New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

more from Kato and Kawai

Posts

more from Kato and Kawai

#1

more from Kato and Kawai

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

An opportunity to get some more translations has come up and the opportunity seized.

To answer a lingering question about optimum cap iron angle they state for planing a Birch test piece that the optimum working of the cap iron occurred with a cap iron angle of 50 degrees, 150 microns back from the blade tip. The implication is that these values could be different for other situations. I have found that more often than not they use a cap iron angle of 50 degrees.

So, a cap iron angle of 50 degrees is a place to start (and stop unless you are into researching this variable).

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#2

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

David Charlesworth

Thanks Bill.

I was mislead by the original video, which I thought was the definitive result !!

best wishes,

David

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#3

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It could be that for a 50 degree cap iron 150 microns (.006 inches) works well, but I cannot see it as any kind of standard for real world use. My own research suggests that a rounded bevel ending in a steeper juncture is much to be preferred. I have been using this technique for over forty years.

The Kato paper which appeared on Steve Elliot's site in 2005 or 2006 gives evidence that an 80 degree cap iron is much more effective than 50 degrees. Some readers did not notice this evidence, but Kato did and in the conclusion of that paper is stated:

# In cutting against the grain at depths of cut greater than 0.05 mm the chipbreaker should be set at the correct position depending on the depth of cut.

# The knife with a chipbreaker whose edge angle is 80 degrees has a larger effect on the prevention of surface damage than one with a chipbreaker whose edge angle is 50 degrees.

Peter Nicholson recommended a rounded cap iron in 1812:


In my own experience there are many variables affecting the cap iron use, among them depth of cut, angle of the grain (rising or falling), angle from the radial (quartersawn to plainsawn continuum), and species. To talk about an ideal setting without reference to these variables is ridiculous.

Here is Pennsylvania we have five native birches. The timbers of Betula lenta and Betula alleghaniensis are markedly different from the other three. There are numerous species of birch in Japan also.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#4

I am hardly unaware of the video

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It was presented, in fact the only public presentation before our recent efforts, at the 3rd International Tooling Symposium, NC State , 1994. At my request Professor Kato sent me a copy of the video, as well as his English translation notes he used to describe the video as it played for the audience.

Additionally, Professor Kato sent me copies of all the papers he published on the topic of planing. I have tried to make it abundantly clear that Kato knew that several variables interactively combined to lead to an "optimum" cap iron effect. **** But this optimum is so broad that a useful setting is not hard to achieve and could vary depending on your specific planing objectives. In many cases Kato and Kawai were concerned with edge life.

You have accurately stated part of the conclusion section of the Kato text accompanying the video. However, these conclusions are in the context of this video and do not represent a conclusion from all the work they did.

Examining all the Kato and Kawai work, they never recommended a cap iron angle setting for general work.

However, we are currently translating a tutorial prepared for their trade school students. The cap iron on the plane being described, and presumably used in the school, and presumably what will be used in their trade, is ground at 50 degrees. It would be nice if the person that is in Japan and deals in Japanese tools (Stu something?) would go measure some off the shelf cap irons to see what they use.

That said, your have cloaked this technique in complexity that has done little to promote its use. No doubt your 40 years experience can tease out a bit of additional benefit of employing the cap iron by adjusting the various plane variables for the situation at hand.

However, for the bystanders watching this discussion it is trivial to get a lot of benefit from what Kato calls the "cap iron effect". Kees demonstrated this fact and once demonstrated how easy it is, many others have since confirmed it. All the mumbo jumbo of how much experience is required to take advantage of the cap iron effect just provides an excuse to the distractors to dismiss the advantage and discourage novices from trying it.

What ever cap iron angle is on the plane works well. Set the cap iron as close as you can see and try it. If the shaving does not scrunch up the cap iron is not too close. Apparently, given the success that novices have in mitigating tear out using this technique, getting variables close enough is good enough. No doubt experience will enable more efficient and effective use of the cap iron in the rare cases where near optimum settings fail.

More on setting the distance when we get the tutorial translated. A simple test shaving is all that is required. As far as angle, 50 degrees was what was used in nearly all the Kato and Kawai work. If inclined, experiment with other angles and report the results here. Or just use what Stanley provided and get on with building stuff. Works for me and many others that have rediscovered that it is easy to get the cap iron to do more than hold the blade in the plane body.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#5

Re: I am hardly unaware of the video

david weaver

Off the shelf caps on japanese planes are all over the place. They either have a primary grind on them, or some are cut off so that the front end is blunt and you finish them. They won't be a reliable source of what's used because unlike a stanley or vintage wooden plane, they are not sent with a profile that's ready to use.

