New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

more from Kato and Kawai

Posts

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#76

Re: There’s a big fat flaw in this line of argum

Brian Holcombe

I like to surface panels with hand planes, but that aside I find it incredibly easy to build parts that are finished off of the plane. I'm adding a lot of time to the work by needing to scrape or sand those pieces.

I'd rather have nice crisp lines and miters right off the plane and be done than touch any of that work with a sander or scraper after ward.

Setting up a plane to do this reliably is something I do in less then a minute after initial setups are worked out. Frankly it takes me longer to tune a scraper.

I use scrapers, absolutely, inside of cabinet that is part assembled sometimes it just impossible to use a plane. But I am going to the plane first, scraper second, because the plane is going to yield the best result for me and keep the surface flat.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#77

Re: There’s a big fat flaw in this line of argum

david weaver

Do the manuals say the scrapers are for flat work?

Charlie, you've spent a lot of time setting up straw scenarios, suggesting that someone who only planes flat work is then pigeonholed if they do curved work (there is nothing that would keep us from scraping curved work. I don't do a lot of furniture with curved work, mostly because I don't find much of it that attractive - especially if it's a mix of curves and straight lines - bad combination - but I have scraped something on every single plane I've made because they have curves).

Scraping curves doesn't make me want to scrape flat surfaces. I generally avoid sanding, but I recognize that's not for everyone. In the rare instances I do sand (mouldings, partially out of laziness - in not profiling some spring steel to scrape- or bad wood for a single iron moulding plane), I still burnish the wood with shavings, otherwise the sanded wood absorbs a lot more finish. Burnishing takes less time.

This discussion started long ago with "double irons aren't better than single irons" to "technically, they are", to "they don't eliminate tearout everywhere" (generally, they do if the plane can work the surface to now "you can't plane the side of a bombe chest").

Ok, what kind of straw scenarios are left? The number of responses to this at random times with straw examples of other peoples' work that doesn't look much like anything discussed on here - it looks like borderline insanity.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#78

Re: There’s a big fat flaw in this line of argum

Charley

Scrapers absolutely are for flat surfaces. They can even be used to even out lacquer applications as they are being sprayed. See Tage Frid.

The deftness, skill, and agility required are up to you. Takes more skill both in preparation and in use than does pushing a plane.

Perhaps this will get your juices flowing.

You've hitched yourself (yoked yourself) to the wrong wagon I'm afraid. I doubt I'll convince you, but I do hope that something will.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#79

Re: There’s a big fat flaw in this line of argum

Charley

Please don't regard what is being said as a suggestion that you should scrape and sand if the surface off the plane is acceptable. It often is. If so, by all means move to the next step. I hope that every board you plane is not, by design, a hair-shirt to test your planing and tool tuning skills. This would obviously be ridiculous.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#80

Re: There’s a big fat flaw in this line of argum

david weaver

I scrape every sprayed surface I've ever sprayed with lacquer, specifically because it doesn't involve loading sandpaper. Even if it's just to quickly remove nubs.

I'm not impressed otherwise with the bloviation that it's now much harder than pushing a plane (which was just not too long ago described as too slow and tedious or not pratical - all of the sudden it is a skill that is too relatively easy).

As my neighbor with dementia often says now "what next"? Of course, she's not really asking, and neither am i.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#81

Re: There’s a big fat flaw in this line of argum

Charley

That's fine David. You are obviously comfortable with the trajectory you're on and in the end that's all that matters.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#82

Whoa Slow down there.............

Mark Hennebury

Lets not get carried away here;

"(generally, they do if the plane can work the surface to now "you can't plane the side of a bombe chest")."

Photo-David Beoff Furnituremaker


Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#83

Re: There’s a big fat flaw in this line of argum

wilbur

”Beautiful, but apply that veneer to something not flat.”

I’m not sure why you continue to repeat this flawed line of reasoning and expect it to stick.

Let’s take it as a given that scraping/sanding is the best option to be used on curved surfaces. It doesn’t mean that it is the best option for a flat surface.

