New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

more from Kato and Kawai

Posts

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#101

Re: A flaw in the flaw

TomD

The admission that planes aren't for planing curved surfaces, though not particularly true, is the point though. If much furniture is curved, and planes don't work on it, then there must be some other acceptable methods. There are quite a few examples of work where planes would probably not be the choice. A thou can be a lot structurally for instance on stuff like bows and some instruments, and thou planes or similar tools are used a lot, it may not be ideal to proceed with them in many cases because the increment of removal is too large, which is their beauty.

It probably doesn't mean much, but is intriguing to ponder that the efficiency of planes is their ability to take a sanded surface and quickly reproduce it. A finish that would not be practical to achieve over a whole wide board, can be created on a plane blade, and then printed on as many boards as one likes. But it all got it's start through abrasion.

It obvious both methods are limited and have their purposes.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#102

Re: Uggh

TomD

"As far as whether one should risk planing a veneered surface: a well set up plane can take a shaving in the 0.001” range, which is a goal that I know that Charley has scoffed at in the past."

.0004" is easy so no question.

" Assuming that the veneer is thick enough, planing the veneer should not be much of a problem. Commercial veneers today are about 0.023” thick, which means that you should be able to take a dozen passes without problems."

That misses the likelihood that the part may not be perfectly flat, and one could loose some thickness as one does in other processes just getting flat. But my thought would be taking your example at face value, why would anyone want a veneer to be .011". It is bad enough this junk is .023 to start with.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#103

Re: There’s a big fat flaw in this line of argum

TomD

"This discussion started long ago with "double irons aren't better than single irons""

That is still obviously in play. There are some situation where they are better. Which as far as I know was the default position for the 35 years I have been in adult woodworking.

"to "technically, they are""

Uh, no.

" to "they don't eliminate tearout everywhere""

And tearout is not a factor everywhere. Your beloved Japanese, and mine, could plane some of their wood with a butter knife it is so nice, as in many NA crafts.

" (generally, they do if the plane can work the surface to now "you can't plane the side of a bombe chest")."

The fact the majority of planes are single blades is a point. A bombe chest is just an example, there are whole languages worth of furniture and parts that can't be, or shouldn't be bothered to be planed to a finish. In general planes are rarely ouot of or far from my hands, but as to slavish adherence to dictums, not interested. I get what people are so charmingly saying when they say they don't care what methods others use, but I wonder why they care what methods they use. If one can't do a good job with most methods, one is just still low on the learning curve.

I once had an illustrative seminar with a Myrtle wood turner. He wanted to be taught how to cut with gouges having heard in the woodworking press that his scraping and sanding method was wrong. Fact was, while I was pretty good in those days, the methods he used were much faster than mine, and worked just fine. The shapes he sold were all-over rounded; He turned at some high speed like 5K stuck in his carbide and then hit it with sandpaper, job done, never any tearout. A better turner or one using today's tool profiles might have shown him something, but in general his method was just fine. He never had a finishing flaw to deal with. He had a huge extractor. I don't know what he did with the dust but it is unlikely that coarse ropes of wood, would have worked out better for him.

I mostly spokeshave the curves on my plane handles.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#104

Re: A flaw in the flaw

TomD

"Charley’s issue is that he seems to think that because scraping/sanding works best on curved surfaces for finish preparation (and I agree with that), that there is no other alternative for flat surfaces."

You may have a point there. My thought was he was saying because there is a to plane and not to plane list, that it demonstrates that not to plane is a viable/necessary/co-equal/why are we arguing/who cares/learn another method/somewhere in italy there is a machine that finishes with abrasives at a speed you can't imagine, technique. I am not sure how anyone can say that under some circumstance (actually a lot) planing isn't an option, it is just a question of what other options are equally viable.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#105

Re: John and Thomas Seymour

TomD

"It is amazing that somehow there was this whole bevel up plane business going on. I read some stuff from 2008-2010 magazines and you have Schwarz and Lonnie Bird gushing about bevel up planes, etc. I am a serious newbie and basically got lucky that when I started some years ago I came across this chip-breaker info here and on Sawmill via David W. Really has made having no machine jointer and planer very manageable."

Yeah the whole "Secret" thing came at a bad time for the industry.

That said, when replacing a jointer or planer I have little use for a sub-blade. The .oo6 (that you may not have in mind), would be at best a 4 thou shaving. I haven't measured them but on hardwoods, my shavings look more like 40-60 thou. And I don't care if I get tear-out or not. If I can get in there with an axe all the better.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#106

Re: Another perspective

Charly

Without doubt this is the rational center, the approach and philosophy that will lead to the least amount of angst and the most amount of progress where it actually counts. Thanks for posting this.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#107

Re: makers...

david weaver

I bring them up only because they have a market for hand done goods. We don't over here. If you showed someone tansu in the united states and told them it would cost $3-$4k for something relatively simple, they'd ask if ikea has it.

"amish made" with everything rounded off is considered "custom furniture" to most, and most of the furniture I've seen, even in nicer houses (docs, etc, ) is dressed up junk.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#109

Re: John and Thomas Seymour

RK near Boston

60 thou is almost a 1/16". I just finished planing a lot of Ash and had a hard time getting a good width 12 thou shavings with the jointer plane and I am stronger than most and my blades are pretty sharp. Jack plane probably can do 60 thou, but even that must be hard work.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#110

Re: makers...

RK near Boston

Yeah, I do not get the whole flaming burl covered in thick shiny poly with live edge thing either. Japanese aesthetic actually seems to be closer to the scandinavian one.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#111

Re: Risk adverse

RK near Boston

How are you going to get better without taking risks? Sometimes one just have to ignore the errors, patch them up and move on while trying to not repeat them.