Some have the primary well finished, and some are so coarsely done on less expensive planes that it looks like they were clipped by a shear.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#6

Re: I am hardly unaware of the video

Warren in Lancaster, PA

However, for the bystanders watching this discussion it is trivial to get a lot of benefit from what Kato calls the "cap iron effect". Kees demonstrated this fact and once demonstrated how easy it is, many others have since confirmed it. All the mumbo jumbo of how much experience is required to take advantage of the cap iron effect just provides an excuse to the distractors to dismiss the advantage and discourage novices from trying it.

The reason for saying that the double iron technique requires skill is that in the past many experts have tried it and pronounced it a waste of time. Like using real hide glue the first time, making a mess, and giving up. More than a year after promoting the cap iron video with much ballyhoo, you wrote this in 2013:

Ash is miserable to plane. Rarely does looking at the slope of the grain offer reliable guidance on what to expect. In this case there were areas of early wood that easily tore regardless of planing direction or cap iron setting, in addition to the more apparent small grain reversals among otherwise straight grained wood. The #5 was nearly useless, the high angle block plane was more useful but the scraper became the weapon of choice.

It does not much good to tell people that planing ash is trivial, if a guy who has read the available literature and been using the double iron for a year can write something as discouraging as this.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#7

Re: I am hardly unaware of the video

Steve Voigt

I think it's true that it's relatively easy (though not trivial) to get a dramatic improvement from the cap iron right away. I think it's also true that it takes a great deal of experience to actually master the double iron.

Let me elaborate a bit. When I first started learning how to employ the chipbreaker (a few months after Bill, Dave, Kees, and others), I experimented with the various mechanical methods that one finds on forums for setting the CB distance. Like taping a feeler gauge to a board, or indenting the cutting iron a few thousandths into a scrap of wood. These methods make it easy, and they work some of the time, but not all the time. They're too "one size fits all."

So I went back to setting the cap iron by eye, and it quickly became apparent that this creates an important feedback loop that actually teaches you something. You set the distance and observe the result. If the result is unsatisfactory, you try again. After many iterations of this, you start to develop a sense of what the setback should be in a given situation. This is a whole lot more complex than just saying "set the cap iron.004 from the edge," but it's a lot more interesting and the results are better.

A few years ago on this forum, Warren wrote

Find a violin player and ask where to put the first finger on the A string to play a B … Try to find a good player who knows this or who thinks in these terms. Tell a guy you want to copy his finger settings so you can play the violin like him and see what he says. They teach you instead to put the finger about here and listen to the result, make adjustments. A violinist knows this stuff well without ever learning any numbers … If there is tearout, move the cap iron. It has been explained this way for 200 years because this is the way craftsmen think. If the violin note is sharp, move the finger, don't get bogged down in measurement.

I don't think this is "cloaking the technique in complexity." I think it's actually a pretty clear road map for learning how to master the double iron. Or any technique, really. Try something. Observe the result. Form a hypothesis. Try again. With this approach, you can conquer all sorts of obstacles without having to be spoonfed a solution.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#8

Another perspective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you want to turn a board into a piece of furniture there is a lot to learn. If one builds furniture part time it is unlikely one will ever "master" any part of the process, particularly if the builds grow in complexity. Time is spent acquiring new capability not "mastering" what is good enough. And if one pauses along the way to master many processes one will never get anything built. (an observation, little gets built on this Forum, see Gallery) With the primary motivation of getting something made in mind, the only practical approach is to get good enough and move on.

If one does not plane to dimension, or prepare surfaces ready for finish, the amount of planing one does in building a piece of furniture becomes a minute of planing here and 30 seconds there, sometimes separated by days. This exposure will never lead to mastery of planing. Hence, I don't have mastering planing as a goal.

The Kees video taught me enough to be good enough to turn the plane into a useful tool where as before it had not been. Kees made it look simple and indeed it is simple to become good enough for most things. Tear out has become now rare in my builds. When there is a threat of tear out I scrape or sand and move on. It is interesting to know that experienced diddling with the settings and technique could enable me to plane the few things I can't now, but for me there are more important things to learn like the complex inlay for a Charlestown table I have in mind.