Perhaps you may not be able to successfully plane a walnut burl veneer on the front of a box. That’s your issue. That doesn’t mean that I should adopt your method of choice, especially since I find planing to be faster, easier, and more enjoyable than scraping/sanding. And yes, that includes the set up time for the plane.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#84

Re: Whoa Slow down there.............

david weaver

Works for me! That's how I'd do it if the radius was gradual enough for my compass plane.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#85

Big Flaw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Earlier Richard wrote this:

I can't really see how prepping a surface polish ready with just hand planes is likely to be a regular practical option when set against the work needed to set up the tools, followed by the care needed with them in use. I have in the past gone through an exercise or two to prep a surface with just planes, and achieved it, but they were slow and painstaking exercises, especially on some 0.6 mm thick American cherry veneer.

Perhaps it's just me, but for handwork, I get a surface acceptably polish ready through using planes that perform 'well enough', scrapers for bits of tearout, and abrasives to finish.

He makes reference to "cost in time and effort" and "marry, as best we can, speed with acceptable end results." I am having trouble seeing how anyone can think that planing, scraping and sanding might be faster than planing alone.

Recently I smoothed a figured drawer front (4x35); the time was 14 seconds. How much time would it save to add on scraping and sanding? I stained this front with water stain in 17 seconds, then ready for finish.

I wrote on this forum in 2007:

In my experience people who disparage double iron planes invariably make comments which lead me to think they do not really know how to use them.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#86

As a practical matter......for the bystanders

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We must realize in these discussion that once someone develops a successful way of doing something it will take a lot of convincing to alter their approach. However, in a typical post there are 4 participants and 250 watching, mostly the silent majority, some of whom are watching to learn. As an additional insight I have been led astray many times by posts on this Form that failed to reveal limitations and details of what was advocated. These details and limitations became fatal in my inexperienced hands.

Wilbur I applaud your ability to plane a 1/32" crotch veneer panel. But, as they say on Mythbusters, "Don't try this at home. We're experts."

It takes a lot of skill and experience ( and risk) to do what you did, both in setting up the plane and using it. And it requires a panel that is flatter than the veneer is thick or one will plane through the high spots. Planing failure, a divot or planing through the veneer, after getting the panel prepared could compromise the whole project. I am thinking about planing through the veneer on the 5 th drawer front of a chest of drawers with matched veneer flitches, for example.

Bottom line, don't try planing veneer until you have become proficient on test pieces. Veneer is easy to screw up sanding, as many of us have found out through experience.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#87

A flaw in the flaw

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Here’s a real world example. I’m not a professional, but I planed the walnut burl veneer that was applied to the front of this Bible box with a Japanese plane without a chipbreaker to prep it prior to finishing, and it survived. I figure if I can do it, so can a whole lot of other people.

Wilbur, I am afraid to say that your example is flawed.

Burl is essentially end grain. The best - and easiest - method for planing this is a low angle plane. Your Japanese smoother fits the bill nicely.

Indeed, I would not use a scraper here as my first choice.

I find the whole issue of plane choice bordering on religious fervour. I am chastened to say, but I am on Charlie's side here. My preference is in the tool that works best - chipbreaker, high angle, low angle, scraper ... even sanding if that does it best (and while I scrape before sanding, scraping is not always possible on tight curves).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#88

Re: As a practical matter......for the bystanders

wilbur

I appreciate the compliments, Bill, but I have a hard time accepting that it’s my innate expertise and skill that led to the result that you see.

At the time that I made this Bible box, I had been woodworking for less than 5 years. And this is as a hobbyist. On top of that, this was my first attempt at making a woodworking project with a veneer like this.

So if your premise is correct, I must be some sort of woodworking prodigy. I highly doubt that is the case.

So the alternative explanation, that this task can be accomplished with less effort than you think, must be true. (There may be a third or fourth alternate explanation, but I’m going with the dichotomy you’ve set up.) I tend to go with this theme: if I can figure this out, so can you.

As an aside, I also applied the veneer with hot hide glue/hammer veneering. I did one test piece. Both came out perfect. In addition, my son gave hammer veneering a try, and his veneer was flawless. He was all of nine years old at the time.

