Re: A flaw in the flaw
wilbur
So here’s a summary of Charley's statements in this discussion.
— The Seymours didn’t use a double iron. (Shows a picture of furniture with flat veneered surfaces.)
— If the double iron is so effective, then why do all the books talk about scrapers? (Nicholson gets quoted as a book that advocates the use of double irons.)
— So what about curved surfaces? (Not germane to the subject, as planes aren’t used on curved surfaces.)
— So what about veneered surfaces? (I show an example of my experience with planing a veneered surface.)
— So what about really large veneered surfaces? I’ve had trouble with those, even with a scraper. And it’s easy to plane 4/4 down to 3/4. (What?)
All I can do is to repeat what my experience has been. In my hands, I was able to plane a flat surface with a walnut burl veneer from modern commercial stock, which I suppose fits the description of “exceedingly thin burl walnut and the like” that Charley was concerned with earlier in the thread. And this was without a whole lot of time fussing with the set up of the plane. I realize that there are other methods of accomplishing this task. For me, planing was the easiest. And again, I don’t think it was the easiest choice for me because I’m some sort of planing savant.
I suppose Charley can continue to move the target until he comes up with a scenario where a plane in my hands might be problematic. He could come up with larger and larger surfaces to cover. He could make it a criteria that the veneers get ever thinner, increasing the risk of blowing through the veneer. He might even decide that I should use a less than optimal approach to gluing that is guaranteed to leave the veneer with bubbles.
It’s clear to me that by constantly shifting the subject, Charley isn’t really interested in a serious discussion. This shouldn’t be a surprise, given his history on this forum and others.
The only thing I can say is that if Charley can’t figure out how to use a plane to get a finish ready surface, that’s not my problem. I don’t care if he likes another method. that’s fine. He can prep his surfaces however he would like. It still doesn’t invalidate this method of work.
By the way, it may not take a whole lot of courage to plane a 4/4 rough stock down to 3/4. But it does, if you want to leave the 3/4 board with a finish ready surface.