Re: There’s a big fat flaw in this line of argum
TomD
"This discussion started long ago with "double irons aren't better than single irons""
That is still obviously in play. There are some situation where they are better. Which as far as I know was the default position for the 35 years I have been in adult woodworking.
"to "technically, they are""
Uh, no.
" to "they don't eliminate tearout everywhere""
And tearout is not a factor everywhere. Your beloved Japanese, and mine, could plane some of their wood with a butter knife it is so nice, as in many NA crafts.
" (generally, they do if the plane can work the surface to now "you can't plane the side of a bombe chest")."
The fact the majority of planes are single blades is a point. A bombe chest is just an example, there are whole languages worth of furniture and parts that can't be, or shouldn't be bothered to be planed to a finish. In general planes are rarely ouot of or far from my hands, but as to slavish adherence to dictums, not interested. I get what people are so charmingly saying when they say they don't care what methods others use, but I wonder why they care what methods they use. If one can't do a good job with most methods, one is just still low on the learning curve.
I once had an illustrative seminar with a Myrtle wood turner. He wanted to be taught how to cut with gouges having heard in the woodworking press that his scraping and sanding method was wrong. Fact was, while I was pretty good in those days, the methods he used were much faster than mine, and worked just fine. The shapes he sold were all-over rounded; He turned at some high speed like 5K stuck in his carbide and then hit it with sandpaper, job done, never any tearout. A better turner or one using today's tool profiles might have shown him something, but in general his method was just fine. He never had a finishing flaw to deal with. He had a huge extractor. I don't know what he did with the dust but it is unlikely that coarse ropes of wood, would have worked out better for him.
I mostly spokeshave the curves on my plane handles.