My point here is that some of the techniques that may seem to require a lot of skill may not be as hard as folks make them out to be.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#89

Re: Whoa Slow down there.............

Mark Hennebury

I must admit i have used a compass plane myself, ( mind you i had to did into the archives for that)


Mark hennebury

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#90

Re: Big Flaw

david weaver

I absolutely agree with the last comment.

I couldn't count how many times I've seen people say "some wood just can't be planed", and then they mention things that are easily planed by a double iron.

The comments in this thread about how long it takes to get a good plane finish are a good indicator of it, too. Nothing is faster, especially not a progression of sandpaper.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#91

Re: A flaw in the flaw

wilbur

Hi Derek,

What you say about the grain orientation of burl may be true, but that doesn’t address the “Dare we put plane to exceedingly thin burl walnut and the like?” issue that Charley mentioned earlier, nor does that change the fact that the edge band veneer didn’t have a problem, even though that was all long grain.

My preference is also for the tool that works best in your hands. Charley’s issue is that he seems to think that because scraping/sanding works best on curved surfaces for finish preparation (and I agree with that), that there is no other alternative for flat surfaces.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#92

Re: Big Flaw

Sgian Dubh

Warren, the point I was making is that in a production or commercial environment, even in workshops undertaking significant handwork, there's a tendency to go for the safer option. I don't dispute it's possible to prep a figured drawer front in a short time with a smoother in good shape.

But in my experience, prepping after machine planing (normal for me) generally requires significant hand planing to prepare a surface polish ready. The visible scalloping, and the invisible sub-surface scalloping left behind by the machines has to be taken out: the sub-surface scalloping can reveal itself after polishing if not removed. This often means taking off more wood than might be the case if prepping behind a previously hand planed surface, e.g., wood hand planed true: your experience might be different, but it's what I've generally found.

Faced with the task of prepping, mostly by hand, a suite comprising, say, a carcase or two, drawers and doors to fit, perhaps a table and some chairs, with parts of these items veneered, it's not surprising most workshops go for the relatively safe option of limiting planing to the solid wood parts, followed by scrapers and sanding, and perhaps sanding alone of the veneered parts.

I'm not sure if, in the last sentence of your message, you're suggesting I'm disparaging double iron planes (blade and cap iron). I'm not. I'm generally satisfied with how my smallish collection of double iron planes function. Slainte.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#93

Re: A flaw in the flaw

Charly

You've misread my posts. By all means plane flat surfaces to a finished point. For sure that's the only kind of surface you can do this on. I'm tickled to death to let a planed surface stand, but I'm not going to fiddle around with the cap iron a whole lot if a spot or two need other treatment.

With regard to the veneer -- this is probably a debate best put off until you have veneered a few large carcase sides, cabinet doors, drawer fronts on a nice-sized casepiece, etc. Trust me, suprises await even your best, most careful efforts. It would be impossible for me to describe how small a bubble in the veneer it takes to catch a plane iron, heck even a scraper. So, please, sally forth and then let's have the honest discussion at a later date. I can promise you that after getting a nice match on a big carcase side with veneer that just loves to cockle on you the last thing you'll even dream of doing is planing it, hand sanding it will feel like a risk.

You need to hunt for two months for just enough, and I mean just enough is all you could find, veneer to build the magnum opus you've always dreamed of and then let us know if you decide to plane it.

Anybody can take a plane to 4/4 rough stock if they're shooting to finish at 3/4. Doesn't take much courage or even skill at the end of the day.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#94

Re: A flaw in the flaw

david weaver

You fit warren's description. you don't know how to use a double iron plane, it's clear and it has been for a while.

There's no "fiddling with a cap iron" to do anything. you set it once when you sharpen. you set it again when you sharpen the next time.

It would be nice if you knew what you were talking about, it would keep you from wasting everyone's time. Maybe you could be one of warren's students for a while, then you might post some examples of your own work where you couldn't do X or Y instead of hiding behind pictures of the work everyone else does.

