?

TomD

Have I just been asleep at the switch, or has there been a precipitous increase in the cost of stones recently. I'm in Canada so gyrations in the dollar can have their effect. But almost all the numbers I look at are US. Plus, even in Canada, the Asian sourced prices tend to be more consistent. Just seems as though all of a sudden a routine stone will be 70 buck?

Re: Finish Planing

#80

Re: HSS and Japanese stones

TomD

Just for those of you who aren't into all the minutia of Japanese tools (pretty much me at this point also). One of my sets of Japanese chisels, purchased around 1980, is a HSS set. It sharpens nicely on Japanese stones. Around the same time I bought two planes, that are HSS Japanese planes, and they are not so nice to sharpen. There are many many variations on these HSS tools. There is nothing all that odd about sharpening HSS on stuff like the lowly King stones. Sop while Japanese carpenters can be really into the match of stones to tools, that doesn't rule out some pretty utilitarian options also.

Re: Finish Planing

#81

Re: HSS and Japanese stones

Brian Holcombe

I haven't noticed any substantial increases, quite the opposite since I'm buying in dollars.

I use a few sources, all relatively reasonable considering that I'm pretty specific about what I like. So Yamashita, Stanley Covington, Mandaraya shop and Aframes all fairly priced. Mandaraya's site is all kanji which makes it more difficult but the proprietor (Teshiba) speaks limited English.

I know someone is fair when I can leave the deal completely open ended and they do not overcharge me by even the slightest bit or recommend something unnecessary.

Re: Finish Planing

#82

Re: HSS and Japanese stones

Hank Knight

Brian,

Is Kayoko still around. She used to have an "in" with the Japanese stone quarries and could find really nice stones to match your particular needs. She found a really nice honyama stone for me some years ago that I treasure for finishing my Japanese irons and chisels. I haven't heard much from her since. I know she went back to Japan to care for Japan's National Treasure Yakaiti before he passed, but I have heard nothing from her since he died.

Hank

Re: Finish Planing

#83

Re: HSS and Japanese stones

Brian Holcombe

Hank,

I've heard about her, but haven't gotten in touch or done any work with her. IIRC she used to be at Hidatool?

Cheers

Brian

Re: Finish Planing

#84

Re: Yataiki

Hank Knight

The Japanese National Treasure sawmaker was Yataiki, not wharever I typed earlier. Sorry about that?

Re: Finish Planing

#85

Re: HSS and Japanese stones

TomD

You guys are not apparently buying from the major retailers. But now that I look at it, it could be mostly currency.

Re: Finish Planing

#86

Re: HSS and Japanese stones

Brian Holcombe

We win out on the currency, since the dollar is still strong (not as good as mid 2015, but still good).

Price aside, I dont really shop with major retailers because I like a close relationship. You have to be a huge account to even be noticed by a large retailer let alone have them make special requests and so forth, and often paying a premium for anything that isn't imported in bulk.

The small shops can do so much more with regard to what would be considered exotic, at least in the US. Small shops can make a personal recommendation and most often you're dealing with someone who actually uses the product or receives feedback from professional users. For instance when So Yamashita recommends a sharpening stone he will ask you a lot of questions and offer very specific stones, he's not trying to make everything work for everything to make a sale.

Re: Finish Planing

#87

Re: I'm thankful....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It is not going to take years of experience to know that some new rock cuts some steel better or worse than some other rock, or stays flat, or whatever. Most woodworking ain't that complicated.

I don't agree with you here, Bill. I know for myself I was still making observations and refining technique after 25 years daily with the same stones. Sharpening tools is an art, which is to say that it is very complicated.

I am reminded of a 10 year old clarinet player. He told me that he planned to learn the oboe after he mastered the clarinet, the flute, and the bassoon. Of course he never mastered the clarinet.