Most people do not see those errors anyways and one has to strike some balance, otherwise one is stuck with the silly sandpaper. I really do not understand how people actually have patience to go through the sanding grit progressions, for me initially that was the biggest turnoff when reading about woodworking.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#112

Re: makers...

David weaver

I'm not a furniture fanatic, but presume that's nakashima? If so, I haven't seen much Japanese stuff like it.

It's more like piston fit drawers with dovetailed carcases and unfinished interior work.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#113

Re: John and Thomas Seymour

david weaver

I've never measured jack shavings, but that would be a hike for me, too. I haven't worked any significant amount of pine in a long time, though, it may be doable for that.

I know that my try plane shavings are between 5 thousandths and a hundredth on medium hardwoods, but that was only out of curiosity to measure those. When I first started woodworking, I remember david charlesworth made the comment somewhere that a 6 thousandth shaving was about the max he could get out of a smoother (maybe it was more generalized than that). A friend thought it was impossible, but it obviously doesn't seem so now.

Jack plane work is one step less than the biggest shaving you can plane if the wood tolerates it, and it is whatever it is. Definitely less in ash/maple/beech than cherry/walnut.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#114

Re: makers...

RK near Boston

I meant more that I like what Tom said:

"valuing plain grained woods, and valuing "natural finishes""

Nakashima is nice enough, I was just being snide about the fact that live edge and poly are in the mainstream now and is being perverted by "hoi polloi" so to say.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#115

Re: makers...

david weaver

Yeah, I never got it, either. I have done wipe polyurethane on one thing in all of the time I've made things. And it was because someone asked me to finish a lamp base for them.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#116

Another flaw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Richard, you have said it is faster to plane, scrape, and sand than to just plane. It is not. Now you say that sanding is a "safer option" to planing. Sanding is safer for an inexperienced worker. I have planed all flat surfaces and sanded none for 37 years now without any trouble.

You give us these phantom problems and then say you are not disparaging the double iron planes. You say you have gone through an exercise or two to prep a surface with just planes, and achieved it, but they were slow and painstaking exercises. It sounds like you have little experience using the double iron.

The double iron is a sophisticated 18th century technique. Unless you can make an effort to learn the technique, it is better to scrape and sand.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#117

Re: Another flaw

Sgian Dubh

Warren, you and I are never going to agree on this issue - that's the end of our exchange in this thread. Slainte.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#118

Clint Searl

From the "Pink Panther"

Clint Searl

Inspector Clouseau is checking into a small hotel'

A small dog is sniffing agound at his feet.

Clouseau to the clerk: "Does your dog bite?"

Clerk: "No, Monsieur."

Clouseau reaches down to pet the dog, and the dog nips him.

Clouseau recoils and says to the clerk: "But you said your dog does not bite!"

Clerk responds: " That is not my dog."

www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXn2QVipK2o

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#119

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

charly

"In my own experience there are many variables affecting the cap iron use, among them depth of cut, angle of the grain (rising or falling), angle from the radial (quartersawn to plainsawn continuum), and species. To talk about an ideal setting without reference to these variables is ridiculous."

To the extent that these changes can happen all in one board, and certainly across an array of boards, can you comment on how many times you change the cap iron setting in a working day? This isn't a question asked to raise anybody's ire, or cause others to fly to your defense. I'm honestly interested in this.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#120

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When I sharpen a plane iron, I set the cap iron for the task at hand, looking ahead to what I am working on. I can see that a beginner may decide the setting is not appropriate and have remove the iron and adjust, not so much an experienced worker. How many times a day do I take the plane apart just to adjust the cap iron? Very near zero. In the 19th century some planes had cap irons that could be adjusted without disturbing the iron, but I don't see the need.

Some guys have seventeen planes and sharpen them all at once, so they can't anticipate what they will be using them for. I don't think this is a good plan.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#121

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

William Duffield

But it is a plan that could work: They could set the cap iron on each one to a different distance, and choose the right plane for the particular task. At first, it would take several trials to find the plane with the optimal setting, but with more experience, it should take fewer and fewer guesses to pick an appropriate plane. With the advantages of on-line tutorials, scientific studies and guidance, it might even take them fewer years of experience than it took you to develop the skill set. ;)

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#122

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think it would make a nice workshop to have a dozen or more planes with an array of depth of cut settings and cap iron settings and have some varied woods available so the participants could get a feel for how these variables interact without having to adjust planes over and over,.

I can't see having a large assortment of planes for day to day work. Too many planes and you lose intimacy with your tools. I think it is helpful to know the tool well, to know how long it has been since last sharpening, how it acts, how you are doing with the camber and the like. Of course it is unavoidable that a tool sometimes sits a week or a month unused, but having redundant tools makes this happen more than necessary.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#123

bridger

Re: Uggh

Bridger

I think that the thickness of modern thin veneers is set by the characteristics of the wood rather than of the tooling. Modern veneer mills consistently produce veneer that is close to transparency. Plane off half of it's thickness and you will be seeing the substrate through it. The stuff comes with a surface that needs very little prep for finishing. They have gone as thin as is practicable.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#124

Re: Uggh

david weaver

It also often has (the knifed) a characteristic of absorbing more finish than "nice" wood. That, to me, is particularly undesirable. When someone is paying for an item and you're making it and cost is an issue, I can see dealing with it.

When you're making something like kitchen cabinets where you can cap the ends and the insides aren't critical, I can see dealing with it.

For everything nice that you're building because you want to...not a big fan.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#125

Re: makers...

TomD

I have a whole german book that compares jap. and german wood styles more or less for their similarities.

Im offline after a go around this evening due to bypass surgery in the am. I will let you know which style of plane jap. or west is easier to use after sternum cleavage. I am guessing jap. But not for a while either way.