Bottom like- From my perspective it is fine to tell the world that being able to plane a figured table top ready for finish starting with a rough board is a skill that will take years to master. But also explain that if you are building stuff and the hand plane sits idle because of tear-out fear, putting the plane to use requires trivial time and effort. It can be taught with a 5 minute video or a 10 minute magazine read. Many people in our club are testimony to this fact.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#9

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

Charley

One wonders if the Seymours would have any clue about what is being discussed in this thread but then it probably wouldn't matter one bloody bit given this:

http://skn-wp-assets.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/news/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/2680b-1861.jpg

Built before there was such a thing as the famous 'double iron.'

Cheerio!

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#10

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

Charley

Better link:

http://www.skinnerinc.com/news/blog/federal-furniture-ladys-secretary-bookcase-thomas-seymour/

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#11

John and Thomas Seymour

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Something is really wrong here Charley. I don't know when you thought the double iron was "invented" or when you thought the Seymours were active, but double iron planes were being made here in Pennsylvania before Thomas Seymour was born. I have assumed they did use the double iron.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#12

Re: John and Thomas Seymour

Charley

Interesting. I see where Thomas had retired from cabinetmaking by 1824. Didn't realize the double iron was widely used by then in the US. Thanks.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#13

Re: John and Thomas Seymour

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would put 1790 as near the time when the double iron became widely or maybe universally used. That would have been when Thomas Seymour was 19. That also coincides with the beginning of the Federal period when the use of figured woods became a main focus. The Dominy family, conservative woodworkers on rural Long Island started making double iron planes for their own use about that time. They had made single iron planes for 30 years. In the Seaton chest (1796) there are double iron jack, fore, trying, jointer, and smoothing planes along with single iron smoother and jack planes.

The Carruthers advertisement in 1767 mentions "double iron'd planes of a late construction", suggesting earlier double iron use. Kees has shown a double iron plane on this forum which appears to be from the 1750s.


An 1828 article in the Journal of the Franklin Institute offers a few incidental comments that bear on the history.

The top iron the editor can remember for 40 years past.

and

The advantage of the "double plane iron" over the "single plane iron" being, therefore, unquestionable, the latter are consequently almost disused...

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#14

Question on cap iron angle

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The work of Kato and Kawai largely supported development of the planing machines. The only paper that is an exception to this fact is the tutorial prepared for students, which is being translated. Any recommendations that come from this work must be interpreted in this context. Their conditions and conclusions may have more or less relevance to a Stanley plane planing walnut.

I have never seen one of these early planes with a "double iron". Was the cap iron a flat piece of metal with some angle ground on its front edge, or a thinner piece of steel shaped similar to the modern Stanley cap iron, or something else.

No doubt that after some years of use the makers/users arrived at a cap iron angle, or range of angles if the optimum is broad, that were optimum for the woods and settings they used (which by and large are the woods we use).

It would be risky looking at one of these planes today and making the assumption that nobody diddled with it since it was used by someone that knew how to use it. Is there any reliable record of how the cap iron was shaped(angled) in the day by a maker/user that was experienced in its application?

That said, it is not uncommon to see torn grain on antique furniture I scrutinize. But here again, the surface today may not be representative of the original.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#15

Re: John and Thomas Seymour

Charley

Fascinating. Thanks again.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#16

Re: Question on cap iron angle *LINK*

Steve Voigt

"I have never seen one of these early planes with a "double iron". Was the cap iron a flat piece of metal with some angle ground on its front edge, or a thinner piece of steel shaped similar to the modern Stanley cap iron, or something else."

Here is the relevant page from the Seaton book that will answer your questions:


You can also see related images on the "about" page of my website:


About

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#17

That's half the answer.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The rest is what is the leading edge angle? can be assume we can measure it from the picture and it will be representative? Is anyone experimenting under US wood and plane conditions to see what angle or range of angle is optimum?

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#18

Re: That's half the answer.....

Steve Voigt

I doubt that you can measure the angle from the hand-drawn picture.

I'm sure lots of people are experimenting with different angles. It's easy to do…it would be easy for you to do. I already gave a detailed answer to this in the thread David Charlesworth started on 8/1, so I won't repeat it here.

Getting back to the original topic for a second, I don't agree at all that a distance of .006" (I refuse to talk in microns, thousandths are already overkill) is optimum, but it depends on what you're doing. For me, when the cap iron is set that close, there is a considerable increase in planing resistance. I don't own a working jointer. When I'm making planes, I'm planing tablesawn or bandsawn surfaces to finish dimensions; when I'm making furniture for my own enjoyment, I'm sawing by hand and jointing/thicknessing with planes. So, I spend a lot of time planing, and I'd rather not get worn out by a cap iron that's set closer than necessary. 1/64" is probably typical, then it's moved a little closer if there is tearout.