Maybe it's because you're afraid that anything you've made, Warren would be quick to suggest he could plane it easily and has done so for pay in less time than it takes you to post about it. Whatever it is, you definitely don't understand much about using the cap iron.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#95

Re: A flaw in the flaw

Charly

I'm not sure who Warren is, but if he has a school can you post a link?

TIA

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#96

Risk adverse

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

That is what I was trying to say but you said it better. Damned if I am going to risk planing 5 drawer fronts where I have sweated to match the veneers and so far all has gone as planned. The closer I get to finished the more risk adverse I become. Some mistakes can't be recovered and I take every pain to avoid making any when the stakes are high.

And while we are on the topic of how easy something is............I have seen with my own eyes Al Sharp SAPFM Cartouche winner fail to hammer stick veneer to a bow front drawer in a demo and Bob Millard, famous Federal maker, fail to stick some crotch mahogany to a large door. The adjacent piece of veneer stuck just fine with a vacuum press and someone with little training did it uneventfully (me).

Of course lots of people can be successful most of the time with 1789 methods but there are more foolproof alternatives for the risk adverse or unexperienced.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#97

Re: A flaw in the flaw

wilbur

So here’s a summary of Charley's statements in this discussion.

— The Seymours didn’t use a double iron. (Shows a picture of furniture with flat veneered surfaces.)

— If the double iron is so effective, then why do all the books talk about scrapers? (Nicholson gets quoted as a book that advocates the use of double irons.)

— So what about curved surfaces? (Not germane to the subject, as planes aren’t used on curved surfaces.)

— So what about veneered surfaces? (I show an example of my experience with planing a veneered surface.)

— So what about really large veneered surfaces? I’ve had trouble with those, even with a scraper. And it’s easy to plane 4/4 down to 3/4. (What?)

All I can do is to repeat what my experience has been. In my hands, I was able to plane a flat surface with a walnut burl veneer from modern commercial stock, which I suppose fits the description of “exceedingly thin burl walnut and the like” that Charley was concerned with earlier in the thread. And this was without a whole lot of time fussing with the set up of the plane. I realize that there are other methods of accomplishing this task. For me, planing was the easiest. And again, I don’t think it was the easiest choice for me because I’m some sort of planing savant.

I suppose Charley can continue to move the target until he comes up with a scenario where a plane in my hands might be problematic. He could come up with larger and larger surfaces to cover. He could make it a criteria that the veneers get ever thinner, increasing the risk of blowing through the veneer. He might even decide that I should use a less than optimal approach to gluing that is guaranteed to leave the veneer with bubbles.

It’s clear to me that by constantly shifting the subject, Charley isn’t really interested in a serious discussion. This shouldn’t be a surprise, given his history on this forum and others.

The only thing I can say is that if Charley can’t figure out how to use a plane to get a finish ready surface, that’s not my problem. I don’t care if he likes another method. that’s fine. He can prep his surfaces however he would like. It still doesn’t invalidate this method of work.

By the way, it may not take a whole lot of courage to plane a 4/4 rough stock down to 3/4. But it does, if you want to leave the 3/4 board with a finish ready surface.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#98

Re: answer

TomD

Not to be arch, the veneers we get are for the most part smooth as heck on one side, at least, and straight off the knife. I get your point though.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#99

Re: makers...

TomD

"warren...

multitudes of japanese workers."

Yeah, but that as much as admits the counter argument as removes it. They have a completely different aesthetic premiss. And a different way of looking at wood. Or their classical culture did. If one started out valuing plain grained woods, and valuing "natural finishes" of course we could have that direction also, as we do in certain pieces, like say windsor chairs.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#100

Re: Bingo

TomD

"That is what I was trying to say but you said it better. Damned if I am going to risk planing 5 drawer fronts where I have sweated to match the veneers and so far all has gone as planned. The closer I get to finished the more risk adverse I become."

Yeah, a pro approach. I can hand bend woods, but as one guitar maker said, you only have to loose, say one side,in a hundred, to make it worth your while to jig up for it. There are no points for hand sanding or bending, there are only points for the result. Sad but true to some extent, but probably a liberation at a certain point.