On the other hand, for someone like Derek, working with really nasty woods as a matter of course, .006" might not be close enough. So once again, we are back to, if there is tearout move the cap iron, and don't get bogged down in measurement. If you want to find the optimum the optimum angle, try a bunch of angles and see which one you like. Post your results here if you like. Dave, Kees, Warren, and I have all posted specific opinions on angles over the last couple years; maybe they could all be compiled in one place.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#19

Re: John and Thomas Seymour

RK near Boston

It is amazing that somehow there was this whole bevel up plane business going on. I read some stuff from 2008-2010 magazines and you have Schwarz and Lonnie Bird gushing about bevel up planes, etc. I am a serious newbie and basically got lucky that when I started some years ago I came across this chip-breaker info here and on Sawmill via David W. Really has made having no machine jointer and planer very manageable.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#20

An hour in the library.......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is a saying among research scientists that comes up when the wheel gets rediscovered or a "brilliant" idea fails.

"A week in the laboratory could have saved an hour in the library." The idea being that if it is already known a small amount of time finding the results in the literature will save many times that time in the lab rediscovering what is already known. Not using the library is a path to some other career (maybe management :) .

For some it might be an enjoyable exercise to rediscover the optimum angle or range of angles. For others it would be regarded a waste of time if this value or range of values was recorded by some past furniture maker that successfully employed the cap iron to mitigate tear-out in building furniture. Regrettably the abstracting services don't include 18th century woodworking.

Pending data to the contrary I will presume Stanley got it right for what I do and carry on.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#21

Re: An hour in the library.......

Warren in Lancaster, PA

By 1975 I had read a lot of the old literature on the double iron: Salivet (1792), Nicholson (1812), Martin (1813), Smith (1816), Holtzapffel (1846), Goodman (1964), and maybe a few others. A lot more than an hour's work to find this stuff. I then did extensive experimentation in the period 1975-77 in order to get the technique to where it was reliably producing superior surfaces. It is easy to see why a lot of guys just through up their hands and said the double iron did not work.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#22

Angles ain't angles

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

A few years ago, when we began experimenting with different chipbreaker settings, I played around with different angles at the leading edge of the chipbreaker, different distances from the edge of the blade, and different frog angles. As I recall, Kees did a more formal evaluation of this (on Steve's website), and we came to the same conclusions that all these features were interconnected. That is, when you change one setting, you need to alter others to compensate.

I have used planes with bed angles from 40 degrees through 55 degrees. With a 50 degree angle at the leading edge of the chipbreaker, they all appear to show the "effect", but there are alterations that need to be made to achieve a similar result. In general, the lower the bed angle, the closer the leading edge needs to be to the blade. And - although we are measuring in 0.1mm increments - the higher the bed angle, the further back the chipbreaker.

The bottom line is that there is no single recipe for a setting. Kees, as I recall, used a 45 degree leading edge. I have come to prefer 50 degrees, but after Warren's comments I will once again try 80 degrees. However, it is likely that the difference in angle is "adjusted" by the individual differences we have in setting the leading edge distance. Angles ain't angles.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#23

It is called a review article

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In many fields involving research (figuring out the effect of planing variables on results is as much research as any) when someone has done an extensive review of the literature on some topic they write a review article summarizing what is known on the topic. The review article saves many others the task of spending days/weeks in the library. In a popular field the review article will attract more readers than the original papers did and hence make a significant contribution to understanding.

On the other hand there are cases where the possession of knowledge provides a potential economic benefit. This reason is given for why LV has not published the results of their planing work.

And there is the case where someone will not share a family recipe. I regard them as just selfish, or wishing to hide the fact that it isn't so special after all.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#24

So it would seem.......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

that the 50 degree angle Kato and Kawai used in almost all their work is a good place to start.......and stop if one is not interested in teasing out the highest capability of their planing for some situation. I need to check but I think their bed angle was 40 degrees.

Re: more from Kato and Kawai

#25

Not in my experience......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"It is easy to see why a lot of guys just through up their hands and said the double iron did not work. "

The usefulness of the cap iron beyond holding the blade in the plane was introduced to our woodworking club. Many tried it and find it helps their planing. No giving up encountered.

The only resistant I have encountered is from people that devoted a life time and many $$ to some alternative. I can understand that something as simple as a used Stanley #5 with a close set cap iron threatens their world view.

If over a short period of history planes moved from single to double cap irons it was because the benefit is easy see and achieve....... for an open mind.